Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

The State, Labour and the Writing of Australian Labour History

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2011), 100, (1), 83–104.

Abstract

A critical literature review of the influence of the twentieth century state in Australia on labour produces a number of findings. First, the disaggregated nature of that state - with its national, state and local levels each including various state ‘arms’ - has generated a multiplicity of outcomes and a diverse literature. Second, the field largely operates within a range of perspectives - pluralist, elite and class-based - that accepts and legitimates unions and state regulation that limits employer behaviour. Third, the neighbouring fields of economic history, political science, labour law and public administration have played crucial roles in shaping what we know about particular, important topic trends. For example, labour law has most to say on the matter of individual legal rights while public administration has contributed substantially on trends in public sector employment. Crucially important too has been the field of industrial relations where sustained - often longitudinal - institutional analysis and a greater propensity to theorising contribute greater breadth, consistency and sophistication. It is really on the topic of collective labour rights - most notably the roles and behaviours of arbitration tribunals and unions - that mainstream labour history, together with historically-sensitive industrial relations, have made major contributions. This reflects the reality that compulsory arbitration - through award-making on the terms and conditions of employment - was undoubtedly the most visible, pervasive and influential mechanism through which the state in Australia affected labour.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Endnotes

1.Greg Patmore, Australian Labour History,Longman Cheshire,, 1991. This involves, unfortunately, overlooking pioneering work by historically informed labour law academics like Orwell de Foenander, Geoff Sorrell and C.P. Mills. Google Scholar

2.Gordon Anderson andMichael Quinlan, ‘The changing role of the state: Regulating work in Australia and New Zealand 1788-2007’, Labour History, no.95, November2008, pp.112-114. Google Scholar

3.See for example,Martin Mowbray, ‘The red shire of Kearsley, 1944-1947: Communists in local government’, Labour History, no.51, November1986, pp.83-94;Michael Hogan, Local Labor: A history of the Labor Party in Glebe, 1891-2003,Federation Press,, 2004;‘Municipal Labor in New South Wales’, Labour History, no.72, May1997, pp.123-148., Google Scholar

4.Jim Hagan, A History of the A.C.T.U.,Longman Cheshire,, 1981, ch. 1. See alsoNeil Massey, ‘A century of laborism and the state, 1891-1993: An historical interpretation’, Labour History, no.66, May1994, pp.45-71. For a more comparative and theoretical discussion of labourism, seeTerry Irving, ‘Labourism: A political genealogy’ Labour History, no.66, May1994, pp.1-13. Google Scholar

5.For a recent thematic view of compulsory arbitration’s workings and effects, seeJoe Isaac andStuart Macintyre(eds), The New Province for Law and Order: 100 Years of Australian Industrial Conciliation and Arbitration,Cambridge University Press,, 2004. Google Scholar

6.Braham Dabscheck, The Struggle of Australian Industrial Relations,Oxford University Press,, 1995, pp.108-113;Margaret Gardner andGill Palmer, Employment Relations: Industrial Relations and Human Resource Management in Australia, 2ndedn,Macmillan,, 1997, pp.37-39. Google Scholar

7.Peter Sheldon andLouise Thornthwaite(eds), Employer Associations and Industrial Relations Change: Catalysts or Captives? Allen & Unwin,, 1999. For an opposing perspective, highlighting the role of the ACTU, seeChris Briggs, ‘Australian exceptionalism: The role of trade unions in the emergence of enterprise bargaining’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.43, no.1, March2001, pp.27-43. Google Scholar

