Romani Studies

The court of the Bayash: Revising a theory

Romani Studies (2013), 23, (1), 1–28.

Abstract

We attempt to nuance the theory that the Gypsy Court is practiced only by Romani-speaking peoples, showing that the memory of this institution and certain elements are still present today among the Bayash of Hungary, western Serbia and northern Croatia. We base our study on recent ethnological and anthropological field studies that we carried out in the regions of Medjimurje (Croatia) and Bačka (Serbia), and on written sources of the Bayash from Hungary. Additionally, we discuss older Romanian ethnographic accounts of the rudiments of the juridical system of the Rudari from southern Romania, which were apparently overlooked by researchers attempting to clarify the mechanisms behind the existence or preservation of this institution among different Gypsy groups.

Access Token
£25.00

Achim, Viorel. 2001. The Roma in Romanian history. Budapest: CEU Press. The Roma in Romanian history Google Scholar

Acton, Thomas. 2003. A three-cornered choice: Structural consequences of value-priorities in Gypsy law as a model for more general understanding of variations in the administration of justice. The American Journal of Comparative Law 51(3): 639-57. A three-cornered choice: Structural consequences of value-priorities in Gypsy law as a model for more general understanding of variations in the administration of justice The American Journal of Comparative Law 51 639 57 Google Scholar

Acton, Thomas. Caffrey, Susan, and Mundy, Gary. 1997. Theorizing Gypsy law. The American Journal of Comparative Law [Symposium on Gypsy Law] 45(2): 237-49. Theorizing Gypsy law The American Journal of Comparative Law [Symposium on Gypsy Law] 45 237 49 Google Scholar

Agócs, Attila. 2003. Sociálna identifikácia Bajášov na Slovensku. Etnologické rozpravy 2: 41-53. Sociálna identifikácia Bajášov na Slovensku Etnologické rozpravy 2 41 53 Google Scholar

Assénova, Petya, and Aleksova, Vassilka. 2008. Observations sur la ‘romanité balkanique’ en Bulgarie. In: Sikimić, Biljana, and Ašić, Tijana, eds. The Romance Balkans. Belgrade: The Institute for Balkan Studies. 161-72. The Romance Balkans 161 72 Google Scholar

Barjaktarović, Mirko. 1964. Oaza apatinskih Cigana (Prilog proučavanju Cigana u Vojvodini). Rad vojvođanskih muzeja 12-13: 191-203. Oaza apatinskih Cigana (Prilog proučavanju Cigana u Vojvodini) Rad vojvođanskih muzeja 12-13 191 203 Google Scholar

Caffrey, Susan, and Mundy, Gary. 2001. Informal system of justice: The formation of law within Gypsy communities. In: Weyrauch, Walter O., ed. Gypsy Law. Romani legal traditions and culture. Berkeley: University of California Press. 101-16. Gypsy Law. Romani legal traditions and culture 101 16 Google Scholar

Calotă, Ion. 1995. Rudarii din Oltenia: Studiu de dialectologie ôi de geografielingvistic a roma neasca. Craiova: Editura Sibila. Rudarii din Oltenia: Studiu de dialectologie ôi de geografielingvistic a roma neasca Google Scholar

Cahn, Claude. 2009. Romani law in the Timiş County Giambaş community. Romani Studies. Fifth Series. 19(2): 87-101. Romani law in the Timiş County Giambaş community Romani Studies. Fifth Series 19 87 101 Google Scholar

Chelcea, Ion. 1944. Rudarii. Contribuţii la o ‘enigmă’ etnografică. Bucureşti: Casa Şcoalelor. Rudarii. Contribuţii la o ‘enigmă’ etnografică Google Scholar

Ćirković, Svetlana. 2005. Od Kavkaza do Banjice: Mečkari. In: Sikimić, Biljana, ed. Banjaši na Balkanu: Identitet etničke zajednice. Beograd: Balkanološki institut. 219-48. Banjaši na Balkanu: Identitet etničke zajednice 219 48 Google Scholar

