Bulletin of Hispanic Studies

Magic, Inherent Evil, and the Proto-feminism of María de Zayas y Sotomayor: A Comparison with Selected novelas of Miguel de Cervantes and Alonso de Castillo Solórzano

Bulletin of Hispanic Studies (2019), 96, (2), 127–143.


Details

This article compares the portrayal of women who use magic in seventeenth-century novelas of María de Zayas y Sotomayor with novelas by Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra and Alonso de Castillo Solórzano to illuminate the complexity and uniqueness of Zayas’s proto-feminism. The article suggests that Zayas provides a nuanced portrayal of these women that departs only partially from the prevailing paradigm reflected in Cervantes’s and Solórzano’s more conventional representations. A restrained approach that blames both men and women for evil arguably permitted Zayas’s work to be published in the censorial environment of her time. Examining who uses magic, how they are described, and the purposes and consequences of its use, is useful in understanding gender portrayal, as well as how Zayas’s work differs from her contemporaries’ and what that difference means for her incipient feminist ideals. Scholars have noted the ambiguous nature of Zayas’s feminism and some have examined her portrayals of the supernatural, but none has conducted a detailed textual comparison integrating these subjects.

Works cited

Berg, Sander, 2017. ‘The Magic of Zayas: Slippery Sorcery, Baroque Games with the Devil and Uncanny Miracles in the Novellas of Mara de Zayas’, PhD dissertation, University of London. Google Scholar

Brownlee, Marina S., 2000. The Cultural Labyrinth of María de Zayas (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press). Google Scholar

Cardaillac Hermosilla, Yvette, 1999. ‘La magia en las novelas de María de Zayas’, in La creatividad feminina en el mundo barroco hispánico: María de Zayas – Isabel Rebeca Correa – Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz, eds. Monika Bosse, Barbara Potthast and André Stoll. Vol. 1. (Kassel, Germany: Edition Reichenberger), pp. 351–94. Google Scholar

Castillo Solórzano, Alonso de, 1665. La pícara; or The Triumphs of Female Subtilty Display’d in the Artifices and Impostures of a Beautiful Woman, who Trapann’d the Most Experienc’d Rogues, and Made all those Unhappy who thought her Handsome, trans. John Davies (London: Printed by W.W. for John Starkey The Mitre Within Temple-Bar). Google Scholar

Cervantes Saavedra, Miguel de, 1961. The Dialogue of the Dogs. Six Exemplary Novels, trans. Harriet de Onis (Great Neck: Barron’s Educational Series). Google Scholar

Clark, Elizabeth A., and Herbert Richardson (eds), 1996. ‘Woman as Witch: Witchcraft Persecutions in the Old and New Worlds: Selections from the Malleus Maleficarum and documents from the Salem Witchcraft Trials’, in Women and Religion: The Original Sourcebook of Women in Christian Thought, eds. Elizabeth A. Clark and Herbert Richardson (New York: HarperSanFrancisco), pp. 119–43. Google Scholar

Davis, Nina Cox, 2003. ‘Re-Framing Discourse: Women before Their Public in María de Zayas’, Hispanic Review, 71.3: 325–44. Google Scholar

Foa, Sandra, 1977. ‘Humor and Suicide in Zayas and Cervantes’, Anales Cervantinos, 16: 71–83. Google Scholar

Friedman, Edward H., 2004. ‘Innocents Punished: The Narrative Models of María de Zayas’, Confluencia, 20.1: 9–16. Google Scholar

Greer, Margaret, 2000. María de Zayas Tells Baroque Tales of Love and the Cruelty of Men (University Park: Penn State University Press). Google Scholar

Grieve, Patricia E., 1991. ‘Embroidering with Saintly Threads: María de Zayas Challenges Cervantes and the Church’, Renaissance Quarterly, 44.1: 86–106. Google Scholar

Griswold, Susan C., 1980. ‘Topoi and Rhetorical Distance: The “Feminism” of María de Zayas’, Revista de Estudios Hispánicos, 14.2: 97–116. Google Scholar

Hernández Pecoraro, Rosilie, 2002. ‘“La fuerza del amor” or “The Power of Self-Love”: Zayas’ Response to Cervantes’ “La fuerza de la sangre”’, Hispanic Review, 70.1: 39–57. Google Scholar

