Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

The Australian Capital Territory Preselection of 1968–69: A Study of Class and Generational Change in the ALP

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2014), 107, (1), 167–179.

Abstract

Changes in the composition of the Australian Labor Party’s membership during the late 1960s and 1970s have been much discussed; however this discussion has taken place primarily with reference to class, occupation and level of education. The ALP’s Canberra branches, which developed an atypically white collar character prior to the 1960s, provide an opportunity to focus on other aspects of this period of change in the ALP. These issues were publicly and viscerally canvassed during the course of a debate surrounding the preselection for the Federal seat of the Australian Capital Territory held in 1968. While anxieties about, and opposition to, the participation of tertiary educated members in the ALP were much in evidence during the course of this debate, the most discussed division was that between generations.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*The author would like to thank the two anonymous referees ofLabour Historyfor their comments and suggestions. Google Scholar

1.Nick Dyrenfurth andFrank Bongiorno, A Little History of the Australian Labor Party(:UNSW Press, 2011), 123, 141–13;Michael Thompson, Labor without Class: The Gentrification of the ALP(:Pluto Press, 1999), 20–21;Michael Sexton, The Great Crash: The Short Life and Sudden Death of the Whitlam Government(:Scribe, 2005), 42;Katherine Betts, The Great Divide(:Duffy and Snellgrove, 1999), 17, 162–63. Google Scholar

2.Andrew Scott, Fading Loyalties: The Australian Labor Party and the Working Class(:Pluto Press, 1991), 25–26, 31–37. Google Scholar

3.Andrew Parkin andJohn Warhurst, ed., Machine Politics in the Australian Labor Party(:George Allen and Unwin, 1983). In particular, see the following essays from that collection:Tom Wheelwright, “New South Wales: The Dominant Right,” 36;James Jupp, “Victoria: Left, Right and Centre,” 83,Wayne Swan, “Queensland: Labor’s Graveyard?,” 117;Geoff Stokes, “South Australia: Consensus Politics,” 137;Dean Jaensch, “Northern Territory: Idiosyncratic Politics,” 224–25;Richard Davis, “Tasmania: Premiers and Parochial Politics,” 200. Google Scholar

4.Marian Wilkinson, The Fixer: The Untold Story of Graham Richardson(:William Heinemann, 1996), 84, 87–89;Ross Fitzgerald andHarold Thornton, Labor in Queensland from the 1880s to 1988(:UQP, 1989), 212. Google Scholar

5.Thompson, Labor without Class;Evan Thornley, “Architecture of Renewal,”inComing to the Party: Where Next for Labor?, ed.Barry Jones(:Melbourne University Publishing, 2006), 153. Google Scholar

6.Tony Harris, “Basket Weavers and True Believers: The Middle Class Left and the ALP: Leichardt Municipality c1970–1990”(PhD diss.,University of New South Wales, 2002), 299. Google Scholar

7.For a particularly egregious example, see the editorial,“Labor: Bourgeois Left versus Union Thugs,” Quadrant 50, no. 4(April2006):2–4. Google Scholar

8.Kevin Gill, interview with author, Canberra, 12 June2012. Google Scholar

9.Eric Sparke, Canberra 1954–1980(:Australian Government Publishing Service, 1988), 145. Google Scholar

10.Scott, Fading Loyalties, 26–44;Ian Ward, “A ‘New Look’ ALP? The Middle Classing of the Victorian Branch of the ALP 1961–1982”(PhD Thesis,Monash University, April1987), 19. Google Scholar

11.Harris, “Basket Weavers,” iii;Ward, “A New Look ALP,” 19. Google Scholar

12.Harris, “Basket Weavers,” 13–14. Google Scholar

13.L. F. Crisp, “The Labor Party: Then and Now,”inLabor Essays 1982, eds.Gareth Evans andJohn Reeves(:Drummond Publishing, 1982), 70–73;Alan White, “Jim Fraser: A Private Member and His Constituency”(Bachelor of Letters thesis,Australian National University, 1983), 87, 89. Google Scholar

