Town Planning Review

Understanding the dilemmas of multifunctional regional planning

Town Planning Review (2017), 88, (5), 531–555.

Abstract

Multifunctional projects integrate land uses to fulfill economic, environmental and social objectives. Planning multifunctional projects is complex because of the interdependence of effects and actors. When selecting functional combinations, actors often encounter dilemmas related to the project priorities. This paper draws on an earlier categorisation of dilemmas, identifying the regulation and investment dilemmas in a multifunctional case in the Dutch South West Delta. Our results show the influence of dilemmas on the course of decision making in a multifunctional project. In our case, the investment dilemma prevails because decision makers must balance the need to select functions based on earning potential while satisfying other stakeholder demands. Furthermore, we shed light on the interrelation between the regulation and investment dilemmas, given the tension of having to transform and preserve values in an area while prioritising regional demands and earning potential.

Access Token
£25.00

AARTS, N., VAN WOERKUM, C. and VERMUNT, B. (2007), ‘Policy and planning in the Dutch countryside: the role of regional innovation networks’, Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 50, 727–44. Policy and planning in the Dutch countryside: the role of regional innovation networks Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 50 727 44 Google Scholar

ADAMS, V. M., PRESSEY, R. L. and STOECKL, N. (2014), ‘Navigating trade-offs in land-use planning: integrating human well-being into objective setting’, Ecology and Society, 19, article no. 53. Navigating trade-offs in land-use planning: integrating human well-being into objective setting Ecology and Society 19 Google Scholar

BANAI, R. (2013), ‘Plan vs project dilemma revisited: a progress review of urban and regional studies literature’, Urban Studies, 50, 807–24. Plan vs project dilemma revisited: a progress review of urban and regional studies literature Urban Studies 50 807 24 Google Scholar

BAŃSKI, J. (2010), ‘Dilemmas for regional development in the concepts seeking to develop Poland’s spatial structure’, Regional Studies, 44, 535–49. Dilemmas for regional development in the concepts seeking to develop Poland Regional Studies 44 535 49 Google Scholar

BEUKERS, E., BERTOLINI, L. and TE BRÖMMELSTROET, M. (2012), ‘Why cost benefit analysis is perceived as a problematic tool for assessment of transport plans: a process perspective’, Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 46, 68–78. Why cost benefit analysis is perceived as a problematic tool for assessment of transport plans: a process perspective Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 46 68 78 Google Scholar

BOONSTRA, B. and BOELENS, L. (2011), ‘Self-organization in urban development: towards a new perspective on spatial planning’, Urban Research & Practice, 4, 99–122. Self-organization in urban development: towards a new perspective on spatial planning Urban Research & Practice 4 99 122 Google Scholar

COBOUW (2015), Geld te kort voor Grevelingen Volkerak-Zoommeer (Short of Money for Grevelingen Volkerak Zoommeer), www.cobouw.nl/nieuws/financiering/2015/01/20/geld-tekort-grevelingen-volkerrak-zoommeer (accessed 23 July 2015). Google Scholar

D’ADDERIO, L. (2014), ‘The replication dilemma unraveled: how organizations enact multiple goals in routine transfer’, Organization Science, 25, 1325–50. The replication dilemma unraveled: how organizations enact multiple goals in routine transfer Organization Science 25 1325 50 Google Scholar

DAVIES, J. S. and MSENGANA-NDLELA, L. G. (2014), ‘Urban power and political agency: reflections on a study of local economic development in Johannesburg and Leeds’, Cities, 44, 131–38. Urban power and political agency: reflections on a study of local economic development in Johannesburg and Leeds Cities 44 131 38 Google Scholar

DI LUCIA, L., AHLGREN, S. and ERICSSON, K. (2012), ‘The dilemma of indirect land-use changes in EU biofuel policy: an empirical study of policy-making in the context of scientific uncertainty’, Environmental Science & Policy, 16, 9–19. The dilemma of indirect land-use changes in EU biofuel policy: an empirical study of policy-making in the context of scientific uncertainty Environmental Science & Policy 16 9 19 Google Scholar

