International Development Planning Review

An emerging cross-boundary metropolis in China: Hong Kong and Shenzhen under 'Two Systems'

International Development Planning Review (2005), 27, (2), 195–225.

Abstract

In comparison with the ever increasing literature on cross-border regions in the era of globalisation and regionalisation, less attention has been paid to paired border cities and their mutual relations. Moreover, existing studies on metropolises straddling international borders have tended to concentrate on North America and Western Europe, with little focus on cases in East Asia. Taking as a case study the first Special Administrative Region of China, Hong Kong, and its adjacent city Shenzhen, the first and most successful Special Economic Zone in China, this paper argues that the two border cities have integrated economically, socially and physically over the past two decades. In consequence, a cross-boundary metropolis is in the making. However, under the unique framework of 'One Country, Two Systems', this emerging cross-boundary metropolis has demonstrated some distinctive characteristics which have fundamental impacts on its development, governance and future prospects.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

BAE, C. C. (2003), 'Tijuana–San Diego: globalization and the transborder metropolis', Annuals of Regional Science, 37, 463–77. Tijuana–San Diego: globalization and the transborder metropolis Annuals of Regional Science 37 463 77 Google Scholar

BETTER HK FOUNDATION (2003), Summary of Strengthening HK's Port and Trade http:// www.betterhongkong.org/archives/images/ExecutiveSummary(English).pdf Google Scholar

BRUTON, M. J., BRUTON, S. G. and LI, Y. (2005), 'Shenzhen: coping with uncertainties in planning', Habitat International, 29, 227–43. Shenzhen: coping with uncertainties in planning Habitat International 29 227 43 Google Scholar

BUURSINK, J. (2001), 'The binational reality of border-crossing cities', Geojournal, 54, 7–19. The binational reality of border-crossing cities Geojournal 54 7 19 Google Scholar

CARTIER, C. (2002), 'Transnational urbanism in the reform-era Chinese city: landscape from Shenzhen', Urban Studies, 39, 1513–32. Transnational urbanism in the reform-era Chinese city: landscape from Shenzhen Urban Studies 39 1513 32 Google Scholar

CDI (COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE OF STATE COUNCIL) (2003), Policy Suggestions on Shenzhen's Position in the New Era, internal document, Shenzhen, Comprehensive Development Institute Press. Google Scholar

CHAN, T. M. H. and KWOK, R. Y. W. (1991), 'Economic development in the Shenzhen Special Economic Zone: appendage to HK?', Southeast Asian Journal of Social Science, 19, 180–205. Economic development in the Shenzhen Special Economic Zone: appendage to HK? Southeast Asian Journal of Social Science 19 180 205 Google Scholar

CHEN, X. (1993), 'The changing role of Shenzhen in China's national and regional development in the 1980s' in G. T Yu (ed.), China in Transition: Economic, Political and Social Developments, Lanham and London, University Press of America, 229–50. The changing role of Shenzhen in China's national and regional development in the 1980s China in Transition: Economic, Political and Social Developments 229 50 Google Scholar

CHEUNG, P. T. Y (2002), 'Managing the HK–Guangdong relationship: issues and challenges' in A. G. O. Yeh et al. (eds), Building a Competitive Pearl River Delta Region: Cooperation, Coordination and Planning, Hong Kong, The Centre of Urban Planning and Environmental Management, University of Hong Kong, 39–58. Managing the HK–Guangdong relationship: issues and challenges Building a Competitive Pearl River Delta Region: Cooperation, Coordination and Planning 39 58 Google Scholar

CHU, D. K. Y, SHEN, J. and WONG, K. Y. (2002), 'Shenzhen-HK as one: modes and prospectus of regional governance in the Pearl River Delta' in K. Y Wong and J. Shen (eds), Resource Management, Urbanization and Governance in HK and the Zhujiang Delta, Hong Kong, The Chinese University Press, 231–48. Shenzhen-HK as one: modes and prospectus of regional governance in the Pearl River Delta Resource Management, Urbanization and Governance in HK and the Zhujiang Delta 231 48 Google Scholar

CLARK, C. (1998), 'The politics of place making in Shenzhen, China', Berkeley Planning Journal, 12, 103–25. The politics of place making in Shenzhen, China Berkeley Planning Journal 12 103 25 Google Scholar