14.Chris Monnox, “ACT Advisory Council Elected Members 1930–1974,” ACT Heritage Library, accessed September 2014,http://www.library.act.gov.au/find/history/frequentlyaskedquestions/personal_stories/act_advisory_council,_1930–1974#ACT%20Advisory%20Council,%201930–1974;“Polling Today in ACT Elections,” Canberra Times, 22 September1951, 4;“Mr W. Byrne to Contest Council Poll,” Canberra Times, 12 August1953, 2;“Advisory Council Bid by Four Unionists,” Canberra Times, 16 July1964, 8;“A. D. Fraser Off Hospital Board Ticket,” Canberra Times, 3 August1964, 1. Google Scholar

15.News Item on ACT Electorate Council, 1957, in Papers of L. F. Crisp, MS 5243 (hereafter Crisp Papers), Box 42, National Library of Australia (NLA), Canberra;“Clerks Seek Cut in Union Fees,” Canberra Times, 31 August1956, 3. Google Scholar

17.White, “Jim Fraser,” 70–71;E. A. Lyall, “Local Issues and the Federal Member for the ACT”(seminar paper presented Australian National University, 3 November1970), 7–9, located in Crisp Papers, Box 49, NLA. Google Scholar

19.“Candidates Open Campaigns,” Canberra Times, 5 April1951, 4. Google Scholar

20.White, “Jim Fraser,” 75–76. Google Scholar

24.Ken Fry, A Humble Backbencher(:Ginninderra Press, 2002), 58. Google Scholar

25.Harris, “Basket Weavers,” 15. Google Scholar

26.Douglas Cole, “Challenge to Fraser for Labor Selection,” Canberra Times, 1 October1968, 1. Google Scholar

27.Ian MacDougall, Letter to the Editor, Canberra Times, 2 November1968, 2. Google Scholar

28.On the size of the Advisory Council, seeMonnox, “ACT Advisory Council Elected Members.”On the role of the Commonwealth in the administration of Canberra, seeSparke, Canberra, 189, 192. Google Scholar

29.Minutes of the 542ndMeeting of the ACT Advisory Council, Part 1, 19 September 1966, 2513–14; Minutes of the 542ndMeeting of the ACT Advisory Council, Part 4, 1 October 1966, 2671–72; Minutes of the 551stMeeting of the ACT Advisory Council, Part 3, 10 July 1967, 3561–70; all at NQ 994.7 AUS, NLA.“Abolish Hanging in the ACT!,” ACT Insight 2, no 1(1967):2. Google Scholar

30.“Calwell to Lead Anti-Ky Protest,” Canberra Times, 10 January1967, 1;“Calwell Applies for Protest Permit,” Canberra Times, 14 January1967, 3. Google Scholar

31.“NSW Police Accused of Brutality,” Canberra Times, 19 January1967, 1, 11;“Methods of NSW Police Backed,” Canberra Times, 20 January1967, 3. Google Scholar

32.Craddock Morton, Letter to the Editor, Woroni, 28 February1967, 2. Google Scholar

33.Minutes of the 546thMeeting of the ACT Advisory Council, Part 1, 31 January1967, 2994–3001. Google Scholar

34.Minutes of the 550thMeeting of the ACT Advisory Council, 23 May 1967, 3374–78; and J. D. Anthony to J. H. Pead, 13 June 1967, in Minutes of the 551stMeeting of the ACT Advisory Council, Part 1, 19 June1967. Google Scholar

35.“Votes Stacked,” Canberra Times, 29 October1968, 1. Google Scholar

36.The supporter was Professor Heinz Arndt; seeHeniz W. Arndt, “The ALP and Vietnam: A Different View,” Woroni, 25 April1966, 7. Google Scholar

37.Lyndall Ryan, Letter to the Editor, Canberra Times, 1 November1968, 2. Google Scholar

