Town Planning Review

Land-policy instruments for densification: the Dutch quest for control

Town Planning Review (2020), 91, (3), 239–258.

Abstract

Land-policy instruments are important to local governments for the implementation of densification. This article explores the factors behind local governments’ motives that determine the use of specific land-policy instruments to achieve densification. The aim is to increase understanding of how available land-policy instruments are applied in practice by local governments to realise housing development at inner-urban locations. In-depth analysis comparing two Dutch municipalities shows that common underlying factors explain municipal land-policy applications, while available instruments are used differently. Insights into these factors help to explain local governments’ behaviour regarding land-policy instruments.

Access Token
£25.00

References

ADDISON, C., ZHANG, S. and COOMES, B. (2013), ‘Smart growth and housing affordability: a review of regulatory mechanisms and planning practices’, Journal of Planning Literature, 28, 215–57. Google Scholar

ALEXANDER, E. R. (2014), ‘Land-property markets and planning: a special case’, Land Use Policy, 41, 533–40. Google Scholar

ALTERMAN, R. (2009), ‘Can the “unearned increment” in land values be harnessed to supply affordable housing?’, UN Habitat GNLT Conference, Warsaw, October 2009. Google Scholar

BECKER, T. and HESSE, M. (2011), ‘Siedlungsentwicklung und Wohnungswesen’, in T. Chilla and C. Schulz (eds), Raumordnung in Luxemburg: Aménagement du territoireau Luxembourg, Luxemburg, Editions Guy Binsfeld, 78–95. Google Scholar

BONTJE, M. (2003), ‘A “planner’s paradise” lost? Past, present and future of Dutch national urbanization policy’, European Urban and Regional Studies, 10, 135–51. Google Scholar

BREHENY, M. (1997), ‘Urban compaction feasible and acceptable?’, Cities, 14, 209–17. Google Scholar

BROITMAN, D. and KOOMEN, E. (2015), ‘Residential density change: densification and urban expansion’, Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, 54, 32–46. Google Scholar

BRUINSMA, F. and KOOMEN, E. (2018), Ruimtelijke ordening in Nederland (Spatial Planning in the Netherlands), Amsterdam, Vrije Universiteit. Google Scholar

BUITELAAR, E. (2010), ‘Cracks in the myth: challenges to land policy in the Netherlands’, Tijdschrift voor Economische en Social Geografie, 101, 349–56. Google Scholar

BUITELAAR, E. and BREGMAN, A. (2016), ‘Dutch land development institutions in the face of crisis: trembling pillars in the planners’ paradise’, European Planning Studies, 24, 1281–94. Google Scholar

BUITELAAR, E., GALLE, M. and SOREL, N. (2011), ‘Plan-led planning systems in development-led practices: an empirical analyses into the (lack of) institutionalism of planning law’, Environment and Planning A, 43, 928–41. Google Scholar

BUITELAAR, E., LAGENDIJK, A. and JACOBS, W. (2007), ‘A theory of institutional change: illustrated by Dutch city-provinces and Dutch land policy’, Environment and Planning A, 39, 891–908. Google Scholar

CBS (2018a), Huizenprijzen op niveau van voor de crisis, https://www.cbs.nl/nl-nl/nieuws/2018/36/huizenprijzen-op-niveau-van-voor-de-kredietcrisis (accessed 1 October 2018). Google Scholar

CBS (2018b), Number of Completed New Residential Units per Year, 2000–2017, http://statline.cbs.nl/Statweb/publication/?DM=SLNL&PA=81955NED&D1=1&D2=1&D3=0&D4=16,33,50,67,84,101&HDR=G1,T&STB=G2,G3&VW=T (accessed 1 October 2018). Google Scholar

CECCARELLI, T., BAJOCCO, S., LUIGI PERINI, L. and LUCA SALVATI, L. (2014), ‘Urbanisation and land take of high quality agricultural soils: exploring long-term land use changes and land capability in northern Italy’, International Journal of Environmental Research, 8, 181–92. Google Scholar

CLAASSENS, J. and KOOMEN, E. (2017), ‘Steden blijven verdichten’ (Cities continue to become more dense), ROm, 35, 18–25. Google Scholar

COUNCIL FOR FINANCIAL RELATIONS (2015), Grond, Geld en Gemeenten: de betekenins en gevolgen van de gemeentelijke grondexploitaties voor de bestuurlijke en financiële verhoudingen (Land, Money and Municipalities: The Meaning and Consequences of Municipal Land Development for Administrative and Financial Relations), The Hague, Council for Public Administration. Google Scholar

DAVY, B. (2018), ‘Bodenmarkt/Bodenpolitik’, in H. H. Blotevogel, T. Döring, S. Grotefels, I. Helbrecht, J. Jessen and C. Schmidt (eds), Handwörterbuch der Stadt- und Raumentwicklung, Hannover, ARL, 267–78. Google Scholar