CULLINANE, S. and CULLINANE, K. (2003), 'City profile: HK', Cities, 20, 279–88. City profile: HK Cities 20 279 88 Google Scholar

EDITORIAL BOARD OF SHENZHEN ALMANAC (2003), The Almanac of Shenzhen 2003, Shenzhen, Shenzhen Almanac Press. Google Scholar

EHLERS, N (2001), 'The utopia of the binational city', Geojournal, 54, 21–32. The utopia of the binational city Geojournal 54 21 32 Google Scholar

EHLERS, N, BUURSINK, J. and BOEKEMA, F. (2001), 'Introduction: binational cities and their regions: from diverging cases to a common research agenda', Geojournal, 54, 1–5. Google Scholar

FEDERATION OF HK INDUSTRIES (2003), Made in PRD: The Changing Face of HK Manufacturers. Part II Full Report, Hong Kong, Federation of HK Industries. Google Scholar

GUANGDONG STATISTIGAL BUREAU (2003), Guangdong Statistical Yearbook 2003, Beijing, China Statistics Press. Google Scholar

HÄKLI, J., and KAPLAN, D. H. (2002), 'Learning from Europe? Borderlands in social and geographical context' in D. H. Kaplan and J. Häkli (eds), Boundaries and Place: European Borderlands in Geographical Context, Oxford, Rowman & Littlefield, 1–17. Learning from Europe? Borderlands in social and geographical context Boundaries and Place: European Borderlands in Geographical Context 1 17 Google Scholar

HERZOG, L. A. (1991), 'Cross-national urban structure in the era of global cities: the US–Mexico transfrontier metropolis', Urban Studies, 28, 519–33. Cross-national urban structure in the era of global cities: the US–Mexico transfrontier metropolis Urban Studies 28 519 33 Google Scholar

HERZOG, L. A. (1997), 'The transfrontier metropolis: a new kind of international city', Harvard Design Magazine, Winter/Spring, 1, 1–5. The transfrontier metropolis: a new kind of international city' Harvard Design Magazine Winter/Spring, 1 1 5 Google Scholar

HK COMMERCIAL DAILY (28 September 2003) http://www.hkcd.com.hk Google Scholar

HKCSD (HKSAR GOVERNMENT CENSUS AND STATISTICS DEPARTMENT) (2OO3), 'Engagement in job-related business activities in the mainland', Thematic Household Survey Report, 13, 109–17. Google Scholar

HKCSD (HKSAR GOVERNMENT CENSUS AND STATISTICS DEPARTMENT) (1980–2003), HK Monthly Digestof Statistics, various issues, Hong Kong, HKSAR Government. Google Scholar

HKSAR FINANCIAL SECRETARY (2004), 2004–05 Budget Speech http://www.budget.gov.hk/ 2004/eng/speech.htm Google Scholar

HKSAR GOVERNMENT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND LABOUR BUREAU, PORT, MARITIME AND LOGISTICS DEVELOPMENT UNIT (2003), Summary Statistics on Port Traffic of HK (November), Hong Kong, HKSAR Government Economic Development and Labour Bureau. Google Scholar

HKSAR GOVERNMENT, FINANCIAL SECRETARY (2002), 2002–03 Budget Speech http://www.budget.gov.hk/2002/eframe.2.htm Google Scholar

HKSAR GOVERNMENT PLANNING DEPARTMENT (2000), Cross-Boundary Travel Survey, Executive Summary, Hong Kong, HKSAR Government. Google Scholar

HKSAR GOVERNMENT PLANNING DEPARTMENT (2001), 'Planning frameworks of Guangzhou, Shenzhen, Zhuhai and Macao' (Working Paper No. 3), HK 2030 Planning Vision and Strategy http://www.info.gov.hk/hk2030content/wpapers/working_paper3/e_plan7.htm Google Scholar

HKSAR GOVERNMENT PLANNING DEPARTMENT (2002), Northbound, Southbound: Profile of Travelling between the Mainland and HK Based on the Cross-Boundary Travel Survey 2001, Hong Kong, HKSAR Government. Google Scholar

HKSAR GOVERNMENT PLANNING DEPARTMENT (2003a), Development Potential of Frontier Closed Area (Working Paper No. 32), Hong Kong, HKSAR Government. Google Scholar