EDEN, C. (1988), ‘Cognitive mapping’, European Journal of Operational Research, 36, 1–13. Cognitive mapping European Journal of Operational Research 36 1 13 Google Scholar

FLYVBJERG, B. (2006), ‘Five misunderstandings about case-study research’, Qualitative Inquiry, 12, 219–45. Five misunderstandings about case-study research Qualitative Inquiry 12 219 45 Google Scholar

GLASER, B. G. and STRAUSS, A. L. (1967), The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research, Chicago, Aldine Pub. Co. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research Google Scholar

GROOT, J. C., ROSSING, W. A., JELLEMA, A., STOBBELAAR, D. J., RENTING, H. and VAN ITTERSUM, M. K. (2007), ‘Exploring multi-scale trade-offs between nature conservation, agricultural profits and landscape quality: a methodology to support discussions on land-use perspectives’, Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 120, 58–69. Exploring multi-scale trade-offs between nature conservation, agricultural profits and landscape quality: a methodology to support discussions on land-use perspectives Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 120 58 69 Google Scholar

GUALINI, E. and MAJOOR, S. (2007), ‘Innovative practices in large urban development projects: conflicting frames in the quest for “new urbanity”’, Planning Theory & Practice, 8, 297–318. Innovative practices in large urban development projects: conflicting frames in the quest for “new urbanity” Planning Theory & Practice 8 297 318 Google Scholar

HARTMANN, T. and SPIT, T. (2015), ‘Dilemmas of involvement in land management: comparing an active (Dutch) and a passive (German) approach’, Land Use Policy, 42, 729–37. Dilemmas of involvement in land management: comparing an active (Dutch) and a passive (German) approach Land Use Policy 42 729 37 Google Scholar

HÖIJER, B., LIDSKOG, R. and UGGLA, Y. (2006), ‘Facing dilemmas: sense-making and decision-making in late modernity’, Futures, 38, 350–66. Facing dilemmas: sense-making and decision-making in late modernity Futures 38 350 66 Google Scholar

HOLCOMBE, R. G. (2012), ‘Planning and the invisible hand: allies or adversaries?’, Planning Theory, 12, 199–201. Planning and the invisible hand: allies or adversaries? Planning Theory 12 199 201 Google Scholar

HOLDEN, M. (2012), ‘Is integrated planning any more than the sum of its parts? Considerations for planning sustainable cities’, Journal of Planning Education and Research, 32, 305–18. Is integrated planning any more than the sum of its parts? Considerations for planning sustainable cities Journal of Planning Education and Research 32 305 18 Google Scholar

JANSSEN-JANSEN, L., LLOYD, G., PEEL, D., and VAN DER KRABBEN, E. (2013), ‘Planning in an environment without growth’, invited essay for the Raad voor de Leefomgeving en Infrastructuur, RLI, The Hague, www.rli.nl/sites/default/files/u21/essay_rli_planning_in_an_environment_without_growth.pdf (accessed 23 April 2015). Google Scholar

JETTER, A. J., and KOK, K. (2014), ‘Fuzzy cognitive maps for futures studies: a methodological assessment of concepts and methods’, Futures, 61, 45–57. Fuzzy cognitive maps for futures studies: a methodological assessment of concepts and methods Futures 61 45 57 Google Scholar

KEARNEY, A. and KAPLAN, S. (1997), ‘Toward a methodology for the measurement of knowledge structures of ordinary people’, Environment and Behavior, 29, 579–617. Toward a methodology for the measurement of knowledge structures of ordinary people Environment and Behavior 29 579 617 Google Scholar

KO, T. T. and CHANG, Y. C. (2012), ‘An integrated spatial planning model for climate change adaptation in coastal zones’, Ocean & Coastal Management, 66, 36–45. An integrated spatial planning model for climate change adaptation in coastal zones Ocean & Coastal Management 66 36 45 Google Scholar

LEWIS, M. W. (2000), ‘Exploring paradox: toward a more comprehensive guide’, Academy of Management Review, 25, 760–76. Exploring paradox: toward a more comprehensive guide Academy of Management Review 25 760 76 Google Scholar

