Town Planning Review

Indicators at the crossroads: Ideas, methods and applications

Town Planning Review (2003), 74, (3), 253–279.

Abstract

This paper provides an overview of the development of indicators, with an emphasis on the British urban and regional planning contexts. It then proposes some pointers to set the agenda for future research and development to move forward the development of indicators. The arguments and suggestions are illustrated with findings from a research project funded by the Economic and Social Research Council on identifying indicators to measure local economic development potential, and the approach used to develop a town and city indicators database for the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister to monitor the performance of the Urban White Paper. The discussion focuses on five broad sets of issues, namely the linkage between theories, concepts and measurement in the development of indicators for urban and regional planning; the importance of policy contexts and values in indicator research; the role of social scientists in the process of indicator development; the use of indicators to inform policy decisions and the data infrastructure; and finally the strengths and weaknesses of different analytical methods to provide research synthesis.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

ARUP ECONOMICS AND PLANNING (1995), Environmental Capacity: A Methodology for Historic Cities (final report to Cheshire County Council, Chester City Council, Department of the Environment and English Heritage), London, ARUP. Google Scholar

AUDIT COMMISSION (1989), Urban Regeneration and Economic Development: The Local Government Dimension, London, HMSO. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

BARTHOLOMEW, D. (1995), 'The measurement of unemployment in the UK (with discussion)', Journal of Royal Statistical Society A, 158, 363–417. The measurement of unemployment in the UK (with discussion) Journal of Royal Statistical Society A 158 363 417 Google Scholar

BAUER, R. A. (1966), Social Indicators, Cambridge, MA, MIT Press. Social Indicators Google Scholar

BEGG, I. (ed.) (2002), Urban Competitiveness: Policies for Dynamic Cities, Bristol, Policy Press. Urban Competitiveness: Policies for Dynamic Cities Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

BERGER, P. L. and KELLNER, H. (1982), Sociology Reinterpreted: An Essay on Method and Vocation, Harmondsworth, Pelican Books. Sociology Reinterpreted: An Essay on Method and Vocation Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

BREHENY, M., HALL, P. and HART, D. (1987), Northern Lights: A Development Agenda for the North in the 1990s, Preston, Derrick Wade and Waters. Northern Lights: A Development Agenda for the North in the 1990s Google Scholar

BROWN, P. J. B. (1989), 'A super profile based affluence ranking of OPCS urban areas', Built Environment, 14, 118–34. A super profile based affluence ranking of OPCS urban areas Built Environment 14 118 34 Google Scholar

BROWN, P. J. B. and BATEY, P. W. J. (1994), Characteristics of Super Profile Lifestyles and Target Markets: Index Tables, Pen Pictures and Geographical Distribution (Super Profile Technical Note 2), Urban Research and Policy Evaluation Regional Research Laboratory, Liverpool, University of Liverpool. Google Scholar

BRYANT, G. A. (1985), Positivism in Social Theory and Research, Basingstoke, Macmillan. Positivism in Social Theory and Research Google Scholar

CAPLAN, N. and BARTON, E. (1978), 'The potential of social indicators: minimum conditions for impact at the national level as suggested by a study of the use of Social Indicators 73', Social Indicators Research, 5, 427–56. The potential of social indicators: minimum conditions for impact at the national level as suggested by a study of the use of Social Indicators 73 Social Indicators Research 5 427 56 Google Scholar

CARLEY, M. (1981), Social Measurement and Social Indicators, London, George Allen & Unwin. Social Measurement and Social Indicators Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

CASTELLS, M. and HALL, P. (1994), Technopoles of the World, London, Routledge. Technopoles of the World Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

CEC (COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES) (1991), Annual Report on the Implementation of the Reform of the Structural Funds 1989, Offce for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg. Google Scholar

CHAMPION, A. G. and GREEN, A. (1990), The Spread of Prosperity and the North–South Divide, Gosforth and Kenilworth, Booming Towns. The Spread of Prosperity and the North–South Divide Google Scholar

COMTE, A. (1844), A Discourse on the Positive Spirit (prefaced and translated by E. S. Beesly, 1903), London, William Reeves. Google Scholar

COOMBES, M., RAYBOULD, S. and WONG, C. (1992), Developing Indicators to Assess the Potential for Urban Regeneration, London, HMSO. Developing Indicators to Assess the Potential for Urban Regeneration Google Scholar

