Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

Marxism for Beginner Nations: Radical Nationalist Historians and the Great War

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2012), 103, (1), 123–144.

Abstract

In 1965 Ken Inglis published a provocative article in Meanjin, in which he challenged historians to give greater consideration to World War I and, in particular, the work of its official historian, Charles Bean. Inglis suggested that his Marxist colleagues were uncomfortable with Great War history because the imperial loyalty of the diggers was contrary to their assumptions about the radicalism of the working class. There was, however, one element of Great War history from which radical historians drew ideological comfort: Inglis believed that historians of the Left had portrayed the conscription debate inaccurately as a battle between an anti-war and anti-British proletariat and a militarist bourgeoisie. This article tests the veracity of Inglis’ claims by examining the work of four historians commonly associated with the radical nationalist movement: Brian Fitzpatrick, Russel Ward, Ian Turner and Geoffrey Serle. It considers how the Great Depression, the rise of the popular front against fascism and (in the case of the last three) service in World War II shaped these men’s approaches to memorialising war and writing history. The paper shows how the radical historians came increasingly to view World War I as the wrecking ball of their socialist dream.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Endnotes

1.K.S. Inglis, ‘The Anzac Tradition’, Meanjin Quarterly, March1965, p.34. Google Scholar

2.Ibid., p.35. Google Scholar

3.Publications such asMarilyn Lake,Henry Reynolds,Mark McKenna,Joy Damousi andCarina Donaldson, What’s Wrong with Anzac? The Militarisation of Australian History,, 2010;Peter Stanley, Bad Characters: Sex, Crime, Mutiny and Murder and the Australian Imperial Force,, 2010;Ross McMullin, ‘Farewell, Dear People’: Biographies of Australia’s Lost Generation,Scribe,, 2012. Google Scholar

4.Neville Meaney, ‘Britishness and Australian Identity: The Problem of Nationalism in Australian History and Historiography’, Australian Historical Studies, vol.32, no. 116, p.84;M. McKernan andM. Browne(eds), Australia: Two Centuries of War and Peace,Australian War Memorial/Allenand, 1988, pp.16-17. Google Scholar

5.McKernan andBrowne(eds), Australia, p.16. Google Scholar

6.Frank Bongiorno andGrant Mansfield, ‘Whose War was It Anyway? Some Australian Historians and the Great War’, History Compass, vol.6, no.1, 2008, p.64. Google Scholar

7.Ernest Scott, A Short History of Australia,Oxford University Press,, 1916. Google Scholar

8.In 1937 there were 12 teachers of history in the six Australian universities. By 1964 there were 150 university historians and in 1971, 750 historians were employed in tertiary institutions;McKernan andBrowne, Australia, p.18. Google Scholar

9.Robin Gollan, Radical and Working Class Politics: A Study of Eastern Australia, 1850-1910,Melbourne University Press,, 1960, pp.111-12;Luke Trainor, British Imperialism and Australian Nationalism: Manipulation, Conflict, and Compromise in the Late Nineteenth Century,Cambridge University Press,, 1994. Google Scholar

10.Don Watson, Brian Fitzpatrick: A Radical Life,Hale and Iremonger,, 1979, p.5. Google Scholar

11.Sheila Fitzpatrick, My Father’s Daughter,Melbourne University Press,, 2010, p.10. Google Scholar

12.Brian Fitzpatrick, The Colonials, unpublished manuscript, quoted inWatson, Brian Fitzpatrick, p.6. Google Scholar

13. Outlook, August1964, p.13, quoted byIan Turner, ‘Introduction’, inBrian Fitzpatrick, A Short History of the Australian Labour Movement, 2ndedn,Macmillan,, 1968, p.2. Google Scholar

14.Fitzpatrick, My Father’s Daughter, p.10. Google Scholar

15.Fitzpatrick described himself later toH.V. Evatt as a‘feeble molly-dook’in all sport;Watson, Brian Fitzpatrick, pp.7, 10. Google Scholar

16.Fitzpatrick, My Father’s Daughter, p.11. Google Scholar

17.Turner, ‘Introduction’, inFitzpatrick, A Short History, p.4. Google Scholar

18.Fitzpatrick, My Father’s Daughter, p.11. Google Scholar

19.Ibid., p.12. Google Scholar

20.Watson, Brian Fitzpatrick, p.9. Google Scholar

21.Fitzpatrick, My Father’s Daughter, p.13. Google Scholar

22.Brian Fitzpatrick, The British Empire in Australia: An Economic History, 1834-1939, 3rdedn,Macmillan,, 1969, p.348. Google Scholar