8.Mark Bray andVic Taylor(eds), Managing Labour? Essays in the Political Economy of Australian Industrial Relations,McGraw-Hill,, 1986;David Brereton, ‘Theoretical perspectives on legislative innovation: The case of compulsory arbitration’, inStuart Macintyre andRichard Mitchell(eds), Foundations of Arbitration: The Origins and Effects of State Compulsory Arbitration 1980-1914,Oxford University Press,, 1989, pp.293-312;Jim Kitay, ‘The state, the labour process and the foundations of arbitration, inMacintyre andMitchell(eds), Foundations of Arbitration, pp.352-364;N.F. Dufty andR.E. Fells, Dynamics of Industrial Relations in Australia,Prentice Hall,, 1989;Braham Dabscheck, Arbitrator at Work: Sir William Raymond Kelly and the Regulation of Australian Industrial Relations,George Allen & Unwin,, 1983, ch. 1;Australian Industrial Relations in the 1980s,Oxford University Press,, 1985, ch. 1;Dabscheck, The Struggle of Australian Industrial Relations, ch. 1;Chris Fisher, Innovation and Australian Industrial Relations: Aspects of the Arbitral Experience 1945-1980,Croom Helm,, 1983, esp. ch. 1;Gerry Treuren, ‘The concept of the state in Australian industrial relations theory’, Labour & Industry, vol.11, no.2, December2000, pp.75-98. Google Scholar

9.Tom Sheridan, Division of Labour: Industrial Relations in the Chifley Years, 1945-49,Oxford University Press,, 1989. This fragmentation has become even more pronounced since Patmore’sAustralian Labour Historymade a similar point in 1991 (p. 14). For discussion of these issues,John Merritt, ‘Labour history’, inG. Osborne andW.F. Mandle(eds), The New History: Studying Australia Today,George Allen & Unwin,, 1982. See alsoPatmore, Australian Labour History, pp.8-17. For an example of an attempt to theorise from within the field,Gary Cross, ‘Labour in settler-state democracies: Comparative perspectives on Australia and the US, 1860-1920’, Labour History, no.70, May1996, pp.1-24. Google Scholar

10.Bede Nairn, Civilising Capitalism: The Labor Movement in New South Wales 1870-1900,ANU Press,, 1973. See alsoHagan, A History of the A.C.T.U. ;Robin Gollan, Radical and Working Class Politics: A Study of Eastern Australia, 1850-1910,Melbourne University Press,, 1960; For an account of the predecessors as well as the Old Left, seePatmore, Australian Labour History, pp.1-8. Google Scholar

11.Ron Bean, Comparative Industrial Relations: An Introduction to Cross-National Perspectives,Routledge,, 1985, pp.110-12;N.G. Butlin,A. Barnard andJ.J. Pincus, Government and Capitalism: Public and Private Choice in Twentieth Century Australia,George Allen & Unwin,, 1982. Google Scholar

12.R.W. Connell andT.H. Irving, Class Structure in Australian History: Documents, Narrative and Argument,Longman Cheshire,, 1980, pp.21-24;Stephen Garton andMargaret E. McCallum, ‘Workers’ welfare: Labour and the welfare state in 20th-century Australia and Canada’, Australia and Canada: Labour Compared:Joint issue ofLabour/Le TravailandLabourHistory, no.71, November1996, pp.117-118;Patmore, Australian Labour History;Anderson andQuinlan, ‘The changing role of the state’;Cross, ‘Labour in settler-state’. For attempts to make the state’s role more explicit for a labour historiography more akin to social history than industrial relations history, see Sydney Labour History Group, What Rough Beast? The State and Social Order in Australian History,George Allen & Unwin,, 1982. Google Scholar

13.Our definition derives from, among others, Gianfranco Poggi, The State:Its Nature, Development and Prospects,Polity Press,, 1990, esp. ch. 1 and 2; andGarton andMcCallum, ‘Workers’welfare, pp.117-118. Google Scholar

14.Andrew Giles, ‘Industrial relations theory, the state, and politics’, inJack Barbash andKate Barbash(eds), Theories and Concepts in Comparative Industrial Relations,University of South Carolina Press,, 1989, p.131.See alsoGardner andPalmer, Employment Relations, pp.150-154;C.B. Fox, ‘The role of the state in industrial relations’, ch. 9 inG.W. Ford,J.M. Hearn andR.D. Lansbury(eds), Australian Labour Relations: Readings, 4thedn,Macmillan,, 1987. Google Scholar

