Hunter Gatherer Research

Representing space and place: hunter-gatherer perspectives

Hunter Gatherer Research (2020), 4, (3), 287–309.


Details

The anthropological sciences have long been interested in how hunter-gatherers perceive and interact with their spatial environment. The spatially flexible and dynamic modes of subsistence and residence typical of many hunter-gatherer communities have been considered to be key factors in the social organisation and ideological framing of such communities. However, close attention to spatial representation – in the form of categories and distinctions as they surface in everyday communication and behaviour, for example – has so far been largely restricted to certain subfields within the language and cognitive sciences. This inquiry, on the other hand, has not been concerned with the hunter-gatherer category as such, and it has rarely addressed spatial representations in their sociocultural context. The present special issue aims to highlight the potentials of a closer integration of these different research perspectives in advancing our understanding of hunter-gatherer space. The contributions – written by experts on a diverse set of communities – address a range of representational phenomena of core concern to this aim. This introductory paper presents space as a domain of inquiry into meaning, it reviews the literature on spatial representation among hunter-gatherer communities, and it outlines some of the major patterns of hunter-gatherer spatial strategies that emerge from the literature and the present contributions. Pointing to both diversity and commonalities across communities, the data offer new views of promising ways forward in the inquiry into hunter-gatherer relationships with the environment.

References

Arnold, G 1958. Nomadic Penan of the Upper Rejang (Plieran), Sarawak. Journal of the Malayan Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society 31(1):40–82. Google Scholar

Basso, KH 1984. Western Apache place-name hierarchies. In Tooker, E (ed) Naming systems. Washington, DC: American Ethnological Society:78–94. Google Scholar

Bickel, B & Nichols, J 2020. Linguistic typology and hunter-gatherer languages. In Güldemann, T, McConvell, P & Rhodes, R (eds) The language of hunter-gatherers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press:67–75. Google Scholar

Binford, LR 2002. In pursuit of the past: decoding the archaeological record. Oakland: University of California Press. Google Scholar

Blasi, DE, Moran, S, Moisik, SR, Widmer, P, Dediu, D & Bickel, B 2019. Human sound systems are shaped by post-Neolithic changes in bite configuration. Science 363(6432):eaav3218. Google Scholar

Boroditsky, L & Gaby, A 2011. Remembrances of times east: absolute spatial representations of time in an Australian Aboriginal community. Psychological Science 21(11):1635–1639. Google Scholar

Bowern, C 2009. Naming Bardi places. In Koch, H & Hercus, L (eds) Aboriginal placenames: naming and re-naming the Australian landscape. Canberra: ANU Press:327–345. Google Scholar

Brenzinger, M 2008. Conceptual strategies of orientation among the Khwe: from sunrise/sunset bisections to a left/right opposition. In Ermisch, S (ed) Khoisan languages and linguistics. Proceedings of the 2nd international symposium. Cologne: Rüdiger Köppe Verlag:15–47. Google Scholar

Brody, H 2001. The other side of Eden: hunter-gatherers, farmers, and the shaping of the world. London: Faber & Faber. Google Scholar

Bromhead, H 2018. Landscape and culture: cross-linguistic perspectives. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing Company. Google Scholar

Brown, CH 1985. Mode of subsistence and folk biological taxonomy. Current Anthropology 26:43–64. Google Scholar

Brown, CH 2020. Ethnobiology and the hunter-gatherer/food producer divide. In Güldemann, T, McConvell, P & Rhodes, RA (eds) The language of hunter-gatherers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press:76–87. Google Scholar

Burenhult, N (ed) 2008a. Language and landscape: geographical ontology in cross-linguistic perspective. Language Sciences 30(2–3) (special issue). Google Scholar

Burenhult, N 2008b. Streams of words: hydrological lexicon in Jahai. Language Sciences 30:182–199. Google Scholar

Burenhult, N & Kruspe, N 2016. The language of eating and drinking: a window on Orang Asli meaning-making. In Endicott, KM (ed) Malaysia’s original people: past, present and future of the Orang Asli. Singapore: NUS Press:175–199. Google Scholar

Burenhult, N & Levinson, SC 2008. Language and landscape: a cross-linguistic perspective. Language Sciences 30:135–150. Google Scholar

Burenhult, N & Purves, R 2020. The spatial properties of forager motion categories: evidence from Jahai. Hunter Gatherer Research 4(3):411–426. Google Scholar

Burenhult, N, Hill, C, Huber, J, van Putten, S, Rybka, K & San Roque, L 2017. Forests: the cross-linguistic perspective. Geographica Helvetica 72:455–464. Google Scholar

Cialone, C 2019. Placing spatial language and cognition in context through an investigation of Bininj Kunwok navigation talk. Unpublished doctoral dissertation. Canberra: Australian National University. Google Scholar