COOMBES, M., RAYBOULD, S., WONG, C. and OPENSHAW, S. (1995), The 1991 Deprivation Index: A Review of Approaches, London, HMSO. The 1991 Deprivation Index: A Review of Approaches Google Scholar

COOMBES, M. and WONG, C. (1994), 'Methodological steps in the development of multi-variate indexes for urban and regional policy analysis', Environment and Planning A, 26, 1297–316. Methodological steps in the development of multi-variate indexes for urban and regional policy analysis Environment and Planning A 26 1297 316 Google Scholar

COOMBES, M., WONG, C., CHARLTON, M. and ATKINS, D. (1994), 'Crime risk in urban and rural neighbourhoods: an experimental analysis of insurance data', Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 21, 489–504. Crime risk in urban and rural neighbourhoods: an experimental analysis of insurance data Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 21 489 504 Google Scholar

COOMBES, M., WONG, C. and RAYBOULD, S. (1993a), Indicators of Disadvantage and the Selection of Areas for Regeneration (Scottish Homes Research Report No. 26), Edinburgh, Scottish Homes. Google Scholar

COOMBES, M., WONG, C. and RAYBOULD, S. (1993b), Local Environment Index: Infrastructural Resources Dimension (a final report to the Department of Employment), Newcastle upon Tyne, Centre for Urban and Regional Development Studies, University of Newcastle upon Tyne. Google Scholar

COUNTRYSIDE COMMISSION, ENGLISH HERITAGE AND ENGLISH NATURE (1993), Conservation Issues in Strategic Plans, Cheltenham, Countryside Commission. Google Scholar

DETR (DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT, TRANSPORT AND THE REGIONS) (1998a), 1998 Index of Local Deprivation: A Summary of Results, London, DETR. Google Scholar

DETR (DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT, TRANSPORT AND THE REGIONS) (1998b), The Future of Regional Planning Guidance, London, DETR. Google Scholar

DETR (DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT, TRANSPORT AND THE REGIONS) (1998c), Planning for the Communities of the Future, London, The Stationery Office. Google Scholar

DETR (DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT, TRANSPORT AND THE REGIONS) (1998d), Sustainability Counts, London, DETR. Google Scholar

DETR (DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT, TRANSPORT AND THE REGIONS) (1999), Monitoring Progress: Indicators for the Strategy for Sustainable Development in the UK, London, DETR. Google Scholar

DETR (DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT, TRANSPORT AND THE REGIONS) (2000), Measuring Multiple Deprivation at the Small Area Level: The Indices of Deprivation 2000, London, HMSO. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

DOE (DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT) (1993), Environmental Appraisal of Development Plans, London, HMSO. Google Scholar

DOE (DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT) (1994), Index of Local Conditions: An Analysis Based on 1991 Census Data, London, DOE. Google Scholar

DOERINGER, P. B., TERKLA, D. G. and TOPAKIAN, G. C. (1987), Invisible Factors in Local Economic Development, New York, Oxford University Press. Invisible Factors in Local Economic Development Google Scholar

DTI (DEPARTMENT OF TRADE AND INDUSTRY) (1998), Regional Competitiveness Indicators, London, DTI. Google Scholar

DTI (DEPARTMENT OF TRADE AND INDUSTRY) (2000), Regional Competitiveness Indicators, London. DTI. Google Scholar

DTI (DEPARTMENT OF TRADE AND INDUSTRY), SCOTTISH OFFICE and WELSH OFFICE (1993), Regional Policy Review of the Assisted Areas of Great Britain, London, DTI. Google Scholar

DUNCAN, O. D. (1969), Towards Social Reporting: Next Steps, New York, Russell Sage Foundation. Google Scholar

DUNN, J., HODGE, I., MONK, S. and KIDDLE, C. (1998), Developing Indicators of Rural Disadvantage (a final report to the Rural Development Commission), Cambridge, Department of Land Economy, University of Cambridge. Google Scholar

FIELDING, A. and HALFORD, S. (1990), Patterns and Processes of Urban Change in the United Kingdom, London, HMSO. Patterns and Processes of Urban Change in the United Kingdom Google Scholar

HALL, P. (1983), 'The Anglo-American connection: rival rationalities in planning theory and practice, 1955–80', Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 10, 41–46. The Anglo-American connection: rival rationalities in planning theory and practice, 1955–80 Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 10 41 46 Google Scholar

HMG (HER MAJESTY'S GOVERNMENT) (1998), Statistics: A Matter of Trust (Green Paper), London, The Stationery Office. Google Scholar

