Hunter Gatherer Research

Can hunter-gatherers ever ‘get to know’ their prey?

The role of environmental experiences and daily interactions in the formation of human–nonhuman relationships in the British Mesolithic and beyond

Hunter Gatherer Research (2019), 4, (2), 193–226.

Abstract

A growing interest in the ‘animal’ has produced a wealth of studies that move beyond characterisations of nonhumans as materials or objects, to explore their active roles in human lives. Archaeology has produced new accounts of complex social human–nonhuman relationships in the past, emerging through meaningful interactions, engagements and experiences. However, some anthropologists and archaeologists argue that only the close and continual human–nonhuman contact afforded in pastoral settings allows humans to come to understand nonhumans as sentient intentional ‘persons’, and to develop meaningful multispecies relationships. This has important implications for how archaeology interprets human–nonhuman relationships in past hunter-gatherer groups, and the material treatment of nonhumans manifest within the archaeological record.

This paper challenges the assertion that hunter-gatherers cannot come to know nonhumans as ‘persons’. Using archaeological evidence from the British Mesolithic, this paper will consider human understanding of nonhumans as emerging through the material, physical and sensorial experiences and encounters that are the result of humans and nonhuman living within shared environments, which ultimately offered the opportunity to understand specific nonhumans as sentient and intentional ‘persons’. However, this paper does not argue hunter-gatherer relations with nonhumans are analogous with those in pastoral settings. Instead, it argues that approaches which use the conditions of pastoral settings to ‘measure’ hunter-gatherer human–nonhuman relationships, and conceive them as somehow ‘less’, fail to consider these relationships in their own terms. They are not ‘less’. Instead, they are inherently different, and it is necessary to focus on the specificities to enhance future accounts of hunter-gatherer human–nonhuman relationships.

Access Token
£25.00

References

Agamben, G 2004. The open: man and animal. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Google Scholar

Argent, G 2010. Do the clothes make the horse? Relationality, roles and statuses in Iron Age Inner Asia. World Archaeology 42(2):157–174. Google Scholar

Argent, G 2013. Inked: human-horse apprenticeship, tattoos, and time in the Pazyryk world. Society & Animals 21(2):178–193. Google Scholar

Århem, K 1996. The cosmic food web: human-nature relatedness in the Northwest Amazon. In Descola, P & Pálsson, G (eds) Nature and society: anthropological perspectives. London and New York: Routledge:185–204. Google Scholar

Armstrong Oma, K 2010. Between trust and domination: social contracts between humans and animals. World Archaeology 42(2):175–187. Google Scholar

Armstrong Oma, K 2013. Human-animal meeting points: use of space in the household arena in past societies. Society & Animals 21(2):162–177. Google Scholar

Ball, JP & Dahlgren, J 2002. Browsing damage on Pine (Pinus sylvestris and P. contorta) by a migrating moose (Alces alces) population in winter: relation to habitat composition and road barriers. Scandinavian Journal of Forest Research 17(5):427–435. Google Scholar

Bamforth, M, Taylor, M, Pomstra, D, Little, A & Radini, A 2018. Woodworking technology. In Milner, N, Conneller, C & Taylor, B (eds) Star Carr. Vol 2. York: White Rose University Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.22599/book2.n. Google Scholar

Baubet, E, Bonenfant, C & Brandt, S 2004. Diet of the Wild Boar in the French Alps. Galemys 16:107–113. Google Scholar

Bell, M 2007. Prehistoric coastal communities: the Mesolithic in western Britain. Vol 149. York: Council for British Archaeology. Google Scholar

Bird-David, N 2006. Animistic epistemology: why do some hunter-gatherers not depict animals? Ethnos 71(1):33–50. Google Scholar

Borić, D 2007. Images of animality: hybrid bodies and mimesis in early Prehistoric Art. In Renfrew, C & Morley, I (eds) Material beginnings: a global prehistory of figurative representation. Cambridge: McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research:89–105. Google Scholar

Brittain, M & Overton, N 2013. The significance of others: a prehistory of rhythm and interspecies participation. Society and Animals 21:135–150. Google Scholar

Brown, LA & Emery, KF 2008. Negotiations with the animate forest: hunting shrines in the Guatemalan Highlands. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 15(4):300–337. Google Scholar