Cialone, C 2020. Geomapped semantics of Bininj Kunwok orientation lexicon. Hunter Gatherer Research 4(3):391–409. Google Scholar

Davis, JE 2006. A historical linguistic account of sign language among North American Indian groups. In Lucas, C (ed) Multilingualism and sign languages. Washington, DC: Gallaudet University Press:3–35. Google Scholar

Diessel, H 1999. Demonstratives: form, function, and grammaticalization. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing Company. Google Scholar

Duncan, SD 2005. Co-expressivity of speech and gesture: manner of motion in Spanish, English, and Chinese. In Chang, C, Houser, MJ, Kim, Y, Mortensen, D, Park-Doob, M & Toosarvandani, M (eds) Proceedings of the 27th Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society. Berkeley, CA: Berkeley Linguistics Society:353–370. Google Scholar

Emmorey, K & Reilly, J (eds) 1995. Language, gesture, and space. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Google Scholar

Epps, P 2013. Inheritance, calquing, or independent innovation? Reconstructing morphological complexity in Amazonian numerals. Journal of Language Contact 6(2):329–357. Google Scholar

Epps, P, Bowern, C, Hansen, CA, Hill, JH & Zentz, J 2012. On numeral complexity in hunter-gatherer languages. Linguistic Typology 16:41–109. Google Scholar

Evans, G 1985. The varieties of reference. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar

Gluck, M 1991. Making sense of human wayfinding: review of cognitive and linguistic knowledge for personal navigation with a new research direction. In Mark, DM & Frank, AU (eds) Cognitive and linguistic aspects of geographic space. Berlin: Springer Science+Business Media:117–135. Google Scholar

Green, JA 2014. Drawn from the ground: sound, sign and inscription in Central Australian sand stories. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar

Guillaume, A 2016. Associated motion in South America: typological and areal perspectives. Linguistic Typology 20(1):81–177. Google Scholar

Güldemann, T, McConvell, P & Rhodes, RA (eds) 2020. Hunter-gatherer anthropology and language. In Güldemann, T, McConvell, P & Rhodes, R (eds) The language of hunter-gatherers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press:3–48. Google Scholar

Haun, DBM & Rapold, CJ 2009. Variation in memory for body movements across cultures. Current Biology 19(23):1068–1069. Google Scholar

Haviland, JB 1998. Guugu Yimithirr cardinal directions. Ethos 26:25–47. Google Scholar

Haviland, JB 2000. Pointing, gesture spaces, and mental maps. In McNeill, D (ed) Language and gesture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press:13–46. Google Scholar

Hoffmann, D 2020. Talking about motion in Aboriginal Australia: how linguistic structure and culture influence motion event encoding. Hunter Gatherer Research 4(3):369–390. Google Scholar

Hunn, E 1996. Columbia plateau Indian place names: what can they teach us? Journal of Linguistic Anthropology 6:3–26. Google Scholar

Ingold, T & Vergunst, JL (eds) 2008. Ways of walking: ethnography and practice on foot. Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing. Google Scholar

Istomin, KV & Dwyer, MJ 2009. Finding the way: a critical discussion of anthropological theories of human spatial orientation with reference to reindeer herders of Northeastern Europe and Western Siberia. Current Anthropology 50(1):29–49. Google Scholar

Jarvenpa, R & Brumbach, HJ 2016. Initializing the landscape: Chipewyan construction of meaning in a recently occupied environment. In Lovis, W & Whallon, R (eds) Marking the land: hunter-gatherer creation of meaning in their environment. New York: Routledge/Taylor and Francis:13–44. Google Scholar

Johnson, LM & Hunn, ES (eds) 2010. Landscape ethnoecology: concepts of biotic and physical space. New York: Berghahn Books Inc. Google Scholar

Jordan, PD 2001. The materiality of shamanism as a ‘world-view’: praxis, artefacts and landscape. In Price, N (ed) The archaeology of shamanism. London: Routledge:87–104. Google Scholar

Kari, J 1989. Some principles of Alaskan Athabaskan toponymic knowledge. In Kay, MR & Hoenigswald, MR (eds) General and Amerindian ethnolinguistics: in remembrance of Stanley Newman. New York: Mouton de Gruyter:129–149. Google Scholar

Kari, J 2008. Ahtna place names lists. Fairbanks: Alaska Native Language Center. Google Scholar

Kari, J 2010. Ahtna travel narratives: a demonstration of shared geographic knowledge among Alaska Athabascans. Fairbanks: Alaska Native Language Center. Google Scholar