38.Megan Stoyles, Secretary’s Annual Report, Canberra Branch, Australian Labor Party, 1969, in Fraser Papers, Box 7, NLA. Google Scholar

39.Stephen Holt, “The Ideological War over Our First MP,” Canberra Times, 5 February2013, accessed September 2014,http://www.canberratimes.com.au/national/public-service/the-ideological-war-over-our-first-mp-20130202–2dqt4.html;Bruce Juddery, White Collar Power: A History of the ACOA(:George Allen and Unwin, 1980), 209–10, 216–17;Jim Gibbney, Canberra 1913–1953(:Australian Government Publishing Service, 1988), 160;Patrick Troy, interview with author, Canberra, 1 May2013. Google Scholar

40.S. G. Foster andMargaret Varghese, The Making of the Australian National University 1946–1996(:Allen and Unwin, 1996), 18, 65, 156–59, 173, 183, 197. Google Scholar

41.Ibid., 144, 149. Google Scholar

42.John Merritt, personal communication with author, 6 March 2014;Bob Whan, interview with author, Sydney, 26 April 2012;Gregory Clark, “Life Story,”chapter 4, 2005, Gregory Clark’s Web Site, accessed September 2014,http://gregoryclark.net/lifestory/page3/page3.html. Google Scholar

43.Commonwealth of Australia, Royal Commission on Australian Government Administration: Appendixes to Report, Volume 3(:Australian Government Publishing Service, 1976), 81, 90–91. Google Scholar

44.Paul Daley, Canberra(:UNSW Press, 2012), 281. Google Scholar

45.“Labor Branch Unhappy with ‘Uni Tag,’” Canberra Times, 30 October1968, 1;“Unions Act to Support Fraser,” Canberra Times, 4 November1968, 3. Google Scholar

46.Merritt, personal communication with author, 6 March2014. Google Scholar

47.Heinz W. Arndt, Letter to the Editor, Canberra Times, 1 November1968, 2;Heinz W. Arndt, A Course Through Life: Memoirs of an Australian Economist(:National Centre for Development Studies, 1985), 92. Google Scholar

49.John McFeat, Letter to the Editor, Canberra Times, 5 November1968, 2. Google Scholar

50.A Lindh, Letter to the Editor, Canberra Times, 18 November1968, 2. Google Scholar

51.Peter McCawley, Letter to the Editor, Canberra Times, 5 November1968, 2. Google Scholar

52.Peter Cantor, Letter to the Editor, Canberra Times, 6 November1968, 2. Google Scholar

53.“The Candidates,” Canberra Times, 3 September1964, 6;Ian Myerscough, “Mr Walsh ‘Unsure of his Future,’” Canberra Times, 6 January1977, 3;Seona Smiles, “The Surprise of a Candid Candidate,” Canberra Times, 6 September1967, 17. Google Scholar

55.J. P. O’Neill, 1966 Census Population and Housing, Volume 1, Part 1: Age(Bureau of Census and Statistics:, 1966), 19. Google Scholar

56.Official Voting List for Hospital Board and Advisory Council Pre-Selection, Canberra Branch, 5 July 1964;“Labor Branch Unhappy with ‘Uni Tag,’” Canberra Times, 30 October1968, 1. Google Scholar

58.White, “Jim Fraser,” 90. Google Scholar

59.Fry, A Humble Backbencher, 60; State Electorate Council Delegates lists 1967, 1968 and 1969 in Minutes of Annual Conferences 1966–1970 and State Congress 1971, [19]73 and [19]75, NSW ALP Records, MSS 5095, Item 525X, ML. Google Scholar

62.Ward, “A New Look ALP,” 238. Google Scholar

63.Scott, Fading Loyalties, 42;Ward, “A New Look ALP,” 48. Google Scholar

64.Harris, “Basket Weavers,” 70, 154, 300. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Monnox, Chris