HMG (HER MAJESTY'S GOVERNMENT) (1999), Building Trust in Statistics (White Paper), London, HMSO. Google Scholar

HMT (HER MAJESTY'S TREASURY) (2000), Framework for National Statistics (1st ed.), London, HMT. Google Scholar

HORN, R. V. (1993), Statistical Indicators for the Economic and Social Sciences, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. Statistical Indicators for the Economic and Social Sciences Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

INNES, J. (1990), Knowledge and Public Policy: The Search of Meaningful Indicators, New Brunswick, NJ, Transaction Publishers. Knowledge and Public Policy: The Search of Meaningful Indicators Google Scholar

INNES, J. E. and BOOHER, D. E. (2000), 'Indicators for sustainable communities: a strategy for building on complexity theory and distributed intelligence', Planning Theory and Practice, 1, 173–86. Indicators for sustainable communities: a strategy for building on complexity theory and distributed intelligence Planning Theory and Practice 1 173 86 Google Scholar

LGMB (LOCAL GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT BOARD) (1995), Sustainability Indicators Research Project: Consultants' Report of the Pilot Phase, Luton, LGMB. Google Scholar

MACLAREN, V. W. (1996), 'Urban sustainability reporting', Journal of the American Planning Association, 62, 184–201. Google Scholar

MACNAGHTEN, P., GROVE-WHITE, R., JACOBS, M. and WYNNE, B. (1995), Public Perceptions and Sustainability in Lancashire: Indicators, Institutions, Participation, Preston, Lancashire County Council. Public Perceptions and Sustainability in Lancashire: Indicators, Institutions, Participation Google Scholar

MACRAE, D. (1985), Policy Indicators: Links Between Social Science and Public Debate, Chapel Hill, NC, University of North Carolina Press. Policy Indicators: Links Between Social Science and Public Debate Google Scholar

MILES, I. (1985), Social Indicators for Human Development, London, Frances Pinter. Social Indicators for Human Development Google Scholar

MYERS, D. (1988), 'Building knowledge about quality of life for urban planning', Journal of the American Planning Association, 54, 347–58. Building knowledge about quality of life for urban planning Journal of the American Planning Association 54 347 58 Google Scholar

NOBLE, M., PENHALE, B., SMITH, G. and WRIGHT, G. (1999), Measuring Multiple Deprivation at the Local Level (Index of Deprivation 1999 Review), Oxford, Department of Applied Social Studies and Social Research, University of Oxford. Google Scholar

NOBLE, M., PENHALE, B., SMITH, G., WRIGHT, G., FIRTH, D. and PAYNE, C. (2000), Report for Formal Consultation Stage 2: Methodology for an Index of Multiple Deprivation (Index of Deprivation 1999 Review), Oxford, Department of Applied Social Studies and Social Research, University of Oxford. Google Scholar

ODPM (OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY PRIME MINISTER) (2002), The Development of a Town and City Indicators Database (Urban Research Summary No. 3), London, ODPM. Google Scholar

ONS (OFFICE FOR NATIONAL STATISTICS) (1998), Regional Trends, 33, London, The Stationery Office. Google Scholar

PA CAMBRIDGE ECONOMIC CONSULTANTS (1990), Indicators of Comparative Regional/Local Economic Performance and Prospects, London, HMSO. Google Scholar

PIEDA (1995), Local Economic Audits: A Practical Guide, Sheffield, Employment Department. Google Scholar

ROBSON, B., BRADFORD, M. and TYE, R. (1995), The 1991 Deprivation Index: A Matrix of Results, London, HMSO. The 1991 Deprivation Index: A Matrix of Results Google Scholar

ROBSON, B., BRADFORD, M. and TOMLINSON, R. (1998), Updating and Revising the Index of Local Deprivation, London, DOE. Updating and Revising the Index of Local Deprivation Google Scholar

ROGERSON, R., FINDLAY, A. and MORRIS, A. (1987), The Geography of Quality of Life (Occasional Paper Series No. 22), Glasgow, Department of Geography, University of Glasgow. Google Scholar

ROGERSON, R. J., FINDLAY, A. M. and MORRIS, A. (1989), 'Indicators of quality of life: some methodological issues', Environment and Planning A, 21, 1655–66. Indicators of quality of life: some methodological issues Environment and Planning A 21 1655 66 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