Brown, RW, Lawrence, MJ & Pope, J 2004. Animals: tracks, trails and signs. London: Bounty Books. Google Scholar

Burns, A 2014. The prehistoric footprints at Formby. Ainsdale: Sefton Coast Landscape Partnership Scheme. Google Scholar

Calarco, M 2008. Zoographies: the question of the animal from Heidegger to Derrida. New York: Colombia University Press. Google Scholar

Cederlund, G, Bergqvist, J, Kjellander, P, Gill, RMA, Gaillard, JM, Boisaubert, B, Ballon, P & Duncan, P 1998. Managing roe deer and their impact on the environment. In Andersen, R, Duncan, P & Linnell, JDC (eds) The European roe deer: the biology of success. Oslo: Scandinavia University Press:337–372. Google Scholar

Cederlund, G, Sandegren, F & Larrson, K 1987. Movement of female moose and dispersal of their offspring. The Journal of Wildlife Management 51(2):342–352. Google Scholar

Chisham, C 2004. Early Mesolithic human activity and environmental change: a case study of the Kennet Valley. Unpublished PhD thesis. Reading: University of Reading. Google Scholar

Clark, JGD 1954. Excavations at Star Carr. An Early Mesolithic site at Seamer near Scarborough, Yorkshire. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar

Clutton-Brock, TH & Albon, SD 1989. Red deer in the Highlands. Oxford: BSP Professional Books. Google Scholar

Clutton-Brock, TH, Guinness, FE & Albon, SD 1982. Red deer: behaviour and ecology of two sexes. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. Google Scholar

Coles, B 2006. Beavers in Britain’s past. Oxford: Oxbow Books. Google Scholar

Conneller, C 2004. Becoming deer. Corporeal transformations at Star Carr. Archaeological Dialogues 11:37–56. Google Scholar

Conneller, C 2012. An archaeology of materials: substantial transformations in early prehistoric Europe. New York: Routledge. Google Scholar

Conneller C & Overton NJ 2018. The British Mesolithic context. In Milner, N, Conneller, C & Taylor, B (eds) Star Carr. Vol 1. York: White Rose University Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.22599/book1.k. Google Scholar

Conneller, C, Bayliss, A, Milner, N & Taylor, B 2016. The resettlement of the British landscape: towards a chronology of Early Mesolithic lithic assemblage types. Internet Archaeology 42. https://intarch.ac.uk/journal/issue42/12/index.html. Google Scholar

Conneller, C, Milner, N, Taylor, B & Taylor, M 2012. Substantial settlement in the European Early Mesolithic: new research at Star Carr. Antiquity 86(334):1004–1020. Google Scholar

da Silva, J, Wooroffe, R & MacDonald, DW 1993. Habitat, food availability and group territoriality in the European badger. Meles meles. Oecologia 95:558–564. Google Scholar

Danilkin, A 1996. Behavioural ecology of Siberian and European roe deer. London: Chapman Hall. Google Scholar

Dardaillon, M 1986. Seasonal variations in habitat selection and spatial distribution of wild boar (Sus scrofa) in the Camargue, Southern France. Behavioural Processes 13:251–268. Google Scholar

Davies, P, Robb, JG & Ladbrook, D 2005. Woodland clearance in the Mesolithic: the social aspects. Antiquity 79(304):280–288. Google Scholar

de Vos, A, Brokx & PAJ & Geist, V 1967. A review of social behaviour of the North American Cervids during the reproductive period. The American Midland Naturalist 77(2):390–417. Google Scholar

D’Earth, RB & Turner, SP 2009. The natural behaviour of the pig. In Marchant-Forde, JN (ed) The welfare of pigs. New York: Springer:15–45. Google Scholar

The Deer Initiative 2008. England and Wales best practice guide. Species ecology: deer signs. www.thedeerinitiative.co.uk/uploads/guides/170.pdf. Google Scholar

De Waal, F 2016. Are we smart enough to know how smart animals are? New York: Norton. Google Scholar

Derrida, J 1998. Of grammatology. Spivak, GC (trans) Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press. Google Scholar

Descola, P 2005. Par-dela Nature et Culture. Paris: Gullimard. Google Scholar

Elliott, B 2012. Antlerworking practices in Mesolithic Britain. Unpublished PhD dissertation. York: University of York. Google Scholar

