Overcoming the disjunctures: competing discourses on informal settlements in South Africa

Cirolia, Liza Rose; Cirolia, Liza Rose

doi:https://doi.org/10.3828/idpr.2017.17

Cirolia, Liza Rose

International Development Planning Review (2017), 39, (4), 443–459.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3828/idpr.2017.17
Language: English
Pages: 17

Abstract

Informal settlements are an undeniable feature of developing cities. Activists, governments, community groups, academics, artists, international funders, built-environment professionals and entrepreneurs all find the challenge of informality an important project and intriguing frontier for practical and conceptual intervention. This paper unpacks four discourses which frame understandings of informal settlements and how they should be addressed. Technology and design discourses, institutional discourses, rights-based discourses and structural discourses all come to bear on the framing of the debate and the propositions for change. Within the sector, the various actors and stakeholders continually struggle to acknowledge the contributions of other discourses. This paper unpacks these discourses and identifies the possible contributions and limitations each has to offer. The paper draws on empirical evidence from South Africa, providing insights relevant both to and beyond this context. In conclusion, it is argued that a generous, multi-scale, interdisciplinary discourse is needed in South Africa and beyond.

FormatArticle

£25.00

READ THIS ARTICLE

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Alexander, P. (2010) ‘Rebellion of the poor: South Africa’s service delivery protests – a preliminary analysis’, Review of African Political Economy, 37(123), 25–40. Rebellion of the poor: South Africa’s service delivery protests – a preliminary analysis Review of African Political Economy 37 25 40 Google Scholar

Amin, A., and Cirolia, L. R. (2017) ‘Politics/matter: governing Cape Town’s informal settlements’, Urban Studies, doi: 0042098017694133. Politics/matter: governing Cape Town’s informal settlements Urban Studies Google Scholar

Anderson, P. M. L., Brown-Luthango, M., Cartwright, A., Farouk, I. and Smit, W. (2013) ‘Brokering communities of knowledge and practice: Reflections on the African Centre for Cities’ CityLab programme’, Cities, 32, 1–10. Brokering communities of knowledge and practice: Reflections on the African centre for cities’ cityLab programme Cities 32 1 10 Google Scholar

Arimah, B. C. (2010) ‘The face of urban poverty: explaining the prevalence of slums in developing countries’ (Working Paper No. 2010.30), World Institute for Development Economics Research. The face of urban poverty: explaining the prevalence of slums in developing countries Google Scholar

Ballard, R., Habib, A., Valodia, I. and Zuern, E. (2005) ‘Globalization, marginalization and contemporary social movements in South Africa’, African Affairs, 104(417), 615–34. Globalization, marginalization and contemporary social movements in South Africa African Affairs 104 615 34 Google Scholar

Bond, P. and Tait, A. (1997) ‘The failure of housing policy in post-apartheid South Africa’, Urban Forum, 8(1), 19–41. The failure of housing policy in post-apartheid South Africa Urban Forum 8 19 41 Google Scholar

Bradlow, B., Bolnick, J. and Shearing, C. (2011) ‘Housing, institutions, money: the failures and promise of human settlements policy and practice in South Africa’, Environment and Urbanization, 23(1), 267–75. Housing, institutions, money: the failures and promise of human settlements policy and practice in South Africa Environment and Urbanization 23 267 75 Google Scholar

Brenner, N., Madden, D. J. and Wachsmuth, D. (2011) ‘Assemblage urbanism and the challenges of critical urban theory’, City, 15(2), 225–40. Assemblage urbanism and the challenges of critical urban theory City 15 225 40 Google Scholar

Bunnell, T. and Harris, A. (2012) ‘Re-viewing informality: perspectives from urban Asia’, International Development Planning Review, 34(4), 339–48. Re-viewing informality: perspectives from urban Asia International Development Planning Review 34 339 48 Google Scholar

