Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

Te Upoko o Mata’oho(Mangere Mountain): The Performative Tensions of a Living Museum

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2010), 99, (1), 55–70.

Abstract

The development of an education centre in the early 1980s as a living museum at Mangere, South Auckland, Aotearoa (New Zealand), began with the purpose of enabling members of the local tribal group, or iwi, to tell their own stories about work, being and colonisation. It was to reflect their ongoing struggle to be able to live and work as recognised as iwi, to talk and show, in a living form, how their ancestors grew crops, lived and sustained family relationships, whanaungatanga. The story of the living museum shows how their important beliefs, their tikanga, and their rights under the Treaty of Waitangi create tensions for local government policy and the civic development of Auckland. The market-based approaches and procedures of local government in the twenty-first century do not readily accommodate collective ways and Maori process. This paper examines the ways that this community volunteer-based organisation, grounded in principles of reciprocity and collectivity, has been shaped, through performative requirements, as a market-modelled organisation.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Endnotes

1.According to local elder,Maurice Wilson(personal communication, April2010), Te Upoko o Mata’oho, meaning the sacred head ofMata’oho, is their name which denotes the sacredness of the mountain. Other names used by government officials and local people includeTe Pane o Mata’oho(the head of Mata’oho) andTe Maunga o Mata’oho(Mata’oho’s Mountain). Google Scholar

2.Ewan Cameron,Bruce Hayward andGraeme Murdoch, A Field Guide to Auckland: Exploring the Region’s Natural and Historic Heritage,Godwit,, 2008;Ian Lawlor, Cultural Heritage Inventory: A Scoping Exercise for the Auckland Region,Auckland Regional Council,, 1991;Susan Bulmer,Prehistoric Polynesian Gardens at Wiri, paper presented to the International Congress of Archaeological and Ethnological Sciences,Vancouver, 1983. Google Scholar

3.Joce Jesson, ‘Community meets university on Mangere Mountain’, inJ. Jesson,V. Carpenter,M. McLean,M. Stephenson andAirini(eds), University Teaching Reconsidered: Justice, Practice, Inquiry,Dunmore Publishing Ltd,, 2010, pp.60-68. Google Scholar

4.Leonard Bell, Colonial Constructs: European Images of Maori 1840-1914,Auckland University Press,, 1992. Google Scholar

5.Conal McCarthy, Exhibiting Maori: A History of Colonial Cultures of Display,Te Papa Press,, 2007. Google Scholar

6.Peter Davis, Ecomuseums: A Sense of Place,Leicester University Press,, 1999. Google Scholar

7.Russell Jacoby, Social Amnesia: A Critique of Conformist Psychology from Adler to Laing,Harvester Press,, 1979, p.5. Google Scholar

8.This amnesia also extends to otherMaori. In 2003, rather than go through the lengthy reconciliation process of the Waitangi Tribunal, Ngati Whatuachose to enter into direct negotiations with the Crown for a claim to large parts of Tamaki Makaurau (Auckland). The Crown personally knew their negotiators, and gaveNgati Whatuathe nod ahead of the other claimant groups. However, the draft settlement precipitated an emergency hearing of the Waitangi Tribunal. Justice Carrie Wainwright, in a lengthy report, recommended that Tamaki Makaurau Settlement be put on hold until the claims of all of the other claimant groups had been heard. She remarked the Crown Process of direct negotiation now shifted from being about reconciliation but had become a process of picking winners, New Zealand Herald, 16June2007. Accessed 28 June 2010 atww.nzherald.co.nz/treaty-of-waitangi/news/article.cfm?c_id=350&objectid=10445984&pnum=0. Google Scholar

9.The boundary crossing between Museum Studies and Labour History was the subject of a special thematic issue ofLabour History, no.85, November2003. That volume presents five in-depth articles on this subject. SeeBobbie Oliver andAndrew Reeves, ‘Crossing disciplinary boundaries: labour history and museum studies’, Labour History, no.85, November2003, pp.1-8. Accessed 23 March 2010 athttp://www.historycooperative.org/journals/lab/85/oliver.html. Google Scholar

10.Charles Fleming, ‘Hochstetter, Dr Ferdinand Ritter Von’, inA.H. McLintock(ed.), An Encyclopedia of New Zealand, 1966. Accessed 15 December 2009 atwww.teara.govt.nz/en/1966. Google Scholar

11.Ahukaramū Charles Royal, ‘Papatūānuku — the land — whakapapa and kaupapa’, inTe Ara: The Encyclopedia of New Zealand, updated1March2009. Accessed 10 January 2010 athttp://www.TeAra.govt.nz/en/papatuanuku-the-land/8. Google Scholar