DIERWECHTER, Y. (2014), ‘The spaces that smart growth makes: sustainability, segregation, and residential change across Greater Seattle’, Urban Geography, 35, 691–714. Google Scholar

FALUDI, A. and VAN DER VALK, A. (1994), Rule and Order: Dutch Planning Doctrine in the Twentieth Century, Dordrecht, Kluwer Academic. Google Scholar

GERBER, J. D. (2016), ‘The managerial turn and municipal land-use planning in Switzerland: evidence from practice’, Planning, Theory and Practice, 17, 192–209. Google Scholar

GERBER, J. D., HENGSTERMANN, A. and VIALLON, F. X. (2018), ‘Land policy: how to deal with scarcity of land’, in J. D. Gerber, T. Hartmann and A. Hengstermann (eds), Instruments of Land Policy: Dealing with Scarcity of Land, New York, Routledge, 8–26. Google Scholar

GERRING, J. (2007), Case Study Research: Principles and Practices, New York, Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar

GIEZEN, M., BALIKCI, S. and ARUNDEL, R. (2018), ‘Using remote sensing to analyse net land-use change from conflicting sustainability policies: the case of Amsterdam’, International Journal of Geo-information, 7, 1–13. Google Scholar

HARTMANN, T. and SPIT, T. (2015), ‘Dilemmas of involvement in land management: comparing an active (Dutch) approach and a passive (German) approach’, Land Use Policy, 42, 729–37. Google Scholar

HOLTSLAG-BROEKHOF, S. (2018), ‘Urban land readjustment: necessary for effective urban renewal? Analysing the Dutch quest for new legislation’, Land Use Policy, 77, 821–28. Google Scholar

JANSSEN-JANSEN L., LLOYD, G., PEEL, D. and VAN DER KRABBEN, E. (2012), Planning in an Environment without Growth, The Hague, Raad voor de Leefomgeving en Infrastructuur. Google Scholar

KNOEPFEL, P., CSIKOS, P., GERBER, J. D. and NAHRATH, S. (2012), ‘Transformation der Rolle des Staates und der Grundeigentümer in städtischen Raumentwicklungsprozessen im Lichte der nachhaltigen Entwicklung’, PVS, 53, 414–43. Google Scholar

LEFCOE, G. (1977), ‘When governments become land developers: notes on the public-sector experience in the Netherlands and California’, California Law Review, 51, 165–263. Google Scholar

LICHTENBERG, E. and DING, C. (2009), ‘Local officials as land developers: urban spatial expansion in China’, Journal of Urban Economics, 66, 57–64. Google Scholar

MATHUR, S. (2014), ‘Impact of urban growth boundary on housing and land prices: evidence from King County, Washington’, Housing Studies, 29, 128–48. Google Scholar

MONK, S., WHITEHEAD, C., BURGESS, G. and TANG, C. (2013), International Review of Land Supply and Planning Systems, Cambridge, Cambridge Centre for Housing and Planning Research. Google Scholar

MUNICIPALITY OF’S-HERTOGENBOSCH(2016), Woonagenda 2017/2018 (Housing Agenda 2017/2018), https://www.s-hertogenbosch.nl/uploads/media/Bijlage_1_Woonagenda_2017-2018.pdf (accessed 14 January 2019). Google Scholar

MUNICIPALITY OF ’S-HERTOGENBOSCH (2018a), Jaarverslag 2017, toelichting grondbedrijf per project (Annual Report 2017 (Attachment): Explanation of Land Development per Project), https://s-hertogenbosch.jaarverslag-2017.nl/assets/docs/19_toelichting_per_project_bie_s.pdf (accessed 14 January 2019). Google Scholar

MUNICIPALITY OF ’S-HERTOGENBOSCH (2018b), Nota Grondbeleid 2018 (Land Policy Memorandum 2018), https://s-hertogenbosch.raadsinformatie.nl/vergadering/453509#ai_3784800 (accessed 14 January 2019). Google Scholar

MUNICIPALITY OF ZWOLLE (2015), Informatienota grondbeleid nieuwe stijl (Information Note on New Forms of Land Policy), https://ibabsonline.eu/Agenda.aspx?site=Zwolleandagendaid=d8a6985a-0f28-4587-be0d-5e605d72a3a3andFoundIDs= (accessed 14 January 2019). Google Scholar

MUNICIPALITY OF ZWOLLE (2016), Stand van zaken grondvoorraadbeleid (Current State of Supply of Land Stock Policy), https://ibabsonline.eu/Agenda.aspx?site=zwolle&agendaid=e4cd241a-f463-426c-93fe-91fc994f44fe&FoundIDs= (accessed 14 January 2019). Google Scholar