CDE (Centre for Development and Enterprise) (2013) ‘Building African cities that work’, http://www.cde.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/Paul%20Collier%20February.pdf (accessed 13 October 2017). Google Scholar

Charlton, S. and Kihato, C. (2006) ‘Reaching the poor? An analysis of the influences on the evolution of South Africa’s housing programme’, in U. Pillay, R. Tomlinson and J. Du Toit (eds), Democracy and delivery: urban policy in South Africa, Cape Town, HSRC Press, 252–82. Reaching the poor? An analysis of the influences on the evolution of South Africa’s housing programme Democracy and delivery: urban policy in South Africa 252 82 Google Scholar

Cirolia, L. R. (2014) ‘The architect can’t save the slum: reflections on design fix housing solutions’, SLUMLab, 9, 113–14. The architect can’t save the slum: reflections on design fix housing solutions SLUMLab 9 113 14 Google Scholar

Cirolia, L. R., Görgens, T., van Donk, M., Smit, W. and Drimie, S. (eds) (2016) Pursuing a partnership-based approach to incremental informal settlement upgrading in South Africa, Cape Town, University of Cape Town Press. Pursuing a partnership-based approach to incremental informal settlement upgrading in South Africa Google Scholar

Clark, M. and Tissington, K. (2016) ‘Courts as a site of struggle for informal settlement upgrading in South Africa’, in Cirolia et al. (eds), 376–91. Courts as a site of struggle for informal settlement upgrading in South Africa 376 91 Google Scholar

Coggin, T. and Pieterse, M. (2012) ‘Rights and the city: an exploration of the interaction between socio-economic rights and the city’, Urban Forum, 23(3), 257–78. Rights and the city: an exploration of the interaction between socio-economic rights and the city Urban Forum 23 257 78 Google Scholar

Cousins, B. (1997) ‘How do rights become real? Formal and informal institutions in South Africa’s land reform’, IDS Bulletin, 28(4), 59–68. How do rights become real? Formal and informal institutions in South Africa’s land reform IDS Bulletin 28 59 68 Google Scholar

De Lille, P. (2015) Budget speech by the city’s executive mayor, Patricia De Lille, at the full Council meeting, 29 May 2015, http://www.capetown.gov.za/en/MediaReleases/Pages/BUDGETSPEECHBYTHECITYSEXECUTIVEMAYORPATRICIADELILLEATTHEFULLCOUNCILMEETINGON29MAY2015.aspx (accessed 10 January 2016). Google Scholar

Duminy, J. and Watson, V. (2011) ‘The ‘Right to the City’ – political slogan or useful concept?’ African Centre for Cities/CUBES South African City Studies Conference, 7–9 September. The ‘Right to the City’ – political slogan or useful concept? Google Scholar

Eglin, R. and Kenyon, M. (2016) ‘Between a shack and an RDP house: managed land settelement’, in Cirolia et al. (eds), 392–407. Between a shack and an RDP house: managed land settelement 392 407 Google Scholar

Fernandes, E. (2007) ‘Constructing the “right to the city” in Brazil’, Social & Legal Studies, 16(2), 201–19. Constructing the “right to the city” in Brazil Social & Legal Studies 16 201 19 Google Scholar

Fox, S. (2014) ‘The political economy of slums: theory and evidence from sub-Saharan Africa’, World Development, 54, 191–203. The political economy of slums: theory and evidence from sub-Saharan Africa World Development 54 191 203 Google Scholar

Friedman, S. (2014) ‘Can South Africa’s courts help the fight for social justice?’, http://www.sacsis.org.za/site/article/2111 (accessed 13 October 2017). Google Scholar

Gibson, N. (2009) ‘Fanonian practices and the politics of space in post-apartheid South Africa: the challenge of the Shack Dwellers Movement (Abahlali baseMjondolo)’, Colloque de Frantz Fanon, Algers, 7 July. Fanonian practices and the politics of space in post-apartheid South Africa: the challenge of the Shack Dwellers Movement (Abahlali baseMjondolo) Google Scholar

