International Development Planning Review

Emergence, formation and outcomes of flexibility in Turkish planning practice

International Development Planning Review (2016), 38, (1), 25–53.

Abstract

We examine three key issues related to flexibility in planning: the first is to understand how flexibility in planning emerges and to define its content; the second relates to how flexibility is formed in planning practices; and the third is to examine the outcomes of flexibility in planning practices. While focusing on the production of large-scale housing projects in Turkey, we examine the emergence of flexibility in planning in Turkey, the extent of this flexibility, how flexibility in Turkey is defined in its planning practices and the outcomes of such planning practices. We base our examination on two projects in Istanbul, one in a newly developing area and the other in an urban renewal area. Some lessons from our research will be relevant to other developing countries that have similar dynamics.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Altin. Y. and Turk, S. S. (2005) ‘An analysis related to plan amendments in Istanbul metropolitan area’ (İstanbul Metropoliten Alanında İmar Planı Değişiklikleri İle İlgili Bir Analiz) 8 Kasım Dünya Şehircilik Günü 29. Kolokyumu Planlamada Yeni Politika ve Stratejiler, Riskler ve Fırsatlar, 7–9 Nov, 2005, Taşkışla, Istanbul (in Turkish). An analysis related to plan amendments in Istanbul metropolitan area’ (İstanbul Metropoliten Alanında İmar Planı Değişiklikleri İle İlgili Bir Analiz) Google Scholar

Atkinson, R. and Blandy, S. (2006) Gated communities, London, Taylor and Francis, Routledge. Gated communities Google Scholar

Baker, D. C, Sipe, N. G. and Brendan, J. G. (2006) ‘Performance-based planning: perspectives from the United States, Australia, and New Zealand’, Journal of Planning Education and Research, 25, 396–409. Performance-based planning: perspectives from the United States, Australia, and New Zealand Journal of Planning Education and Research 25 396 409 Google Scholar

Balaban, O. (2012) ‘The negative effects of construction boom on the urban planning and environment in Turkey: unraveling the role of the public sector’, Habitat International, 36, 26–35. The negative effects of construction boom on the urban planning and environment in Turkey: unraveling the role of the public sector Habitat International 36 26 35 Google Scholar

Booth, P. (1999) ‘Discretion in planning versus zoning’, in B. Cullingworth (ed.) British planning: 50 years of urban and regional policy, London, the Athlone press, 31–43. Discretion in planning versus zoning British planning: 50 years of urban and regional policy 31 43 Google Scholar

Booth, P. (2003) Planning by consent: the origins and nature of British development control, London, Routledge. Planning by consent: the origins and nature of British development control Google Scholar

Booth, P. (2007) ‘The control of discretion: planning and the common law tradition’, Planning Theory, 6(2), 127–45. The control of discretion: planning and the common law tradition Planning Theory 6 127 45 Google Scholar

Crook, A. and Monk, S. (2011) ‘Planning gains, providing homes’, Housing Studies, 26(7–8), 997–1018. Planning gains, providing homes Housing Studies 26 997 1018 Google Scholar

De Kam, G. (2014) ‘Inclusionary housing in the Netherlands: breaking the institutional path?’, Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 29(3), 439–54. Inclusionary housing in the Netherlands: breaking the institutional path? Journal of Housing and the Built Environment 29 439 54 Google Scholar

Dieleman, M. (2011) ‘New town development in Indonesia: renegotiating, shaping and replacing, institutions’, Bijdragen tot de Taal-, Land-en Volkenkunde, 167(1), 60–85. New town development in Indonesia: renegotiating, shaping and replacing, institutions Bijdragen tot de Taal-, Land-en Volkenkunde 167 60 85 Google Scholar

DiMaggio, P. and Powell, W. (1983) ‘The iron cage revisited: institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields’, American Sociological Review, 48, 147–60. The iron cage revisited: institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields American Sociological Review 48 147 60 Google Scholar