Elliott, B 2015. Facing the chop: redefining British antler mattocks to consider larger-scale maritime networks in the early fifth millennium cal BC. European Journal of Archaeology 18(2):222–244. Google Scholar

Ellis, CJ, Allen, MJ, Gardiner, J, Harding, P, Ingrem, C, Powell, A & Scaife, RG 2003. An Early Mesolithic seasonal hunting site in the Kennet Valley, Southern England. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 69:107–135. Google Scholar

Evans, JG 1975. The environment of early man in the British Isles. London: Paul Elek. Google Scholar

Fausto, C 2007. Feasting on people. eating animals and humans in Amazonia. Current Anthropology 48(4):497–530. Google Scholar

Garrow, D & Sturt, F 2011. Grey waters bright with Neolithic argonauts? Maritime connections and the Mesolithic–Neolithic transition within the ‘western seaways’ of Britain, c.5000–3500 BC. Antiquity 85(327):59–72. Google Scholar

Geist, V 1963. On the behaviour of the North American moose (alces alces andersoni Peterson 1950) in British Colombia. Behaviour 20 (3/4):377–416. Google Scholar

Geist, V 1998. Deer of the world: their evolution, behaviour and ecology. Mechaniesburg: Stackpole. Google Scholar

Gill, RMA & Beardall, V 2001. The impact of red deer on woodlands: the effects of browsing and seed dispersal on vegetation structure and composition. Forestry 74(3):209–218. Google Scholar

Halsey, C 2006. The former Sanderson site, Oxford Road, Denham, UB9, county of Buckinghamshire: an archaeological post-excavation assessment and updated project design. London: Museum of London Archaeology Service. Google Scholar

Haraway, D 2003. The companion species manifesto: dogs, people and significant otherness. Chicago: Prickly Paradigm Press. Google Scholar

Haraway, D 2008. When species meet. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. Google Scholar

Harris, K 2014. Hunting, performance and incorporation: human–deer encounter in Late Bronze Age Crete. In Sykes, N, Baker, N, Carden, R & Madgwick, R (eds) Deer and people. Oxford: Windgather Press:48–58. Google Scholar

Helander-Renvall, E 2010. Animism, personhood and the nature of reality: Sami perspectives. Polar Record 46(236):44–56. Google Scholar

Hewison, AJM, Vincent, JP & Reby, D 1998. Social organisation of European roe deer. In Andersen, R, Duncan, P & Linnell, JDC (eds) The European roe deer: the biology of success. Oslo: Scandinavia University Press:189–219. Google Scholar

Hill, E 2011. Animals as agents: hunting ritual and relational ontologies in prehistoric Alaska and Chukotta. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 21(3):467–426. Google Scholar

Ingold, T 1994. What is an animal? London: Routledge Google Scholar

Ingold, T 1996. Hunting and gathering as ways of perceiving the environment. In Ellen, RF & Fukui, K (eds) Redefining nature: ecology, culture, and domestication. London: Berg:117–155. Google Scholar

Ingold, T 2000. The perception of the environment: essays on livelihood, dwelling and skill. London and New York: Routledge. Google Scholar

Jones, P 2009. Considering living-beings in the aceramic Neolithic of Cyprus. Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology 22(1):75–99. Google Scholar

Jordan, PD 2001. Cultural landscapes in colonial Siberia: Khanty settlements of the sacred, the living and the dead. Landscapes 2(2):83–105. Google Scholar

Jordan, PD 2008. Northern landscapes, northern minds: on the trail of an ‘archaeology of hunter-gatherer belief’. In Hays-Gilpin, K & Whitley, DS (eds) Belief in the past: theoretical approaches to the archaeology of religion. Walnut Creek: Left Coast Press:227–246. Google Scholar

Kamler, JF, Jedrzejewski, W & Jedrzejewska, B 2008. Home ranges of red deer in a European old growth forest. The American Midland Naturalist 159:75–82. Google Scholar

Kitchener, A 2001. Beavers. Stowmarket: Whittet Books. Google Scholar

Knight, J 2005. Introduction. In Knight, J (ed) Animals in person: cultural perspectives on human–animal intimacies. Oxford and New York: Berg:1–13. Google Scholar

