Identifying and conceptualising context-specific barriers to transit-oriented development strategies: the case of the Netherlands

Tan, Wendy; Bertolini, Luca; Janssen-Jansen, Leonie; Tan, Wendy; Bertolini, Luca; Janssen-Jansen, Leonie

doi:https://doi.org/10.3828/tpr.2014.38

Town Planning Review (2014), 85, (5), 639–663.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3828/tpr.2014.38
Language: English
Pages: 25

Abstract

Transit-oriented development strategies (TODS) are widely embraced. However, their implementation remains challenging. Institutional barriers play a key role here, and the literature provides an overview of the most important ones and ways of overcoming them. Yet, application of such insights remains elusive, due to the context-specific nature of barriers. As a first and necessary step to cope with the implementation challenge of TODS, this paper proposes an approach to identify barriers within a given context. The approach is applied to a hypothesis-generating case, the Netherlands. The findings indicate a vicious cycle of mutually reinforcing formal and informal barriers hampering implementation. The approach could be useful for cities elsewhere that face similar implementation difficulties.

FormatArticle

£25.00

READ THIS ARTICLE

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

AL-DUBIKHI, S. and MEES, P. (2010), ‘Bus rapid transit in Ottawa, 1978 to 2008: assessing the results’, Town Planning Review, 81, 407-24. ‘Bus rapid transit in Ottawa, 1978 to 2008: assessing the results’ Town Planning Review 81 407 24 Google Scholar

AYRES, S. and PEARCE, G. (2004), ‘Devolution to the English regions: assessing its implications for transport’, Town Planning Review, 75, 231-55. ‘Devolution to the English regions: assessing its implications for transport’ Town Planning Review 75 231 55 Google Scholar

BANISTER, D. (1998), ‘Barriers to the implementation of urban sustainability’, International Journal of Environment and Pollution, 10, 65-83. ‘Barriers to the implementation of urban sustainability’ International Journal of Environment and Pollution 10 65 83 Google Scholar

BANISTER, D. (2004), ‘Overcoming barriers to the implementation of sustainable transport’, in P. Rietveld and R. Stough (eds), Barriers to Sustainable Transport: Institutions, Regulation and Sustainability, Oxford: Taylor & Francis, 54-68. Barriers to Sustainable Transport: Institutions, Regulation and Sustainability 54 68 Google Scholar

BANISTER, D. (2005), Unsustainable Transport: City Transport in the New Century, London, Routledge. Unsustainable Transport: City Transport in the New Century Google Scholar

BARTHOLOMEW, K. (2007), ‘Land use transportation scenario planning: promise and reality’, Transportation, 34, 397-412. ‘Land use transportation scenario planning: promise and reality’ Transportation 34 397 412 Google Scholar

BERTOLINI, L. (2000), ‘Planning in the borderless city: a conceptualisation and an application to the case of station area redevelopment’, Town Planning Review, 71, 455-74. ‘Planning in the borderless city: a conceptualisation and an application to the case of station area redevelopment’ Town Planning Review 71 455 74 Google Scholar

BERTOLINI, L., CURTIS, C. and RENNE, J. (2012), ‘Station area projects in Europe and beyond: towards transit oriented development?’, Built Environment, 38, 31-50. ‘Station area projects in Europe and beyond: towards transit oriented development?’ Built Environment 38 31 50 Google Scholar

BPZ (BESTUURLIJK PLATFORM ZUIDVLEUGEL) (2007), Ruimtelijke Ambitie Stedenbaan 2020, Den Haag, Bestuurlijk Platform Zuidvleugel. Google Scholar

BRUIL, A. W. and BRUIL, I. (2004), Integrale Gebiedsontwikkeling, Amsterdam, Uitgeverij SUN. Integrale Gebiedsontwikkeling Google Scholar

BRYMAN, A. (2004), Social Research Methods, Oxford, Oxford University Press. Social Research Methods Google Scholar

CBS (CENTRAAL BUREAU VOOR DE STATISTIEK) (2010), Mobiliteit Nederlandse Bevolking, Motief, Vervoerwijze, 1985-2007, Heerlen, CBS. http://statline.cbs.nl Google Scholar

CERVERO, R. (1998), The Transit Metropolis: A Global Inquiry, Washington, DC, Island Press. The Transit Metropolis: A Global Inquiry Google Scholar

CLIFFORD, S., BLACKLEDGE, D., MAY, T., JOPSON, A., SESSA, C. and HAON, S. (2005), DELIVERABLE 11: Final Report, 1-64. http://www.iuav.it/Ateneo1/docenti/…/lettura-6-LUTR-Final_Report.pdf Google Scholar