Čičovački, Predrag. 1997. Crtice iz života monoštorskih Cigana. PČESA [Cigane moj (Romi u Vojvodini)] XIII:270-2. Crtice iz života monoštorskih Cigana PČESA [Cigane moj (Romi u Vojvodini)] XIII 270 2 Google Scholar

Dorondel, Ştefan. 2007. Ethnicity, state and access to natural resources in the southeastern Europe. The Rudari case. In: Şerban, Stelu, and Dorondel, Ştefan, eds. Transborder identities. The Romanian-speaking population in Bulgaria. Bucureşti: Paideia. 215-39. Transborder identities. The Romanian-speaking population in Bulgaria 215 39 Google Scholar

Filipescu, Teodor. 1906. Coloniile române din Bosnia. Studiu etnografic şi antropogeografic. Bucureşti: Carol Göbl. Coloniile române din Bosnia. Studiu etnografic şi antropogeografic Google Scholar

Fine, Gary, and Deegan, James. 1996. Three principles of serendip: Insight, chance, and discovery in qualitative research. Qualitative Studies in Education 9(4): 434-47. Three principles of serendip: Insight, chance, and discovery in qualitative research Qualitative Studies in Education 9 434 47 Google Scholar

Hedeşan, Otilia. 2005. Jedan teren: Trešnjevica u dolini Morave. In: Sikimić, Biljana, ed. Banjaši na Balkanu: Identitet etničke zajednice. Beograd: Balkanološki institut. 13-106. Banjaši na Balkanu: Identitet etničke zajednice 13 106 Google Scholar

Hrvatić, Neven. 2004. Romi u Hrvatskoj: od migracija do interkulturalnih odnosa. Migracijske i etničke teme 20(4): 367-85. Romi u Hrvatskoj: od migracija do interkulturalnih odnosa Migracijske i etničke teme 20 367 85 Google Scholar

Kemény, István. 2002. Linguistic groups and usage among the Hungarian Gypsies/Roma. In: Kállai, Ernö, ed. The Gypsies/the Roma in Hungarian Society. Budapest: Regio - Teleki László Foundation. 28-34. The Gypsies/the Roma in Hungarian Society 28 34 Google Scholar

Kovalcsik, Katalin. 1991. Karácsonyi köszöntés a beás cigányoknál. Zenetudományi dolgozatok 1990/1991: 213-40. Karácsonyi köszöntés a beás cigányoknál Zenetudományi dolgozatok 1990/1991 213 40 Google Scholar

Kovalcsik, Katalin. 1993. The folk music traditions of Boyash Gypsies. In: Barna, Gábor, ed. Gypsy Ethnographical Studies 1. Salgótarján: Mikszáth Kiadó. 231-44. Gypsy Ethnographical Studies 1 231 44 Google Scholar

Kovalcsik, Katalin. 1996. Roma or Boyash identity? The music of the ‘Ard'elan’ Boyashes in Hungary. The World of Music 38(1): 77-93. Roma or Boyash identity? The music of the ‘Ard'elan’ Boyashes in Hungary The World of Music 38 77 93 Google Scholar

Kovalcsik, Katalin. Konrád, Imre, and Ignácz, János. 2001. Aminy ku putyere - Bátor emberek: Beás cigány történetek, szokáselbeszélések és mesék iskolás gyermekek számára. Pécs: Gandhi Közalapítványi Gimnázium és Kollégium. Aminy ku putyere - Bátor emberek: Beás cigány történetek, szokáselbeszélések és mesék iskolás gyermekek számára Google Scholar

Leschber, Corinna. 2008. Romanian-Serbian code-mixing phenomena. In: Sikimić, Biljana, and Ašić, Tijana, ed. The Romance Balkans. Belgrade: The Institute for Balkan Studies. 247-60. The Romance Balkans 247 60 Google Scholar

Marushiakova, Elena. 1998. Self-government among Bulgarian Gypsies. In: Taras, Ray, ed. National identities and ethnic minorities in Eastern Europe. London: Macmillan. 199-207. National identities and ethnic minorities in Eastern Europe 199 207 Google Scholar

Marushiakova, Elena. and Popov, Vesselin. 1998. Bear-trainers in Bulgaria (tradition and contemporary situation). Ethnologia Bulgarica 1: 106-16. Bear-trainers in Bulgaria (tradition and contemporary situation) Ethnologia Bulgarica 1 106 16 Google Scholar