RSS (ROYAL STATISTICAL SOCIETY) (1998), The Response of the Royal Statistical Society to the Government's Consultation Document 'Statistics: A Matter of Trust', London, Royal Statistical Society. Google Scholar

SAWICKI, D. S. (2002), 'Improving community indicator systems: injecting more social science into the folk movement', Planning Theory and Practice, 3, 13–32. Improving community indicator systems: injecting more social science into the folk movement Planning Theory and Practice 3 13 32 Google Scholar

SHONFIELD, A. and SHAW, S. (eds) (1972), Social Indicators and Social Policy, London, Heinemann Educational Books. Social Indicators and Social Policy Google Scholar

SMITH, T.W. (1980/81), 'Social indicators: a review essay', Journal of Social History, 14, 739–47. Google Scholar

SOCIAL EXCLUSION UNIT (2000), Better Information (Social Exclusion Unit Policy Action Team Report 18), London, Social Exclusion Unit. Google Scholar

STONE, R. (1971), Demographic Accounting and Model Building, Paris, Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. Demographic Accounting and Model Building Google Scholar

TAYLOR, C. L. (1981), 'Progress towards indicator systems: an overview' in C. L. Taylor (ed.), Indicator Systems for Political, Economic and Social Analysis, Cambridge, MA, Gunn & Hain, 1–10. 'Progress towards indicator systems: an overview' Indicator Systems for Political, Economic and Social Analysis 1 10 Google Scholar

UNCED (UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON ENVIRONMENT AND DEVELOPMENT) (1992), Agenda 21, Switzerland, Conches. Google Scholar

UN STATISTICAL OFFICE (1975), Towards a System of Social and Demographic Statistics (Studies in Methods, Series F, No. 18), New York, UN Statistical Office. Google Scholar

US DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH, EDUCATION AND WELFARE (1969), Toward a Social Report, Washington DC, US Government Printing Office. Google Scholar

WEBER, M. (1964), Basic Concepts in Sociology, New York, Citadel Press. Basic Concepts in Sociology Google Scholar

WMEB (1993), Study of Existing Evidence on Local Economic Development and TECs (a final report to the Department of Employment), Birmingham, WMEB Consultants. Google Scholar

WONG, C. (1995), 'Developing quantitative indicators' in R. Hambleton and H. Thomas (eds), Urban Policy Evaluation, London, Paul Chapman, 111–22. 'Developing quantitative indicators' Urban Policy Evaluation 111 22 Google Scholar

WONG, C. (1996), What is Local Economic Development? A Conceptual Overview (Occasional Paper No. 49), Manchester, Department of Planning and Landscape, University of Manchester. Google Scholar

WONG, C. (1997), 'Crime risk in urban neighbourhoods: the use of insurance data to analyse the changing spatial forms', Area, 29, 228–40. Crime risk in urban neighbourhoods: the use of insurance data to analyse the changing spatial forms Area 29 228 40 Google Scholar

WONG, C. (1998a), 'Determining factors for local economic development: the perception of practitioners in the North West and Eastern Regions of the UK', Regional Studies, 32, 707– 20. Determining factors for local economic development: the perception of practitioners in the North West and Eastern Regions of the UK Regional Studies 32 707 20 Google Scholar

WONG, C. (1998b), 'Interrelationships between key actors in local economic development', Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 16, 463–81. Interrelationships between key actors in local economic development Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 16 463 81 Google Scholar

WONG, C. (2000), 'Indicators in use: challenges to urban and environmental planning in Britain', Town Planning Review, 71, 213–39. Indicators in use: challenges to urban and environmental planning in Britain Town Planning Review 71 213 39 Google Scholar

WONG, C. (2001), 'The relationship between quality of life and local economic development: an empirical study of local authority areas in England', Cities, 18, 25–32. The relationship between quality of life and local economic development: an empirical study of local authority areas in England Cities 18 25 32 Google Scholar

WONG, C. (2002a), 'Developing indicators to inform local economic development in England', Urban Studies, 39, 1833–63. Developing indicators to inform local economic development in England Urban Studies 39 1833 63 Google Scholar

WONG, C. (2002b), Development of Town and City Indicators: Review, Interpretation and Analysis (a final report to the Department for Transport, Local Government and the Regions), Liverpool, University of Liverpool. Google Scholar

WONG, C. (2002c), 'The crossroads of community indicators', Planning Theory and Practice, 3, 259–60. The crossroads of community indicators Planning Theory and Practice 3 259 60 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Wong, Cecilia