HKSAR GOVERNMENT PLANNING DEPARTMENT (2003b), HK 2030: Planning Vision and Strategy (Stage 3 Public Consultation), Hong Kong, HKSAR Government. Google Scholar

HKSAR GOVERNMENT PLANNING DEPARTMENT (1980–2003), Monthly Traffic and Transport Digest, Hong Kong, HKSAR Government. Google Scholar

KWOK, R. Y. W. and FONG, P. K. W. (1984), 'The economic and social impact of Shenzhen SEZ development: a planning analysis' in V F. S. Sit (ed.), Resources and Development of The Pearl River Delta, Hong Kong, Wide Angle Press, 135–48. The economic and social impact of Shenzhen SEZ development: a planning analysis Resources and Development of The Pearl River Delta 135 48 Google Scholar

LIN, G. C. S. (2003), An emerging global city-region? Economic and social integration between HK and the Pearl River Delta' in A. Y So (ed.), China's Developmental Miracle: Origins,Transformations, and Challenges, Armonk, NY, and London, M. E. Sharpe, 79–107. An emerging global city-region? Economic and social integration between HK and the Pearl River Delta China's Developmental Miracle: Origins,Transformations, and Challenges 79 107 Google Scholar

LO, C. P (1997), 'Dispersed spatial development: HK's new city form and its economic implications after 1997', Cities, 14, 273–77. Dispersed spatial development: HK's new city form and its economic implications after 1997 Cities 14 273 77 Google Scholar

LUNDÉN, T. and ZALAMANS, D. (2001), 'Local cooperation, ethnic diversity and state territoriality: the case of Haparanda and Tornio on the Sweden–Finland border', Geojournal, 54, 33–42. Local cooperation, ethnic diversity and state territoriality: the case of Haparanda and Tornio on the Sweden–Finland border Geojournal 54 33 42 Google Scholar

MATTHIESEN, U. and BÜRKNER, H. (2001), Antagonistic structures in border areas: local milieux and local politics in the Polish–German twin city Gubin/Guben', Geojournal, 54, 43–50. Antagonistic structures in border areas: local milieux and local politics in the Polish–German twin city Gubin/Guben' Geojournal 54 43 50 Google Scholar

MCGEE, T. G. (1991), 'The Emergence of Desakota regions in Asia: expanding a hypothesis' in N. Ginsburg, B. Koppel and T. G. McGee (eds), The Extended Metropolis: Settlement Transition in Asia, Honolulu, University of Hawaii Press, 3–25. The Emergence of Desakota regions in Asia: expanding a hypothesis The Extended Metropolis: Settlement Transition in Asia 3 25 Google Scholar

NEWMAN, D. and PAASI, A. (1998), 'Fences and neighbours in the postmodern world: boundary narratives in political geography', Progress in Human Geography, 22, 186–207. Fences and neighbours in the postmodern world: boundary narratives in political geography Progress in Human Geography 22 186 207 Google Scholar

NG, M. K. (2002), 'Sustainable urban development issues in Chinese transitional cities: HK and Shenzhen', International Planning Studies, 7, 7–36. Sustainable urban development issues in Chinese transitional cities: HK and Shenzhen International Planning Studies 7 7 36 Google Scholar

NG, M. K. (2003), 'City profile: Shenzhen', Cities, 20, 429–41. City profile: Shenzhen Cities 20 429 41 Google Scholar

NG, M. K. and TANG, W. S. (1999), 'Land-use planning in "OCTS": HK, Guangzhou and Shenzhen', International Planning Studies, 4, 7–27. Land-use planning in "OCTS": HK, Guangzhou and Shenzhen International Planning Studies 4 7 27 Google Scholar

NG, M. K. and TANG, W. S. (2004), 'The role of planning in the development of Shenzhen, China: rhetoric and realities', Eurasian Geography and Economics, 45, 190–211. The role of planning in the development of Shenzhen, China: rhetoric and realities Eurasian Geography and Economics 45 190 211 Google Scholar

NIU, H. (2002), Planning for Rapid Growth in Shenzhen, China http://www.asu.edu/caed/ proceedings02/nui/nui.htm Google Scholar

O'DONNELL, M. A. (2001), 'Becoming HK, razing Baoan, preserving Xin'an: an ethnographic account of urbanization in the Shenzhen Special Economic Zone', Cultural Studies, 15, 419–43. Becoming HK, razing Baoan, preserving Xin'an: an ethnographic account of urbanization in the Shenzhen Special Economic Zone Cultural Studies 15 419 43 Google Scholar

