Town Planning Review

Building suburbs, Toronto-style: land development regimes, institutions, critical junctures and path dependence

Town Planning Review (2015), 86, (4), 411–436.

Abstract

A fundamental characteristic of Toronto-region suburban development has been the creation of a distinctive and robust model of planning for greenfield land development, at relatively high densities, with a mix of housing types, and significant continuity of built form. A plan-led system was created with subdivision control as the primary instrument, and zoning used only to lock in the detailed development patterns negotiated between municipalities and developers, the reverse of most US practice. The system became highly path-dependent because it created a stable institutional setting, reduced risks, and generated a powerful new actor, the oligopoly of large housing developers.

Access Token
£25.00

BACON, M. (1984), ‘Planning (?) in Ontario prior to 1977’, Plan Canada, 24, 115–17. Planning (?) in Ontario prior to 1977 Plan Canada 24 115 17 Google Scholar

BEN-ZADOK, E. (2005), ‘Consistency, concurrency and compact development: three faces of growth management implementation in Florida’, Urban Studies, 42, 2167–90. Consistency, concurrency and compact development: three faces of growth management implementation in Florida Urban Studies 42 2167 90 Google Scholar

BOURNE, L. S. (2001), ‘Designing a metropolitan region: the lessons and lost opportunities of the Toronto experience’, in M. Freire and R. Stren (eds), The Challenge of Urban Government: Policies and Practices, Washington, World Bank Institute, 27–46. Designing a metropolitan region: the lessons and lost opportunities of the Toronto experience The Challenge of Urban Government: Policies and Practices 27 46 Google Scholar

BUNCE, M. (1985), ‘Agricultural land as a real estate commodity: implications for farmland preservation in the North American urban fringe’, Landscape Planning, 12, 177–92. Agricultural land as a real estate commodity: implications for farmland preservation in the North American urban fringe Landscape Planning 12 177 92 Google Scholar

CAPOCCIA, G. and KELEMEN, R. D. (2007), ‘The study of critical junctures: theory, narrative, and counterfactuals in historical institutionalism’, World Politics, 59, 341–69. The study of critical junctures: theory, narrative, and counterfactuals in historical institutionalism World Politics 59 341 69 Google Scholar

CHAPIN, F. S. (1957), Urban land use planning, New York, Harper. Urban land use planning Google Scholar

COLLIER, R. B. and COLLIER, D. (1991), Shaping the Political Arena, Princeton, Princeton University Press. Shaping the Political Arena Google Scholar

CULLINGWORTH, J. B. (1997), Planning in the USA, London, Routledge. Planning in the USA Google Scholar

DEGROVE, J. M. and MINESS, D. A, (1992), The New Frontier for Land Policy: Planning and Growth Management in the States, Cambridge, Lincoln Institute of Land Policy. The New Frontier for Land Policy: Planning and Growth Management in the States Google Scholar

DOWNS, A. (2005), ‘Smart growth – why we discuss it more than we do it’, Journal of the American Planning Association, 71, 367–80. Smart growth – why we discuss it more than we do it Journal of the American Planning Association 71 367 80 Google Scholar

FILION, P. (1999), ‘Rupture or continuity? Modern and postmodern planning in Toronto’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 23, 421–45. Rupture or continuity? Modern and postmodern planning in Toronto International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 23 421 45 Google Scholar

FILION, P. (2000), ‘Balancing concentration and dispersion? Public policy and urban structure in Toronto’, Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 18, 163–89. Balancing concentration and dispersion? Public policy and urban structure in Toronto Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 18 163 89 Google Scholar

FILION, P. (2001), ‘Suburban mixed-use centres and urban dispersion: what difference do they make’, Environment and Planning A, 33, 141–60. Suburban mixed-use centres and urban dispersion: what difference do they make Environment and Planning A 33 141 60 Google Scholar

FILION, P. (2003), ‘Towards Smart Growth? The difficult implementation of alternatives to urban dispersion’, Canadian Journal of Urban Research, 12, 48–70. Towards Smart Growth? The difficult implementation of alternatives to urban dispersion Canadian Journal of Urban Research 12 48 70 Google Scholar

FILION, P. (2010), ‘Reorienting urban development? Structural obstruction to new urban forms’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 34, 1–19. Reorienting urban development? Structural obstruction to new urban forms International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 34 1 19 Google Scholar

FILION, P., BUNTING, T. and WARRINER, K. (1999), ‘The entrenchment of urban dispersion: residential preferences and location patterns in the dispersed city’, Urban Studies, 36, 1317–47. The entrenchment of urban dispersion: residential preferences and location patterns in the dispersed city Urban Studies 36 1317 47 Google Scholar

FISCHLER, R. (1998), ‘The metropolitan dimension of early zoning: revisiting the 1916 New York City Ordinance’, Journal of the American Planning Association, 64, 170–88. The metropolitan dimension of early zoning: revisiting the 1916 New York City Ordinance Journal of the American Planning Association 64 170 88 Google Scholar

