Memory, Narrative and the Great War

BookMemory, Narrative and the Great War

Memory, Narrative and the Great War

Rifleman Patrick MacGill and the Construction of Wartime Experience


April 3rd, 2013

Access Token


Other Formats



Memory, Narrative and the Great War provides a detailed examination of the varied and complex war writings of a relatively marginal figure, Patrick MacGill, within a general framework of our current pre-occupation with blood, mud and suffering. In particular, it seeks to explain how his interpretation of war shifted from the heroic wartime autobiographical trilogy, with its emphasis on 'the romance of the rifleman' to the pessimistic and guilt-ridden interpretations in his post-war novel, Fear!, and play, Suspense. Through an exploration of the way in which war-time experiences were remembered (and re-remembered) and retold in strikingly different narratives, and using insights from cognitive psychology, it is argued that there is no contradiction between these two seemingly opposing views. Instead it is argued that, given the present orientation and problem-solving nature of both memory and narrative, the different interpretations are both 'true' in the sense that they throw light on the ongoing way in which MacGill came to terms with his experiences of war. This in turn has implications for broader interpretations of the Great War, which has increasingly be seen in terms of futile suffering, not least because of the eloquent testimony of ex-Great War soldiers, reflecting on their experiences many years after the event. Without suggesting that such testimony is invalid, it is argued that this is one view but not the only view of the war. Rather wartime memory and narrative is more akin to an ever-changing kaleidoscope, in which pieces of memory take on different (but equally valid) shapes as they are shaken with the passing of time.

1. This is the first detailed study of Patrick MacGill's war writings, and gives consideration to important but neglected sources, most notably his novel, Fear! and his play Suspense. 2. The cross-disciplinary approach, drawing on elements of cognitive (rather than Freudian) psychology, is distinctive. 3.The book also provides a critique of the changing interpretations of the Great war and the sources available to the historian.

Author Information

David Taylor is Emeritus Professor of History at the University of Huddersfield.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents
Section TitlePagePrice
Title page4
Copyright page5
List of Illustrations10
Part I34
Chapter 136
Chapter 257
Chapter 379
Part II102
Chapter 4104
Chapter 5148
Chapter 6172
Select Bibliography218