OHMAE, K. (1995), The End of the Nation State, New York, The Free Press. The End of the Nation State Google Scholar

ONE COUNTRY TWO SYSTEMS RESEARGH INSTITUTE (2002), Socio-economics of 24-Hour Operation of Land Boundary Control Points on HK (Executive Summary), submitted to the Central Point Unit, HKSAR Government. Google Scholar

PERKMANN, M. and SUM, N. L. (eds) (2002), Globalization, Regionalization and Cross-Border Regions, Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan. Globalization, Regionalization and Cross-Border Regions Google Scholar

SASSEN, S. (1991), The Global City, Princeton, Princeton University Press. The Global City Google Scholar

SASSEN, S. (ed.) (2003), Global Networks: Linked Cities, New York and London, Routledge. Global Networks: Linked Cities Google Scholar

SCOTT, A. J. (ed.) (2001), Global City-Regions: Trends, Theory, Policy, New York, Oxford University Press. Global City-Regions: Trends, Theory, Policy Google Scholar

SHEN, J. (2003), 'Cross-border connection between HK and Mainland China under "two systems" before and beyond 1997', Geografiska Annaler (Series B, Human Geography), 85, 1–17. Cross-border connection between HK and Mainland China under "two systems" before and beyond 1997 Geografiska Annaler (Series B, Human Geography) 85 1 17 Google Scholar

SHENZHEN MUNICIPAL GOVERNMENT (2001), The Tenth Five-Year Plan of Social-Economic Developmentof Shenzhen http://www.shenzhen.net.cn/jujiao/zhuanti/zt1/default.htm Google Scholar

SHENZHEN STATISTICAL BUREAU (2003), Shenzhen Statistics Yearbook 2003, Beijing, China Statistics Press. Google Scholar

SHIU, S. P. and YANG, C. (2002), 'A study on developing the HK–Shenzhen border zone' in A. G. Yeh, Y F Lee, T Lee and N. D. Sze (eds), Building a Competitive Pearl River Delta Region: Cooperation, Coordination and Planning, Hong Kong, Centre for Urban Planning and Environmental Management, 245–70. A study on developing the HK–Shenzhen border zone Building a Competitive Pearl River Delta Region: Cooperation, Coordination and Planning 245 70 Google Scholar

SIT, V. F. S. (1988), 'China's export-oriented open areas: the export processing zone concept', Asian Survey, 28, 661–75. China's export-oriented open areas: the export processing zone concept Asian Survey 28 661 75 Google Scholar

SIT, V. F. S. and YANG, C. (1997), 'The transborder economic region of HK–Shenzhen', Acta Geographica Sinica, 52 (Supplement), 16–27 (in Chinese). Google Scholar

SKELDON, R. (1997), 'HK: colonial city to global city to provincial city?', Cities, 14, 265–71. HK: colonial city to global city to provincial city? Cities 14 265 71 Google Scholar

SMART, J. and SMART, A. (1991), 'Personal relations and divergent economies: a case study of HK investment in China', International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 15, 216–33. Personal relations and divergent economies: a case study of HK investment in China International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 15 216 33 Google Scholar

SO, A. Y. (1988), 'Shenzhen Special Economic Zone: China's struggle for independence development', Canadian Journal of Development Studies, 9, 313–23. Shenzhen Special Economic Zone: China's struggle for independence development Canadian Journal of Development Studies 9 313 23 Google Scholar

SPARKE, M., SIDEAWAY, J. D., BUNNELL, T. and GRUNDY-WARR, C. G. (2004), 'Triangulating the borderless world: geographies of power in the Indonesia–Malaysia–Singapore Growth Triangle', Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 29, 485–98. Triangulating the borderless world: geographies of power in the Indonesia–Malaysia–Singapore Growth Triangle Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 29 485 98 Google Scholar

SPARROW, G. (2001), 'San Diego–Tijuana: not quite a binational city or region', Geojournal, 54, 73–83. San Diego–Tijuana: not quite a binational city or region Geojournal 54 73 83 Google Scholar

STATE STATISTICS BUREAU (CHINA) (1987–2003), China Statistical Yearbook, Beijing, China Statistical Press. Google Scholar

