The Indexer: The International Journal of Indexing

Carols for indexers

The Indexer: The International Journal of Indexing (2011), 29, (2), 50–55.

Abstract

The twentieth century saw a number of collections of carols, often very erudite and scholarly, intended for use in both the study and the choir stalls. And they came complete not only with music but also with a number of find aids including a variety of indexes and index-like tables of contents. The arrangement of the carols was often itself a map to help you get where you wanted to be, and many typographical devices were used to the same end. This article looks at a dozen or so of these collections and their differing approaches to the indexing task. The authors focus in particular on how well the presentation of the collections answers the needs of the user looking for the place under pressure and in a hurry. Is the day of the omnibus collection past, as a tailing off towards the end of the century suggested? Probably not, if the arrival in 2005 of the RSCM carol book (complete with lots of indexes) is anything to go by. And what about the Kindle?

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Barlow, H. and Morgenstein, S. (1950) Dictionary of vocal themes. New York: Crown Publishing. Dictionary of vocal themes Google Scholar

Dreamer, P. and Shaw, M. (eds) (1938) English carol book: complete edition. London: Mowbrays. English carol book: complete edition Google Scholar

Dreamer, P., Vaughan Williams, R. and Shaw, M. (eds) (1928) The Oxford book of carols. London: Oxford University Press. The Oxford book of carols Google Scholar

Iliff, D. and Barnard, J. (eds) (2005) RSCM Carol book. London: Royal School of Church Music. RSCM Carol book Google Scholar

Jacques, R. and Willcocks, D. (eds) (1961) Carols for choirs 1: fifty Christmas carols. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Carols for choirs 1: fifty Christmas carols Google Scholar

Keyte, H. and Parrott, A. (eds) (1993) The shorter new Oxford book of carols. Oxford: Oxford University Press. The shorter new Oxford book of carols Google Scholar

Moldoveanu, N. (ed.) (1983) Repertoriu coral. Bucharest: Publishing House for the Biblical Institute and Missions to the Romanian Orthodox Church. Repertoriu coral Google Scholar

National Gallery of Art (1992) Joy to the world: a Christmas song book. New York: Rizzoli International. Google Scholar

Poston, E. (ed.) (1965) The Penguin book of Christmas carols I, 1st edn. London: Penguin. The Penguin book of Christmas carols I Google Scholar

Poston, E. (ed.) (1970) The Penguin book of Christmas carols II, 1st edn. London: Penguin. The Penguin book of Christmas carols II Google Scholar

Rosenberry, E. (arranger) (1969) The Faber book of carols and Christmas songs. London: Faber. The Faber book of carols and Christmas songs Google Scholar

Routley, E. (ed.) (1978) University carol book: a collection of carols from any lands, for all seasons. Brighton, UK: Freeman. University carol book: a collection of carols from any lands, for all seasons Google Scholar

Willcocks, D. (compiler and arranger) (1985) Carols for Christmas. London: Guild Publishing London. Carols for Christmas Google Scholar

Willcocks, D. and Rutter, J. (eds) (1989) Carols for all. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Carols for all Google Scholar

Willcocks, D. and Rutter, J. (eds) (1970) Carols for choirs 2: fifty carols for Christmas and Advent. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Carols for choirs 2: fifty carols for Christmas and Advent Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Russell, Mary

MacGlashan, Maureen