Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

“Those Knights of the Pen and Pencil”: Women Journalists and Cultural Leadership of the Women’s Movement in Australia and the United States

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2013), 104, (1), 81–100.

Abstract

Journalism has been crucial to progressive political movements, and the work of journalists has provided the cultural leadership necessary for recruiting members and advancing the cause. This cultural leadership is explored through the journalism of three women who in Australia and the United States, wrote for a labour and socialist readership and also edited a periodical. Combining paid work and activism, journalism gave them an occupation that was an example to other women, and a vehicle for publicising women’s rights. Exercising leadership through print media was important in expanding women’s economic citizenship and their political engagement. Through their words and personal example over a century, these three women journalists - Alice Henry, Jennie Scott Griffiths and Della Elliott - provided the leadership that helped construct women in the twentieth century as active political subjects.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*The author would like to thank the two anonymous referees ofLabour Historyfor their comments and suggestions. Google Scholar

1.Jennie Scott Griffiths, “Editorial Chat,” Australian Woman’s Weekly, January 15, 1916, 1. Google Scholar

2.Della Elliott, “Freedom of the Press,” Seamen’s Journal 21, no. 3(March1966):57. Google Scholar

3.Diane Kirkby, Alice Henry: The Power of Pen and Voice(:Cambridge University Press, 1991), 77. Google Scholar

4.Ibid.See alsoSusan Magarey, Unbridling the Tongues of Women: The Life of Catherine Helen Spence(:Hale and Iremonger, 1985). Google Scholar

5.Alice Henry, Trade Union Woman(:Appleton, 1915), 255. Google Scholar

6.For a theoretical and historical discussion of journalism and democracy seeGeraldine Muhlmann, Journalism for Democracy, trans.Jean Birrell(:Polity Press, 2010), first published France 2004. Google Scholar

7.Ronald Heifetz, “Leadership, Authority and Women: A Man’s Challenge,”inWomen and Leadership: The State of Play and Strategies for Change, ed.Barbara Kellerman and Deborah Rhode(:Jossey-Bass, 2007), 314. Google Scholar

8.Ibid., 316–17, 314. Google Scholar

9.Karin Klenke, Women in Leadership: Contextual Dynamics and Boundaries(:Emerald Group, 2011), 7–8. Google Scholar

10.Martha Solomon, “The Role of the Suffrage Press in the Woman’s Rights Movement,”inA Voice of their Own: The Woman Suffrage Press, 1840-1910, ed.Martha Solomon(:University of Alabama Press, 1991), 4. Google Scholar

11.Michelle Tusan, Women Making News: Gender and Journalism in Modern Britain(:University of Illinois Press, 2005). Google Scholar

12.Muhlmann, Journalism for Democracy, 5. A large literature on the history of journalism and newspaper publishing accepts but has not analysed this relationship. Google Scholar

13.Bob Ostertag, People’s Movements, People’s Press: The Journalism of Social Justice Movements(:Beacon Press, 2006), 1. Google Scholar

14.A point also made about South Africa byDon Pinnock, Writing Left: The Radical Journalism of Ruth First(:University of South Africa Press, 2007), xiii–xiv, 141, 151et seq. Google Scholar

15.Ostertag, People’s Movements, 20; Frank Bongiorno, “Constituting Labour: The Radical Press in Victoria, 1885-1914,” inJournalism, Print Politics and Popular Culture, ed. Ann Curthoys and Julianne Schultz (St. Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1999), 70-82. Google Scholar

16.A point made byD. J. Murphy, “Henry Boote’s Papers,” Labour History, no. 15 (November1968):71–73; for an example, see Elizabeth Faue, Writing the Wrongs: Eva Valesh and the Rise of Labor Journalism(Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2002). Google Scholar

