Town Planning Review

Neither market nor government: Comparing the performance of user rights regimes

Town Planning Review (2003), 74, (3), 315–330.

Abstract

This paper takes a different perspective on the market versus government debate. This debate is often too general, too political and not fruitful. Starting from the assumption that many actors make decisions about changes in land use and that those decisions have to be coordinated in some ways, three models of coordination (market, hierarchy and network) are identified. These models, which in practice are often mixed, represent different ways of coordinating decisions about changing the content of user rights and/or changing the ownership of user rights in order to change land use. Which model is 'best' cannot be determined in general, but has to be evaluated by comparing the performance of user rights regimes.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

ALCHIAN, A. A. and DEMSETZ, H. (1973), 'The property right paradigm', Journal of Economic History, 33, 16–27. The property right paradigm Journal of Economic History 33 16 27 Google Scholar

ALEXANDER, E. R. (1992), 'A transaction cost theory of planning', Journal of the American Planning Association, 58, 190–200. A transaction cost theory of planning Journal of the American Planning Association 58 190 200 Google Scholar

ALEXANDER, E. R. (2001a), 'A transaction-cost theory of land use planning and development control; toward the institutional analysis of public planning', Town Planning Review, 72, 45–75. A transaction-cost theory of land use planning and development control; toward the institutional analysis of public planning Town Planning Review 72 45 75 Google Scholar

ALEXANDER, E. R. (2001b), 'Why planning vs. markets is an oxymoron: asking the right question', Planning andMarkets, 4, 1– 8. Why planning vs. markets is an oxymoron: asking the right question Planning andMarkets 4 1 8 Google Scholar

BOOTH, P. (2002), 'From property rights to public control; the quest for public interest in the control of urban development', Town Planning Review, 73, 153–69. From property rights to public control; the quest for public interest in the control of urban development Town Planning Review 73 153 69 Google Scholar

BUITELAAR, E. (2002), New Institutional Economics and Planning: A Different Perspective on the Market Versus Government Debate in Spatial Planning (GAP Working Paper Series 11), Nijmegen, Nijmegen School of Management. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

CHEUNG, N. S. (1990), On the New Institutional Economics (Discussion Paper 118), Hong Kong, Department of Economics, University of Hong Kong. Google Scholar

COASE, R. H. (1960), 'The problem of social cost', Journal of Law and Economics, 3, 1–44. The problem of social cost Journal of Law and Economics 3 1 44 Google Scholar

CORKINDALE, J. (1999), 'Land development in the United Kingdom: private property rights and public policy objectives', Environment and Planning A, 31, 2053–70. Land development in the United Kingdom: private property rights and public policy objectives Environment and Planning A 31 2053 70 Google Scholar

CPB (CENTRAAL PLANBUREAU) (1999), De grondmarkt: een gebrekkige markt en een onvolmaakte overheid (The Dutch Land Market: An Imperfect Market and a Fallible Government), Den Haag, Sdu Uitgevers. Google Scholar

DE ALESSI, L. (1990), 'Development of the property right approach' in E. G. Furubotn and R. Richter (eds) (1991), The New Institutional Economics: A Collection of Articles from the Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, Tübingen, Mohr, 45–53. 'Development of the property right approach' (1991) The New Institutional Economics: A Collection of Articles from the Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics 45 53 Google Scholar

DIXIT, A. K. (1996), The Making of Economic Policy: A Transaction-Cost Politics Perspective, Cambridge, MA, MIT Press. The Making of Economic Policy: A Transaction-Cost Politics Perspective Google Scholar

ELLICKSON, R. C. (1977), 'Alternatives to zoning: covenants, nuisance rules, and fines as land use controls', University of Chicago Law Review, 40, 681–781. Alternatives to zoning: covenants, nuisance rules, and fines as land use controls University of Chicago Law Review 40 681 781 Google Scholar

ELLICKSON, R. C. (1993), 'Property in land', Yale Law Journal, 102, 1315–400. Property in land Yale Law Journal 102 1315 400 Google Scholar