Gilbert, A. (2009) ‘Extreme thinking about slums and slum dwellers: a critique’, SAIS Review of International Affairs, 29(1), 35–48. Extreme thinking about slums and slum dwellers: a critique SAIS Review of International Affairs 29 35 48 Google Scholar

Hajer, M. (2005) ‘Coalitions, practices, and meaning in environmental politics: from acid rain to BSE’, in D. Howarth and J. Torfing (eds) Discourse theory in European politics, London, Palgrave Macmillan, 297–315. Coalitions, practices, and meaning in environmental politics: from acid rain to BSE Discourse theory in European politics 297 315 Google Scholar

Harrison, P., Todes, A. and Watson, V. (2008) Planning and transformation: learning from the postapartheid experience. Royal Town Planning Institute Series. Abingdon, Routledge. Planning and transformation: learning from the postapartheid experience Google Scholar

Hart, G. (2013) Rethinking the South African crisis: nationalism, populism, hegemony, Athens, University of Georgia Press. Rethinking the South African crisis: nationalism, populism, hegemony Google Scholar

Huchzermeyer, M. (2003) ‘Housing rights in South Africa: invasions, evictions, the media, and the courts in the cases of Grootboom, Alexandra, and Bredell’, Urban Forum, 14(1), 80–107. Housing rights in South Africa: invasions, evictions, the media, and the courts in the cases of Grootboom, Alexandra, and Bredell Urban Forum 14 80 107 Google Scholar

Huchzermeyer, M. (2004) ‘From “contravention of laws” to “lack of rights”: redefining the problem of informal settlements in South Africa’, Habitat International, 28(3), 333–47. From “contravention of laws” to “lack of rights”: redefining the problem of informal settlements in South Africa Habitat International 28 333 47 Google Scholar

Huchzermeyer, M. (2008) ‘Slum upgrading in Nairobi within the housing and basic services market: a housing rights concern’, Journal of Asian and African Studies, 43(1), 19–39. Slum upgrading in Nairobi within the housing and basic services market: a housing rights concern Journal of Asian and African Studies 43 19 39 Google Scholar

Huchzermeyer, M. (2011) Cities with slums: from informal settlement eradication to the right to the city in Africa, Cape Town, UCT Press. Cities with slums: from informal settlement eradication to the right to the city in Africa Google Scholar

Huchzermeyer, M. (2014) ‘Troubling continuities: use and utility of the term “slum”’, in S. Oldfield and S. Parnell (eds), 86–97. Troubling continuities: use and utility of the term “slum” 86 97 Google Scholar

Isandla Institute and CORC (2011) ‘The right to the city in a South African context’, National Roundtable, http://isandla.org.za/publications/149/ (accessed 13 October 2017). Google Scholar

Lemanski, C. (2009) ‘Augmented informality: South Africa’s backyard dwellings as a by-product of formal housing policies’, Habitat International, 33(4), 472–84. Augmented informality: South Africa’s backyard dwellings as a by-product of formal housing policies Habitat International 33 472 84 Google Scholar

McFarlane, C. and Silver, J. (2017) ‘The poolitical city: “seeing sanitation” and making the urban political in Cape Town’, Antipode, 49(1), 125–48. The poolitical city: “seeing sanitation” and making the urban political in cape Town Antipode 49 125 48 Google Scholar

McLennan, A. M. (2007) ‘Unmasking delivery: revealing the politics’, Progress in Development Studies, 7(1), 5–20. Unmasking delivery: revealing the politics Progress in Development Studies 7 5 20 Google Scholar

Marx, C. (2009) ‘Conceptualising the potential of informal land markets to reduce urban poverty’, International Development Planning Review, 31(4), 335–53. Conceptualising the potential of informal land markets to reduce urban poverty International Development Planning Review 31 335 53 Google Scholar