23.Geoffrey Blainey, ‘Foreword’, inFitzpatrick, The British Empire, p.vii. Google Scholar

24.Ian Turner, ‘Australian Nationalism and Australian History’,Leonie Sandercock andStephen Murray-Smith(eds), Room for Manoeuvre: Writings on History, Politics, Ideas and Play,Drummond,, 1992, p.10. Google Scholar

25.Blainey, ‘Foreword’, inFitzpatrick, The British Empire, p.vii. Google Scholar

26.Fitzpatrick, The British Empire, p.271. Google Scholar

27.Brian Fitzpatrick, The Australian People: 1788-1945,Melbourne University Press,, 1951, p.237. Google Scholar

28.Brian Fitzpatrick, The Australian Commonwealth: A Picture of the Community, 1901-1955,Cheshire,, 1956, p.209. Google Scholar

29.Geoffrey Serle, From Deserts the Prophets Come: The Creative Spirit in Australia, 1788-1972,William Heinemann,, 1973, p.177. Google Scholar

30.Russel Ward, A Radical Life,Macmillan,, 1988, p.147. Google Scholar

31.Janet McCalman, Journeyings: The Biography of a Middle-Class Generation, 1920-1990,Melbourne University Press,, 1993, p.178. Google Scholar

32.Ward, A Radical Life, p.54. Google Scholar

33.Ibid, p.207. Google Scholar

34.Ibid. Google Scholar

35.Ibid., p.195. Google Scholar

36.Russel Ward, The Australian Legend,Oxford University Press,, 1974, p.226. Google Scholar

37.Ward, A Radical Life, pp.233-34. Google Scholar

38.Ward, The Australian Legend, p.231. Google Scholar

39.Ibid., p.230. Google Scholar

40.Ibid. Google Scholar

41.Ibid., p.233. Google Scholar

42.Alan Atkinson, ‘A Great Historian?’, inCarl Bridge(ed.), Manning Clark: Essays on his Place in History,Melbourne University Press,, 1994, p.122. Google Scholar

43.Russel Ward, A Nation for a Continent: The History of Australia 1901-1975,Heinemann Education Australia,, rev. edn, 1983, p.126. Google Scholar

44.Ibid., p.127. Google Scholar

45.Ibid., p.104. Google Scholar

46.Ibid., p.127. Google Scholar

47.Ibid. Google Scholar

48.Ibid. Google Scholar

49.Stuart Macintyre, A Concise History of Australia, 3rdedn,Cambridge University Press,, 2009, p.131. Google Scholar

50.Ken Inglis, ‘Remembering Anzac’, an address delivered at the University of Melbourne 18 April 1996, published inJohn Lack(ed.), Remembering Anzac: Selected Writings of K.S. Inglis,History Department, University of Melbourne,, 1998, pp.228-47. Google Scholar

51.Inglis, ‘Remembering Anzac’, p.230. Google Scholar

52.Ibid., p.231. Google Scholar

53.Amirah Inglis, The Hammer and Sickle and the Washing Up: Memories of an Australian Woman Communist,Hyland House,, 1995, p.16. Google Scholar

54.Inglis, The Hammer, p.17;, Journeyings, p.208. Google Scholar

55.Ibid., p.6. Google Scholar

56.Turner, ‘My Long March’, inSandercock andMurray-Smith(eds), Room for Manoeuvre, p.106.Amirah Inglis describedIan Turner‘s parents as‘mismatched’inThe Hammer, p.41. Google Scholar

57.Inglis, The Hammer, p.116. Turner’s father Frank cut Ian out of his will. Google Scholar

58.Turner, ‘My Long March’, p.115. Google Scholar

59.Ibid., p.119. Google Scholar

60.Ibid., p.117. Google Scholar

61.Turner, ‘Australian Nationalism’, p.10. Google Scholar

62.Turner, ‘Temper Democratic, Bias Australian’, inSandercock andMurray-Smith(eds), Room for Manoeuvre, p.164. Google Scholar

63.Turner, ‘My Long March’, p.122. Google Scholar

64.Ibid., p.131. Google Scholar

65.Ibid. Google Scholar

66.Ibid., p.132. Google Scholar

67.Ibid., p.143. Google Scholar

68.John McLaren, Free Radicals: Of the Left in Postwar Melbourne,Australian Scholarly Publishing,, 2003, p.151. Google Scholar

69.Ian Turner, Industrial Labour and Politics: The Dynamics of the Labour Movement in Eastern Australia, 1900-1921, 2ndedn,Hale and Iremonger,, 1979, p.xvii. Google Scholar