17.R. J. Guyatt, “The Publicists: The Labour Press, 1880-1915,”inPrelude to Power: The Rise of the Labour Party in Queensland, 1885-1915, ed.D. J. Murphy, R. B. Joyce and C. A. Hughes(:Jacaranda Press, 1970); Faue, Writing the Wrongs;Henry Mayer, The Press in Australia(Melbourne: Lansdowne Press, 1964), 192, 199. For an analysis of one Australian labour paper’s attitude to the women’s movement, see Patricia Grimshaw, “The ‘Equals and Comrades of Men?’Tocsinand the Woman Question,” inDebutante Nation: Feminism Contests the 1890s, ed. Susan Magarey, Susan Rowley and Susan Sheridan (Sydney: Allen and Unwin, 1993); J. P. Henningham, “Two Hundred Years of Australian Journalism: A History Waiting to be Written,”Australian Cultural History7 (1988): 49-64; Sam Pizzigati and Fred Solowey, eds, The New Labor Press: Journalism for a Changing Labor Movement(Ithaca: ILR Press, 1992). Google Scholar

18.Barbara Onslow, Women of the Press in Nineteenth-Century Britain(:Macmillan, 2000) specifically explores writers, novelists and journalism. Notable Australian poets and writers who worked in journalism include names like Henry Lawson, Mary Gilmore, Banjo Patterson, Miles Franklin; see Frank S. Greenop, History of Magazine Publishing in Australia(Sydney: K. G. Murray, 1947). For the connections between journalism and literature in the United States, see Jean Marie Lutes, Front Page Girls: Women Journalists in American Culture and Fiction, 1880-1930(Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2006), 1-11; Muhlmann, Journalism for Democracy, 3 explains this was not the case in France. Google Scholar

19.Tusan, Women Making News, 8. Google Scholar

20.Solomon, “The Role of the Suffrage Press,” 2. Google Scholar

21.Tusan, Women Making News, 2. Google Scholar

22.Solomon, “The Role of the Suffrage Press,” 15. Google Scholar

23.Jan Whitt, Women in American Journalism(:University of Illinois Press, 2008); Kay Mills, A Place in the News: From the Women’s Pages to the Front Page(New York: Columbia University Press, 1990); Anne Sebba, Battling for News: Rise of the Woman Reporter(London: Hodder and Stoughton, 1994); Marjory Lang, Women Who Made the News: Female Journalists in Canada, 1880-1945(Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 1999); Patricia Clarke, Pen Portraits: Women Writers and Journalists in Nineteenth-Century Australia(Sydney: Allen and Unwin,1988); Sharyn Pearce, Shameless Scribblers: Australian Women’s Journalism 1880-1995(Rockhampton: Central Queensland University Press, 1998); Valerie Lawson, Connie Sweetheart: The Story of Connie Robertson(Port Melbourne: Heinemann, 1990); see also Janet McCallum, Women and Their Worlds: Notable Pioneers in New Zealand Journalism(Masterton: Fraser Books, 2009). Google Scholar

24.Tusan, Women Making News;Lutes, Front Page Girls, 1–11;Alice Fahs, Out on Assignment: Newspaper Women and the Making of Public Space(:University of North Carolina Press, 2011). Google Scholar

25.Tusan, Women Making News, 2. Google Scholar

26.Michelle Tusan, “Reforming Work: Gender, Class, and the Printing Trade in Victorian Britain,” Journal of Women’s History 16, no. 1(2004): 103-26. Google Scholar

27.Tusan, Women Making News, 2. Google Scholar

28.Ibid., 3. Google Scholar

29.Lutes, Front Page Girls, 1–11. Google Scholar

30.Pearce, Shameless Scribblers, 14; see alsoBrian Matthews, Louisa(:McPhee Gribble, 1987). Google Scholar

31.Maya Tucker, “The Emergence and Character of Women’s Magazines in Australia 1880-1914,”(PhD thesis,University of Melbourne, 1975); Helena Studdart, “Women’s Magazines,” inA History of the Book in Australia 1891-1945, ed. Martyn Lyons and John Arnold (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 2001), 278-81 is more cursory and overlooks theAustralian Woman’s Weekly. Google Scholar

32.Tusan, Women Making News, 3. Google Scholar

33.Sharon Harris, ed., Blue Pencils and Hidden Hands: Women Editing Periodicals, 1830-1910(:Northeastern University Press, 2004), xii. Google Scholar