12.For a comprehensive discussion of this history, seePaul Moon, The Struggle for Tamaki Makaurau: The Maori Occupation of Auckland to 1820,David Ling,, 2007. Google Scholar

13.Waiohua(andNga Tai, a relatediwi)continue to make representations to every council and government plan change through rights gained through the Resource Management Act 1991, seeking recognition of their existence and their spiritual knowledge. One of the latest was their successful appeal along with other local groups to the Environment Court, (2010) NZEnvC 211, Judgment 22 June 2010 against the proposed Manukau City Council plan change to enable a Marine Village development. This was on one of the estuaries they regard as part of theirwhakapapa. Google Scholar

14.William Hobson,James Busby andJames Stuart Freeman, ‘The Treaty of Waitangi printed in 1845’and‘Governor (1839-1841: Hobson)’, inThe Treaty of Waitangi,,New Zealand Electronic Text Centre. Accessed 10 December 2009 athttp://www.nzetc.org/tm/scholarly/name-122436.html. Google Scholar

15.Ibid. Google Scholar

16.Much of the social amnesia is generated in schools, where teachers’ lack of knowledge, fear or conservatism results in the promotion of a colonial view of history; the ‘NZ standard story’. SeeTamsin Hanly, Preparing students for a bicultural relationship: Pakeha primary teachers and histories of Aotearoa, MA thesis,Faculty of Education, University of Auckland2007, especially ch. 7, pp.150-70. Google Scholar

17.Hazel Petrie, ‘Maori enterprise; ships and flour mills’, inI. Hunter,D. Morrow,H. Petrie, City of Enterprise: Perspectives on Auckland Business History,Auckland University Press,, 2006, p.37. Google Scholar

18.Ibid. Google Scholar

19.Ibid, p.229. Google Scholar

20.P. Goldsmith andM. Bassett, Puketutu and its People,David Ling,, 2008. Google Scholar

21.Letters to his father,J.L. Campbell, 1841, cited inR.C.J. Stone, Makers of Fortune: A Colonial Business Community and its Fall,Auckland University Press,, 1973, p.45. Google Scholar

22.K. Sinclair, A History of New Zealand,Penguin Books,, 1959. Google Scholar

23.Pei Te Hurinui Jones, Nga Iwi o Tainui: Nga Koorero Tuku Iho a Nga Tuupuna: The Traditional History of the Tainui People,Bruce Biggs(ed. and trans.),Auckland University Press,, 2004. Google Scholar

24.John Elsdon Gorst, The Maori King, or The Story of our Quarrel with the Natives of New Zealand,Paul’s Book Arcade,, 1959(1864). Google Scholar

25.Ibid. Google Scholar

26.The Waitangi Tribunal, Report of the Waitangi Tribunal on the Manukau Claim (WAI-8),,Waitangi Tribunal, Department of Justice, 1985. Accessed 2 December 2008 atwww.waitangitribunal.govt.nz/scripts/reports/reports/8/7FFC574E-B152-435D-8FD8-5EAFE075D839.pdf. Google Scholar

27.The manyMaori-Chinese families around Auckland, some which date back to these market garden relationships, are the subject of two recent books,Jenny Bol Jun Lee, Jade Taniwha: Māori-Chinese Identity and Schooling in Aotearoa,Rautaki Ltd,, 2007(which focuses particularly on aTe Waiohualinked family); andManying Ip(ed.), The Dragon and the Taniwha: Māori and Chinese in New Zealand,Auckland University Press,, 2009, which has a wider focus. However, much of the literature about the history of market-gardens around Auckland takes the land ownership question for granted and so renders underlying tensions and struggles invisible. Google Scholar

28.Joan Metge, Rautahi: The Maoris of New Zealand,Routledge,, 2004. Google Scholar

29.Bradon Ellem andPeter Franks, ‘Trade union structure and politics in Australia and New Zealand’, Labour History, no. 95, 2008, pp.43-67. Google Scholar

30.The Official Website of Waikato-Tainui, Background to Raupatu. Accessed 10 January 2008 atwww.tainui.co.nz, 2008. See alsoT. van Meijl, ‘The Maori King Movement: unity and diversity in past and present’,Bijdragen tot de Taal, Landen Volkenkunde, Politics, Tradition and Change in the Pacific, vol.149, no. 4, 1993, pp.673-89. Google Scholar

31.Karl Polanyi, The Great Transformation,Beacon Press,, 1944, p.68. Google Scholar

