Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

Labor and the Anzac Legend, 1915–45

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2014), 106, (1), 163–188.

Abstract

This article reconsiders the Australian Labor Party’s relationship with the so-called “Anzac Legend.” Examining the period between the first anniversary of the Gallipoli landings and World War II’s conclusion, it argues that ALP and mainstream union attitudes towards Anzac are more nuanced than historians have typically allowed. According to received historiographical wisdom, the conservative “hijack” of Australian nationalism during the latter stages of the Great War, in addition to the vicious Labor schism over conscription, meant that Labor found itself alienated from the “imperialist” legend for most of the inter-war period. Not until John Curtin heroically led the country through World War II, so the story goes, could Laborites identify with Anzac-style patriotism. Through a close reading of the speeches and writings of Labor politicians and publicists, I will stress Labor’s more complex relationship with Anzac, in turn problematising the simplistic “hijack” thesis.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

Footnotes

1.Westralian Worker, 4 May 1917, cited inJames Curran, Curtin’s Empire(:Cambridge University Press, 2011), 36. Google Scholar

2. Westralian Worker, 3 May1918. Google Scholar

3.Geoffrey Serle, “The Digger Tradition and Australian Nationalism,” Meanjin 24, no. 2(1965):156. Google Scholar

4.Russel Ward, A Nation for a Continent: The History of Australia 1901–1975(:Heinemann Educational Australia, 1977), 126–27. Google Scholar

5.Marilyn Lake, “The Power of Anzac,”inAustralia: Two Centuries of War and Peace, ed.Michael McKernanandMargaret Browne(:Australian War Memorial, 1988), 220–22. Google Scholar

6.Humphrey McQueen, Gallipoli to Petrov: Arguing with Australian History(:Allen & Unwin, 1984), 5;Humphrey McQueen, “Gallipoli’s Shadows,” Age, 25 April2003, accessed March 2014,http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2003/04/25/1050777403378.html. Google Scholar

7.Neville Kirk, “‘Australians for Australia’: The Right, the Labor Party and Contested Loyalties to Nation and Empire in Australia, 1917 to the Early 1930s,” Labour History, no. 91 (November2006):99–103. Google Scholar

8.Curran, Curtin’s Empire, 55 and, more generally, ch. 2. Google Scholar

9.Nick Dyrenfurth, Heroes and Villains: The Rise and Fall of the Early Australian Labor Party(:Australian Scholarly Publishing, 2011), chs 3–4. Google Scholar

10. Ibid.160–68and172. Google Scholar

11. Labor Call, 28 October1915. Google Scholar

12.Foreword byJay Winter, inKen Inglis, Sacred Places: War Memorials in the Australian Landscape(:Miegunyah Press, 2008), iv. Google Scholar

13.Dyrenfurth, Heroes and Villains, 183. Google Scholar

14.Alistair Thomson, Anzac Memories: Living with the Legend(:Oxford University Press, 1994), 7. Google Scholar

15. Daily Post, 28 April1916. Google Scholar

16.Carl Bridge, “Anzac Day,”inThe Oxford Companion to Australian Military History, ed.Peter Dennis,Jeffrey Grey,Ewan MorrisandRobin Prior, 2nd ed. (:Oxford University Press, 2008), accessed March 2014,www.oxfordreference.com. On Garland, seeJohn Moses, “The Struggle for Anzac Day, 1916–1930 and the Role of the Brisbane Anzac Day Commemoration Committee,” Journal of the Royal Australian Historical Society 88, no. 1(June2002):54–74. Google Scholar

17.Quoted inDavid Day, Andrew Fisher: Prime Minister of Australia(:Fourth Estate, 2008), 366. Google Scholar

18. Daily Post, 28 April1916. Google Scholar

19. Westralian Worker, 19 May1916. Google Scholar

20. Worker(Brisbane), 9 December1915. Google Scholar

21.Dyrenfurth, Heroes and Villains, 185–91. Google Scholar

23.Cited inL. C. Jauncey, The Story of Conscription in Australia(:Macmillan, 1968), 235. Google Scholar

24.Dennis Altman, “The Myth of Mateship,” Meanjin Quarterly 46, no. 2(June1987):169–70. Google Scholar

25. Age, 28 March1917. Google Scholar

26. Manifesto to the Electors of the Commonwealth of Australia(:Returned Soldiers No-Conscription League of Australia, Victorian Branch, 1916), accessed March 2014,http://www.reasoninrevolt.net.au/objects/pdf/a000405.pdf. Google Scholar

27. Worker(Brisbane), 5 October1916. Google Scholar

28. Daily Standard, 26 April1918. Google Scholar

29. Daily Post, 25 April1918. Google Scholar

30. Daily Standard, 25 April1917. Google Scholar

31. Worker(Brisbane), 16 May1918. Google Scholar

32.Kirk, “Australians for Australia,” 95–97. Google Scholar

33. Brisbane Courier, 17 December1917. Google Scholar

34.Quoted inJ. F. Williams, Anzacs, the Media and the Great War(:University of New South Wales Press, 1999), 25. Google Scholar

