Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

‘Conscription is Not Abhorrent to Laborites and Socialists’: Revisiting the Australian Labour Movement’s Attitude towards Military Conscription during World War I

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2012), 103, (1), 145–164.

Abstract

Historical accounts of the 1916-17 conscription referendums have tended to portray the Australian labour movement’s anti-conscriptionism as a natural phenomenon. Prime Minister Billy Hughes and other Laborite pro-conscriptionists were ‘rats’ who had acted against the anti-militaristic creed of the working class and its major political representative, the Australian Labor Party (ALP). By contrast, this article builds upon recent work in the field to suggest that labour movement opposition to conscription was not some fait accomplit. Drawing upon contemporary labour movement newspaper writings, union and ALP conference proceedings and, in particular, the views of the Victorian-based federal Labor MP, Frank Anstey, it argues that the labour movement was not in theory opposed to conscription. Rather the movement objected to a form of conscription which applied to human life but excluded the nation’s wealth. In turn, the article questions the inevitability of the disastrous Labor split which followed the holding of the first referendum.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Endnotes

1.Ross McMullin, The Light on the Hill: The Australian Labor Party, 1891-1991,Oxford University Press,, 1992, p.92;Ian Turner, Industrial Labour and Politics: The Dynamics of the Labour Movement in Eastern Australia, 1900-1921,Hale and Iremonger,, 1979, pp.70-71;D.W. Rawson, Labor in Vain? A Survey of the Australian Labor Party,Longmans,, 1966, p.103. Google Scholar

2. Argus, 1August1914. Google Scholar

4.Vere Gordon Childe, How Labour Governs: A Study of Workers’ Representation in Australia, 2nded.,Melbourne University Press,, [1923]1964, pp.48, 52. Google Scholar

5.Maurice Blackburn, The Conscription Referendum of 1916,Anti-Conscription Celebration League,, 1936, p.10. See alsoLeslie Jauncey’s The Story of Conscription in Australia,G. Allen & Unwin,, 1935. Google Scholar

6.Russel Ward, A Nation for a Continent: The History of Australia, 1901-1975,Heinemann Educational Australia,, 1977, p.111;Humphrey McQueen, A New Britannia: An Argument Concerning the Social Origins of Australian Radicalism and Nationalism,Penguin Books,, 1970, pp.38-39;Stuart Macintyre, The Oxford History of Australia, Volume 4, 1901-1942: The Succeeding Age,Oxford University Press,, 1986, p.161. Google Scholar

7.Terry Irving, ‘Labour, State and Nation Building in Australia’, inStefan Berger andAngel Smith(eds), Nationalism, Labour and Ethnicity 1870-1939,Manchester University Press,, 2003, p.206;John Hirst, ‘Australian Defence and Conscription: A Reassessment’, Australian Historical Studies, vol.25, no.101, October1993, pp.608-27; andJohn Hirst, ‘Labor and the Great War’, inRobert Manne(ed.), Australian Century: Political Struggle in the Building of a Nation,Text Publishing,, 1999, pp.53, 55-56. I will refer to the latter source. In a similar vein to Irving, seeRawson, Labor in Vain?p.15. Google Scholar

8. Labor Call, 28December1915. Google Scholar

9. Argus, 1August1914.There is simply no evidence to sustain John Hirst’s claim that Hughes mechanically fed this quote to Fisher; seeHirst, ‘Labor and the Great War’, pp.48-49. Google Scholar

10.Edward Humphreys, Andrew Fisher: A Forgotten Man,Sports and Editorial Services,, 2008, p.63. Google Scholar

11. Argus, 5August1914; cited inMcMullin, The Light on the Hill, p.93. Google Scholar

12.Cited inFrank Farrell, The Fractured Society: Australia during the Great War,CCH Australia,, 1985, p.8. Google Scholar

13.Cited inL.F. Fitzhardinghe, The Little Digger: A Political Biography of William Morris Hughes, Volume 2,Angus&, 1979, p.5;‘Manifesto of the Australian Labor Party, 1914’, cited inWorker(), 13August1914;Worker(), 13August1914. Google Scholar