15.For a recent discussion of populism in (cultural) practice,Nick Dyrenfurth, ‘“Truth and time against the world’s wrongs”: Montagu Scott, Jim Case and the lost world of the BrisbaneWorkercartoonists’, Labour History, no.99, November2010, pp.115-148. For populism and its socioeconomic bases and expressions,Raymond Markey, The Making of the Labour Party in New South Wales 1880-1900,New South University Press,, 1988, ch.10. Google Scholar

16.John Merritt, ‘Labour history’, pp.116-122. Google Scholar

17.See, for example, the essays in H.R. Nicholls Society, Arbitration in Contempt: The Proceedings of the Inaugural Seminar of the H R Nicholls Society,H.R. Nicholls Society,, 1986. For employer associations and New Right influences,Sheldon andThornthwaite(eds), Employer Associations and Industrial Relations Change, especially the editors’ chs 1, 2 and 3;Damien Cahill, ‘Business mobilisation, the new right and Australian Labor governments in the 1980s’, Labour History, no.98, May2010, pp.7-24. Google Scholar

18.Sheldon andThornthwaite, Employer Associations. Google Scholar

19.For the history of assisted immigration, seeDavid Meredith andBarrie Dyster, Australia in the Global Economy: Continuity and Change,Cambridge University Press,, 1999pp.112-13, 181-83;A.G. Kenwood, Australian Economic Institutions Since Federation: An Introduction,Oxford University Press,, 1995, pp.139-45; for social welfare,Jill Roe(ed.), Social Policy in Australia: Some Perspectives 1901-1975,Cassell Australia,, 1976;Robert van Krieken, Children and the state: Child welfare in New South Wales, 1890-1915’, Labour History, no.51, November1986, pp.33-53. For training and skills, see for example,John Shields, ‘A Matter of skill: The rise of compulsory apprenticeship in early twentieth century New South Wales’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.37no.2, 1995, pp.236-262. Google Scholar

20.For the1930s depression, seeC.B. Schedvin, Australia and the Great Depression: A Study of Economic Development and Policy in the 1920s and 1930s,Sydney University Press,, 1970, and for its effects on labour,Peter Sheldon, ‘State-level basic wages in Australia during the Depression 1929-35: Institutions and politics over markets, Australian Economic History Review, vol.47, no.3, November, 249-77. For post-war full-employment policy, Meredith and Dyster, Australia in the Global Economy, pp.174-76. Google Scholar

21.For nineteenth century railway investment,N.G. Butlin, Investment in Australian Economic Development, 1861-1900,Cambridge University Press,, 1964, ch. 5. For twentieth century industrialisation through foreign direct investment, Meredith and Dyster, Australia in the Global Economy, pp, 136, 197-201, 205-8; Kenwood, Australian Economic Institutions, pp.190-198; Google Scholar

22.See for example,Joe Collins andDrew Cottle, ‘Labor neoliberals or pragmatic neo-laborists? the Hawke and Keating Labor Governments in Office, 1983-1996’, Labour History, no.98, May2010, pp.25-37. For a political economy perspective,Dick Bryan, ‘National competitiveness and the subordination of labour: An Australian policy study’, Labour & Industry, vol.11, no.2, December2000, pp.1-16. Google Scholar

23.Kenwood, Australian Economic Institutions, ch. 4 and 5;Stephen Bell, Ungoverning the Economy: The Political Economy of Australian Economic Policy,Oxford University Press,, 1997, ch. 9. Google Scholar

24.Gardner andPalmer, Employment Relations, pp.408-413; Dabscheck, The Struggle of Australian Industrial Relations, ch. 2;Peter Beilharz, Transforming Labor: Labour Tradition and the Labor Decade in Australia,Cambridge University Press,, 1994, ch. 5 and 6;Gwynneth Singleton, The Accord and the Australian Labour Movement,Melbourne University Press,, 1990. Google Scholar

