Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

Doing Without the Boss: Workers’ Control Experiments in Australia in the 1970s

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2012), 103, (1), 103–122.

Abstract

Experiments with workers’ control occurred in many countries during the late post-war boom period in circumstances of heightened industrial militancy and a crisis in employer and state authority. They are again popular under different conditions, especially in Argentina and Venezuela. Such episodes demonstrate that labour can exist without capital, whereas capital is always dependent on labour. This essential autonomy of labour from capital is a notion elaborated most cogently by ‘autonomist’ Marxists, especially Antonio Negri. His concepts of autonomy, self-valorisation and political crisis are used to describe and analyse Australian workers’ control experiments during the 1970s, focusing especially on the Sydney Opera House work-in of April-May 1972, the Whyalla Glove Factory occupation of November 1972 and formation of a workers’ co-operative that lasted until September 1973, and the Nymboida mine work-in and takeover under workers’ and union control from February 1975 to August 1979.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Endnotes

1.Pete Thomas, The Mine the Workers Ran: The 1975-79 Success Story at Nymboida,Australian Coal & Shale Employees Federation,, 1979, p.36. Google Scholar

3.Andrée Hoyles, Imagination in Power: The Occupation of Factories in France in 1968,Spokesman Books,, 1973;Dave Sherry, Occupy! A Short History of Workers’ Occupations,Bookmarks Publications,, 2010, esp. pp.99-99. Google Scholar

4.Paulo Spriano, The Occupation of the Factories: Italy 1920,Pluto Press,, 1975;Gwyn A. Williams, Proletarian Order: Antonio Gramsci, Factory Councils and the Origins of Italian Communism, 1911-1921,Pluto Press,, 1975;Martin Clark, ,Yale University Press,, 1977. Google Scholar

5.Ken Coates, Work-Ins, Sit-Ins and Industrial Democracy,Spokesman Books,, 1981;Ken Coates(ed.), The New Worker Co-operatives,Spokesman Books,, 1976;John Foster andCharles Woolfson, The Politics of the UCS Work-In: Class Alliances and the Right to Work,Lawrence & Wishart,, 1986;Hilary Wainwright andDave Elliott, The Lucas Plan: A New Trade Unionism in the Making?,Allison and Busby,, 1982;Tony Eccles, Under New Management: The Story of Britain’s Largest Worker Co-operative: Its Successes and Failures,Pan Books,, 1981;Ralph Darlington andDave Lyddon, Glorious Summer: Class Struggle in Britain 1972,Bookmarks,, 2001;Sherry, Occupy!, pp.113-28. Google Scholar

6.Colin Crouch, Class Conflict and the Industrial Relations Crisis: Compromise and Corporatism in the Policies of the British State,Humanities Press,, 1977. See alsoAlwyn W. Turner, Crisis? What Crisis? Britain in the 1970s,Aurum Press,, 2008. Google Scholar

7.See, for example, Laval Collective, Sin Patrón: Stories from Argentina’s Worker-Run Factories, Haymarket Books, 2007. The Call for Papers for a Special Interest Stream in‘Alternative Work Organisations’at the 28th Annual International Labour Process Conference at Rutgers University, 15-17 March 2010, stated that, in the labour movement’s history, one of the forms in which the dominating system has been contested has been through workers’ run and controlled production. ‘Defined as workers self-management orautogestion, to use the more catchy Spanish definition, different forms of workers‘ empowerment at the level of production have been used in different geographical contexts alongside the history of the capitalist system of production’. Google Scholar

8.Drew Cottle andAngela Keys, ‘The 1971 Harco “Stay-Put”: Workers’ Control in One Factory?’, The Hummer, vol.4, no. 1, Summer2003-04, pp.40-40. See alsoLloyd Caldwell andMick Tubbs, The Harco Work-In: An Experience of Workers’ Control,A National Workers’ Control Conference Publication (roneod),, February1973. Google Scholar