LOCKE, K. (2001), Grounded Theory in Management Research, London and Thousand Oaks, Sage Publications. Grounded Theory in Management Research Google Scholar

MCLAUGHLIN, R. B. (2012), ‘Land use regulation: where have we been, where are we going?’, Cities, 29, S50–S55. Land use regulation: where have we been, where are we going? Cities 29 S50 S55 Google Scholar

MANTERE, S. and KETOKIVI, M. (2013), ‘Reasoning in organization science’, Academy of Management Review, 38, 70–89. Reasoning in organization science Academy of Management Review 38 70 89 Google Scholar

MINISTERIE VAN INFRASTRUCTUUR EN MILIEU (Ministry of Infrastructure and Environment) (2014), Milieueffectrapport bij de Rijksstructuurvisie Grevelingen en Volkerak-Zoommeer [Environmental Impact Assessment in the Grevelingen Volkerak Zommeer], Den Haag, the Netherlands. Google Scholar

MORONI, S. (2010), ‘Rethinking the theory and practice of land-use regulation: towards nomocracy’, Planning Theory, 9, 137–55. Rethinking the theory and practice of land-use regulation: towards nomocracy Planning Theory 9 137 55 Google Scholar

MOUTER, N., ANNEMA, J. A. and VAN WEE, B. (2013), ‘Attitudes towards the role of cost–benefit analysis in the decision-making process for spatial-infrastructure projects: a Dutch case study’, Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 58, 1–14. Attitudes towards the role of cost–benefit analysis in the decision-making process for spatial-infrastructure projects: a Dutch case study Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 58 1 14 Google Scholar

NEEDHAM, B. (2014), Dutch Land-Use Planning: The Principles and the Practice, Farnham, Ashgate Publishing Ltd. Dutch Land-Use Planning: The Principles and the Practice Google Scholar

NORTHCRAFT, G. B. and TENBRUNSEL, A. E. (2011), ‘Effective matrices, decision frames, and cooperation in volunteer dilemmas: a theoretical perspective on academic peer review’, Organization Science, 22, 1277–85. Effective matrices, decision frames, and cooperation in volunteer dilemmas: a theoretical perspective on academic peer review Organization Science 22 1277 85 Google Scholar

PROJECT TEAM (provinces South Holland, Zeeland, RWS, Municipality Goeree-Overflakkee, Municipality Shouwen-Duiveland) (2013), Getijdencentrale Brouwersdam (Tidal Power Plant Brouwersdam), Den Haag. Google Scholar

RODENBURG, C. A., NIJKAMP, P., DE GROOT, H. L. and VERHOEF, E. T. (2010), ‘Willingness to pay for multifunctional megaprojects: a stated preference analysis among firms in the Amsterdam Zuidas area’, European Planning Studies, 18, 709–35. Willingness to pay for multifunctional megaprojects: a stated preference analysis among firms in the Amsterdam Zuidas area European Planning Studies 18 709 35 Google Scholar

ROE, M. and MELL, I. (2013), ‘Negotiating value and priorities: evaluating the demands of green infrastructure development’, Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 56, 650–73. Negotiating value and priorities: evaluating the demands of green infrastructure development Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 56 650 73 Google Scholar

ROOT, L., VAN DER KRABBEN, E. and SPIT, T. (2014), ‘Bridging the financial gap in climate adaptation: Dutch planning and land development through a new institutional lens’, Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 58, 1–18. Bridging the financial gap in climate adaptation: Dutch planning and land development through a new institutional lens Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 58 1 18 Google Scholar

SACHS, W., DIELEMAN, M., FENDT, J., KAMINSKA-LABBÉ, R., MCKELVEY, B. and THOMAS, C. (2006), ‘Managing dilemmas in organizations: irregular oscillation and coevolving causalities’, Paper presented at EGOS Conference, Bergen, Norway, 7–9 July 2006. Managing dilemmas in organizations: irregular oscillation and coevolving causalities Google Scholar

SAGER, T. (2013), ‘The comprehensiveness dilemma of cost–benefit analysis’, EJTIR, 13, 169–83. The comprehensiveness dilemma of cost–benefit analysis EJTIR 13 169 83 Google Scholar