25.See, for example many of the chapters inJohn Iremonger,John Merritt andGraeme Osborne(eds), Strikes: Studies in Twentieth Century Australian Social History,Hale and Iremonger,, 1973;Frank Cain, The Wobblies at War: A History of the IWW and the Great War in Australia,Spectrum,, 1993; work byStuart Svensen, such asIndustrial War: The Great Strikes 1890-94,Ram Press,, 1995;Les Louis, ‘The cold/class war, and the jailing of Ted Roach’, Labour History, no.86, May2004, pp.157-172. An interesting survey article is,Mark Finnane andStephen Garton, ‘The work of policing: Social relations and the criminal justice system in Queensland 1880- 1914: Part I’, Labour History, no.62, May1992, pp.52-70. Google Scholar

26.Markey, The Making of the Labour Party. Google Scholar

27.Macintyre andMitchell(eds), Foundations of Arbitration;R Norman Dufty, Arbitration in Western Australia: The First 25 Years, Industrial Relations Research Centre, Monograph 24,University of New South Wales, August1990, ch. 1.David Plowman andGenevieve Calkin, ‘The origins of compulsory arbitration in Western Australia’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.46, no.1, March2004, pp.53-83. Google Scholar

28.Beyond Macintyre andMitchell(eds), Foundations of Arbitration, see for,P.G. Macarthy, ‘Wage determination in New South Wales:1890-1921’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.10, no.3, pp.189-205. For,Dabscheck, Arbitrator at Work, pp.78-88; For,Bradley Bowden,Simon Blackwood,Cath Rafferty andCameron Allan(eds), Work and Strife in Paradise: The History of Labour Relations in Queensland 1859-2009,Federation Press,, 2009. Google Scholar

29.P.G. Macarthy, ‘Victorian wages boards: Their origins and the doctrine of the living wage’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.10, no.2, July1968, pp.116-34;KW. Hince, ‘Wages boards in Victoria’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.7. no.2, July1965. Google Scholar

30.See for examplePeter Sheldon, ‘Compulsory arbitration’s role in Australian union recovery after the 1890s’ Depression: The New South Wales Government Railways and Tramways’, Historical Studies in Industrial Relations, no.14, Autumn2002, pp.99-133;Peter Sheldon, ‘Compulsory arbitration and union recovery: Maritime-related unions 1900-1912’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.40, no.3, September1998, pp.422-40;Peter Sheldon, ‘Missing nexus? union recovery, growth and behaviour during the first decades of arbitration: Towards a re-evaluation’, Australian Historical Studies, no.104, April1995, pp.415-37;Peter Sheldon, ‘In division is strength: Unionism among Sydney labourers, 1890-1910’, Labour History, no.56, May1989, pp.43-59;Roy Adams andRay Markey, ‘How the state influences trade union growth: A comparative analysis of developments in Europe, North America and Australasia’, International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations, vol.13, no.4, Winter1997, pp.285-303.Ray Markey, ‘Explaining union mobilisation in the 1880s and early 1900s’, Labour History, no.83, November2002, pp.19-42;Rae Cooper, ‘“To organise wherever the necessity exists”: The activities of the organising committee of the Labor Council of NSW, 1900-10’, Labour History, no.83, November2002, pp.43-64. Google Scholar

31.Raj Jadeja andEwan Maidment, ‘The super unions: Amalgamations and archives, 1903-1994, Labour History, no.68, May1995, pp.173-180;Dabscheck, The Struggle, pp.131-136. Google Scholar