FURUBOTN, E. G. and RICHTER, R. (1991), 'The new institutional economics: an assessment' in E. G. Furubotn and R. Richter (eds), The New Institutional Economics: A Collection of Articles from the Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, Tübingen, Mohr, 1–32. 'The new institutional economics: an assessment' The New Institutional Economics: A Collection of Articles from the Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics 1 32 Google Scholar

HAYEK, F. VON (1944), The Road to Serfdom, London, Routledge. The Road to Serfdom Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

HAZEU, C. A. (2000), Institutionele economie: een optiek op organisatie-en sturingsvraagstukken, Bussum, Coutinho uitgeverij. Institutionele economie: een optiek op organisatie-en sturingsvraagstukken Google Scholar

HEALEY, P. (1998), 'Regulating property development and the capacity of the development industry', Journal of Property Research, 15, 211–27. Regulating property development and the capacity of the development industry Journal of Property Research 15 211 27 Google Scholar

HEIKKILA, E. J. (2000), The Economics of Planning, New Brunswick, Center for Urban Policy Research. The Economics of Planning Google Scholar

HOOGERWERF, A. (1995), Politiek als evenwichtskunst: dilemma's rond overheid en markt, Alphen aan den Rijn, Samsom H. D. Tjeenk Willink. Politiek als evenwichtskunst: dilemma's rond overheid en markt Google Scholar

JACOBS, H. M. (1998), Who Owns America?: Social Conflict over Property Rights, Wisconsin, University of Wisconsin Press. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

KEOGH, G. and D'ARCY, É. (1999), 'Property market efficiency: an institutional economics perpective', Urban Studies, 13, 2401–14. Property market efficiency: an institutional economics perpective Urban Studies 13 2401 14 Google Scholar

KLOSTERMAN, R. E. (1985), 'Arguments for and against planning', Town Planning Review, 56, 5–20. Arguments for and against planning Town Planning Review 56 5 20 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

KORTHALS ALTES, W. K. (1998), Grondbeleid als marktinterventie (inaugural lecture), Delft, Delft University Press. Google Scholar

KREUKELS, A. M. J. (1980), Planning en planningproces, Den Haag, VUGA Boekerij. Planning en planningproces Google Scholar

LAI, L. W. C. (1994), 'The economics of land use zoning. A literature review and analysis of the work of Coase', Town Planning Review, 65, 77–98. The economics of land use zoning. A literature review and analysis of the work of Coase Town Planning Review 65 77 98 Google Scholar

LAI, L. W. C. (1997), 'Property rights justifications for planning and a theory of zoning' in D. Diamond and B. H. Massam (eds), Progress in Planning, 48, Exeter, BPC Wheatons, 161–245. 'Property rights justifications for planning and a theory of zoning' Progress in Planning 48 161 245 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

MANNHEIM, K. (1940), Man and Society in an Age of Reconstruction: Studies in Modern Social Structure, London, Routledge & Kegan Paul. Man and Society in an Age of Reconstruction: Studies in Modern Social Structure Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

MICELLI, E. (2002), 'Development rights markets to manage urban plans', Urban Studies, 39, 141–54. Development rights markets to manage urban plans Urban Studies 39 141 54 Google Scholar

MUNZER, S. R. (1990), A Theory of Property, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. A Theory of Property Google Scholar

NADIN, V., HAWKES, P., COOPER, S., SHAW, D. and WESTLAKE, T. (1997), The EU Compendium of Spatial Planning Systems and Policies, Luxembourg, Office for the Official Publications of the European Union. The EU Compendium of Spatial Planning Systems and Policies Google Scholar

NEEDHAM, B. (2001), 'De markt is een maaksel van de maatschappij' in B. Dankbaar and J. Jonker (eds), Meer dan overheid en markt. Management in de nieuwe economie, Assen, Koninklijke Van Gorcum, 47–50. 'De markt is een maaksel van de maatschappij' Meer dan overheid en markt. Management in de nieuwe economie 47 50 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