14. Worker(), 10September1914;Worker(), 13August1914. Google Scholar

15.Hirst, ‘Labor and the Great War’, p.50. Google Scholar

16. Labor Call, 27August1914. Google Scholar

17. Worker(), 13August1914. Google Scholar

18.Ibid. Google Scholar

19. Australian Worker, 13August1914. Google Scholar

20. The Age, 8July1914. Google Scholar

21. Westralian Worker, 28August1914. Google Scholar

22. Worker(), 6August1914. Google Scholar

23. Labor Call, 13August1914. Google Scholar

24.Ibid. Google Scholar

25.Ibid., 6August1914. Google Scholar

26. Worker(), 27August1914. Google Scholar

27.Ibid., 13August1914. Google Scholar

28. Westralian Worker, 21September1914. Google Scholar

29.Geoffrey Sawer, Australian Federal Politics and Law 1901-1919,Melbourne University Press,, 1972, p.128. Google Scholar

30. Labor Call, 10September1914. Google Scholar

31. Australian Worker, 17September1914;Labor Call, 6August1914. Google Scholar

32. Australian Worker, 1October1914;Ibid., 6August1914. Google Scholar

33.Ernest Scott, Australia during the War,Angus&, 1938, p.660;E.J, Holloway, The Australian Victory over Conscription,Anti-Conscription Jubilee Committee,, 1966, p.3. Google Scholar

34.John Murdoch, A Million to One Against: A Portrait of Andrew Fisher,Minerva Press,, 1998, p.85. Google Scholar

35.Marnie Haig-Muir, ‘The Economy at War’, inJoan Beaumont(ed.), Australia’s War 1914-1918,Allen&, 1995, p.109;Stuart Macintyre, A Concise History of Australia,Cambridge University Press,, 1999, pp.161-63;McMullin, Light on the Hill, pp.100-101. Google Scholar

36.SeeNick Dyrenfurth, Heroes and Villains: The Rise and Fall of the Early Australian Labor Party,Australian Scholarly Publishing,, 2011, chs 3 and 4. Google Scholar

37. Sydney Morning Herald, 1December1915; quoted inR.P. Davis, Eighty Years’ Labor: The ALP in Tasmania, 1903-1983,Sassafras Books,, 1983, p.11. Google Scholar

38. Labor Call, 25March1915;Commonwealth Parliamentary Debates (CPD), 14October1914, 75:147. Google Scholar

39.Cited inHirst, ‘Labor and the Great War’, p.55. Anstey’s articles during 1915 were turned intoLabor Callpamphlets such as the anti-Semitic ‘The Kingdom of Shylock’, revised and expanded into a book of the same title in 1917, and finally as a larger volumeMoney Powerin 1921sansanti-Semitism. Google Scholar

40. CPD, 29April1915, 76: 2766. Google Scholar

41. Labor Call, 13May1915. Google Scholar

42. CPD, 3June1915, 77:3667. Google Scholar

43.Bronwyn Stevens andPatrick Weller, The Australian Labor Party and Federal Politics: A Documentary Survey,Melbourne University Press,, 1976, p.76;Official Report of the Sixth Commonwealth Conference of the Australian Labor Party, Adelaide, 31 May 1915,Worker Trade Union Printery, 1915, pp.30, 31-34. Google Scholar

44.Cited inTurner, Industrial Labour and Politics, p.97. Google Scholar

45. Labor Call, 14October1915. Google Scholar

46. Australian Worker, 4November1915. Google Scholar

47.Cited inStevens andWeller, The Australian Labor Party and Federal Politics, p.28. Google Scholar

48. Sixth Commonwealth Conference of the Australian Labor Party, pp.10, 11. Google Scholar

49.Cited inLabor Call, 12April1917. Google Scholar

50. Worker(), 4November1915;Labor Call, 22July1915. Google Scholar

51.Cited inRoss McMullin, ‘Leading the World’, inJohn Faulkner andStuart Macintyre(eds), True Believers: The Story of the Federal Parliamentary Labor Party,Allen&, 2001, p.101. Google Scholar

52.Cited inPeter Love,Frank Anstey: A Political Biography, unpublishedPhD thesis,Australian National University, 1990, p.272;Labor Call, 2December1915and13January1916. Google Scholar

53. Labor Call, 2December1915;Australian Worker, 16December1915. Revealingly, whilst Hughes was later overseas visiting Britain and France, Pearce, as Acting Prime Minister, used theWar Precautions Actto impose price controls on flour and bread in March 1916 and, in July 1916, created the Necessary Commodities Commission with commissioners in each state empowered to impose price controls on any items. SeeJohn Connor, Anzac and Empire: George Foster Pearce and the Foundations of Australian Defence,Cambridge University Press, 2011, p.78. Google Scholar