32.For a few accounts of internal union dynamics including emphasis on internal democracy, seeT. Sheridan, Mindful Militants: The Amalgamated Engineering Union in Australia, 1920-1972,Cambridge University Press,, 1975;Stephen J. Frenkel andAlice Coolican, Unions Against Capitalism? A Sociological Comparison of the Australian Building and Metal Workers’ Unions,George Allen & Unwin,, 1984;Mark Bray andMalcolm Rimmer, Delivering the Goods: A History of the Transport Workers’ Union in New South Wales, 1888-1986,Allen & Unwin,, 1987;Meredith Burgmann andVerity Burgmann, Green Bans, Red Union: Environmental Activism and the New South Wales Builders Labourers’ Federation,University of NSW Press,, 1998;John Benson, Unions at the Workplace: Shop Steward Leadership and Ideology,Oxford University Press,, 1991. Google Scholar

33.Sandra Cockfield, ‘Mobilising the Workplace: State regulation and collective action in three workplaces, 1900 to the 1920s’, Labour History, no.93, November2007, pp.35-56;Barbara Webster, ‘A “cosy relationship” if you had it: Queensland Labor’s arbitration system and union organising strategies in Rockhampton, 1916-57’, Labour History, no.83, November2002, pp.89-106. Google Scholar

34.Naomi Segal, ‘“War conducted under certain rules, but nonetheless war”: Arbitration, capital and labour in the Western Australian gold mining industry, 1901-1914’, Labour History, no.93, November2007, pp.109-126. Google Scholar

35.P.G. Macarthy, ‘Justice Higgins and the Harvester judgement’, Australian Economic History Review, vol.9, no.1, March1969, pp.17-38;K.J..Hancock, ‘The wages of the workers’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.11, no.1, March1969, pp.17-38; and‘The first half-century of Australian wage policy (part 1)’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.21no.1, March1979, pp.1-19. Google Scholar

36.J.D. Hill.‘Australian industrial relations and the “national character”’, ch. 8 inFord,Hearn andLansbury(eds), Australian Labour Relations;Andrew Wells, ‘State regulation for a moral economy: Peter Macarthy and the meaning of the Harvester judgement’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.40, no.3, September1998, pp.371-382. Google Scholar

37.K.J. Hancock andKathryn Moore, ‘The occupational wage structure in Australia since 1914’, British Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.10, March1972;K.J. Hancock, ‘The first half-century of Australian wage policy (part 2)’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.21no.2, June1979, pp.129-160. Google Scholar

38.Laura Bennett, ‘The construction of skill: Craft unions, women workers and the conciliation and arbitration court’, Law in Context, no.2, 1984, pp.118;‘Job classification and women workers: Institutional practices, technological change and the conciliation and arbitration system, 1907-1972’, Labour History, no.51, November1986, pp.11-23;‘Equal pay and comparable worth and the Australian Conciliation and Arbitration Commission’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.30, no.4, December1988, pp.533-545;Raelene Frances, The Politics of Work: Gender and Labour in Victoria, 1880-1939,Cambridge University Press,, 1993; and‘Gender, skill and the regulation of labour markets: Victoria 1890-1930’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.40, no.3, September1998, pp.401-408. Google Scholar

39.Verity Burgmann, Revolutionary Industrial Unionism: The Industrial Workers of the World in Australia,Cambridge University Press,, 1995, ch. 13.Frank Cain, ‘The Industrial Workers of the World: Aspects of its suppression in Australia’, Labour History, no.42, May1982, pp.54-62; andCain, The Wobblies at War. Google Scholar

40.Anne Curthoys andJohn Merritt(eds), Better Dead than Red: Australia’s First Cold War: 1945-1959,Allen & Unwin,, 1986;David McKnight, ‘Rethinking cold war history’, Labour History, no.95, November2008, pp.185-196. Google Scholar

41.For an activist’s contribution,Joe Harris, The Bitter Fight: A Pictorial History of the Australian Labor Movement,University of Queensland Press,, 1979. For an important collections of work on major disputes,D.J. Murphy(ed.), The Big Strikes: Queensland 1889-1965,University of Queensland Press,, 1983; andIremonger,Merritt andOsborne(eds), Strikes. For the 1949 coal strike, seePhillip Deery, ‘Chifley, the army and the 1949 coal strike’, Labour History, no.68, May1995, pp.80-97;Sheridan, Division of Labour, ch. 12. For NSW Builders’ Labourers’ Federation, Burgmann and Burgmann, Green Bans, ch.12. Google Scholar