Emlak GYO (2011) 01 Ocak–30 Haziran 2011 Dönemine Ait Yönetim Kurulu Faaliyet Raporu (01 January–30 June 2011 Term Administrative Council Annual Report), http://www.emlakkonut.com.tr/PDFs/Faaliyet/20110101–20110630-Donemi-Emlak-Konut-GYOFaaliyet-Raporu.pdf (accessed 18 April 2012) (in Turkish). Google Scholar

Emlak Konut (2014) ‘2014 Ara Dönem Faaliyet Raporu III’ (2014 mid-term activity report III), http:www.emlakkonut.com.tr/Projeler/tr_devamEdenProjeler.aspx (accessed 10 August 2014). Google Scholar

Ennis, F. (2003) Infrastructure provision and negotiating process, Fanham, Ashgate. Infrastructure provision and negotiating process Google Scholar

Eraydin, A. (2011) ‘The outcome of neoliberal policies on Istanbul metropolitan area: what neoliberal planning stands for?’ in T. Taşan-Kok and G. Beaten (eds) Contradictions of neoliberal planning: cities, policies, and politics, Dordrecht, Springer, 61–68. The outcome of neoliberal policies on Istanbul metropolitan area: what neoliberal planning stands for? Contradictions of neoliberal planning: cities, policies, and politics 61 68 Google Scholar

Eraydin, A. and Taşan-Kok, T. (2013) ‘State response to contemporary urban movements in Turkey: a critical overview of state entrepreneurialism and authoritarian interventions’, Antipode, 46(1), 110–29. State response to contemporary urban movements in Turkey: a critical overview of state entrepreneurialism and authoritarian interventions Antipode 46 110 29 Google Scholar

Eskanat, R. (2012) ‘Türk inşaat sektöründeki TOKI’nin yeri ve etkisi’ (The location and effect of TOKI in the Turkish construction sector), DPU Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 2(32), 159–72 (in Turkish). ‘Türk inşaat sektöründeki TOKI’nin yeri ve etkisi’ (The location and effect of TOKI in the Turkish construction sector) DPU Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi 2 159 72 Google Scholar

European Commission (1997) The EU compendium of spatial planning systems and policies, Regional Development Studies 28, Luxembourg, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities. Google Scholar

Firman, T. (2004) ‘Major issues in Indonesia’s urban land development’, Land Use Policy, 21(4), 347–55. Major issues in Indonesia’s urban land development Land Use Policy 21 347 55 Google Scholar

Fligstein, N. (1997) ‘Social skill and institutional theory’, American Behavioural Scientist, 40(4), 397–405. Social skill and institutional theory American Behavioural Scientist 40 397 405 Google Scholar

Geray, C. (2007) ‘Toplumsal konut yöneltisi ve TOKI’nin tutum ve yöneltilerindeki son değişiklikler’ (Social housing policy and the latest changes in policy of TOKI) in A. Mengi (ed.) Kent ve Planlama (City and Planning), Istanbul, İmge Yayınevi, 283–353 (in Turkish). Toplumsal konut yöneltisi ve TOKI’nin tutum ve yöneltilerindeki son değişiklikler Kent ve Planlama 283 353 Google Scholar

Gervan, A., Demir, H. and Yilmaz, A. (2013) Kentsel dönüşüm projelerinde mülkiyet kazanımlarının ekonomik analizinin Ayazma Kentsel Dönüşüm Projesi örneğinde incelenmesi (Economic analysis for change of ownership in urban renewal projects based on Ayazma renewal project case), HKMO 14. Türkiye Harita Bilimsel ve Teknik Kurultayı, Ankara (in Turkish). Kentsel dönüşüm projelerinde mülkiyet kazanımlarının ekonomik analizinin Ayazma Kentsel Dönüşüm Projesi örneğinde incelenmesi Google Scholar

Gielen, D. M. (2010) Capturing value increase in urban redevelopment, Leiden, Sidestone Press. Capturing value increase in urban redevelopment Google Scholar

Gielen, D. M. and Tasan-Kok, T. (2010) ‘Flexibility in planning and the consequences for public-value capturing in UK, Spain and the Netherlands’, European Planning Studies, 18(7), 1097–131. Flexibility in planning and the consequences for public-value capturing in UK, Spain and the Netherlands European Planning Studies 18 1097 131 Google Scholar

