Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

Labor Neoliberals or Pragmatic Neo-Laborists? The Hawke and Keating Labor Governments in Office, 1983––96

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2010), 98, (1), 25–37.

Abstract

The economic “reforms” associated with the broader neoliberal agenda first found expression in Australia through the policies of the Hawke and Keating Labor Governments. This article examines the politics of this period using Antonio Gramsci’s notion of hegemony. It argues that the Hawke and Keating administrations were a “conjunctural episode” in an “organic movement” to re-establish “ruling class hegemony” after the breakdown of the post-war capitalist order. The period of continuous Labor rule from 1983 to 1996 represented the birth of “Neo-Laborism”, a pragmatic policy approach which sought to reconcile the problems of electoralism and “Laborism” that had plagued former Labor governments. Their “Neo-Laborist” agenda was underwritten by economic changes aimed at ensuring sustained growth coupled with corporatist agreements to appease organised labour. This article distinguishes the pragmatic policies of the ALP from the calculated tactics of an emerging neoliberalism.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Endnotes

1.Kevin Rudd, ‘The global financial crisis’, The Monthly, February2009, p.20. Google Scholar

2.Ibid., p.22. Google Scholar

3.Michael Stutchbury, ‘No market reform on Rudd’s recovery road: the PM bags the deregulation of the past 25 years but claims he wants to boost productivity’, The Australian, 28July2009, p.14. Google Scholar

4.Ibid. Google Scholar

5.David Uren andMatthew Franklin, ‘Henry Warns of Second Shockwave’, The Australian, Tuesday 18August2009, p.4. Google Scholar

6.Leslie Sklair, ‘Who are the globalisers? a study of key globalisers in Australia’, Journal of Australian Political Economy, vol.38, 1995, p.18. Google Scholar

7.Ibid., p.20. Google Scholar

8.Damien Cahill, ‘The contours of neoliberal hegemony in Australia’, Rethinking Marxism, vol.19, no.2, 2007, p.229. Google Scholar

9.Raewyn Connell, ‘Moloch Mutates: global capitalism and the evolution of the Australian ruling class 1977-2002’, inNathan Hollier(ed.), Ruling Australia: The Power, Privilege & Politics of the New Ruling Class,Australian Scholarly Publishing,, 2004, p.33. Google Scholar

10.Simon Mohun, ‘The Australian rate of profit 1985-2001’, Journal of Australian Political Economy, vol.52, 2003, p.88. Google Scholar

11.Cahill, ‘The contours of neoliberal hegemony in Australia’, p.228-9. Google Scholar

12.Connell,‘Moloch Mutates’, p.4. Google Scholar

13.Kevin Rudd, ‘The Global Financial Crisis’, p.25. Google Scholar

14.Ibid., p.25. Google Scholar

15.Drew Cottle, ‘Looting the lucky country: economic restructuring in Australian capitalism’, inNational Fightback Conference,Canberra Fightback,, 1987, p.1. Google Scholar

16.Bob Catley, ‘Australia in the world crisis’, inG. Duncan(ed.), Essays in Australian Politics,Edward Arnold,, 1978, p.223. Google Scholar

17.Michael Pusey, ‘Econo-rot’, inPeter Craven(ed.), The Best Australian Essays 2003,Black Inc.,, 2003, p.133. Google Scholar

18.OECD Council, Towards Full Employment and Price Stability,OECD,, 1977, p.344. Google Scholar

19.Ernest Mandel, Decline of the Dollar: A Marxist View of the Monetary Crisis.Monad Press,, 1972, p.103. Google Scholar

20.Catley, ‘Australia in the world crisis’, p.232. Google Scholar

21.Ibid., p.232. Google Scholar

22.Ibid., p.232. Google Scholar

23.OECD Council, ‘Towards full employment and price stability’, pp.16-17. Google Scholar

24.Ibid., pp.16-17. Google Scholar

25.Stephen Bell, Ungoverning the Economy: The Political Economy of Australian Economic Policy,Oxford University Press,, 1997, p.82. Google Scholar

26.Stephen Jolly, ‘Australia Reconstructed: A Socialist Response’, Australian Marxist Bulletin, Summer, 1988, p.3. Google Scholar

27.Bell, Ungoverning the Economy, p.83. Google Scholar

28.Jolly, ‘Australia Reconstructed’, p.3. Google Scholar

29.Bell, Ungoverning the Economy, p.4. Google Scholar

30.Ronald E. Walker, The Australian Economy in War and Reconstruction,Oxford University Press,, 1947, p.133. Google Scholar

31.Dennis Woodward, Australia Unsettled: The Legacy of ‘Neo-liberalism’,Pearson Education Australia,, 2005, p.6. Google Scholar