42.For Heydon’s deregistration of labourers unions, seePeter Sheldon, ‘System and strategy: The changing shape of unionism among NSW construction labourers, 1910-19’, Labour History, no.64, November, 1993, pp.115-35. For the Clarrie O’Shea dispute,Ashley Lavelle, ‘Under pressure: The Whitlam Labor opposition and class struggle, 1967–72’, Labour History, no.96, May2009, pp.117-134; for a contemporary account of those penal powers,J.E. Isaac, ‘Penal powers under Commonwealth arbitration’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.5, no.2, October1963; for the Federated Engine Drivers and Firemen’s Association in the 1950s,Mark Westcott, ‘One of the boys or the common good?: Workplace activism in the NSW Branch of the Federated Engine Drivers and Firemen’s Association’, Labour History, no.91, November2006, pp.75-94. Google Scholar

43.Breen Creighton,Bill Ford andRichard Mitchell, Labour Law, 2nded,Law Book Company,, 1993, pp.17-26. Google Scholar

44.Adrian Merritt, ‘The historical role of law in the regulation of employment: Abstentionist or interventionist?’ Australian Journal of Law and Society, vol.1, no.1, 1982, p.56. Google Scholar

45.Philip Selznick, Law, Society and Industrial Justice,Russell Sage Foundation,, 1969, p.130. Google Scholar

46.Laura Bennett, Making Labour Law in Australia: Industrial Relations, Politics and Law,Law Book Company,, 1994. Google Scholar

47.Robert Castle andJim Hagan, ‘Regulation of Aboriginal labour in Queensland: Protectors, agreements and trust accounts 1897-1965’, Labour History, no.72, May1997, pp.66-76. Google Scholar

48.Lenore Layman, ‘“To keep up the Australian standard”: Regulating contract labour migration 1901-50’, Labour History, no.70, May1996, pp.25-52. Google Scholar

49.Ross Shanahan, ‘Making workplace agreements contractual: Then and now’, inDavid Palmer,Ross Shanahan andMartin Shanahan(eds), Australian Labour History Reconsidered,Australian Humanities Press,, 1999, pp.117-131at p.119. Google Scholar

50.Rosemary Owens andJoellen Riley, The Law of Work,Oxford University Press,, 2007, pp.219-270. Google Scholar

51.Owens andRiley, The Law of Work;Richard Naughton, ‘Implied obligation of mutual trust and confidence’, Australian Journal of Labour Law, vol.10, 1997, p.287. Google Scholar

52.Marilyn Pittard andRichard Naughton, Australian Labour Law: Text, Cases and Commentary, 5thedn,Lexis Nexis Butterworths,, 2010, pp.1100-1209. Google Scholar

53.Michael Quinlan(ed.),‘Occupational health and safety’, special issue ofLabour History, no.73, November1997; and in particular,Bobbie Oliver, ‘“Lives of misery and melancholy”: The rhetoric and reality of industrial reform in post-World War I Western Australia’, ibid, pp.105-122;Beris Penrose, ‘Occupational lead poisoning at Mount Isa Mines in the 1930s’ ibid, pp.123-141. See alsoPamela Kinnear, ‘The politics of coal dust: Industrial campaigns for the regulation of dust disease in Australian coal mining, 1939-49’, Labour History, no.80, May2001, pp.65-82. Google Scholar

54.Paula Cowan, ‘From exploitation to innovation: The development of early workers compensation legislation in Queensland’, Labour History, no.73, May1997, pp.93-104;Adrian Merritt, ‘One hundred and fifty years of legislation: One step forward, two steps backward’, Occupational Health and Safety, UNSW Occasional Paper 10, 1985;W.G. (Kit) Carson, ‘Occupational health and safety: A political economy perspective, Labour & Industry, vol.2, no.2, 1989, pp.301-316. Google Scholar