Kahiluoto Rudat, Eva M., 1975. ‘Ilusión y desengaño: el feminismo barroco de María de Zayas y Sotomayor’, Letras Femininas, 1.1: 27–43. Google Scholar

Kramer, Heinrich, and James Sprenger, 1971. The Malleus Maleficarum of Heinrich Kramer and James Sprenger, trans. Montague Summers (New York: Dover). [Online.] Available at: >www.freeinfosociety.com/media/pdf/5533.pdf> [accessed 25 November 2018]. Google Scholar

Lagreca, Nancy, 2004. ‘Evil Women and Feminist Sentiment: Baroque Contradictions in María de Zayas’s “El prevenido engañado” and “Estragos que causa al vicio”’, Revista Canadiense de Estudios Hispánicos, 28.3: 565–82. Google Scholar

Lerner, Gerda, 1993. The Creation of Feminist Consciousness: From the Middle Ages to Eighteen-seventy (New York: Oxford University Press). Google Scholar

Maroto Camino, Mercedes, 1999. ‘María de Zayas and Ana Caro: The Space of Woman’s Solidarity in the Spanish Golden Age’, Hispanic Review, 67.1: 1–16. Google Scholar

Martín de Castañega, Fray, 1997 [1529]. Tratado de las Supersticiones y Hechicerías, ed. Fabián Alejandro Campagne (Buenos Aires: Universidad de Buenos Aires). Google Scholar

Matos-Nin, Ingrid, 2010. Las novelas de María de Zayas (1590–1650): lo sobrenatural y lo oculto en la literatura femenina española del siglo XVII (Lewiston: Edwin Mellen Press). Google Scholar

Merrim, Stephanie, 1999. Early Modern Women’s Writing and Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz (Nashville: Vanderbilt University Press). Google Scholar

Paun de García, Susan, 1992. ‘Magia y poder en María de Zayas’, Cuadernos de ALDEEU, 8.1: 43–54. Google Scholar

Pérez-Erdélyi, Mireya, 1979. La pícara y la dama: la imagen de las mujeres en las novelas picaresco-cortesanas de María de Zayas y Sotomayor y Alonso del Castillo Solórzano (Miami: Ediciones Universal). Google Scholar

Perry, Mary Elizabeth, 1990. Gender and Disorder in Early Modern Seville (Princeton: Princeton University Press). Google Scholar

Sánchez Ortega, María Helena, 1992. ‘Woman as Source of “Evil” in Counter Reformation Spain’, trans. Susan Isabel Stein, in Culture and Control in Counter-Reformation Spain, eds. Anne J. Cruz and Mary Elizabeth Perry (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press), pp. 196–215. Google Scholar

Stackhouse, Kenneth A., 1978. ‘Verisimilitude, Magic, and the Supernatural in the novelas of María de Zayas y Sotomayor’, Hispanofila, 62: 65–76. Google Scholar

Vitoria, Francisco de, 2006. Sobre la magia, ed. Luis Frayle Delgado (Salamanca: San Esteban). Google Scholar

Vollendorf, Lisa, 1997. ‘Fleshing out Feminism in Early Modern Spain: María de Zayas’s Corporeal Politics’, Revista Canadiense de Estudios Hispánicos, 22.1: 87–108. Google Scholar

Whitenack, Judith, 1995. ‘“Lo que ha menester”: Erotic Enchantment in “La inocencia castigada”’, in María de Zayas: The Dynamics of Discourse, eds. Amy Williamsen and Judith White-nack (London: Associated University Presses), pp. 170–91. Google Scholar

Zamora Calvo, María Jesús, 2004. ‘Madrid: cuna de embrujos, hechizos y represiones en el Siglo de Oro’, Alpha – Revista de Artes, Letras y Filosofía, 20: 273–78. Google Scholar

Zayas y Sotomayor, María de, 1948. Novelas amorosas y ejemplares de María de Zayas y Sotomayor, ed. Agustín G. de Amezúa (Madrid: Aldus, S.A. de Artes Gráficas). Google Scholar

Zayas y Sotomayor, María de, 1990. The Enchantments of Love. Amorous and Exemplary Novels, trans. H. Patsy Boyer (Berkeley: University of California Press). Google Scholar

Zayas y Sotomayor, María de, 1997. The Disenchantments of Love. Desengaños amorosos, trans. H. Patsy Boyer (Albany: State University of New York Press). Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Author details

Manley, Stewart