URBANRAIL.NET (2004), Shenzhen http://www.urbanrail.net/as/shen/shenzhen.htm Google Scholar

VAN GEENHUIZEN, M. and RATTI, R. (2001), 'Reflections on active space development: emerging issues and new research path' in M. Van Geenhuizen and R. Ratti (eds), Gaining Advantage from Open Borders: An Active Space Approach to Regional Development, Aldershot, Ashgate, 389–98. Google Scholar

WANG, J. J. and SLACK, B. (2000), 'The evolution of a regional container port system: the Pearl River Delta', Journal of Transport Geography, 8, 263–75. The evolution of a regional container port system: the Pearl River Delta Journal of Transport Geography 8 263 75 Google Scholar

WONG, K. Y. and CHU, D. K. Y (1985), Modernization in China: The Case of Shenzhen Special Economic Zone, Oxford, Oxford University Press. Modernization in China: The Case of Shenzhen Special Economic Zone Google Scholar

WONG, K. Y. and SHEN, J. (2002), Resource Management, Urbanization and Governance in Hong Kong and the Zhujiang Delta, Hong Kong, The Chinese University Press. Resource Management, Urbanization and Governance in Hong Kong and the Zhujiang Delta Google Scholar

WOWEIYIKUANG (Pseudonym) (2002), 'Shenzhen: who has abandoned you?' ('Shenzhen:Nibeishuipaoqi') http://home.donews.com/donews.article/3/36569 Google Scholar

WU, S., BIN, Y, MA, D. and XIAO, Z. (eds) (1985), The History of Shenzhen: In Window of Opening, Shenzhen, China Youth Publishing Agency. The History of Shenzhen: In Window of Opening Google Scholar

WU, W. (1997), 'Proximity and complementarity in HK–Shenzhen industrialization', AsianSurvey, 37, 771–94. Proximity and complementarity in HK–Shenzhen industrialization AsianSurvey 37 771 94 Google Scholar

WU, W. (1999), Pioneering Economic Reform in China's Special Economic Zones: The Promotion of Foreign Investment and Technology Transfer in Shenzhen, Aldershot and Brookfield, Ashgate. Pioneering Economic Reform in China's Special Economic Zones: The Promotion of Foreign Investment and Technology Transfer in Shenzhen Google Scholar

XIA, H. (2001), Hierarchy of Chinese Government (Zhongguo Zhengfu Jiagou), Beijing, Tsinghua University Press. Hierarchy of Chinese Government (Zhongguo Zhengfu Jiagou) Google Scholar

YAN, X. and LENG, Y (1997), 'Study on the coordinative development of Shenzhen–HK twin cities', Acta Geographica Sinica, 52 (Supplement), 95–103 (in Chinese). Google Scholar

YANG, C. (2004), 'From market-led to institution-based economic integration: the case of the Pearl River Delta and Hong Kong', Issues and Studies, 40, 79–118. From market-led to institution-based economic integration: the case of the Pearl River Delta and Hong Kong Issues and Studies 40 79 118 Google Scholar

YANG, C. (forthcoming), 'The Pearl River Delta and Hong Kong: an evolving cross-boundary region under "One Country, Two Systems"', Habitat International (in press). Google Scholar

YEH, A. G. O., LEE, F. Y S., LEE, T. and SZE, N. D. (eds) (2002), Building a Competitive Pearl River DeltaRegion: Cooperation, Coordination, and Planning, Hong Kong, Centre of Urban Planning and Environmental Management, The University of Hong Kong. Building a Competitive Pearl River DeltaRegion: Cooperation, Coordination, and Planning Google Scholar

YEUNG, Y M. (1997), 'Planning for Pearl City: HK's future, 1997 and beyond', Cities, 14, 249–56. Planning for Pearl City: HK's future, 1997 and beyond Cities 14 249 56 Google Scholar

YEUNG, Y. M. (2003), 'Integration of the Pearl River Delta', International Development Planning Review, 25, iii–viii. Google Scholar

ZHU, J. (1999), 'The formation of a market-oriented local property development industry in transitional China: a Shenzhen case study', Environment and Planning A, 31, 1839–56. The formation of a market-oriented local property development industry in transitional China: a Shenzhen case study Environment and Planning A 31 1839 56 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Yang, Chun