55.Greg McGarry, ‘Promotion and disciplinary appeals for government employees’, Journal of Industrial Relations, September1976, pp.255-271;Louise Thornthwaite, ‘Ever-widening ripples: The impact of specialist industrial tribunals on management practice’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.36, no.2, June1994, pp.285-298; andLouise Thornthwaite ‘The operation of anti-discrimination legislation in New South Wales in relation to employment complaints’, Australian Journal of Labour Law, vol.6, no.1, March1993, pp.31-48;Margaret Thornton, The Liberal Promise: Anti-Discrimination Legislation in Australia,Oxford University Press,, 1990. Google Scholar

56.Ann McGrath andKay Saunders, withJackie Huggins(eds), Aboriginal Workers, a special issue ofLabour History, no.69, November1995. Google Scholar

57.This is the case also with histories of the nineteenth century public sector, although there notable exceptions; includingHilary Golder, Politics, Patronage and Public Works: The Administration of New South Wales, 1842-1900,UNSW Press,, 2005. Google Scholar

58.G.E. Caiden, Career Service: An Introduction to the History of Personnel Administration in the Commonwealth Public Service of Australia 1901-1961,Melbourne University Press, 1965,;, Public Administration in Australia,NSW Government Printer, 1973. Google Scholar

59.H. Bland, Shadows and Realities of Government,WEA of Australia,, 1923;H. Bland, Planning the Modern State,Angus & Robertson,, 1937;R.S. Parker, The Government of New South Wales,University of Queensland Press,, 1978. Google Scholar

60.Caiden, Career Service, pp.105-158;G.E. Caiden, The Commonwealth Bureaucracy,Melbourne University Press,, 1967. Google Scholar

61.For blue collar public employment, see eg:Peter Sheldon, ‘Public vs private employers on New South Wales Public Works, 1890-1910’, Australian Economic History Review, vol.36, no.1, March1993, pp.49-72;Peter Sheldon, ‘The dimming of illusions: Changing attitudes of labourers to direct government employment on NSW Public Works, 1899-1916’, Australian Journal of Public Administration, vol.48, no.2, June1989, pp.139-45;Peter Sheldon, ‘The dirtiest of jobs: Maintaining Sydney’s sewers, 1890-1910’, Labour History, no.93, November2007, pp.127-144; andSheldon, ‘Compulsory arbitration’s role’.Margo Beasley, The Sweat of their Brows: 100 Years of the Sydney Water Board 1888-1988,Sydney Water Board,, 1988. For government owned businesses,Greg Patmore, ‘“American hustling methods”: The Lithgow Small Arms Factory 1912-1922’, Labour History, no.67, November1994, pp.45-56;Murray Goot, ‘Labor, government business enterprises and competition policy’, Labour History, no.98, May2010, pp.77-96. Google Scholar

62.Peter Sheldon, ‘Compulsory arbitration’s role’. Google Scholar

63.Lucy Taksa, ‘“Defence not defiance”: Social protest and the NSW general strike of 1917’, Labour History, no.60, May1991, pp.16-33;Robert Tierney, ‘The New South Wales Railway Commissioners’ strategic pre-planning for the mass strike of 1917’, Labour History, no.98, May2010, pp.143-161;Simon Blackwood andDoug Hunt, ‘Strikes: Limits to industrial action?’inBowdenet al, Work and Strife in Paradise, p.198;Graham F. Smith, ‘From consensus to coercion: The Australian air pilots dispute’, Journal of Industrial Relations, vol.32, no.2, pp.238-253. Google Scholar