32.Catley, ‘Australia in the world crisis’, p.230. Google Scholar

33.Greg Crough,Ted Wheelwright andTed Wilshire(eds), Australian and World Capitalism,Penguin Books,, 1980, p.46. Google Scholar

34.Ibid. Google Scholar

35.Catley, ‘Australia in the world crisis’, p.230. Google Scholar

36.Robert Catley andBruce McFarlane, Australian Capitalism in Boom and Depression,Alternative Publishing Cooperative,, 1981, pp.104-5. Google Scholar

37.Karl Marx, Capital: Vol. 3,Penguin Books,, 1981, p.319. Google Scholar

38.Bob Rowthorn, ‘Late capitalism’, New Left Review, vol.98, July-August1976, pp.59-83. Google Scholar

39.Mohun, ‘The Australian rate of profit 1985-2001’, p.88. Google Scholar

40.Marx, Capital: Vol. 3, p.319. Google Scholar

41.Mohun, ‘The Australian rate of profit 1985-2001’, p.88. Google Scholar

42.Pusey, ‘Econo-rot’, p.134. Google Scholar

43.Christopher Lloyd, ‘Australian capitalism since 1992: a new regime of accumulation?’, Journal of Australian Political Economy, vol.61, June2008, p.40. Google Scholar

44.Tom Bramble, ‘Thirteen wasted years: Labor in power (1983-96) and its accord with the unions’, inKenneth Wilson,Joanne Bradford andMaree Fitzpatrick(eds), Australia in Accord: An Assessment of Australia’s Incomes Policy Experiment during the Hawke-Keating Years,South Pacific Publishing,, 2004, p.4. Google Scholar

45.Georgina Murray, Capitalist Networks and Social Power in Australia and New Zealand,Ashgate,, 2006, p.11. Google Scholar

46.Ibid., p.45. Google Scholar

47.R.W. Connell, Ruling Class, Ruling Culture,Cambridge University Press,, 1977, p.vii. Google Scholar

48.Catley andMcFarlane, Australian Capitalism in Boom and Depression, p.11. Google Scholar

49.Catley, ‘Australia in the world crisis’, pp.87-8. Google Scholar

50.Lloyd, ‘Australian capitalism since 1992’, p.35. Google Scholar

51.Connell, Ruling Class, Ruling Culture, pp.108-9. Google Scholar

52.Shaun Goldfinch, Remaking New Zealand and Australian Economic Policy: Ideas, Institutions and Policy Communities,Georgetown University Press,, 2000, p.158. Google Scholar

53.Ibid., p.158. Google Scholar

54.Dennis Woodward, Australia Unsettled: The Legacy of ‘Neo-liberalism’, p.49. Google Scholar

55.Ibid., p.49. Google Scholar

56.Judith Brett, ‘Ideology’, inJudith Brett,James Gillespie andMurray Groot(eds)., Developments in Australian Politics,Macmillan,, 1994, p.14. Google Scholar

57.Boris Frankel, ‘Beyond labourism and socialism: how the Australian Labor Party developed the model of “New Labor”’, New Left Review, vol.221, January-February1997, p.8. Google Scholar

58.John Mangan, ‘Australian manufacturing: de-industrialisation or restructuring?’, inRobert Castle,Don Lewis andJohn Mangan(eds), Australian Studies: Work, Leisure and Technology,Longman Cheshire,, 1986, p.53. Google Scholar

59.Bramble, ‘Thirteen wasted years’, p.18. Google Scholar

60.Damien Cahill, ‘Labo(u)r, the boom and the prospects for an alternative to neo-liberalism’, Journal of Australian Political Economy, vol.61, 2008, p.322. Google Scholar

61.Ian MacFarlane, The Search for Stability: Boyer Lectures 2006,ABC Books,, 2006, p.36. Google Scholar

62.Cahill, ‘Labo(u)r, the boom and the prospects for an alternative to neo-liberalism’, p.322. Google Scholar

63.John Edwards, Quiet Boom: How the Long Economic Upswing is Changing Australia and its Place in the World,Longueville Media,, 2006, p.26. Google Scholar

64.Mark Berger, ‘Up from neoliberalism: free-market mythologies and the coming crisis of global capitalism’, Third World Quarterly, vol.20, no.2, 1999, p.453. Google Scholar

65.Cahill, ‘Labo(u)r, the boom and the prospects for an alternative to neo-liberalism’, p.333. Google Scholar

66.Tom Bramble, Trade Unionism in Australia: A History from Flow to Ebb Tide,Cambridge University Press,, p.158. Google Scholar

67.Cahill, ‘The contours of neoliberal hegemony in Australia’, p.228-9. Google Scholar

68.Brett, ‘Ideology’, p.12. Google Scholar

69.Michael Pusey, Economic Rationalism in Canberra: A Nation Building State Changes its Mind,Cambridge University Press,, 1991, p.6. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Collins, Joe

Cottle, Drew