34.David Davies, The Postwar Decline of American Newspapers 1945-65(:Praeger2006). For the impact of the Cold War on particular journalists, see Pinnock, Writing Left;Tom Heenan, From Traveller to Traitor: The Life of Wilfred Burchett(Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 2006); Nicholas Daniloff, Of Spies and Spokesmen: My Life as a Cold War Correspondent(Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 2008). Google Scholar

35.See Henningham, Two Hundred Years of Australian Journalism, for a bibliographic survey. Mayer’s study concluded in the 1960s, well before the radical press of gay rights and the Women’s Liberation Movement emerged. For a study of an individual journalist working in the Cold War climate, see Ross Fitzgerald, Alan “Red Fox” Reid(Sydney and Chicago: UNSW Press, 2010). Women journalists’ campaign for equal work is covered by Sandy George, “South Australian Women Journalists and the Struggle for Equal Career Opportunities in Newspaper Journalism,”Cabbages and Kings6 (1978): 14-24. Women journalists played a part in desegregating public drinking spaces in the 1950s-60s, see Diane Kirkby and Tanja Luckins, “‘Winnies and Pats … Brighten Our Pubs’: Transforming the Gendered Spatial Economy of the Australian Pub, 1920-70,” inCulinary Distinction, ed. Sian Supski and Emma Constantino, special issueJournal of Australian Studies, no. 87 (August 2006): 75-86. Google Scholar

36.“Alice Henry”, Melbourne Press Club, accessed March2013,http://www.melbournepressclub.com/halloffame/inductees/alicehenry; Pearce, Shameless Scribblers, 10. Google Scholar

37.Alice Henry, Collection of Articles, MSS QA 824/H, Mitchell Library, Sydney. Google Scholar

38.Pearce, Shameless Scribblers, 8. Google Scholar

39.Kirkby, Alice Henry.For later periods, see Paula Hamilton, “Journalists, Gender and Workplace Culture 1900-1940,” in Curthoys and Schultz, Journalism, Print Politics and Popular Culture, 97-116; Patricia Clarke, “The Transformation of Stella Allan: From Soapbox Socialist to Conservative Women’s Page Editor,”Australian Journalism Review33, no. 2 (2011): 41-49. Google Scholar

40.Kirkby, Alice Henry, 54. Google Scholar

41.Ibid., 36–46. Google Scholar

42.Mari Jo Buhle, Women and American Socialism, 1870 to 1920(:University of Illinois Press, 1981), 53. Google Scholar

43.Alice Henry, “Women and the Trade Union Movement in the United States,” Academy of Political Science in the City of New York 1, no. 1(October1910):109–18. Google Scholar

44.Buhle, Women and American Socialism, 161. Google Scholar

45.Kirkby, Alice Henry, 73; Buhle, Women and American Socialism, 189; Nancy Schrom Dye, As Equals and as Sisters: Feminism, the Labor Movement and the Women’s Trade Union League of New York(Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 1980). Google Scholar

46.Dye, Shameless Scribblers, 47. Google Scholar

47.Kirkby, Alice Henry, 72, 90; see also Jill Roe, Stella Miles Franklin(Pymble: Fourth Estate, 2008). Google Scholar

48.Kirkby, Alice Henry, 103–4. Google Scholar

49.Buhle, Women and American Socialism, 191. Google Scholar

50.Alice Henry and Miles Franklin, “Why 50,000 Refused to Sew,” Englishwoman 10(June1911), 297–308; Kirkby, Alice Henry, 91. Google Scholar

51.Henry, The Trade Union Woman. Google Scholar

52.Ibid., 113. Google Scholar

53.Buhle, Women and American Socialism, 194, 196. Google Scholar

54.Annalise Orleck, Common Sense and a Little Fire: Women and Working-Class Politics in the United States, 1900-1965(:University of North Carolina Press, 1995). Google Scholar

55.Frances Perkins to Sir Owen Dixon, April 3, 1943, Alice Henry Papers, MSS 1066/57, National Library of Australia (hereafter NLAMSS 1066). Google Scholar

57.Clippings, Henry papers, NLAMSS1066/28;Henry, Trade Union Woman, xxi. Google Scholar