64.Desley Deacon, Managing Gender,Oxford University Press,, 1989;Clare Burton, The Promise and the Price: The Struggle for Equal Opportunity in Women’s Employment,Allen & Unwin,, 1991.Marjorie Theobold andDonna Dwyer, ‘An episode in feminist politics: TheMarried Women (Lecturers and Teachers) Act, 1932-47, Labour History, no76, May1999, pp.59-77;Donna Dwyer, ‘Justice at last?: The Temporary Teachers Club and the Teaching Service (Married Women) Act 1956’, Labour History, no.91, 2006, pp.151-168. Google Scholar

65.Greg Patmore, ‘Systematic management and bureaucracy: The NSW Railways prior to 1932’, Labour & Industry, vol.1, no.1, 1988, pp.306-321;Duncan McDonald, ‘Management and the labour process in two New South Wales government organisations’, inBray andTaylor(eds), Managing Labour, pp.48-74. Google Scholar

66.Christopher Wright, The Management of Labour,Oxford University Press,, 1995. More recently, however, scholars have begun asking whether the nature of work and employment in Australia’s public sector was so unique: for instance,Linda Colley, ‘How secure was that public service job: Redundancy in the Queensland Public Service’, Labour History, no.89, November2005has critically examined the assumption that, as part of the career service model, public servants had, for most of the century, enjoyed a job security unrivalled in the private sector. Google Scholar

67.R.S. Parker, The Government of New South Wales,Queensland University Press,, 1978.Caiden, The Commonwealth Bureaucracy;Parker, The Government of New South Wales. Google Scholar

68.G.E. Caiden, The A.C.P.T.A.: A Study of White Collar Public Service Unionism in the Commonwealth of Australia 1885-1922,Australian National University,, 1966. Google Scholar

69.Greg Patmore, ‘The origins of the National Union of Railwaymen’, Labour History, no.43, November1982, pp.44-52;Sheldon, ‘The dirtiest of jobs’;Sheldon, ‘Compulsory arbitration’s role’. Google Scholar

70.Glenda Strachan, The History of the Nurses Association in Queensland 1860-1950,Allen & Unwin,, 1996;John O’Brien, A Divided Unity: The Politics of the NSW Teacher Militancy since 1945,Allen & Unwin,, 1987;Andrew Spaull andMartin Sullivan, A History of the Queensland Teachers’ Union,Allen & Unwin, 1989;Margaret Gardner, ‘The fateful meridian: Trade union strategies and women workers’, inBray andTaylor(eds), Managing Labour?, pp.168-194. On police unionism:Jenny Fleming, ‘Shifting the emphasis: The impact of police nionism in Queensland: 1915-1925’, Labour History, no.68, 1995, pp.98-114;Mark Finnane, When Police Unionise:The Politics of Law and Order in Australia,Institute of Criminology Press,, 2002. Google Scholar

71.Elizabeth Windschuttle(ed.), Women, Class and History: Feminist Perspectives on Australia 1788-1978,Fontana Collins,, 1980;Margaret Bevege,Margaret James, andCarmel Shute(eds), Worth Her Salt: Women at Work in Australia,Hale & Iremonger,, 1982. Google Scholar

72.Louise Thornthwaite, ‘Regulating state employment: The origins and development of public sector appeal systems in NSW, 1880-1980’, Labour History, no.68, May1995, pp.132-154. Google Scholar

73.Margaret Gardner(ed.), Human Resource Management and Industrial Relations in the Public Sector,Macmillan,, 1993;Ciaran O’Faircheallaigh,John Wanna andPat Weller(eds), Public Sector Management in Australia: New Challenges, New Directions, 2ndedn,CAPSM,, 1992. Google Scholar

74.Colley, ‘How secure was that public service job, pp.141-157;Bobbie Oliver, ‘“They can’t take a trade off you”: varying perceptions of job security over 50 years at the Midland Government Railway Workshops’, inJulie Kimber andPeter Love(eds), The Time of Their Lives: The Eight Hour Day and Working Life,ASSLH,, 2007, pp.153-168. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Sheldon, Peter

Thornthwaite, Louise