CURTIS, C. (2008), ‘Planning for sustainable accessibility: the implementation challenge’, Transport Policy, 15, 104-12. ‘Planning for sustainable accessibility: the implementation challenge’ Transport Policy 15 104 12 Google Scholar

CURTIS, C., RENNE, J. and BERTOLINI, L. (2009), Transit Oriented Development: Making it Happen, Farnham, Ashgate. Transit Oriented Development: Making it Happen Google Scholar

DITTMAR, H. and OHLAND, G. (2004), The New Transit Town: Best Practices in Transit-Oriented Development, Washington, DC, Island Press. The New Transit Town: Best Practices in Transit-Oriented Development Google Scholar

DUMBAUGH, E. (2004), ‘Overcoming financial and institutional barriers to TOD: Lindbergh Station case study’, Journal of Public Transportation, 7, 43-70. ‘Overcoming financial and institutional barriers to TOD: Lindbergh Station case study’ Journal of Public Transportation 7 43 70 Google Scholar

FILION, P. and MCSPURREN, K. (2007), ‘Smart growth and development reality: the difficult co-ordination of land use and transport objectives, Urban Studies, 44, 501-24. ‘Smart growth and development reality: the difficult co-ordination of land use and transport objectives Urban Studies 44 501 24 Google Scholar

FRANCKE, J. (2010), Verkenning Mobiliteit en Bereikbaarheid 2011-2015, Den Haag, Minsterie van Verkeer en Waterstaat. Verkenning Mobiliteit en Bereikbaarheid 2011-2015 Google Scholar

GEERLINGS, H. and STEAD, D. (2003), ‘The integration of land use planning, transport and environment in European policy and research’, Transport Policy, 10, 187-96. ‘The integration of land use planning, transport and environment in European policy and research’ Transport Policy 10 187 96 Google Scholar

HESS, D. B. and LOMBARDI, P. A. (2004), ‘Policy support for and barriers to transit-oriented development in the inner city: literature review’, Transportation Research Record, 1887, 26-33. ‘Policy support for and barriers to transit-oriented development in the inner city: literature review’ Transportation Research Record 1887 26 33 Google Scholar

HULL, A. (2008), ‘Policy integration: what will it take to achieve more sustainable transport solutions in cities?’, Transport Policy, 15, 94-103. ‘Policy integration: what will it take to achieve more sustainable transport solutions in cities?’ Transport Policy 15 94 103 Google Scholar

HULL, A. (2010), Transport Matters: Integrated Approaches to Planning City-Regions, London, Routledge. Transport Matters: Integrated Approaches to Planning City-Regions Google Scholar

IENM (MINISTERIE VAN INFRASTRUCTUUR EN MILIEU) (2012), Structuurvisie Infrastructuur en Ruimte, Den Haag, Ministerie van Infrastructuur en Milieu. Google Scholar

JANSSEN-JANSEN, L. and SMIT, N. (2013), ‘Visie versus vraag: over de TOD-maakbaarheidsutopie’, in W. Tan, H. Koster and M. Hoogerbrugge (eds), Knooppuntontwikkeling in Nederland, Den Haag, Platform31, 43-54. Knooppuntontwikkeling in Nederland 31 Google Scholar

JANSSEN-JANSEN, L. B., VAN DER KRABBEN, E., PEEL, D. and LLOYD, M. G. (2012), Planning In An Environment Without Growth, The Hague, Raad voor de leefomgeving en infrastructuur (Rli). Planning In An Environment Without Growth Google Scholar

JORRITSMA, P., BAKKER, P., BERVELING, J., DERRIKS, H., FRANCKE, J., GORDIJN, H., GROOT, W., HOEN, A., KANSEN, M., KORTEWEG, J. A., VAN DER LOOP, H., SAVELBERG, F. and WOUTERS, P. (2010), Mobiliteitsbalans 2010, 1-140, Den Haag, Minsterie van Verkeer en Waterstaat. Mobiliteitsbalans 2010 1 140 Google Scholar

KORTEWEG, J. A. (2007), Dutch Mobility Policy Document in a European Context, Den Haag: Netherlands Institute for Transport Policy Analysis (KiM). Dutch Mobility Policy Document in a European Context Google Scholar

LIJPHART, A. (1971), ‘Comparative politics and the comparative method’, American Political Science Review, 65, 682-93. ‘Comparative politics and the comparative method’ American Political Science Review 65 682 93 Google Scholar

MADANIPOUR, A. (2001), ‘How relevant is "planning by neighbourhoods" today?’, The Town Planning Review, 72, 171-91. ‘How relevant is "planning by neighbourhoods" today?’ The Town Planning Review 72 171 91 Google Scholar