SALET, W., BERTOLINI, L. and GIEZEN, M. (2013), ‘Complexity and uncertainty: problem or asset in decision making of mega infrastructure projects?’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 37, 1984–2000. Complexity and uncertainty: problem or asset in decision making of mega infrastructure projects? International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 37 1984 2000 Google Scholar

SAVINI, F. (2013), ‘Political dilemmas in peripheral development: investment, regulation, and interventions in metropolitan Amsterdam’, Planning Theory & Practice, 14, 333–48. Political dilemmas in peripheral development: investment, regulation, and interventions in metropolitan Amsterdam Planning Theory & Practice 14 333 48 Google Scholar

SAVINI, F., SALET, W. and MAJOOR, S. (2014), ‘Dilemmas of planning: intervention, regulation, and investment’, Planning Theory, 14, 296–315. Dilemmas of planning: intervention, regulation, and investment Planning Theory 14 296 315 Google Scholar

SCHREYÖGG, G. and SYDOW, J. (2010), ‘Organizing for fluidity? On the dilemmas of new organizational forms’, Organization Science, 21, 1251–62. Organizing for fluidity? On the dilemmas of new organizational forms Organization Science 21 1251 62 Google Scholar

STEELE, W. and RUMING, K. J. (2012), ‘Flexibility versus certainty: unsettling the land-use planning shibboleth in Australia’, Planning Practice and Research, 27, 155–76. Flexibility versus certainty: unsettling the land-use planning shibboleth in Australia Planning Practice and Research 27 155 76 Google Scholar

STOREY, J. and SALAMAN, G. (2010), Managerial Dilemmas: Exploiting Paradox for Strategic Leadership, Chichester, John Wiley & Sons. Managerial Dilemmas: Exploiting Paradox for Strategic Leadership Google Scholar

TURNER, K. G., ODGAARD, M. V., BØCHER, P. K., DALGAARD, T. and SVENNING, J. C. (2014), ‘Bundling ecosystem services in Denmark: trade-offs and synergies in a cultural landscape’, Landscape and Urban Planning, 125, 89–104. Bundling ecosystem services in Denmark: trade-offs and synergies in a cultural landscape Landscape and Urban Planning 125 89 104 Google Scholar

VAN BROEKHOVEN, S., BOONS, F., VAN BUUREN, A. and TEISMAN, G. (2015), ‘Boundaries in action: a framework to analyse boundary actions in multifunctional land-use developments’, Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 33, 1005–23. Boundaries in action: a framework to analyse boundary actions in multifunctional land-use developments Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 33 1005 23 Google Scholar

VAN BUUREN, A., DRIESSEN, P. P., VAN RIJSWICK, M., RIETVELD, P., SALET, W., SPIT, T. and TEISMAN, G. (2013), ‘Towards adaptive spatial planning for climate change: balancing between robustness and flexibility’, Journal for European Environmental & Planning Law, 10, 29–53. Towards adaptive spatial planning for climate change: balancing between robustness and flexibility Journal for European Environmental & Planning Law 10 29 53 Google Scholar

VAN DER KRABBEN, E. and JACOBS, H. M. (2013), ‘Public land development as a strategic tool for redevelopment: reflections on the Dutch experience’ Land Use Policy, 30, 774–83. Public land development as a strategic tool for redevelopment: reflections on the Dutch experience Land Use Policy 30 774 83 Google Scholar

VAN MEERKERK, I., BOONSTRA, B. and EDELENBOS, J. (2013), ‘Self-organization in urban regeneration: a two-case comparative research’, European Planning Studies, 21, 1630–52. Self-organization in urban regeneration: a two-case comparative research European Planning Studies 21 1630 52 Google Scholar

WEICK, K. E. (1995), Sensemaking in Organizations, Volume 3, Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage. Sensemaking in Organizations, Volume 3 Google Scholar

YIN, R. K. (2013), Case Study Research: Design and Methods, Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage Publications. Case Study Research: Design and Methods Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Castaño, Julieta Matos

Hartmann, Timo

Dewulf, Geert