Town Planning Review

Special Landscape Areas: Landscape conservation or confusion in the town and country planning system?

Town Planning Review (2004), 75, (2), 205–230.

Abstract

This paper assesses the efficacy and relevance of the Special Landscape Area (SLA) designation – a non-statutory planning designation within the British planning system. SLAs cover significant areas of countryside, yet they remain neglected in planning research. The research reported here uses primary and secondary data to allow a critical assessment of SLAs across Wales. The results reveal confusion and contradiction within contemporary guidance and development plan policy, highlighting an emerging discourse between planners who seek to protect landscape using SLAs and those who advocate a more holistic approach. It is concluded that the emphasis on designation as a prime tool for landscape planning is outdated and in need of urgent reform towards a more multifunctional assessment of landscape character.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

ANDERSON, M. A. (1981), 'Planning policies and development control in the Sussex Downs AONB', Town Planning Review, 52, 5–25. Planning policies and development control in the Sussex Downs AONB Town Planning Review 52 5 25 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

BLAENAU GWENT COUNTY BOROUGH COUNCIL (1991), Blaenau Gwent Local Plan (1991–2006), Ebbw Vale, Blaenau Gwent County Borough Council. Google Scholar

BOWEN-REES, I. (1995), Beyond National Parks, Consuming the Landscape of a Democratic Wales, Llandyssul, Gomer Press. Beyond National Parks, Consuming the Landscape of a Democratic Wales Google Scholar

BROTHERTON, I. (1982), 'Development pressures and control in the National Parks 1966–81', Town Planning Review, 53, 439–59. Development pressures and control in the National Parks 1966–81 Town Planning Review 53 439 59 Google Scholar

CAERPHILLY COUNTY COUNCIL (1999), Unitary Development Plan (Deposit), Caerphilly Caerphilly County Council. Google Scholar

CARMARTHENSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL (2002), Unitary Development Plan (Draft Deposit), Carmarthen, Carmarthenshire County Council. Google Scholar

CEREDIGION COUNTY COUNCIL (1998), Ceredigion Local Plan (Deposit Version), Aberaeron, Ceredigion County Council. Google Scholar

COBHAM RESOURCE CONSULTANTS (1993), Review of Special Landscape Areas in Kent (Report for Kent County Council), Oxford, Cobham Resource Consultants. Google Scholar

COUNTRYSIDE AGENCY/RURAL DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION (1998), Rural Development and Land Use Planning Policies (Research Notes RDR 38/S), Salisbury, Countryside Agency. Google Scholar

COUNTRYSIDE AGENCY and SCOTTISH NATURAL HERITAGE (2002), Landscape Character Assessment: Guidance for England and Scotland, Cheltenham/Edinburgh, Countryside Agency/Scottish Natural Heritage. Google Scholar

CCW (COUNTRYSIDE COUNCIL FOR WALES) (1996), The Welsh Landscape: A Policy Document, Bangor, CCW. Google Scholar

CCW (COUNTRYSIDE COUNCIL FOR WALES) (1998), LANDMAP: The Landscape Assessment and Decision Making Process, Bangor, CCW. Google Scholar

CCW (COUNTRYSIDE COUNCIL FOR WALES) (2001), The LANDMAP Information System, Bangor, CCW. Google Scholar

CULLINGWORTH, J. B. and NADIN, V. (1997), Town and Country Planning in the UK (Twelfth edition) London, Routledge. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

CURRY, N R. and OWEN, S. (1996), Changing Rural Policy in Britain: Planning Administration, Agriculture and the Environment, Cheltenham, Countryside and Community Press. Changing Rural Policy in Britain: Planning Administration, Agriculture and the Environment Google Scholar

DOE (DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT) (1992), The Countryside and Rural Economy (Planning Policy Guidance Note 7), London, HMSO. Google Scholar

DOE (DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT) (1997), The Countryside: Environmental Quality and Economic and Social Development (Planning Policy Guidance Note 7), London, HMSO. Google Scholar

ELSON, M. (1986), Green Belts: Conflict and Mediation in the Urban Fringe, London, Heinemann. Green Belts: Conflict and Mediation in the Urban Fringe Google Scholar