9. Sydney Morning Herald, 6May1972, p.2;12May1972, p.1. Google Scholar

10. Wyong News, 8May, 15May, 29May, 5June, 26June, 28August1974;Newcastle Morning Herald, 3-18May1974;Wyong Advocate, 15May, 26June1974;Gosford Star, 22May, 29May;Gosford Central Coast Express, 8May, 15May, 29May1974;‘Building Workers Demand the Right to Work’, leaflet, no date (c.May1974), authorised by the locked-out workers from Miruzzi South Seas;‘Why Wyong Workers Work-In’, poster authorised by Joe Owens and Bob Pringle on behalf of the NSW Builders Labourers Federation, Federated Engine Drivers and Firemens Association of Australasia (FEDFA), Central Coast Labor Council;Scrounge, 31May-14June1974, pp.9-12;FED News, Supplement, 17May1974, authorised by Jack Cambourn, Secretary FEDFA; Meredith Burgmann and Verity Burgmann, Green Bans, Red Union: Environmental Activism and the New South Wales Builders Labourers’ Federation,UNSW Press,, pp.101-2. Google Scholar

11. Common Cause, 15Sept1975, p.3. Google Scholar

12.Ibid., 1Sept1975, pp. 1, 4. Google Scholar

13.Anon, ‘The Sanyo Work In’, Australian Left Review, no. 66, September1978, pp.26-30;J.A. Dalton,The Work-In/Sit-In: The Occupation as a Form of I Relations Post-Graduates’ Conference,University of Melbourne,12 November 1980, in possession of the authors, pp.15-27. Google Scholar

14.Dalton, The Work-In/Sit-In, pp.28-29. Google Scholar

15.Steve Prytz, unpublished manuscript in possession of the authors;Gary Nicholls, unpublished manuscript in possession of the authors;Grey Collar: Bulletin of the Public Servants’ Action Group, vol.2, no. 2August-September1981, vol.2, no. 5, June1982;Jim Peace, ‘Social Security: Some Bad, Some Not So Bad’, ACOA, Jan-February1982, pp.3-4;ACOA, Bulletins, various dates1981;Grey Collar, The Fight for Jobs: Social Security 1981,Public Servants Action Group,, no date (c.1982). Google Scholar

16.Dalton, The Work-In/Sit-In, p.i. Google Scholar

17.Ibid., pp.28-29. Google Scholar

18. Direct Action, 25October1979, quoted inDalton, The Work-In/Sit-In, p.29. Google Scholar

20.Steve Wright, ‘Mapping Pathways within Italian Autonomist Marxism: A Preliminary Survey’, Historical Materialism, vol.16, no. 4, 2008, p.113;Toni Negri et al.,‘Do You Remember Revolution? A Proposal for an Interpretation of the Italian Movement in the 1970s’, inNegri, Revolution Retrieved, pp.236-37. Google Scholar

21. Australian, 2April1972. Google Scholar

23.John Wallace andJoe Owens, Workers Call the Tune at Opera House,booklet produced by National Workers Control Conference,, 1973. Google Scholar

24.Ibid., p.3. Google Scholar

25.Ibid., p.5. Google Scholar

26.Negri, ‘Keynes’, p.13. Google Scholar

27.Wallace and Owens, Workers Call the Tune at Opera House, p.5. Google Scholar

28.Ibid., p.8. Google Scholar

29.Ibid., p.5. Google Scholar

30. Sydney Morning Herald, 24April1972, p.3. Google Scholar

31.Wallace and Owens, Workers Call the Tune at Opera House, p.5. Google Scholar

32.Ibid., p.10. Google Scholar

33.Ibid., p.6. Google Scholar

34.Ibid., pp.17-18 Google Scholar

35.Ibid., p.5. Google Scholar

36.Ibid., pp.8-9. Google Scholar

37.Ibid., p.20. Google Scholar

38.Ibid., p.18. Google Scholar

39.Ibid., pp.17-18. Google Scholar

40. Sydney Morning Herald, 24April1972, p.3;1May1972, p.8. Google Scholar

41.Wallace and Owens, Workers Call the Tune at Opera House, p.12. Google Scholar

42.Ibid., p.13. Google Scholar

43. Sydney Morning Herald, 21April1972, p.3;24April1972, p.3. Google Scholar

44.Ibid., p.3;Wallace and Owens, Workers Call the Tune at Opera House, p.13. Google Scholar