Glasze, G. (2005) ‘Some reflections on the economic and political organisation of the private neighborhoods’, Housing Studies, 20(2), 221–33. Some reflections on the economic and political organisation of the private neighborhoods Housing Studies 20 221 33 Google Scholar

Gleeson, B. J. and Low, N. P. (2000) Australian urban planning: new challenges, new agendas, Sydney, Allen and Unwin. Australian urban planning: new challenges, new agendas Google Scholar

Healey, P. (1992) ‘An institutional model of the development process’, Journal of Property Research, 9, 33–44. An institutional model of the development process Journal of Property Research 9 33 44 Google Scholar

Healey, P. and Williams, R. (1993) ‘European urban planning systems: Diversity and convergence’, Urban Studies, 30(4/5), 701–20. European urban planning systems: Diversity and convergence Urban Studies 30 701 20 Google Scholar

Karaman, O. (2013) ‘Urban renewal in Istanbul: reconfigured spaces, robotic lives’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 37(2), 715–33. Urban renewal in Istanbul: reconfigured spaces, robotic lives International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 37 715 33 Google Scholar

Kim, J. H. (2011) ‘Linking land use planning and regulation to economic development: a literature review’, Journal of Planning Literature, 26(1), 35–47. Linking land use planning and regulation to economic development: a literature review Journal of Planning Literature 26 35 47 Google Scholar

Klosterman, R. E. (1996) ‘Arguments for and against planning’ in Campbell, S. and Fainstein, S. (eds) Readings in planning theory, Malden, MA, Blackwell, 150–68. Arguments for and against planning Readings in planning theory 150 68 Google Scholar

Kostova, T., Roth, K. and Dacin, M. T. (2008) ‘Institutional theory in the study of multinational corporations: a critique and new directions’, Academy of Management Review, 33(4), 994–1006. Institutional theory in the study of multinational corporations: a critique and new directions Academy of Management Review 33 994 1006 Google Scholar

Kurtulus, H. (2006) ‘Kentsel dönüşüme modern kent mitini çerçevesinde bakmak’, Planlama Dergisi, 2, 7–11. Kentsel dönüşüme modern kent mitini çerçevesinde bakmak Planlama Dergisi 2 7 11 Google Scholar

Kuyucu, T. (2013) ‘Law, property and ambiguity: the uses and abuses of legal ambiguity in remaking Istanbul’s informal settlements’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, DOI: 10.111/1468–2427.12026. Law, property and ambiguity: the uses and abuses of legal ambiguity in remaking Istanbul’s informal settlements International Journal of Urban and Regional Research Google Scholar

Kuyucu, T. and Ünsal, Ö. (2010) ‘Urban transformation as state-led property transfer: an analysis of two cases of urban renewal in Istanbul’, Urban Studies, 47(7), 1479–99. Urban transformation as state-led property transfer: an analysis of two cases of urban renewal in Istanbul Urban Studies 47 1479 99 Google Scholar

Le Goix, R. (2005) Gated communities: sprawl and social segregation in Southern California, Housing Studies, 20(2), 323–43. Gated communities: sprawl and social segregation in Southern California Housing Studies 20 323 43 Google Scholar

Lovering, J. and Turkmen, H. (2011) ‘Bulldozer neoliberalism in Istanbul: the state-led construction of property markets and the displacement of the urban poor’, International Planning Studies, 16(1), 73–96. Bulldozer neoliberalism in Istanbul: the state-led construction of property markets and the displacement of the urban poor International Planning Studies 16 73 96 Google Scholar

Monk, S. (2010) ‘Affordable housing through the planning system: the role of section 106’, in N. Calavita and A. Mallach (eds) Inclusionary housing in international perspective, Lincoln, Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, 127–63. Affordable housing through the planning system: the role of section 106 Inclusionary housing in international perspective 127 63 Google Scholar

Morgan, G. and Kristensen P. H. (2006) ‘The contested space of multinationals: varieties of institutionalism, varieties of capitalism’, Human Relations, 59(11), 1467–90. The contested space of multinationals: varieties of institutionalism, varieties of capitalism Human Relations 59 1467 90 Google Scholar