Knight, J 2012. The anonymity of the hunt: a critique of hunting as sharing. Current Anthropology 53(3):334–355. Google Scholar

Lewis, J & Rackham, J 2011. Three Ways Wharf, Uxbridge: a late glacial and Early Holocene hunter-gatherer site in the Colne valley. London: Museum of London Archaeology. Google Scholar

Little, A, Elliott, B, Conneller, C, Pomstra, D, Evans, AA, Fitton, LC, Holland, A, Davis, R, Kershaw, R, O’Connor, S & O’Connor, T 2016. Technological analysis of the world’s earliest shamanic costume: a multi-scalar, experimental study of a red deer headdress from the Early Holocene site of Star Carr, North Yorkshire, UK. PloS One 11(4). Google Scholar

Lloyd, HG 1980. Habitat requirements of the Red Fox. In Zimen, E (ed) The red fox: symposium of behaviour and ecology, The Hauge: Junk BV:7–25. Google Scholar

Massei, G & Genov, PV 2004. The environmental impact of wild boar. Galemys 16:135–145. Google Scholar

Mayle, BA, Putman, RJ & Wyllie, I 2000. The use of trackway counts to establish an index of deer presence. Mammal Review 30(3):233–237. Google Scholar

Mech, LD and Boitani, L 2003. Wolf social ecology. In Mech, LD & Boitani, L (eds) Wolves: behaviour, ecology and conservation. Chicago: University of Chicago Press:1–35. Google Scholar

Mills, EA 1913. In beaver world. Boston and New York: Riverside Press Cambridge. Google Scholar

Milner, N, Bamforth, M, Beale, G, Carty, J, Chatzipanagis, K, Croft, S, Conneller, C, Elliott, B, Fitton, L, Knight, B, Kroger, R, Little, A, Needham, A, Panter, I, Robson, H, Rowley, C & Taylor, B 2016. A unique, engraved pendant from the Early Mesolithic site of Star Carr: the oldest Mesolithic art in Britain. Internet Archaeology 40. http://dx.doi.org/10.11141/ia.40.8. Google Scholar

Mitchell, B & Grant, W 1981. Notes on the performance of red deer, Cervus elaphus, in woodland habitat. Journal of Zoology London 194:279–284. Google Scholar

Monterroso, P, Brito, JC, Ferreras, P & Alves, PC 2009. Spatial ecology of the European Wildcat in a Mediterranean ecosystem: dealing with small radio-tracking datasets in species conservation. Journal of Zoology 279:27–35. Google Scholar

Moore, J 2000. Forest fire and human interaction in the Early Holocene woodlands of Britain. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 164:125–137. Google Scholar

Nadasdy, P 2007. The gift of the animal: the ontology of hunting and human–animal sociality. American Ethnologist 34(1):25–43. Google Scholar

Neal, EG 1977. Badgers. Poole: Blanford Press. Google Scholar

Nuttall, M 2000. Becoming a hunter in Greenland. Etudes/Inuit/Studies 24(2):33–45. Google Scholar

Overton, NJ 2014. Memorable meetings in the Mesolithic: tracing the biography of human–nonhuman relationships in the Kennet and Colne valleys with social zooarchaeology. Unpublished PhD thesis. Manchester: University of Manchester. Google Scholar

Overton, NJ 2016. More than skin deep: reconsidering isolated remains of ‘fur-bearing species’ in the British and European Mesolithic. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 26(4):561–578. Google Scholar

Overton, NJ 2018. The rhythm of life: exploring the role of daily and seasonal rhythms in the development of human–nonhuman relationships in the British Early Mesolithic. In Pilaar Birch, SE (ed) Multispecies archaeology. New York: Routledge:295–309. Google Scholar

Overton, NJ & Hamilakis, Y 2013. A manifesto for a social zooarchaeology. Swans and other beings in the Mesolithic. Archaeological Dialogues 20(2):111–136. Google Scholar

Paulson, I 1968. The preservation of animal bones in the hunting rites of some North-Eurasian peoples. Popular beliefs and folklore traditions in Siberia. The Hague: Mouton:448–451. Google Scholar