MUNICIPALITY OF ZWOLLE (2017), Woonvisie Zwolle: ruimte voor wonen 2017–2027 (Housing Vision Zwolle: Space for Housing 2017–2027), https://www.zwolle.nl/sites/default/files/woonvisie-ruimte-voor-wonen-2017-2027.pdf (accessed 14 January 2019). Google Scholar

MUNOZ-GIELEN, D. (2011), Het verhalen van waardestijging in stedelijke herstructurering, http://www.urbsadvies.nl/attachments/Voorpagina NLSamenvatting.pdf (accessed 30 July 2018). Google Scholar

NEEDHAM, B. (1992), ‘A theory of land prices when land is supplied publicly: the case of the Netherlands’, Urban Studies, 29, 669–86. Google Scholar

NEEDHAM, B. (1997), ‘Land policy in the Netherlands’, Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie, 88, 291–96. Google Scholar

NEEDHAM, B. (2014), Dutch Land-Use Planning: The Principles and the Practice, London, Taylor and Francis Ltd. Google Scholar

NEPROM (2018), Investeringsstrategie voor duurzame verstedelijking: hoe nu verder? (Investment Strategy for Sustainable Urban Development: Where to Go from Here?), https://www.neprom.nl/nieuws/artikel.aspx?ID=1003 (accessed 24 February 2020). Google Scholar

NEUMAN, M. (2005), ‘The compact city fallacy’, Journal of Planning Education and Research, 25, 11–26. Google Scholar

OOI, J. T. L., SIRMANS, C. F. and TURNBULL, G. K. (2011), ‘Government supply of land in a dual market’, Real Estate Economics, 39, 167–84. Google Scholar

PLOEGMAKERS, H., VAN DER KRABBEN, E. and BUITELAAR, E. (2013), ‘Understanding industrial land supply: how Dutch municipalities make decisions about supplying serviced building land’, Journal of Property Research, 30, 324–44. Google Scholar

PRIEMUS, H. and LOUW, E. (2003), ‘Changes in Dutch land policy: from monopoly toward competition in the building market’, Environment and Planning B, 30, 369–78. Google Scholar

TENNEKES, J. (2018), ‘Negotiated land use plans in the Netherlands: a central instrument in Dutch “active” and “passive” land policy’, in Gerber et al. (eds), 101–13. Google Scholar

TOUATI-MOREL, A. (2015), ‘Hard and soft densification policies in the Paris city-region’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 39, 603–12. Google Scholar

VALTONEN, E., FALKENBACH, H. and VAN DER KRABBEN, E. (2017), ‘Risk management in public land development projects: comparative case study in Finland and the Netherlands’, Land Use Policy, 62, 246–57. Google Scholar

VAN DER CAMMEN, H. and DE KLERK, L. (2010), Ruimtelijke ordening: Van grachtengordel tot Vinexwijk, Utrecht, Het Spectrum. Google Scholar

VAN DER KRABBEN, E. and JACOBS, H. M. (2013), ‘Public land development as a strategic tool for redevelopment: reflections on the Dutch experience’, Land Use Policy, 30, 774–83. Google Scholar

VAN DER KRABBEN, E. and NEEDHAM, B. (2008), ‘Land readjustment for value capturing: a new planning tool for urban redevelopment’, Town Planning Review, 79, 651–72. Google Scholar

VAN OOSTEN, T., WITTE, P. and HARTMANN, T. (2018), ‘Active land policy in small municipalities in the Netherlands: “We don’t do it, unless …”’, Land Use Policy, 77, 829–36. Google Scholar

VERGNES, A., PELLISSIER, V., LEMPERIERE, G., ROLLARD, C. and CLERGEAU, P. (2014), ‘Urban densification causes the decline of ground-dwelling arthropods’, Biodiversity and Conservation, 23, 1859–77. Google Scholar

VINING, A., and WEIMER, D. (2015), ‘Policy analysis’, in J. D. Wright (ed.), International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2nd edn, 18, 273–80. Google Scholar

WEBSTER, C. J. and LAI, L. W. (2003), Property Rights, Planning and Markets: Managing Spontaneous Cities, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar. Google Scholar

WESTERINK, J., HAASE, D., BAUER, A., RAVETZ, J., JARRIGE, F. and AALBERS, C. (2013), ‘Dealing with sustainability trade-offs of the compact city in peri-urban planning across European city regions’, European Planning Studies, 21, 473–97. Google Scholar

YE, L., MANDPE, S. and MEYER, P. B. (2005), ‘What is “smart growth” – really?’, Journal of Planning Literature, 19, 301–15. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Meijer, Rick

Jonkman, Arend