ENGLISH HERITAGE (1996), Conservation Issues in Local Plans, London, English Heritage. Google Scholar

GOLD, J. R. and BURGESS, J. (eds) (1982), Valued Environments, London, George Allen & Unwin. Valued Environments Google Scholar

GREGORY, D. G. (1971), Green Belts and Development Control: A Case Study in the West Midlands, Birmingham, Centre for Urban and Regional Studies, University of Birmingham. Green Belts and Development Control: A Case Study in the West Midlands Google Scholar

HARVEY, G. (1998), The Killing of the Countryside, London, Vintage. The Killing of the Countryside Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

MOORE-COLYER, R. (2002), A voice clamouring in the wilderness: H. J. Massingham (1888–1952) and Rural England', Rural History, 13, 199–224. A voice clamouring in the wilderness: H. J. Massingham (1888–1952) and Rural England' Rural History 13 199 224 Google Scholar

ODPM (OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY PRIME MINISTER) (2003), The Countryside: Environmental Quality and Economic and Social Development (PPG 7 [1997], revised) http://www.planning.odpm.gov.uk/ ppg/ppg7/o4.htm Google Scholar

O'RIORDAN, T. (1983), 'Development and control of rural resources' in B. Johnson (ed.), The Conservation and Development Programme for the UK: A Response to the World Conservation Strategy, London, Kogan Page, 191. Development and control of rural resources The Conservation and Development Programme for the UK: A Response to the World Conservation Strategy 191 Google Scholar

OWEN, S. (1994), 'Fresh perspectives for village planning', Town and Country Planning, 63, 132–34. Fresh perspectives for village planning Town and Country Planning 63 132 34 Google Scholar

PEPPER, D. (1996), Modern Environmentalism: An Introduction, London, Routledge. Modern Environmentalism: An Introduction Google Scholar

PREECE, R. (1990), 'Development control studies; scientific method and policy analysis', Town Planning Review, 61, 59-74 'Development control studies; scientific method and policy analysis' Town Planning Review 61 59 74 Google Scholar

SCOTT, A. J. (2001), 'Special Landscape Areas: Their operation and effectiveness in Ceredigion, Wales', Town Planning Review, 72, 469–80. Special Landscape Areas: Their operation and effectiveness in Ceredigion, Wales Town Planning Review 72 469 80 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

SCOTT, A. J. (2002b), 'Assessing public perception of landscape: the LANDMAP experience', Landscape Research, 27, 271–95. Assessing public perception of landscape: the LANDMAP experience Landscape Research 27 271 95 Google Scholar

SCOTT, A. J. (forthcoming), Assessing public perception of landscape: from practice to policy', Journal of Environment Policy and Planning. Google Scholar

SCOTTISH OFFICE (1998), National Planning Policy Guidelines 14: Natural Heritage', Edinburgh, The Scottish Office. Google Scholar

SELMAN, P. (2002), 'Multi-function landscape plans: a missing link in sustainability planning?', Local Environment, 7, 283–94. Multi-function landscape plans: a missing link in sustainability planning? Local Environment 7 283 94 Google Scholar

SHOARD, M. (1982a), 'The lure of the moors' in Gold and Burgess (eds), 55–73. The lure of the moors 55 73 Google Scholar

SHOARD, M. (1982b), The Theft of the Countryside, London, Temple Smith. The Theft of the Countryside Google Scholar

TEWDWR JONES, M. and PHELPS, N. (2000), 'Levelling the uneven playing field: inward investment, interregional rivalry and the planning system', Regional Studies, 34, 429–40. Levelling the uneven playing field: inward investment, interregional rivalry and the planning system Regional Studies 34 429 40 Google Scholar

TORFAEN COUNTY BOROUGH COUNCIL (2000), Torfaen Local Plan, Pontypool, Torfaen Council. Google Scholar

WELSH ASSEMBLY GOVERNMENT (2002), Planning Policy Wales, Cardiff, Welsh Assembly Government. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Scott, Alister

Bullen, Anna