British Journal of Canadian Studies

Between Freedom and Belonging: Ignatieff and Berlin on Nationalism

British Journal of Canadian Studies (2009), 22, (2), 155–175.

Abstract

This article aims to make sense of the apparent incoherencies in Michael Ignatieff's theory of nationalism by first considering how he interprets his mentor's theory of nationalism. Ignatieff was greatly influenced by Isaiah Berlin in his writings on liberalism and nationalism, to the point of mirroring some of his inconsistencies. The resulting discrepancies in the two men's theories arise from a certain tension between liberalism and nationalism that has induced them both to define the latter in terms reflecting the integrity of the former. Understanding Ignatieff's interpretation of Berlin's ideas makes apparent that, in his own work, he draws on Berlin's use of empathy as a method, and on his rejection of violence as a criterion, in distinguishing between fundamental types of nationalism.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Berlin, Isaiah, 1969, 'Two Concepts of Liberty', in Four Essays on Liberty (Oxford: Oxford University Press) www.nyu.edu/projects/nissenbaum/papers/twoconcepts.pdf Google Scholar

Berlin, Isaiah, 1980, 'Benjamin Disraeli, Karl Marx and the Search for Identity', in Against the Current (London: The Hogarth Press), pp. 252–86. Google Scholar

Berlin, Isaiah, 1990, 'The Bent Twig: On the Rise of Nationalism', in The Crooked Timber of Humanity (Princeton: Princeton University Press), pp. 238–62. Google Scholar

Berlin, Isaiah, 2001a, 'The Origins of Israel', in The Power of Ideas (London: Pimlico), pp. 143–61. Google Scholar

Berlin, Isaiah, 2001b, 'Jewish Slavery and Emancipation', in The Power of Ideas (London: Pimlico), pp. 162–85. Google Scholar

Cocks, Joan, 2002, Passion and Paradox (Princeton: Princeton University Press). Passion and Paradox Google Scholar

Diebel, Linda, 2008, 'Ignatieff Apologizes for Israeli War Crime Comment', Toronto Star (14 April), A13. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1984, The Needs of Strangers (New York: Picador). The Needs of Strangers Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1992a, 'Explaining the Referendum to Europeans', Edmonton Journal (30 September), A3. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1992b, 'Lesson for the World', The Ottawa Citizen (21 October), A11. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1992c, 'Why Neo-Nazis are Winning…', Toronto Star (21 November), D5. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1993a, Blood and Belonging (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux). Blood and Belonging Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1993b, 'Bosnia: Atrocity Born in Atrocity, as Crime is in Crime', The Edmonton Journal (1 May), A13. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1993c, 'Boundaries of Pain', New Republic 209:18, 36–9. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1993d, 'Nationalism. An Ugly Twisted Face', The Ottawa Citizen (12 April), A11. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1993e, 'Strange Attachments', New Republic, 208:13 (Spring), 42–6. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1995a, 'Nationalism and the Narcissism of Minor Differences', The Ottawa Citizen (2 July), C1. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1995b, 'On Civil Society', Foreign Affairs, 74:2 (Spring), 128–36. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1997a, 'The Rock of Sages', Times Higher Education Supplement, 1295:20 (29 August). Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1997b, 'Zionism at 100', The New Republic, 217:20, 12–24. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1998a, Isaiah Berlin: A Life (Toronto: Penguin). Isaiah Berlin: A Life Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1998b, 'First Loves', New Yorker, 74:29, 60–75. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 1999b, 'Nationalism and the Narcissism of Minor Differences', in Ronnie Beiner (ed.), Theorizing Nationalism (Albany: State University of New York Press). Nationalism and the Narcissism of Minor Differences Theorizing Nationalism Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2000a, The Rights Revolution (Toronto: House of Anansi Press). The Rights Revolution Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2000b, Virtual War: Kosovo and Beyond (Toronto: Viking). Virtual War: Kosovo and Beyond Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2000c, Nationalism and Self-Determination: Is there an Alternative to Violence? (Colombo: ICES). Nationalism and Self-Determination: Is there an Alternative to Violence? Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2001a, Human Rights as Politics and Idolatry (Princeton: Princeton University Press). Human Rights as Politics and Idolatry Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2001b, 'Lemkin's Word', The Ottawa Citizen (8 April), C6. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2004, Peace, Order and Good Government, OD Skelton Lecture (12 March 2004) http://www.hks.harvard.edu/cchrp/pdf/Skelton.pdf Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2005a, 'The Coming Constitutional Crisis', National Post (16 April), A.19. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2005b. The Challenges Ahead, (1 October) http://www.michaelignatieff.ca/en/about/speeches/903_the-challenges-ahead Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2005c, The Lesser Evil (Princeton: Princeton University Press). The Lesser Evil Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2005d, Law and Politics in the Canadian Constitutional Tradition (15 April) http://www.michaelignatieff.ca/en/about/speeches/901_law-and-politics-in-the-canadian-constitutional-tradition Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2006a, 'Being Equal, as Canadians…', The Globe and Mail (9 November), A25. Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2006b, Agenda for Nation-Building. Available at http://www. politics.ryerson.ca/rubenson/downloads/Ignatieff_book.pdf Google Scholar

Ignatieff, Michael, 2006c, Canada in the World (30 March) http://www. michaelignatieff.ca/en/about/speeches/906_canada-in-the-world Google Scholar

Ipperciel, Donald, forthcoming, 'Ignatieff et le nationalisme québécois', in F. Boily and D. Ipperciel (eds), D'une nation à l'autre: discours nationaux au Canada (in press). Google Scholar

Kymlicka, Will, 1995, Multicultural Citizenship (Oxford: Oxford University Press). Multicultural Citizenship Google Scholar

Long, David, 2006, 'Liberalism, Imperialism, and Empire', Studies in Political Economy, 78, 201–23. 'Liberalism, Imperialism, and Empire' Studies in Political Economy 78 201 23 Google Scholar

Miller, David, 2005, 'Crooked Timber or Bent Twig? Isaiah Berlin's Nationalism', Political Studies, 53, 100–23. 'Crooked Timber or Bent Twig? Isaiah Berlin's Nationalism' Political Studies 53 100 23 Google Scholar

Morgan, Michael Cotey, 2006, 'Michael Ignatieff: Idealism and the Challenge of the "Lesser Evil"', International Journal, 61:4, 971–85. Google Scholar

Parekh, Serena, 2007, 'Resisting "Dull and Torpid" Assent', Human Rights Quarterly, 29:3, 754–8. Google Scholar

Schaefer, Brain, 2005, 'Human Rights: Problems with the Foundationless Approach', Social Theory and Practice, 31:1, 27–50. Google Scholar

Smith, Denis, 2006, Ignatieff 's World: A Liberal Leader for the 21st Century? (Toronto: James Lorimer & Company). Ignatieff 's World: A Liberal Leader for the 21st Century? Google Scholar

Wollheim, Richard, 2001, 'Berlin and Zionism', in Mark Lilla, Ronald Dworkin and Robert B. Silvers (eds), The Legacy of Isaiah Berlin (New York: New York Review of Books). Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Ipperciel, Donald

Woo, Jennifer