45.Wallace and Owens, Workers Call the Tune at Opera House, p.14;Sydney Morning Herald, 24April1972, p.3;26April1972, p.3;1May1972, p.8;6May1972, p.2. Google Scholar

46.Wallace and Owens, Workers Call the Tune at Opera House, p.17. Google Scholar

47. Sydney Morning Herald, 24April1972, p.3;1May1972, p.8;2May1972, p.2;Wallace and Owens, Workers Call the Tune at Opera House, p.15. Google Scholar

48.Wallace and Owens, Workers Call the Tune at Opera House, p.17. Google Scholar

49.Ibid., pp.2, 20. Google Scholar

50. Sydney Morning Herald, 6May1972, p.2. Google Scholar

52. Hansard: South Australia, House of Assembly, 25June1973, p.41. Google Scholar

54.Ibid. Google Scholar

55.Ibid. Google Scholar

56.Ibid. Google Scholar

58. Advertiser, 21November1972. Google Scholar

59. Whyalla News, editorial, 22November1972. Google Scholar

60.Jim Gettings, interviews with Ray Jureidini, 10 February 1979, 21 March 1979, 21 April 1979, transcript in possession of authors;Stan Aungles andIvan Szelenyi, ‘Structural Conflicts between the State, Local Government and Monopoly Capital: The Case of Whyalla in South Australia’, Australian New Zealand Journal of Sociology, vol.15, no. 1, March1979, p.33. Google Scholar

62.In February 1972, about 45 women, employed making leather uppers for shoes at a factory in Fakenham in East Anglia, had declared the factory under workers’ control in response to its impending closure due to the employer’s bankruptcy. With machinery and scraps of leather to hand, they began producing leather items such as bags for sale locally under the label of ‘Fakenham Occupation Workers‘. However, the unions concerned were unsupportive; one official even told the Fakenham women they were ‘silly girls’. SeeJudy Wacjman, Women in Control: Dilemmas of a Worker’s Co-operative,Open University Press,, 1983. pp.48-48. Google Scholar

66.Ibid.; Blakeley, interviews with Jureidini, 20 July 1978, 10 February 1979, 21 March 1979, 20 April 1979; Hudson, interviews with Jureidini, 22 March 1979, 23 April 1979; Myers, interview with Jureidini, 25 April 1979. Google Scholar

72.Ibid. Google Scholar

75. Common Cause, 10February1975, pp.1, 4. Google Scholar

76.Thomas, The Mine the Workers Ran, pp.2-9. Google Scholar

77. Common Cause, 17February1975, p.1. Google Scholar

78.ABC documentary, May 1976, quoted inThomas, The Mine the Workers Ran, p.47. Google Scholar

79. Common Cause, 24February1975, p.1. Google Scholar

80.Ibid., 3March1975, pp. 1, 4. Google Scholar

81.Ibid., 10March1975, p.1. Google Scholar

82.Ibid., 17March1975, p.4. Google Scholar

83.Ibid., 21March1975, p.2. Google Scholar

84.Thomas, The Mine the Workers Ran, pp.2-9, 27, 41. Google Scholar

85.Quoted inIbid., p.56. Google Scholar

86. Common Cause, 14Feb1978, p.2. Google Scholar

87.Quoted inThomas, The Mine the Workers Ran, p.64. Google Scholar

88. Common Cause, 5Sept1979, p.3. Google Scholar

89.Thomas, The Mine the Workers Ran, p.49;Common Cause, 21March1975, p.1;21April1975, p.1. Google Scholar

90. Common Cause, 10October1975, p.3. Google Scholar

91.Ibid., 14February1978, p.2. Google Scholar

92.Ibid., 21March1975, p.1. Google Scholar

93.Ibid., 23June1975, p.4. Google Scholar

94.Quoted inThomas, The Mine the Workers Ran, p.49. Google Scholar

95.Ibid., p.40. Google Scholar

96.Waterfront and Industrial Pioneer, quoted inThomas, The Mine the Workers Ran, p.43. Google Scholar