54.L.F. Crisp, The Australian Federal Labour Party: 1901-1951,Longmans,, 1955, p.56. Google Scholar

55.Cited inHirst, ‘Labor and the Great War’, pp.58-59. Google Scholar

56.Carl Bridge, William Hughes: Australia: Peace Conferences of 1919-23 and Their Aftermath,Haus Publishing,, 2011, pp.61-64;Ward, A Nation for a Continent, p.111. Google Scholar

57. Australian Worker, 3August1916. Google Scholar

58.Blackburn, The Conscription Referendum of 1916, p.12. Google Scholar

59.Cited inAustralian Worker, 3February1916. Google Scholar

60.Bobbie Oliver, War and Peace in Western Australia: The Social and Political Impact of the Great War, 1914—1926,University of Western Australia Press,, 1995, p.93. Google Scholar

61.Cited inLabor Call, 4January1917; cited inCrisp, Australian Federal Labour Party, p.135. SeeRawson, Labor in Vain, p.36. Google Scholar

62.K.S. Inglis, ‘Conscription in Peace and War, 1911-1945’, inRoy Forward andBob Reece(eds), Conscription in Australia,University of Queensland Press,, 1968, pp.27-28. The European population of the then British colony of Natal were likewise compelled; seeConnor, Anzac and Empire, p.27. Google Scholar

63.‘Appeal To All Who Love Liberty’, Executive Committee of Queensland Labor, cited inWorker(), 21September1916(emphasis in original). Google Scholar

64. Australian Worker, 11May1916. For Labor’s arguments against conscription, seeNick Dyrenfurth andFrank Bongiorno, A Little History of the Australian Labor Party,University of New South Wales Press,, 2011, pp.63-64. Google Scholar

65. CPD, 8July1915, 77:4716. Google Scholar

66. CPD, 18May1916, 79: 8010. Google Scholar

67.Love,Frank Anstey, p.288. Google Scholar

68.Cited inLove,Frank Anstey, pp.278-79, 303. Google Scholar

69.D.J. Murphy, ‘Queensland’, inD.J. Murphy(ed.), Labor in Politics: The State Labor Parties in Australia, 1880-1920,University of Queensland Press,, 1975, p.193. Google Scholar

70.Peter Love, Labour and the Money Power: Australian Labour Populism 1890-1950,Melbourne University Press,, 1984, p.70. Google Scholar

71. Australian Worker, 27January1916. Google Scholar

72. Official Report of the Queensland Branch of the Australian Workers’ Union Third Annual Delegate Meeting, Brisbane, January 1916,Worker Newspaper,, 1916. Google Scholar

73. Australian Trade Unionism and Conscription, Report of Proceedings of the Australian Trade Union Congress,Labor Call Print,, 1916, Riley and Ephemera Collection, State Library of Victoria, pp.4, 12-13. Google Scholar

74. Labor Call, 4May1916. Google Scholar

75. Australian Worker, 4May1916. Google Scholar

76.H.J. Gibbney, ‘Western Australia’, inMurphy(ed.), Labor in Politics, p.369. Google Scholar

77.Triennial Congress of the West Australian Division of the Australian Labour Federation, 31May,, cited inWest Australian, 2June1916. Google Scholar

78. Daily Post, 28July1916. Google Scholar

79.Marilyn Lake, A Divided Society: Tasmania during World War One,Melbourne University Press,, 1975, p.65. Google Scholar

80. Labor Call, 7September1916. In 1916 he was General Secretary of Trades Hall, president of both the Victorian PLC and the ALP federal executive, as well as founding secretary of the national anticonscription executive. Google Scholar

81. Worker(), 10February1916;Ibid., 27April1916. Google Scholar

82.Ibid., 11May1916. Google Scholar

83.Ibid., 7September1916. Google Scholar

84. Australian Worker, 13January1916. Google Scholar

85.Ibid., 10August1916;Ibid., 9March1916. Google Scholar

86. Worker(), 26October1916. Google Scholar

87.Claude Marquet, ‘The Glorious 28th’, Australian Worker, 2November1916. Google Scholar

88.Cited inNeville Kirk, ‘“Australians for Australia”: The Right, the Labor Party and Contested Loyalties to Nation and Empire in Australia, 1917 to the Early 1930s’, Labour History, no.91, November2006, pp.99-100. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Dyrenfurth, Nick