NELISSEN, N. (2001), 'De 'Overmarkt' stuit op haar grenzen' in B. Dankbaar and J. Jonker (eds), Meer dan overheid en markt. Management in de nieuwe economie, Assen, Koninklijke Van Gorcum, 41–45. 'De 'Overmarkt' stuit op haar grenzen' Meer dan overheid en markt. Management in de nieuwe economie 41 45 Google Scholar

NORTH, D. C. (1990), 'A transaction cost theory of politics', Journal of Theoretical Politics, 2, 355–67. A transaction cost theory of politics Journal of Theoretical Politics 2 355 67 Google Scholar

PENNINGTON, M. (1999), 'Free market environmentalism and the limits of land use planning', Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 1, 43–59. Free market environmentalism and the limits of land use planning Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning 1 43 59 Google Scholar

PIGOU, A. C. (1920), The Economics of Welfare, London, Macmillan. The Economics of Welfare Google Scholar

POLANYI, K. (1957), The Great Transformation, New York, Rinehart. The Great Transformation Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

PUTNAM, R. D. (1993),Making Democracy Work, Civic Traditions in Modern Italy, Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press. Making Democracy Work, Civic Traditions in Modern Italy Google Scholar

RANKIN, K. (1998), 'Compulsory freedom', New Zealand Political Review, 7, 12–15. Compulsory freedom New Zealand Political Review 7 12 15 Google Scholar

ROB (RAAD VOOR HET OPENBAAR BESTUUR) (1998), De overheid de markt in-of uitprijzen, Den Haag, ROB. Google Scholar

SCHARPF, F. W. (1993), 'Coordination in hierarchies and networks' in F. W. Scharpf (ed.), Games in Hierarchies and Networks, Frankfurt am Mein, Campus Verlag; Boulder, CO, Westview Press, 125–65. Google Scholar

SORENSEN, T. (1994), 'Further thoughts on Coasian approaches to zoning. A response to Lai Wai Chung', Town Planning Review, 65, 197–203. Further thoughts on Coasian approaches to zoning. A response to Lai Wai Chung Town Planning Review 65 197 203 Google Scholar

TAYLOR, N. (1998), Urban Planning Theory Since 1945, London, Sage. Urban Planning Theory Since 1945 Google Scholar

THOMPSON, G., FRANCES J., LEVAČIĆ, R. and MITCHELL, J. (eds) (1991), Markets, Hierarchies and Networks: The Coordination of Social Life, London, Sage. Markets, Hierarchies and Networks: The Coordination of Social Life Google Scholar

WEBSTER, C. J. (1998), 'Public choice, Pigouvian and Coasian planning theory', Urban Studies, 35, 53–75. Public choice, Pigouvian and Coasian planning theory Urban Studies 35 53 75 Google Scholar

WEBSTER, C. and LAI, L. W. C. (2003), Property Rights, Planning and Markets: Managing Spontaneous Cities, Cheltenham UK/Northampton, MA, Edward Elgar. Property Rights, Planning and Markets: Managing Spontaneous Cities Google Scholar

WILLIAMSON, O. E. (1975), Markets and Hierarchies, New York, Free Press. Markets and Hierarchies Google Scholar

WILLIAMSON, O. E. (1999), 'Public and private bureaucracies: a transaction costs economics perspective', Journal of Law, Economics and Organisation, 15, 306–42. Public and private bureaucracies: a transaction costs economics perspective Journal of Law, Economics and Organisation 15 306 42 Google Scholar

WOLF, C. (1979), 'A theory of nonmarket failure: framework for implementation analysis', Journal of Law and Economics, 22, 107–39. A theory of nonmarket failure: framework for implementation analysis Journal of Law and Economics 22 107 39 Google Scholar

WOLF, C. (1988), Markets or Governments: Choosing Between Imperfect Alternatives, Cambridge, MIT Press. Markets or Governments: Choosing Between Imperfect Alternatives Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Buitelaar, Edwin