97.Quoted inIbid., p.64. Google Scholar

98. Common Cause, 14February1978, p.2. Google Scholar

99.Quoted inThomas, The Mine the Workers Ran, p.35. Google Scholar

100.Ibid., pp.69-69. Google Scholar

101.Waterfront and Industrial Pioneer, quoted inIbid., p.43. Google Scholar

102. Common Cause, 10March1975, p.1. Google Scholar

103.Ibid., 17March1975, p.8. Google Scholar

104.Ibid., 21April1975, p.1. Google Scholar

105.Ibid., 9June1975, p.2. Google Scholar

106.Quoted inThomas, The Mine the Workers Ran, p.29. Google Scholar

107. Common Cause, 10October1975, p.3. Google Scholar

108.Quoted inThomas, The Mine the Workers Ran, p.51. Google Scholar

109.Ibid., pp.6, 36. See alsoPete Thomas, The Nymboida Story: The Work-Ins that Saved a Coalmine,Australian Coal & Shale Employees Federation,, 1975. Google Scholar

110.Quoted inThomas, The Mine the Workers Ran, p.56. Google Scholar

111.Quoted inIbid., pp.56-57. Google Scholar

112.Steve Wright, Storming Heaven: Class Composition and Struggle in Italian Autonomist Marxism,Pluto Press,, 2002, pp.1-4. Google Scholar

113.Negri, ‘Archaeology and Project’, p.209. Google Scholar

114.Nick Dyer-Witheford, Cyber-Marx: Cycles and Circuits of Struggle in High-Technology Capitalism,University of Illinois Press,, 1999, p.65. Google Scholar

115.Negri, ‘Archaeology and Project’, p.226. Google Scholar

116.Timothy S. Murphy, ‘Editor’s Introduction’, in Negri, Books for Burning, p.x;Wright, Storming Heaven, pp.1-4. Google Scholar

117.Glossary, inNegri, Books for Burning, pp.xxxiv-xxxv. Google Scholar

118.Antonio Negri, ‘Preface to the Italian Edition: 1997: Twenty Years Later’, trans.Francesca Novello andTimothy S. Murphy, inNegri, Books for Burning, p.xlii. Google Scholar

119.Mario Tronti, ‘Lenin in England’, inWorking Class Autonomy and the Crisis,London,, 1979, p.1;Antonio Negri, ‘Marx on Cycle and Crisis’, inToni Negri, Revolution Retrieved: Writings on Marx, Keynes, Capitalist Crisis and New Social Subjects,Red Notes,, 1988, p.78;Antonio Negri, The Politics of Subversion: A Manifesto for the Twenty-First Century, trans.James Newell,Polity Press,, 1989, pp.64-65. Google Scholar

120.Antonio Negri, ‘Keynes and the Capitalist Theory of the State Post-1929’[1968], inNegri, Revolution Retrieved, p.15. Google Scholar

121.Ibid., pp.12-13. Google Scholar

122.Ibid., p.29. Google Scholar

123.Ibid., p.30. Google Scholar

124.Ibid., pp.35-6;Negri, The Politics of Subversion, p.68. Google Scholar

125.Antonio Negri.,‘Crisis of the Planner State: Communism and Revolutionary Organization’, inAntonio Negri, Books for Burning: Between Civil War and Democracy in 1970s Italy, trans.Arianna Bove,Ed Emery,Timothy S. Murphy&Francesca Novello,Verso,, 2005, pp.34, 41. Google Scholar

126.Negri, ‘Keynes’, p.35. Google Scholar

127.Antonio Negri, ‘Crisis of the Crisis-State’, inNegri, Revolution Retrieved, p.185. Google Scholar

128.Ibid., pp.185-86. Google Scholar

129.Antonio Negri, ‘Archaeology and Project: The Mass Worker and the Social Worker’, inNegri, Revolution Retrieved, p.211. Google Scholar

130.Negri, ‘Crisis of the Planner State’, p.41. Google Scholar

131. Sydney Morning Herald, 13April1972, p.10. Google Scholar

132.Ibid., 8May1972, p.2. Google Scholar

133.Ibid., 28April1972, p.4. Google Scholar

134.Editorial, Employers’ Review, April1972, quoted inSydney Morning Herald, 29April1972, p.3. Google Scholar

135.Quoted inThomas, The Mine the Workers Ran, p.14. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Burgmann, Verity

Jureidini, Ray

Burgmann, Meredith