Kathage, B 2004. Konzeptualisierung von Landschaft im Mbukushu [Conceptualisation of landscape in Mbukushu]. Cologne: Rüdiger Köppe Verlag. Google Scholar

Kelly, RL 1983. Hunter-gatherer mobility strategies. Journal of Anthropological Research 39(3):277–306. Google Scholar

Kelly, RL 2013. The lifeways of hunter-gatherers: the foraging spectrum. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar

Kendon, A 1988. Parallels and divergences between Warlpiri sign language and spoken Warlpiri: analyses of signed and spoken discourses. Oceania 58:239–254. Google Scholar

Kendon, A 1989. Sign languages of Aboriginal Australia: cultural, semiotic and communicative perspectives. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar

Koch, H 1984. The category of ‘associated motion’ in Kaytej. Language in Central Australia 1:23–34. Google Scholar

Kopecka, A & Narasimhan, B (eds) 2012. Events of putting and taking: a crosslinguistic perspective. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing Company. Google Scholar

Lee, RB & DeVore, I (eds) 1968. Man the hunter. Chicago: Aldine. Google Scholar

Levinson, SC 2003. Space in language and cognition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar

Levinson, SC & Wilkins, DP (eds) 2006. Grammars of space. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar

Levinson, SC, Cutfield, S, Dunn, MJ, Enfield, NJ, & Meira, S (eds) 2018. Demonstratives in cross-linguistic perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar

Levinson, SC, Kita, S, Haun, DBM & Rasch, BH 2002. Returning the tables: language affects spatial reasoning. Cognition 84(2):155–188. Google Scholar

Lewis, HM, Vinicius, L, Strods, J, Mace, R & Bamberg Migliano, A 2014. High mobility explains demand sharing and enforced cooperation in egalitarian hunter-gatherers. Nature Communications 5:5789. Google Scholar

Li, P & Gleitman, L 2002. Turning the tables: language and spatial reasoning. Cognition 83:265–294. Google Scholar

Lovis, WA & Whallon, R 2016. The creation of landscape meaning by mobile hunters and gatherers. In Lovis, W & Whallon, R (eds) Marking the land: hunter-gatherer creation of meaning in their environment. New York: Routledge/Taylor and Francis:1–10. Google Scholar

Lye, TP 2016. Signaling presence: how Batek and Penan hunter-gatherers in Malaysia mark the landscape. In Lovis, W & Whallon, R (eds) Marking the land: hunter-gatherer creation of meaning in their environment. New York: Routledge/Taylor and Francis:231–260. Google Scholar

Majid, A & Kruspe, N 2018. Hunter-gatherer olfaction is special. Current Biology 28(3):409–413. Google Scholar

Majid, A, Bowerman, M, Kita, S, Haun, DBM & Levinson, SC 2004. Can language restructure cognition? The case for space. Trends in Cognitive Science 8(3):108–114. Google Scholar

Mamontova, N, Klyachko, E & Thornton, T 2020. ‘The track is never the same’: the fluidity of geographic terminology and conceptualisation of space among Ewenki. Hunter Gatherer Research 4(3):311–337. Google Scholar

Mark, DM, Turk, AG, Burenhult, N & Stea, D (eds) 2011. Landscape in language: transdisciplinary perspectives. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing Company. Google Scholar

McNeill, D 1997. Imagery in motion event descriptions: gestures as part of thinking-for-speaking in three languages. In Juge, ML & Moxley, JL (eds) Proceedings of the 23rd Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society. Berkeley, CA: Berkeley Linguistics Society:255–267. Google Scholar

Migliano, AB, Page, AE, Gómez-Gardeñes, J, Salali, GD, Viguier, S, Dyble, M, Thompson, J, Chaudhary, N, Smith, D, Strods, J, Mace, R, Thomas, MG, Latora, V & Vinicius, L 2017. Characterization of hunter-gatherer networks and implications for cumulative culture. Nature Human Behaviour 1(0043):1–6. Google Scholar

Obert, K 2019. The linguistic encoding of space in Dâw. Unpublished doctoral dissertation. São Paulo: Universidade de São Paulo. Google Scholar

Oetelaar, GA 2016. Places on the Blackfoot homeland: markers of cosmology, social relationships and history. In Lovis, WA & Whallon, R (eds) Marking the land: hunter-gatherer creation of meaning in their environment. New York: Routledge/Taylor and Francis:45–66. Google Scholar

O’Meara, C 2010. Seri landscape classification and spatial reference. Unpublished doctoral dissertation. Buffalo: State University of New York. Google Scholar

O’Meara, C 2011. Frames of reference in Seri. Language Sciences 33(6):1025–1046. Google Scholar