32.Ibid, p.140. Google Scholar

33.SeeJames Belich, Replenishing the Earth: The Settler Revolution and the Rise of the Anglo-World, 1783-1939,Oxford University Press,, 2009;Chris Rudd andBrian S. Roper(eds), The Political Economy of New Zealand,Oxford University Press,, 1997;Brian S. Roper andChris Rudd(eds), State and Economy in New Zealand,Oxford University Press,, 1993;Mike O’Brien andChris Wilkes, The Tragedy of the Market: A Social Experiment in New Zealand,Dunmore Press,, 1993;Miles Fairburn, The Ideal Society and its Enemies: The Foundations of Modern New Zealand Society, 1850-1900,Auckland University Press,, 1989. Google Scholar

34.Michael Burawoy, ‘From Polanyi to Pollyanna: the false optimism of global labor studies’, Global Labour Journal, vol.1, no. 2, 2010, pp.301-13. Google Scholar

35.For example,Richard Hill, State Authority, Indigenous Autonomy: Crown-Maori Race Relations in New Zealand/Aotearoa, 1900-1950,Victoria University Press,, 2004;Richard Hill, Maori and the State: Crown-Maori relations in New Zealand/Aotearoa, 1950-2000,Victoria University Press,, 2009;R. Boast andR. Hill, Raupatu: The Confiscation of Maori land,Victoria University Press,, 2009;Andrew Sharp, Justice and the Maori: The Philosophy and Practice of Maori Claims in New Zealand since the 1970s(2nd edn),Oxford University Press,, 1997. Google Scholar

36.James Belich andLydia Wevers, withRichard Hill andBrigitte BönischBrednich, ‘Understanding New Zealand Cultural Identities’, discussion paper prepared by the Stout Research Centre for New Zealand Studies, Victoria University of Wellington, for the Ministry of Culture and Heritage, 2008. Google Scholar

37.Janine Hayward(ed.), Local Government and the Treaty of Waitangi,Oxford University Press,, 2003. Google Scholar

38. Waitangi Tribunal (Wai-8), Section 06, pp.61, 62. Google Scholar

39.Manuka Henare, ‘Tapu, Mana, Mauri, Hau, Wairua: A Maori philosophy of vitalism and cosmos’, inJohn A. Grim(ed.), Indigenous Traditions and Ecology: The Interbeing of Cosmology and Community,Center for the Study of World Religions, Harvard Divinity School, distributed by Harvard Press,, 2001, pp.197-221. Google Scholar

40.Manukau City Council Governance Structures, downloaded10August2010atwww.tomorrowsmanukau.co.nz/how/governance.html. Google Scholar

41.Robert Joseph,Denial, Acknowledgement and Peace Building through Reconciliatory Justice, August2001. Accessed 20 February 2010 athttp://lianz.waikato.ac.nz/PAPERS/Rob/Denial.pdf. Google Scholar

42.Mahia Wilson, Korero about Mangere, personal conversations with author (1989-2008).Mahia Wilson passed away inJanuary2008. Google Scholar

44.Bruce Jesson, Only Their Purpose is Mad: The Money Men Take Over New Zealand,Dunmore Press,, 1999. Google Scholar

45.Hayward, Local Government and the Treaty. Google Scholar

46.Ibid., p.5. Google Scholar

48.www.moh.govt.nz/primaryhealthcare. Google Scholar

49.Stephen Ball, ‘The teacher’s soul and the terrors of performativity’, Journal of Education Policy, vol.18, 2003, pp.215-28. Google Scholar

50.Frank Coffield(ed.), The Necessity of Informal Learning,Policy Press,, 2000. Google Scholar

51.Mani Barr(with input fromIan Lawlor,Dave Veart,Maurice Wilson andSaul Roberts), I Nga Ra o Mua: In the Old Days: Stories about the Mountain,Mangere Mountain Education Centre,, 2006. Google Scholar

52.Metge, Rautahi. Google Scholar

53.Joce Jesson, ‘Community education’, inM. Thrupp andR. Irwin(eds), Another Decade of Change in Education: Where to Now?,Wilf Malcolm Institute of Educational Research,, forthcoming2010. Google Scholar

54.Personal communication, 2007. Google Scholar

55.Jesson, ‘Community education’. Google Scholar

56.Minutes of the Mangere Mountain Education Trust, 2003-08, personal collection. Google Scholar

58.Waikato-Tainui Te Kauhanganui Incorporated (WTTKI) manages and distributes income for the collective benefit of approximately 57,000+ registered Waikato-Tainui tribal members from that settlement. Website for Waikato Tainui Corporation (WTTKI) accessed 4 January 2010 atwww.tainui.co.nz/companyprofile/currentdevelopments.html. Google Scholar

59.Elizabeth Rata, ‘The rise and rise of the neo-tribal elite’,Summer Sounds Symposium, Marlborough Sounds,, 2005. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Jesson, Joce