58.Ibid., 221, 218. Google Scholar

59.Ibid., ix. Google Scholar

60. The Times(London), March 3, 1916, clipping in NLAMSS 1066/28. Google Scholar

61.Coast Seamen’s Journal, c.1916, typescript, in NLAMSS 1066/28. Google Scholar

62.Orleck, Common Sense and a Little Fire, 43, 3, 311. Google Scholar

63.Ibid., 30; Buhle, Women and American Socialism, 106, 161. Google Scholar

64.Orleck, Common Sense and a Little Fire, 31. Google Scholar

65.Ibid., 50. Google Scholar

66.Kirkby, Alice Henry, 105–9; Diane Kirkby, “Class, Gender and the Perils of Philanthropy: The Story ofLife and Laborand Labor Reform in the Women’s Trade Union League,”Journal of Women’s History4, no. 2, (Fall 1992): 36-51. Google Scholar

67.Kirkby, Alice Henry, 123–24. Google Scholar

68.Alice Henry, Women and the Labor Movement(:Appleton, 1923), reprinted by Arno Press [1975]; reviews in NLAMSS 1066. Google Scholar

70.Jennie Scott Griffiths, “Recollections,” Jennie Scott Griffiths Papers, MSS 1071, National Library of Australia (hereafter NLA MSS 1071); T. H. Irving, “Scott Griffiths, Jennie (1875-1951),”Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University, accessed March2013,http://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/scott-griffiths-jennie-11641. Google Scholar

71.Review ofThe Trade Union WomaninNew York Call, February 27, 1916, clipping in NLAMSS 1066/28. Google Scholar

72.Her politics have been examined byJoy Damousi, Women Come Rally: Socialism, Communism and Gender in Australia 1890-1955(:Oxford University Press, 1994), 20, 86, 106. Google Scholar

73.Alice Henry to Miles Franklin, June 9, 1920, reprinted inMy Congenials: Miles Franklin and Her Friends in Letters, 2nd ed., ed.Jill Roe(:Angus and Robertson, 2010), 151. Google Scholar

75.Ibid.. Google Scholar

76.Tucker, “The Emergence and Character of Women’s Magazines,” 411. Google Scholar

77.Ibid., 289. Google Scholar

78.Ibid., 411. Google Scholar

79.Ibid., 421. Google Scholar

80.Ibid. Google Scholar

81.Ibid. Google Scholar

82.Ibid. Google Scholar

83. Australian Woman’s Weekly, January 18, 1913, 3(quoted in Tucker, “The Emergence and Character of Women’s Magazines,” 413). Google Scholar

84.Tucker, “The Emergence and Character of Women’s Magazines,” 322a, 354. Google Scholar

85.Mayer, The Press in Australia, 197. Google Scholar

86.Jan Roberts, Maybanke Anderson: Sex, Suffrage and Social Reform(:Hale and Iremonger, 1993), 136. Google Scholar

87.Alice Henry, “Equality of Men and Women is the First Principle of Socialism,”unidentified clipping, NLAMSS 1066/25. Google Scholar

88. Australian Woman’s Weekly, June 1914. Google Scholar

89. Australian Woman’s Weekly, April1915. Google Scholar

90.Jennie Scott Griffiths, “Recollections,”typescript, NLAMSS 1071. Google Scholar

92.“An Interviewer Interviewed,” Australian Woman’s Weekly, November 29, 1913, 4. Google Scholar

93. Australian Woman’s Weekly, August 8, 1914, 4. Google Scholar

94.Australian Woman’s Weekly, August 22, 1914, 5; August 8, 1914, 4; September 26, 1914, 6; October 3, 1914, 4; October 10, 1914, 6; August 15, 1914, 6; September 19, 1914, 4. Google Scholar

95.Tucker, “The Emergence and Character of Women’s Magazines,” 336. Google Scholar

96.W. H. Wilde, Courage a Grace: A Biography of Dame Mary Gilmore(:Melbourne University Press, 1988), 148. Google Scholar