Morrison, N. and Burgess, G. (2014) ‘Inclusionary housing policy in England: the impact of the downturn on the delivery of affordable housing through Section 106’, Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 29(3), 423–38. Inclusionary housing policy in England: the impact of the downturn on the delivery of affordable housing through Section 106 Journal of Housing and the Built Environment 29 423 38 Google Scholar

Nelson, R. H. (2005) Private neighborhoods and the transformation of local government, Urban Institute Press, Washington D.C. Private neighborhoods and the transformation of local government Google Scholar

NHPAU (National Housing Planning Advice Unit) (2009) Review of European planning systems, UK, National Housing Planning Advice Unit. Google Scholar

Nordahl, B. I. (2014) ‘Convergences and discrepancies between the policy of inclusionary housing and Norway’s liberal housing and planning policy: an institutional perspective’, Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 29(3), 489–506. Convergences and discrepancies between the policy of inclusionary housing and Norway’s liberal housing and planning policy: an institutional perspective Journal of Housing and the Built Environment 29 489 506 Google Scholar

North, D. C. (1990) Institutions, institutional change and economic performance, New York, Cambridge University Press. Institutions, institutional change and economic performance Google Scholar

Ostrom, E. (2005) Understanding institutional diversity, Princeton, NJ., Princeton. Understanding institutional diversity Google Scholar

Peterson, G. E. (2009) Unlocking land values to finance urban infrastructure, trends and policy options, Washington, World Bank. Unlocking land values to finance urban infrastructure, trends and policy options Google Scholar

Rivolin, U. J. (2008) ‘Conforming and performing planning systems in Europe: an unbearable cohabitation’, Planning, Practice and Research, 23(2), 167–86. Conforming and performing planning systems in Europe: an unbearable cohabitation Planning, Practice and Research 23 167 86 Google Scholar

Spaans, M., Janssen-Jansen, L. and van Der Veen M. (2011) ‘Market-oriented compensation instruments: lessons for Dutch urban redevelopment’, Town Planning Review, 82(4), 425–40. Market-oriented compensation instruments: lessons for Dutch urban redevelopment Town Planning Review 82 425 40 Google Scholar

Steele, W. and Ruming, K. J. (2012) ‘Flexibility versus certainty: unsettling the land use planning shibboleth in Australia’, Planning, Practice and Research, 27(2), 155–76. Flexibility versus certainty: unsettling the land use planning shibboleth in Australia Planning, Practice and Research 27 155 76 Google Scholar

Stoker, G. (1991) ‘Trends in Western European local government’, in R. Batley and G. Stoker (eds) Local government in Europe, London, Macmillan, 1–20. Trends in Western European local government Local government in Europe 1 20 Google Scholar

Stoker, G. (1998) ‘Governance as theory: five propositions’, International Social Science Journal, 50(155), 17–28. Governance as theory: five propositions International Social Science Journal 50 17 28 Google Scholar

Tang, B. and Tang R. M. H. (1999) ‘Development control, planning incentives and urban redevelopment: evaluation of a two-tier plot ratio system in Hong Kong’, Land Use Policy, 16(1), 33–43. Development control, planning incentives and urban redevelopment: evaluation of a two-tier plot ratio system in Hong Kong Land Use Policy 16 33 43 Google Scholar

Taşan-Kok, T. (2008) ‘Changing interpretations of “flexibility” in the planning literature: from opportunism to creativity?’, International Planning Studies, 13(3), 183–95. Changing interpretations of “flexibility” in the planning literature: from opportunism to creativity? International Planning Studies 13 183 95 Google Scholar

Tewdwr-Jones, M. (1999) ‘Discretion, flexibility, and certainty in British planning: emerging ideological conflicts and inherent political tensions’, Journal of Planning Education and Research, 18, 244–56. Discretion, flexibility, and certainty in British planning: emerging ideological conflicts and inherent political tensions Journal of Planning Education and Research 18 244 56 Google Scholar

Toki (2012) Retrieved from http://www.toki.gov.tr/ (accessed 10 March 2012). Google Scholar