FRISKEN, F. (2007), The Public Metropolis : the Political Dynamics of Urban Expansion in the Toronto Region, 1924–2003, Toronto, Canadian Scholars’ Press. The Public Metropolis : the Political Dynamics of Urban Expansion in the Toronto Region, 1924–2003 Google Scholar

GOMME, T. (1984), ‘Municipal planning in Ontario’, Plan Canada, 24, 102–14. Municipal planning in Ontario Plan Canada 24 102 14 Google Scholar

GORDON, D. and VIPOND, S. (2005), ‘Gross density and New Urbanism,’, Journal of the American Planning Association, 71, 41–54. Gross density and New Urbanism, Journal of the American Planning Association 71 41 54 Google Scholar

HALL, P. A. and SOSKICE, D. W. (2001), Varieties of Capitalism: the Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage, Oxford, Oxford University Press. Varieties of Capitalism: the Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage Google Scholar

HALL, P. A. and TAYLOR, R. C. R. (1996), ‘Political science and the three new institutionalisms’, Political Studies, 44, 936–57. Political science and the three new institutionalisms Political Studies 44 936 57 Google Scholar

HARE, M. (2001), Exploring Growth Management Roles in Ontario: Learning from ‘Who Does What’ Elsewhere, Toronto, The Ontario Professional Planners Institute. Who Does What Exploring Growth Management Roles in Ontario: Learning from ‘Who Does What’ Elsewhere Google Scholar

HARRIS, R. (1996), Unplanned Suburbs: Toronto’s American Tragedy, 1900 to 1950, Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press. Unplanned Suburbs: Toronto’s American Tragedy, 1900 to 1950 Google Scholar

HESS, P. M. (2009). ‘Avenues or arterials: the struggle to change street building practices in Toronto, Canada’, Journal of Urban Design, 14, 1–28. Avenues or arterials: the struggle to change street building practices in Toronto, Canada Journal of Urban Design 14 1 28 Google Scholar

HESS, P. M. and SORENSEN, A. (2015), ‘Compact, concurrent, and contiguous: smart growth and 50 years of residential planning in the Toronto region’, Urban Geography, 36, 127–51. Compact, concurrent, and contiguous: smart growth and 50 years of residential planning in the Toronto region Urban Geography 36 127 51 Google Scholar

HOLTZ, G., BRUGNACH, M. and PAHL-WOSTL, C. (2008), ‘Specifying‚ “regime” – ‘A framework for defining and describing regimes in transition research’, Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 75, 623–43, doi: 10.1016/j.techfore.2007.02.010. Specifying‚ “regime” – ‘A framework for defining and describing regimes in transition research Technological Forecasting and Social Change Google Scholar

LANG, R. (2003), Edgeless Cities: Exploring the Elusive Metropolis, Washington, Brookings Institution Press. Edgeless Cities: Exploring the Elusive Metropolis Google Scholar

LEMON, J. (1985), Toronto since 1918: an Illustrated History, Toronto, James Lorimer and Company. Toronto since 1918: an Illustrated History Google Scholar

LORIMER, J. and JACOBS, J. (1970), The Real World of City Politics, Toronto, James Lewis & Samuel, Publishers. The Real World of City Politics Google Scholar

LOW, N. and ASTLE, R. (2009), ‘Path dependence in urban transport: an institutional analysis of urban passenger transport in Melbourne, Australia, 1956–2006’, Transport Policy, 16, 47–58. Path dependence in urban transport: an institutional analysis of urban passenger transport in Melbourne, Australia, 1956–2006 Transport Policy 16 47 58 Google Scholar

MAHONEY, J. (2000), ‘Path dependence in historical sociology’, Theory and Society, 29, 507–48. Path dependence in historical sociology Theory and Society 29 507 48 Google Scholar

MARTIN, R. and SUNLEY, P. (2006), ‘Path dependence and regional economic evolution’, Journal of Economic Geography, 6, 395–437. Path dependence and regional economic evolution Journal of Economic Geography 6 395 437 Google Scholar

MILNER, J. B. (1963), Community Planning: a Casebook on Law and Administration, Toronto, University of Toronto Press. Community Planning: a Casebook on Law and Administration Google Scholar

ONTARIO MINISTRY OF PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE RENEWAL (2006), Places to Grow: Better Choices, Brighter Future, Toronto, Ontario Ministry of Public Infrastructure Renewal. ONTARIO MINISTRY OF PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE RENEWAL (2006) Places to Grow: Better Choices, Brighter Future Google Scholar

PIERSON, P. (2004), Politics in Time: History, Institutions, and Social Analysis, Princeton, Princeton University Press. Politics in Time: History, Institutions, and Social Analysis Google Scholar