Marushiakova, Elena. and Popov, Vesselin. 2004. Segmentation vs. consolidation: The example of four Gypsy groups in CIS. Romani Studies. Fifth Series. 14(2): 145-91. Segmentation vs. consolidation: The example of four Gypsy groups in CIS Romani Studies. Fifth Series 14 145 91 Google Scholar

Marushiakova, Elena. and Popov, Vesselin. 2005. The Gypsy Court as a concept of consensus among service nomads in the northern Black Sea area. In: Leder, Stefan, and Streck, Bernhard. Shifts and drifts in nomad-sedentary relations. Wiesbaden: Reichert. 123-47. Shifts and drifts in nomad-sedentary relations 123 47 Google Scholar

Marushiakova, Elena. and Popov, Vesselin. 2007. The Gypsy Court in Eastern Europe. Romani Studies. Fifth Series. 17(1): 67-101. The Gypsy Court in Eastern Europe Romani Studies. Fifth Series 17 67 101 Google Scholar

Mišetić, Anka. 2005. The socio-cultural features of the Romani population. In: Štambuk, Maja, ed. Kako žive Hrvatski Romi [How do Croatian Roma live]. Zagreb: Institute of Social Sciences ‘Ivo Pilar’. 343-63. Kako žive Hrvatski Romi [How do Croatian Roma live] 343 63 Google Scholar

Orsós, Anna. 1997. Language groups of Gypsies in Hungary. Studies in Roma (Gypsy) Ethnography 6: 194-9. Language groups of Gypsies in Hungary Studies in Roma (Gypsy) Ethnography 6 194 9 Google Scholar

Petrovici, Emil. 1938. ‘Românii’ din Serbia Occidentală. Dacoromania IX: 224-36. ‘Românii’ din Serbia Occidentală Dacoromania IX 224 36 Google Scholar

Radosavljević, Petar. 2007. Romi Bajaši u Hrvatskoj - govornici rumunjskog dijalekta. In: Granić, Jagoda, ed. Jezik i identiteti. Zagreb/Split: Hrvatsko društvo za primijenjenu lingvistiku. 505-15. Jezik i identiteti 505 15 Google Scholar

Radosavljević, Petar. 2011. Privire de ansamblu asupra graiurilor băieşeşti din Croaţia. Piramida. Thematic issue: ‘Băieşii în contextul sud-slav’, 2(I): 50-61. Privire de ansamblu asupra graiurilor băieşeşti din Croaţia. Piramida Thematic issue: ‘Băieşii în contextul sud-slav’ 2 50 61 Google Scholar

Reisman, W. Michael. 1993. Autonomy, interdependence and responsibility. The Yale Law Journal 103(2): 401-17. Autonomy, interdependence and responsibility The Yale Law Journal 103 401 17 Google Scholar

Saramandu, Nicolae. 1997. Cercetări dialectale la un grup necunoscut de vorbitori ai românei: băiaşii din nordul Croaţiei. Fonetică şi dialectologie XVI: 97-130. Cercetări dialectale la un grup necunoscut de vorbitori ai românei: băiaşii din nordul Croaţiei Fonetică şi dialectologie XVI 97 130 Google Scholar

Sikimić, Biljana. 2005a. Banjaši u Srbiji. In: Sikimić, Biljana, ed. Banjaši na Balkanu: Identitet etničke zajednice. Beograd: Balkanološki institut. 249-75. Banjaši na Balkanu: Identitet etničke zajednice 249 75 Google Scholar

Sikimić, Biljana. 2005b. Бањаши на Балкану. In: Sikimić, Biljana, ed. Banjaši na Balkanu: Identitet etničke zajednice. Beograd: Balkanološki institut. 7-12. Banjaši na Balkanu: Identitet etničke zajednice 7 12 Google Scholar

Sikimić, Biljana. 2006. Srbi i Romi/Bejaši u mađarskoj Baranji. Etnografija Srba u Mađarskoj 5: 101-12. Srbi i Romi/Bejaši u mađarskoj Baranji Etnografija Srba u Mađarskoj 5 101 12 Google Scholar