MAJOOR, S. (2008), Disconnected Innovations: New Urbanity in Large-Scale Development Projects: Zuidas Amsterdam, Ørestad Copenhagen and Forum Barcelona, Delft, Eburon. Disconnected Innovations: New Urbanity in Large-Scale Development Projects: Zuidas Amsterdam, Ørestad Copenhagen and Forum Barcelona Google Scholar

MARSDEN, G. and STEAD, D. (2011), ‘Policy transfer and learning in the field of transport: a review of concepts and evidence’, Transport Policy, 18, 492-500. ‘Policy transfer and learning in the field of transport: a review of concepts and evidence’ Transport Policy 18 492 500 Google Scholar

MARSDEN, G., FRICK, K. T., MAY, A. D. and DEAKIN, E. (2011), ‘How do cities approach policy innovation and policy learning? A study of 30 policies in northern Europe and North America’, Transport Policy, 18, 501-12. ‘How do cities approach policy innovation and policy learning? A study of 30 policies in northern Europe and North America’ Transport Policy 18 501 12 Google Scholar

MAY, A. D. (2013), Urban transport and sustainability: the key challenges’, International Journal of Sustainable Transportation, 7, 170-85. Urban transport and sustainability: the key challenges’ International Journal of Sustainable Transportation 7 170 85 Google Scholar

NÆSS, P., STRAND, A., NÆSS, T. and NICOLAISEN, M. (2011), ‘On their road to sustainability?: the challenge of sustainable mobility in urban planning and development in two Scandinavian capital regions’, Town Planning Review, 82, 285-316. ‘On their road to sustainability?: the challenge of sustainable mobility in urban planning and development in two Scandinavian capital regions’ Town Planning Review 82 285 316 Google Scholar

NEEDHAM, B. (2005), ‘The new Dutch spatial planning act: continuity and change in the way in which the Dutch regulate the practice of spatial planning’, Planning Practice and Research, 20, 327-40. ‘The new Dutch spatial planning act: continuity and change in the way in which the Dutch regulate the practice of spatial planning’ Planning Practice and Research 20 327 40 Google Scholar

NORTH, D. C. (1991), ‘Institutions’, The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 5, 97-112. ‘Institutions’ The Journal of Economic Perspectives 5 97 112 Google Scholar

OECD (ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT) (2007), Randstad Holland, Netherlands, Paris, OECD. Google Scholar

OSTROM, E., SCHROEDER, L. and WYNNE, S. (1993), Institutional Incentives and Sustainable Development: Infrastructure Policies in Perspective, Boulder, CO, Westview Press. Institutional Incentives and Sustainable Development: Infrastructure Policies in Perspective Google Scholar

PAULLEY, N. and PEDLER, A. (2000), ‘TRANSLAND: Integration of Transport and Land Use Planning’, Transland Deliverable 4, London, Transport Research Laboratory. ‘TRANSLAND: Integration of Transport and Land Use Planning’ Google Scholar

PEEK, G. J. (2006), Locatiesynergie: Een Participatieve Start van de Herontwikkeling van Binnenstedelijke Stationslocaties, Delft, Eburon. Locatiesynergie: Een Participatieve Start van de Herontwikkeling van Binnenstedelijke Stationslocaties Google Scholar

PFLIEGER, G., KAUFMANN, V., PATTARONI, L. and JEMELIN, C. (2009), ‘How does urban public transport change cities? Correlations between past and present transport and urban planning policies’, Urban Studies, 46, 1421-37. ‘How does urban public transport change cities? Correlations between past and present transport and urban planning policies’ Urban Studies 46 1421 37 Google Scholar

PRESSMAN, J. L. and WILDAVSKY, A. (1974), Implementation: How Great Expectations in Washington are Dashed in Oakland, Berkeley, CA, University of California Press. Implementation: How Great Expectations in Washington are Dashed in Oakland Google Scholar

PROGRAMMABUREAU STEDENBAANPLUS (2010), Stedenbaan Monitor 2010, den Haag, Programmabureau StedenbaanPlus. Google Scholar

PROVINCIE NOORD-HOLLAND and GOUDAPPEL COFFENG (2010), Knooppunten Ontwikkelen: Denken in Corridors, 1-54, Haarlem, Provincie Noord-Holland and Goudappel Coffeng. Google Scholar

RENNE, J. (2008), ‘Smart growth and transit-oriented development at the state level: lessons from California, New Jersey, and Western Australia’, Journal of Public Transportation, 11, 77-108. ‘Smart growth and transit-oriented development at the state level: lessons from California, New Jersey, and Western Australia’ Journal of Public Transportation 11 77 108 Google Scholar