70.Ian Turner, ‘Socialist History and the Socialist Historian’, inSandercock andMurray-Smith(eds), Room for Manoeuvre, p.273. Google Scholar

71.Ibid., p.180. Google Scholar

72.Ibid. Google Scholar

73.Turner, Industrial Labour, introduction to 2ndedn, p.xxiv. Google Scholar

74.Ibid., p.xxi. Google Scholar

75.Ian Turner(ed.), The Australian Dream: A Collection of Anticipations about Australia from Captain Cook to the Present Day,Sun Books,, 1968, p.xix. The book is dedicated to Manning Clark ‘who taught me and many others that knowledge comes from doubt, and love from understanding’. Google Scholar

76.Ibid. Google Scholar

77.Ibid. Google Scholar

78.C.E.W. Bean, In Your Hands, Australians, extract printed inTurner(ed.), The Australian Dream, p.284. Google Scholar

79.Turner, ‘Australian Nationalism’, p.6. Google Scholar

80.Ibid. Google Scholar

81.Ibid.;Turner(ed.), The Australian Dream, p.xviii. Google Scholar

82.Ian Turner, ‘1914-1919’,F.K. Crowley, (ed.), A New History of Australia,William Heinemann,, 1974, p.323. Google Scholar

83.Ibid., p.352. Google Scholar

84.Inglis, ‘The Anzac Tradition’, p.35. Google Scholar

85.Ibid. Google Scholar

86.Ibid. Google Scholar

87.Bean, In Your Hands, Australians, extract printed inTurner(ed.), The Australian Dream, p.283. Google Scholar

88.C.J. Dennis, Digger Smith, quoted inTurner, ‘1914-1919‘, p.156. Google Scholar

89.Turner, ‘Temper Democratic’, p.157. Google Scholar

90.Inglis, ‘The Anzac Tradition’, p.41. Google Scholar

91.Ibid. Google Scholar

92.Stephen Murray-Smith in Hume Dow (ed.), Memories of Melbourne University: Undergraduate Life in the Years Since 1917,Hutchinson,, 1983, p.123. Google Scholar

93.Inglis, ‘The Anzac Tradition’, p.31. Google Scholar

94.Ken Inglis, ‘Return to Gallipoli’, inLack(ed.), Remembering Anzac, p.48. Google Scholar

95.Alan Seymour, The One Day of the Year,Angus and Robertson,, 1993, p.77. Google Scholar

96.Craig Wilcox, introduction toK.S. Inglis, Observing Australia: 1959-1999,Melbourne University Press,, 1999, p.3. Google Scholar

97.Interview with author, December2010. Google Scholar

98.Wilcox, introduction toInglis, Observing Australia, p.5. Google Scholar

99.Lack(ed.), Remembering Anzac, Preface, p.3. Google Scholar

100.Inglis, ‘The Anzac Tradition’, p.44. Google Scholar

101.Serle, From Deserts the Prophets Come, p.xii. Google Scholar

102.Geoffrey Serle, ‘Austerica Unlimited?’, Meanjin Quarterly, vol.26, no.3, 1967, p.21, quoted inJohn Thompson, The Patrician and the Bloke: Geoffrey Serle and the Making of Australian History,Pandanus Books,, 2006. Google Scholar

103.Geoffrey Serle, Robin Boyd: A Life,Melbourne University Press,, 1995, p.77. Google Scholar

104.McCalman, Journeyings, p.223. Google Scholar

105.Ibid. Google Scholar

106.Thompson, The Patrician, pp.98-101. Google Scholar

107.McCalman, Journeyings, p.223. Google Scholar

108.Manning Clark, The Quest for Grace,Penguin,, 1990, pp.149, 165. Google Scholar

109.Geoffrey Serle, ‘Autobiographical Notes’, quoted inThompson, The Patrician, p.17. Google Scholar

110.Geoffrey Serle, ‘The Digger Tradition and Australian Nationalism’, Meanjin, vol.24, no.2, June1965, p.149. Google Scholar

111.Ibid., pp.155, 152. Google Scholar

112.Ibid., p.156. Google Scholar

113.Ibid. Google Scholar

114.Ibid., p.158. Google Scholar

115.Ibid. Google Scholar

116.Inglis, ‘The Anzac Tradition’. Google Scholar

117.Turner, ‘Temper Democratic’, p.157. Google Scholar

118.Lake,Reynolds,McKenna,Damousi andDonaldson, What’s Wrong with Anzac? Google Scholar

119.Turner, The Australian Dream, p.xvii. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Holbrook, Carolyn