Turgut, S. and Ceylan, E. Ç. (2010) Bir yerel yönetim deneyiminin ardından, Küçükçekmece Ayazma-Tepeüstü Kentsel Dönüşüm Projesi (A local government experience, Urban transformation project of Küçükçekmece, Ayazma and Tepeüstü), Alfa Yayınevi, Istanbul (in Turkish). Bir yerel yönetim deneyiminin ardından, Küçükçekmece Ayazma-Tepeüstü Kentsel Dönüşüm Projesi Google Scholar

Turk, S. S. and Demircioglu, E. (2013) ‘Using of market-led measures for land assembly in Turkey’, Habitat International, 40, 201–10. Using of market-led measures for land assembly in Turkey Habitat International 40 201 10 Google Scholar

Turk, S. S. and Korthals Altes, W. K. (2010a) ‘Institutional capacities in the land development for housing on greenfield sites in Istanbul’, Habitat International, 34(2), 183–95. Institutional capacities in the land development for housing on greenfield sites in Istanbul Habitat International 34 183 95 Google Scholar

Turk, S. S. and Korthals Altes, W. K. (2010b) ‘The planning system and land provision for social housing in Turkey’, Housing Finance International, Autumn 2010, 26–32. The planning system and land provision for social housing in Turkey Housing Finance International 26 32 Google Scholar

Turk, S. S. and Korthals Altes, W. K. (2013a) ‘The applicability of inclusionary housing (IH) in Turkey’, Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, DOI: 10.1007/s10901–013–9358–1. The applicability of inclusionary housing (IH) in Turkey Journal of Housing and the Built Environment Google Scholar

Turk, S. S. and Korthals Altes, W. K. (2013b) ‘Recovery of social housing and infrastructure costs in urban renewal: some lessons from Turkey’, in M. E. Leary and J. McCarthy (eds) The Routledge companion to urban regeneration, London, Routledge. Recovery of social housing and infrastructure costs in urban renewal: some lessons from Turkey The Routledge companion to urban regeneration Google Scholar

Turkun, A. (2011) ‘Urban regeneration and hegemonic power relationships’, International Planning Studies, 16(1), 61–72. Urban regeneration and hegemonic power relationships International Planning Studies 16 61 72 Google Scholar

Unal, Y. (2008) Türk Şehir Planlama ve İmar Mevzuatının Kentsel Dönüşüm ve Deprem Ağırlıklı İncelenmesi (Examination of Turkish Urban planning and legislation in terms of urban regeneration and earthquake), Istanbul, Yetkin Kitabevi (in Turkish). Türk Şehir Planlama ve İmar Mevzuatının Kentsel Dönüşüm ve Deprem Ağırlıklı İncelenmesi Google Scholar

Unsal, F. (2009) ‘Critical evaluation of legal and institutional context of urban planning in Turkey: the case of Istanbul’, PLPR Conference, Aalborg, Denmark. 11–13 February 2009. Critical evaluation of legal and institutional context of urban planning in Turkey: the case of Istanbul Google Scholar

Whitehead, C. (2007) ‘Planning policies and affordable housing: England as a successful case study?’, Housing Studies, 22(1), 25–44. Planning policies and affordable housing: England as a successful case study? Housing Studies 22 25 44 Google Scholar

Winarso, H. and Firman, T. (2002) ‘Residential land development in Jabotabek, Indonesia: triggering economic crisis?’, Habitat International, 26, 487–506. Residential land development in Jabotabek, Indonesia: triggering economic crisis? Habitat International 26 487 506 Google Scholar

Zariç, S. (2012) ‘Türkiye’de kent planlama ve TOKI’nin planlama yetkilerindeki genişlemenin boyutları’ (Urban planning in Turkey and dimensions in increasing of TOKI’s planning authorities), Akademik Bakış Dergisi, 28, 1–19 (in Turkish). Türkiye’de kent planlama ve TOKI’nin planlama yetkilerindeki genişlemenin boyutları’ (Urban planning in Turkey and dimensions in increasing of TOKI’s planning authorities) Akademik Bakış Dergisi 28 1 19 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Ozkan, Hatice Aysun

Turk, Sevkiye Sence