Meth, P. (2013) ‘Millennium development goals and urban informal settlements: unintended consequences’, International Development Planning Review, 35(1), v–xiii. Millennium development goals and urban informal settlements: unintended consequences International Development Planning Review 35 v xiii Google Scholar

Miraftab, F. (2003) ‘The perils of participatory discourse: housing policy in post-apartheid South Africa’, Journal of Planning Education and Research, 22(3), 226–39. The perils of participatory discourse: housing policy in post-apartheid South Africa Journal of Planning Education and Research 22 226 39 Google Scholar

Mutua, M. (1997) ‘Hope and despair for a new South Africa: the limits of rights discourse’, Harvard Human Rights Journal, 10(1), 63–114. Hope and despair for a new South Africa: the limits of rights discourse Harvard Human Rights Journal 10 63 114 Google Scholar

Napier, M., Berrisford, S., Kihato, C. W., McGaffin, R. and Royston, L. (2013) Trading places: accessing land in African cities, Somerset West, African Minds. Trading places: accessing land in African cities Google Scholar

National Department of Housing (2004) Breaking new ground. A comprehensive plan for the development of sustainable human settlements. Pretoria. Google Scholar

Nyar, A. and Wray, C. (2012) ‘Understanding protest action: some data collection challenges for South Africa’, Transformation: Critical Perspectives on Southern Africa, 80(1), 22–43. Understanding protest action: some data collection challenges for South Africa Transformation: Critical Perspectives on Southern Africa 80 22 43 Google Scholar

ODI (Overseas Development Institute) (1999) What can we do with a rights-based approach to development? (Briefing paper 3), https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/odi-assets/publications-opinion-files/2614.pdf (accessed 12 October 2017). Google Scholar

Oldfield, S. and Parnell, S. (2014) ‘From the South’, in S. Oldfield and S. Parnell (eds) The Routledge handbook on cities of the global south, London, Routledge, 1–4. From the South The Routledge handbook on cities of the global south 1 4 Google Scholar

Overy, N. (2012) ‘The Social Justice Coalition and access to basic sanitation in informal settlements in Cape Town, South Africa (November 2012)’, International Budget Partnership Impact Case Study, Study No. 1, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2333670 (accessed 13 October 2017). Google Scholar

Parnell, S. and Pieterse, E. (2010) ‘The “right to the city”: institutional imperatives of a developmental state’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 34(1), 146–62. The “right to the city”: institutional imperatives of a developmental state International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 34 146 62 Google Scholar

Parnell, S. and Robinson, J. (2012) ‘(Re)theorizing cities from the global South: looking beyond neoliberalism’, Urban Geography, 33(4), 593–617. (Re)theorizing cities from the global South: looking beyond neoliberalism Urban Geography 33 593 617 Google Scholar

Parnell, S. (2013) Inclusionary approaches to urban planning: lessons in poverty reduction from South Africa, http://citiesgeographylse.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/LSE-ParnellOct22102013.pdf (accessed 12 October 2017). Google Scholar

Parsons, T. (1997) ‘“Kibra is our blood”: the Sudanese military legacy in Nairobi’s Kibera location, 1902–1968’, International Journal of African Historical Studies, 30(1), 87–122. “Kibra is our blood”: the Sudanese military legacy in Nairobi’s Kibera location, 1902–1968 International Journal of African Historical Studies 30 87 122 Google Scholar

Pieterse, E. (2008) City futures: confronting the crisis of urban development, London, Zed Books. City futures: confronting the crisis of urban development Google Scholar

Pieterse, E. (2013) ‘City/university interplays amidst complexity’, Territorio, 66, 26–32. City/university interplays amidst complexity Territorio 66 26 32 Google Scholar