Sikimić, Biljana. 2008. Karavlachs in Bosnia and Herzegovina today. In: Sikimić, Biljana, and Ašić, Tijana, ed. The Romance Balkans. Belgrade: The Institute for Balkan Studies. 227-46. The Romance Balkans 227 46 Google Scholar

Slavkova, Magdalena. 2005. Rudari u istočnoj Bugarskoj i evanđeoski pokret. In: Sikimić, Biljana, ed. Banjaši na Balkanu: Identitet etničke zajednice. Beograd: Balkanološki institut. 277-94. Banjaši na Balkanu: Identitet etničke zajednice 277 94 Google Scholar

Slavkova, Magdalena. 2008. Contemporary labour migrations of Gypsies from Bulgaria to Spain. In: Marushiakova, Elena, ed. Dynamics of national identity and transnational identities in the process of European integration. Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars Publishing. 189-213. Dynamics of national identity and transnational identities in the process of European integration 189 213 Google Scholar

Sorescu-Marinković, Annemarie. 2007. The gurban displaced: Bayash guest workers in Paris. In: Sikimić, Biljana, and Hristov, Petko, ed. Kurban in the Balkans. Belgrade: The Institute for Balkan Studies. 137-51. Kurban in the Balkans 137 51 Google Scholar

Sorescu-Marinković, Annemarie. 2008. The Bayash in Croatia: Romanian vernaculars in Baranja and Medjimurje. In: Sikimić, Biljana, and Ašić, Tijana, ed. The Romance Balkans. Belgrade: The Institute for Balkan Studies. 173-225. The Romance Balkans 173 225 Google Scholar

Sorescu-Marinković, Annemarie. 2011. Strategies for creating an explanatory Bayash dictionary in Serbia. Revue Roumaine de Linguistique LVI 1: 17-34. Strategies for creating an explanatory Bayash dictionary in Serbia Revue Roumaine de Linguistique LVI 1 17 34 Google Scholar

Stewart, Michael. 1997. Time of the Gypsies. Boulder, Co: Westview Press. Time of the Gypsies Google Scholar

Stojanović, Vladimir. 1997. Cigani u Sonti. PČESA [Cigane moj (Romi u Vojvodini)] XIII: 245-7. Cigani u Sonti PČESA [Cigane moj (Romi u Vojvodini)] XIII 245 7 Google Scholar

Şerban, Stelu. 2007. Politics against ethnicity. The case of Rudari from Varna district. In: Şerban, Stelu, and Dorondel, Ştefan, eds. Transborder identities. The Romanian-speaking population in Bulgaria. Bucureşti: Paideia. 241-76. Transborder identities. The Romanian-speaking population in Bulgaria 241 76 Google Scholar

Škarić-Jurić, Tatjana, Klarić, I. M., Narancić, N. S., Drmić, S., Salihović, M. P., L. B. Lauc, J. Milicić, M. Barabalić, M. Zajc, B. Janićijević. 2007. Trapped between tradition and transition: Anthropological and epidemiological cross-sectional study of Bayash Roma in Croatia. Croat Medical Journal 48: 708-19. Trapped between tradition and transition: Anthropological and epidemiological cross-sectional study of Bayash Roma in Croatia Croat Medical Journal 48 708 19 Google Scholar

Šolaja, Marija. 1997. Knez Roma u Vajskoj. PČESA [Cigane moj (Romi u Vojvodini)] XIII:218-20. Knez Roma u Vajskoj PČESA [Cigane moj (Romi u Vojvodini)] XIII 218 20 Google Scholar

Weyrauch, Walter Otto, ed. 2001. Gypsy Law: Romani legal traditions and culture. Berkeley: University of California Press. Gypsy Law: Romani legal traditions and culture Google Scholar

Weyrauch, Walter Otto ed. Anne Bell, Maureen. 1993. Autonomous lawmaking: The case of the ‘Gypsies’. The Yale Law Journal 103(2): 323-99. Autonomous lawmaking: The case of the ‘Gypsies’ The Yale Law Journal 103 323 99 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Sorescu-Marinković, Annemarie