RIETVELD, P. (2004), ‘Urban Transport Policies: The Dutch Struggle with Market Failures and Policy Failures’ (Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper No. 126), Amsterdam, VU University Amsterdam. ‘Urban Transport Policies: The Dutch Struggle with Market Failures and Policy Failures’ Google Scholar

RIETVELD, P. and STOUGH, R. (2004), Barriers to Sustainable Transport: Institutions, Regulation and Sustainability, Oxford, Taylor & Francis. Barriers to Sustainable Transport: Institutions, Regulation and Sustainability Google Scholar

SCHWANEN, T., DIJST, M. and DIELEMAN, F. M. (2004), ‘Policies for urban form and their impact on travel: the Netherlands experience’, Urban Studies, 41, 579-603. ‘Policies for urban form and their impact on travel: the Netherlands experience’ Urban Studies 41 579 603 Google Scholar

STADSREGIO ARNHEM NIJMEGEN (2011), Knooppunten! Bereikbaarheid en Ruimtelijke Ontwikkeling op Knooppunten van Openbaar Vervoer, Arnhem, Stadsregio Arnhem Nijmegen. Google Scholar

VAN DER CAMMEN, H. and DE KLERK, L. A. (2003), Ruimtelijke Ordening: Van Grachtengordel tot Vinex-Wijk, Utrecht, Centraal Boekhuis. Ruimtelijke Ordening: Van Grachtengordel tot Vinex-Wijk Google Scholar

VAN DER VALK, A. (2002), ‘The Dutch planning experience’, Landscape and Urban Planning, 58, 201-10. ‘The Dutch planning experience’ Landscape and Urban Planning 58 201 10 Google Scholar

VAN DER WOUDEN, R., SPAANS, M., FOEKEN, G., HOLLANDER, K., TRIP, J. J., MILDER, J. and DE WIT, P. (2009), Evaluatie Sleutelproject, Gouda, Bureau StedPlan. Evaluatie Sleutelproject Google Scholar

VENW (MINISTERIE VAN VERKEER EN WATERSTAAT) (1993), Tracéwet: Wet van 16 September 1993, Houdende Regels Voor de Besluitvorming Met Betrekking Tot de Aanleg of Wijziging van Hoofdwegen, van Landelijke Railwegen en van Hoofdvaarwegen, BWBR0006147. Google Scholar

VENW (MINISTERIE VAN VERKEER EN WATERSTAAT) (2004), Wet BDU Verkeer en Vervoer, BWBR0017828. Google Scholar

VENW (MINISTERIE VAN VERKEER EN WATERSTAAT) (2005), Nota Mobiliteit, 1-160, Den Haag, Ministerie Verkeer en Waterstaat. Google Scholar

VIGAR, G. (2000), ‘Local "barriers" to environmentally sustainable transport planning’, Local Environment, 5, 19-32. ‘Local "barriers" to environmentally sustainable transport planning’ Local Environment 5 19 32 Google Scholar

VROM (MINISTERIE VAN VOLKSHUISVESTING EN RUIMTELIJKE ORDENING) (2006), Nieuwe Sleutelprojecten op Stoom, 1-40, Den Haag, Ministerie van Volkshuisvesting en Ruimtelijke Ordening. Google Scholar

VROM (MINISTERIE VAN VOLKSHUISVESTING EN RUIMTELIJKE ORDENING) (2008), Structuurvisie Randstad 2040, Den Haag, Ministerie van VROM. Google Scholar

VROM, LNV, VENW and EZ (MINISTERIE VAN VOLKSHUISVESTING EN RUIMTELIJKE ORDENING, MINISTERIE VAN LANDBOUW, NATUURBEHEER EN VOEDSELKWALITEIT, MINISTERIE VAN VERKEER EN WATERSTAAT, MINISTERIE VAN ECONOMISCHE ZAKEN) (2006), Nota Ruimte: Ruimte voor Ontwikkeling, Den Haag, Ministerie van Volkshuisvesting en Ruimtelijke Ordening. Google Scholar

VROM-RAAD (2009), Acupunctuur in de Hoofdstructuur. Naar een Betere Verknoping van Verstedelijking en Mobiliteit, Advies 071, Den Haag, VROM-Raad. Google Scholar

WAGENAAR, H. (1996), ‘The Well-Tempered Interviewer’, Beleid & Maatschappij, 23, 152-57. ‘The Well-Tempered Interviewer’ Beleid & Maatschappij 23 152 57 Google Scholar

WOLMAN, H. and PAGE, E. (2002), ‘Policy Transfer Among Local Governments: an Information-Theory Approach’, Governance, 15, 477-502. ‘Policy Transfer Among Local Governments: an Information-Theory Approach’ Governance 15 477 502 Google Scholar