Pieterse, E. and van Donk, M. (2014) ‘Citizenship, design activism and institutionalising informal settlement upgrading’, in South African Cities Network, From housing to human settlements: perspectives on South African cities, Johannesburg: South African Cities Network, 149–72. Citizenship, design activism and institutionalising informal settlement upgrading From housing to human settlements: perspectives on South African cities 149 72 Google Scholar

Pithouse, R. (2005) ‘The explosive alliance’, CLR James Journal, 11(1), 44–78. The explosive alliance CLR James Journal 11 44 78 Google Scholar

Pithouse, R. (2008) ‘A politics of the poor: shack dwellers’ struggles in Durban’, Journal of Asian and African Studies, 43(1), 63–94. A politics of the poor: shack dwellers’ struggles in Durban Journal of Asian and African Studies 43 63 94 Google Scholar

Pithouse, R. (2013) ‘Conjunctural remarks on the political significance of “the local”’, Thesis Eleven, 115(1), 95–111. Conjunctural remarks on the political significance of “the local” Thesis Eleven 115 95 111 Google Scholar

Robins, S. (2014) ‘The 2011 Toilet Wars in South Africa: justice and transition between the exceptional and the everyday after apartheid’, Development and Change, 45(3), 479–501. The 2011 Toilet Wars in South Africa: justice and transition between the exceptional and the everyday after apartheid Development and Change 45 479 501 Google Scholar

Rubin, M. (2011) ‘Perceptions of corruption in the South African housing allocation and delivery programme: what it may mean for accessing the state’, Journal of Asian and African Studies, 46(5), 479–90. Perceptions of corruption in the South African housing allocation and delivery programme: what it may mean for accessing the state Journal of Asian and African Studies 46 479 90 Google Scholar

Sacks, J. (2014) ‘Sweet home: a preliminary investigation into the socio-political character of recent road blockades by protesting shack dwellers in South Africa’, Journal of Asian and African Studies, 49(1), 115–25. Sweet home: a preliminary investigation into the socio-political character of recent road blockades by protesting shack dwellers in South Africa Journal of Asian and African Studies 49 115 25 Google Scholar

Schneider, T. and Till, J. (2009) ‘Beyond discourse: notes on spatial agency’, Footprint, 3(1), 97–112. Beyond discourse: notes on spatial agency Footprint 3 97 112 Google Scholar

Skuse, A. and Cousins, T. (2007) ‘Spaces of resistance: informal settlement, communication and community organisation in a Cape Town township’, Urban Studies, 44(5–6), 979–95. Spaces of resistance: informal settlement, communication and community organisation in a Cape Town township Urban Studies 44 979 95 Google Scholar

Swilling, M. (2011) ‘Reconceptualising urbanism, ecology and networked infrastructures’, Social Dynamics, 37(1), 78–95. Reconceptualising urbanism, ecology and networked infrastructures Social Dynamics 37 78 95 Google Scholar

Tissington, K. (2011) A resource guide to housing in South Africa 1994–2010, Johannesburg, Socioeconomic Rights Institute of South Africa. A resource guide to housing in South Africa 1994–2010 Google Scholar

Tomlinson, M. (2006) ‘From “quantity” to “quality”: restructuring South Africa’s housing policy ten years after’, International Development Planning Review, 28(1), 85–104. From “quantity” to “quality”: restructuring South Africa’s housing policy ten years after International Development Planning Review 28 85 104 Google Scholar

UN-Habitat (2003) Global report on human settlements: the challenge of slums, Nairobi. Google Scholar

Google Scholar

Von Holdt, K., Langa, M., Molapo, S., Mogapi, N., Ngubeni, K., Dlamini, J. and Kirsten, A. (2011) ‘The smoke that calls: insurgent citizenship, collective violence and the struggle for a place in the new South Africa: eight case studies of community protest and xenophobic violence’, Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation (CSVR) & Society, Work and Development Institute (SWOP). The smoke that calls: insurgent citizenship, collective violence and the struggle for a place in the new South Africa: eight case studies of community protest and xenophobic violence Google Scholar