POND, D. (2009), ‘Institutions, political economy and land-use policy: greenbelt politics in Ontario’, Environmental Politics, 18, 238–56. Institutions, political economy and land-use policy: greenbelt politics in Ontario Environmental Politics 18 238 56 Google Scholar

SANDBERG, L. A., GILBERT, L. and WEKERLE, G. R. (2013), The Oak Ridges Moraine Battles: development, Sprawl, and Nature Conservation in the Toronto Region, Toronto, University of Toronto Press. The Oak Ridges Moraine Battles: development, Sprawl, and Nature Conservation in the Toronto Region Google Scholar

SCARBOROUGH ONTARIO PLANNING BOARD (1966), ‘How Scarborough plans’, Scarborough, Scarborough Ontario Planing Board. ‘How Scarborough plans’ Google Scholar

SCARBOROUGH PLANNING BOARD, APRIL (1965), ‘Scarborough Planning Board Minutes, April’, Scarborough, Scarborough Ontario Planning Board. Scarborough Planning Board Minutes, April Google Scholar

SCARBOROUGH TOWNSHIP PLANNING BOARD (1957), ‘Township of Scarborough Official Plan’, Scarborough, Scarborough Township Planning Board. Township of Scarborough Official Plan Google Scholar

SCARBOROUGH TOWNSHIP PLANNING BOARD (1960), Township of Scarborough Official Plan, First Revision’. Scarborough, Scarborough Township Planning Board. Township of Scarborough Official Plan, First Revision Google Scholar

SEWELL, J. (1993), The Shape of the City: Toronto Struggles with Modern Planning, Toronto, Buffalo, London, University of Toronto Press. Google Scholar

SEWELL, J. (2009), The Shape of the Suburbs : Understanding Toronto’s Sprawl, Toronto, University of Toronto Press. The Shape of the Suburbs : Understanding Toronto’s Sprawl Google Scholar

SKABURSKIS, A. (2006), ‘New urbanism and sprawl – A Toronto case study’, Journal of Planning Education and Research, 25, 233–48. New urbanism and sprawl – A Toronto case study Journal of Planning Education and Research 25 233 48 Google Scholar

SOLOMON, L. (2007), Toronto Sprawls : a History, Toronto, University of Toronto Press. Toronto Sprawls : a History Google Scholar

SORENSEN, A. (2011), ‘Toronto megacity: growth, planning institutions, sustainability’, in A. Toronto megacity: growth, planning institutions, sustainability Google Scholar

Sorensen and J. Okata (eds), Megacities: Urban Form, Governance, and Sustainability, Tokyo, Springer Verlag, 245–72. Megacities: Urban Form, Governance, and Sustainability 245 72 Google Scholar

SORENSEN, A. (2015), ‘Taking path dependence seriously: an historical institutionalist research agenda in planning history’, Planning Perspectives, 30, 17–38. Taking path dependence seriously: an historical institutionalist research agenda in planning history Planning Perspectives 30 17 38 Google Scholar

SORENSEN, A. and HESS, P. M. (2007), ‘Metropolitan form, density, transportation,’ Regional Comparisons, http://www.neptis.org/sites/default/files/posters/metropolitan_20070123.jpg (accessed April 2015). Google Scholar

SPURR, P. (1976), Land and Urban Development: a Preliminary Study, Toronto, James Lorimer. Land and Urban Development: a Preliminary Study Google Scholar

STEWART, G. and HESS, P. (2014), ‘Neighbourhood planning: smart growth in the context of the 1960s’, in F. Vanlaethem and M.-J. Therrien (eds), La Sauvegarde de l’Architecture Modern,. Quebec, Presses de l’Université de Quebec. Neighbourhood planning: smart growth in the context of the 1960s La Sauvegarde de l’Architecture Modern,. Quebec, Presses de l’Université de Quebec Google Scholar

TEAFORD, J. C. (2006), The Metropolitan Revolution: The Rise of Post-Urban America, New York, Columbia University Press. The Metropolitan Revolution: The Rise of Post-Urban America Google Scholar

TOLL, S. I. (1969), Zoned American, New York, Grossman Publishers. Zoned American Google Scholar

WHITE, R. (2003), Urban Infrastructure and Urban Growth in the Toronto Region, 1950s to the 1990s, Toronto, Neptis Foundation. Urban Infrastructure and Urban Growth in the Toronto Region, 1950s to the 1990s Google Scholar

WHITE, R. (2007), The Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe in Historical Perspective, Toronto, Neptis Foundation. The Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe in Historical Perspective Google Scholar

WILLIAMS, G. (1999), ‘Institutional capacity and metropolitan governance: the Greater Toronto area’, Cities, 16, 171–80. Institutional capacity and metropolitan governance: the Greater Toronto area Cities 16 171 80 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Sorensen, Andre

Hess, Paul