Pedersen, MA 2001. Totemism, animism and North Asian indigenous ontologies. The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 7(3):411–427. Google Scholar

Pereboom, V, Mergey, M, Villerette, N, Helder, R, Gerard, JF & Lode, T 2008. Movement patterns, habitat selection and corridor use of a typical woodland-dweller, the European Pine Marten (Martes martes) in fragmented landscape. Canadian Journal of Zoology 86:983–991. Google Scholar

Pollard, J 2017. Substantial and significant pits in the Mesolithic of Britain and adjacent regions. Hunter Gatherer Research 3(1):165–184. Google Scholar

Quenette, PY & Gerard, JF 1992. From individual to collective vigilance in wild boar (Sus scrofa). Canadian Journal of Zoology 70:1632–1635. Google Scholar

Reynolds, EE 1942. A book of Grey Owl. Pages from the writings of Wa-Sha-Quon-Asin. London: Peter Davies. Google Scholar

Roberts, AJ, Barton, RNE & Evans, JG 1998. The Early Mesolithic mastic radiocarbon dating and analysis of organic residues from Thatcham III, Star Carr and Lackford Heath. In Ashton, NM, Healy, F & Pettie, PB (eds) Stone Age archaeology: essays in honour of John Wymer. Lithics Studies Occasional Paper 6, Oxbow Monograph 102. Oxford: Oxbow Books:185–192. Google Scholar

Roberts, G 2009. Ephemeral, subfossil mammalian, avian and hominid footprints within Flandrian sediment exposures at Formby Point, Sefton coast, North West England. Ichnos 16(1–2):33–48. Google Scholar

Simmons, IG 2001. Ecology into landscape: some English moorlands in the Later Mesolithic. Landscapes 2:42–55. Google Scholar

Spitz, F & Janeau, G 1995. Daily selection of habitat in wild boar (Sus scrofa). Journal of Zoology London 237:423–434. Google Scholar

Sturt, F, Garrow, D, & Bradley, S 2013. New models of North West European Holocene palaeogeography and inundation. Journal of Archaeological Science 40(11):3963–3976. Google Scholar

Taylor, M, Bamforth, M, Robson, H, Watson, C, Little, A, Pomstra, D, Milner, N, Carty, J, Colonese, A, Lucquin, A & Allen, S 2018. The wooden artefacts. In Milner, N, Conneller, C & Taylor, B (eds) Star Carr. Vol 2. York: White Rose University Press. Google Scholar

Truve, J & Lemel, J 2003. Timing and distance of natal dispersal for wild boar Sus scrofa in Sweden. Wildlife Biology 9:51–57. Google Scholar

van Vuure, T 2002. History, morphology and ecology of the Aurochs (Bos primigenius). Lutra 45(1):1–16. Google Scholar

Vera, FWM 2000. Grazing ecology and forest history. Wallingford: CABI Publishing. Google Scholar

Viveiros de Castro, V 1998. Cosmological dexis and Amerindian perspectivism. The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 4(3):469–488. Google Scholar

Waddington, C, Bailey, G, Boomer, I, Milner, N, Pederson, K, Shiel, R & Stevenson, T 2003. A Mesolithic settlement at Howick, Northumberland. Antiquity 77(295):198–204. Google Scholar

Welander, J 2000. Spatial and temporal dynamics of wild boar (Sus scrofa): rooting in a mosaic landscape. The Zoology Society of London 252:263–271. Google Scholar

Whitridge, P 2013. The imbrication of human and animal paths: an Arctic case study. In Watts, C (ed) Relational archaeologies: humans, animals, things. New York: Routledge:228–244. Google Scholar

Willerslev, R 2004. Not animal, not not animal: hunting, imitation and empathetic knowledge among the Siberian Yukaghirs. The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 10(3):629–652. Google Scholar

Wolfe, C 2003. Introduction. In Wolfe, C (ed) Zoontologies: the question of the animal. Minneapolis and London: University of Minnesota Press:ix–xxiii. Google Scholar

Woodman, P 1985. Excavations at Mount Sandel, 1973–77, County Londonderry. Belfast: HM Stationery Office. Google Scholar

Wymer, JJ 1962. Excavations at the Maglemosian sites at Thatcham, Berkshire, England. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 28:329–361. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Overton, Nick J