35.John Hirst, “The Pioneer Legend,” Australian Historical Studies 71(1978):216–17, 334. Google Scholar

36.Serle, “The Digger Tradition,” 156. Google Scholar

37. Herald(Melbourne), 25 April1925. Google Scholar

38.Martin Crotty, “The Returned Sailors’ and Soldiers’ Imperial League of Australia, 1916–1946,”inAnzac Legacies: Australians and the Aftermath of War, ed.Martin CrottyandMarina Larsson(:Australian Scholarly Publishing, 2010), 169and176. Google Scholar

39.Lake, “The Power of Anzac,” 203–4. Google Scholar

40.Peter Dennis,Jeffrey Grey,Ewan Morris,Robin Prior, andJean Bou, “Anzac Legend,”inDennis et al., The Oxford Companion to Australian Military History, accessed March2014,www.oxfordreference.com. Google Scholar

41. The Bayonet, 7 March1919. Google Scholar

42. Ibid., 17 April1919. Google Scholar

43.Crotty, “The Returned Sailors’ and Soldiers’ Imperial League,” 168. Google Scholar

44.John Rickard, Australia: A Cultural History, 2nd ed. (:Longman, 1996), 128. Google Scholar

45. Commonwealth Parliamentary Debates(House of Representatives) 3(1925), 2481. Google Scholar

46.SeePhillip DeeryandFrank Bongiorno, “Labor, Loyalty and Peace: Two Anzac Controversies of the 1920s,”in this collection. Google Scholar

47. Westralian Worker, 25 April1924. Google Scholar

48.Curran, Curtin’s Empire, 55. Google Scholar

49.Cited inIbid., 29. Google Scholar

50. Westralian Worker, 20 April1928. Google Scholar

51. Australian Worker, 26 April1922. Google Scholar

52. Ibid., 25 April1923. Google Scholar

53.Nick DyrenfurthandFrank Bongiorno, A Little History of the Australian Labor Party(:University of New South Wales Press, 2011), 76–84. Google Scholar

54. Canberra Times, 27 April1932. Google Scholar

55. Sydney Morning Herald(SMH), 25 April1930. Google Scholar

56. SMH, 25 April1931. Google Scholar

57. Australian Worker, 7 May1930. Google Scholar

58. SMH, 14 April1931. Google Scholar

59. Labor Daily, 25 April1931. Google Scholar

60. Ibid., 25 April1932. Google Scholar

61. Westralian Worker, 21 April1933. Google Scholar

62. Ibid., 24 April1931. Google Scholar

63. Worker(Brisbane), 10 May1933. Google Scholar

64. Ibid., 25 April1939. Google Scholar

65. Courier-Mail(Brisbane), 7 August1937. Google Scholar

66.Geoffrey Bolton, The Oxford History of Australia, Volume 5, 1942–1995(:Oxford University Press, 1996), 7;Joan Beaumont, “War, Memory and National Identity in Australia,”inMemory, Identity and Historiography, ed.Estevão Chaves de Rezende Martins(:Textos de Historia, 2004), 42. Google Scholar

67.DyrenfurthandBongiorno, A Little History, 91–93. Google Scholar

68. Ibid., 94. Google Scholar

69. Canberra Times, 2 July1943. Google Scholar

70.Richard White, Inventing Australia: Images and Identity, 1788–1980(:Allen and Unwin, 1981), 153. Google Scholar

71. Westralian Worker, 5 December1941. Google Scholar

72. SMH, 24 April1943. Google Scholar

73.Dennis et al., “Anzac Legend.” Google Scholar

74.Cited in KenInglis, “TheAnzac Tradition,” Meanjin 24(1965), 43. Google Scholar

75. Age, 25 April1943. Google Scholar

76.John Curtin, “Anzac Day Message,”25 April1945, Prime Ministerial Library, Records of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation, JCPML00408/15, accessed March 2014,http://john.curtin.edu.au/audio/00408_15web.html. Google Scholar

77. West Australian, 26 July1941. Google Scholar

78. Age, 25 April1942. Google Scholar

79.John Curtin, “Speech to America,”14 March1942, JCPML00434/1, Prime Ministerial Library, Records of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation, accessed March 2014,http://john.curtin.edu.au/audio/00434.html. Google Scholar

80.DyrenfurthandBongiorno, A Little History, 96. Google Scholar

81. Worker(Brisbane), 9 August1945. Google Scholar

82.Geoffrey Serle, “Curtin, John (1885–1945),” Australian Dictionary of Biography,National Centre of Biography, Australian National University, accessed March2014,http://adbonline.anu.edu.au/biogs/A130616b.htm. Google Scholar

83.John Hirst, Looking for Australia: Historical Essays(:Black Inc., 2010), 196. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Dyrenfurth, Nick