O’Meara, C & Henzi, M In press. Mapeo de los nombres de lugares con los comcaac (seri). In Guerrero, L & Arellanes Arellanes, F (eds) Estudios lingüísticos y filológicos en lenguas indígenas mexicanas. Celebración por los 30 años del Seminario de Lenguas Indígenas. Mexico: UNAM-IIFL. Google Scholar

O’Meara, C & Pérez Báez, G 2011. Spatial frames of reference in Mesoamerican languages. Language Sciences 33(6):837–852. Google Scholar

Pederson, E, Danziger, E, Wilkins, DP, Levinson, SC, Kita, S & Senft, G 1998. Semantic typology and spatial conceptualization. Language 74:557–589. Google Scholar

Pontzer, H, Raichlen, DA, Wood, BM, Mabulla, AZP, Racette, SB & Marlowe, FW 2012. Hunter-gatherer energetics and human obesity. PLOS One 7(7):1–8. Google Scholar

Pontzer, H, Raichlen, DA, Wood, BM, Emery Thompson, M, Racette, SB, Mabulla, AZP & Marlowe, FW 2015. Energy expenditure and activity among Hadza hunter-gatherers. American Journal of Human Biology 27(5):628–637. Google Scholar

Raichlen, DA, Wood, BM, Gordon, AD, Mabulla, AZP, Marlowe, FW & Pontzer, H 2014. Evidence of Lévy walk foraging patterns in human hunter-gatherers. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 111(2):728–733. Google Scholar

Rothstein, M 2016. Regnskovens religion: forestillinger og ritualer blandt Borneos sidste jæger-samlere [The religion of the rainforest: beliefs and rituals among Borneo’s last hunter-gatherers]. Copenhagen: U Press. Google Scholar

Rothstein, M 2020. Being lost: landscape, troubling spirits and ritual strategies among the Eastern Penan. Hunter Gatherer Research 4(3):355–368. Google Scholar

Rybka, K 2016. The linguistic encoding of landscape in Lokono. Amsterdam: LOT. Google Scholar

Schultze-Berndt, E 2006. Sketch of a Jaminjung grammar of space. In Levinson, SC & Wilkins, DP (eds) Grammars of space. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press:63–114. Google Scholar

Sercombe, P 2020. Narratives about space and place in Eastern Penan. Hunter Gatherer Research 4(3):339–354. Google Scholar

Slobin, DI 1996. Two ways to travel: verbs of motion in English and Spanish. In Shibatani, M & Thompson, S (eds) Grammatical constructions. Oxford: Clarendon Press:195–219. Google Scholar

Talmy, L 1985. Lexicalization patterns: semantic structure in lexical forms. In Shopen, T (ed) Language typology and syntactic description. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press:36–149. Google Scholar

Talmy, L 2000. Toward a cognitive semantics. Vol 2. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Google Scholar

Terrill, A & Burenhult, N 2008. Orientation as a strategy of spatial reference. Studies in Language 32(1):93–136. Google Scholar

Thompson, B 2016. Sense of place among hunter-gatherers. Cross-Cultural Research 50(4):283–324. Google Scholar

Thornton, TF 1997. Know your place: the organization of Tlingit geographic knowledge. Ethnology 36(4):295–307. Google Scholar

Thornton, TF 2008. Being and place among the Tlingit. Seattle: University of Washington Press. Google Scholar

Tuan, Y-F 1974. Topophilia: a study of environmental perception, attitudes, and values. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Google Scholar

Whallon, R 2006. Social networks and information: Non-‘utilitarian’ mobility among hunter-gatherers. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 25:259–270. Google Scholar

Widlok, T 1997. Orientation in the wild: the shared cognition of Hai||om bushpeople. The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 3(2):317–332. Google Scholar

Wilkins, DP 1999. Spatial deixis in Arrernte speech and gesture: on the analysis of a species of composite signal as used by a Central Australian Aboriginal group. In André, E, Poesio, M & Rieser, H (eds) Proceedings of the workshop on deixis, demonstration and deictic belief in multimedia contexts. Utrecht: Eleventh European Summer School in Logic, Language and Information:30–42. Google Scholar

Wilkins, DP 2006. Towards an Arrernte grammar of space. In Levinson, SC & Wilkins, DP (eds) Grammars of space. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press:24–62. Google Scholar

Zaman, T & Winschiers-Theophilus, H 2015. Penan’s oroo’ short message signs (PO-SMS): co-design of a digital jungle sign language application. In Abascal, J, Barbosa, S, Fetter, M, Gross, T, Palanque, P & Winckler, M (eds) Human-computer interaction – INTERACT 2015 Part II. Berlin: Springer:489–504. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Author details

O’Meara, Carolyn

Burenhult, Niclas

Rothstein, Mikael

Sercombe, Peter