97.Pearce, Shameless Scribblers, 42. Google Scholar

98.Wilde, Courage a Grace, 189. Google Scholar

99.Frank Cain, The Origins of Political Surveillance in Australia(:Angus and Robertson, 1983). Ernest Scott, Australia During the War(Sydney: Angus and Robertson, 1937), 65, 144. Google Scholar

100.See alsoDamousi, Women Come Rally, 103. Google Scholar

101.Kathleen Kennedy, Disloyal Mothers and Scurrilous Citizens: Women and Subversion During World War I(:Indiana University Press, 1999), xiii. Google Scholar

102.SeeBill Sutton, “She Fought Where She Stood,”typescript, n.d., MSS F566,University of Queensland Fryer Library. Google Scholar

103.Raymond Evans, Loyalty and Disloyalty: Social Conflict on the Queensland Homefront, 1914-18(:Allen and Unwin, 1987); Raymond Evans, The Red Flag Riots: A Study in Intolerance(St. Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1988). Google Scholar

104.Bob Brodsky to Mrs F Brodskyin New York, March 25, 1919, QF 3611, National Archives of Australia. Google Scholar

105.Tucker, “The Emergence and Character of Women’s Magazines,” 410; “Editorial Chat,” Australian Woman’s Weekly, December 11, 1916, 1; Griffiths, “Recollections,” NLAMSS 1071. Google Scholar

106.Tucker, “The Emergence and Character of Women’s Magazines,” 410. Google Scholar

107.Sutton, She Fought Where She Stood;Damousi, Women Come Rally. Google Scholar

108.Alice Henry, “La Follette - Radical: The Seamen’s Friend,” Marine Stewards Journal(November1925):12, clipping in NLAMSS 1066/24. Google Scholar

109.Rowan Cahill, “Kondelea (Della) Elliott, 1917-2011,” The Hummer 7, no. 1(2011), accessed March 2013,http://asslh.org.au/hummer/vol-7-no-1/della/. Google Scholar

110.Ibid. Google Scholar

111.Marilyn Lake, Getting Equal: The History of Australian Feminism(:Allen and Unwin, 1999), 178–81; Edna Ryan and Anne Conlon, Gentle Invaders: Australian Women at Work(Ringwood: Penguin, 1989). Google Scholar

112.Cahill, “Della Elliott”; Barbara Curthoys and Audrey McDonald, More than a Hat and Glove Brigade: The Story of the Union of Australian Women(:Bookpress, 1996). Google Scholar

113.Union of Australian Women, For the Rights of Women: Three Decades of Struggle, 1950-1980(:Union of Australian Women, 1980), 12. Google Scholar

114. “Union of Australian Women (1950-),” The Australian Women’s Register, accessed March 2013,http://www.womenaustralia.info/biogs/AWE0106b.htm. Google Scholar

115.Cahill, “Della Elliott”. Google Scholar

116.Diane Kirkby, Voices from the Ships: Australia’s Seafarers and Their Union(:UNSW Press, 2008), 110–39. Google Scholar

117.Diane Kirkby, “‘The Defeated and Now Forgotten Warriors’: Early 20th Century American Activists,”(paper presented to the International Women’s Day conference, State Library of New South Wales in conjunction with Macquarie University, March 8, 2011). Google Scholar

118. Seamen’s Journal 24(May-June1969), 135–36. Google Scholar

119.Henry, The Trade Union Woman, xi. Google Scholar

120.Ibid.; Kirkby, Voices from the Ships. Google Scholar

121.Cahill, “Della Elliott”; Alan Oliver, “Memories of Della,” Seamen’s Journal 40, no. 2(February1989). Google Scholar

122.Della Elliott, “25 Years of S.U.A. Women’s Organisation,” Seamen’s Journal 22, December 12, 1967, Special Supplement, 314. Google Scholar

123.Ibid., 315. Google Scholar

124.L. Sharpen, “Sex and the Seamen,” Seamen’s Journal, 20, no. 9(September1965), 209. Google Scholar

125.Elliott, Freedom of the Press. Google Scholar

126.Kirkby, Voices from the Ships, 309–23. Google Scholar

127.Ibid., 319;Seamen’s Journal, June 1978; October 1984; January 1987. Google Scholar

128. Australian Woman’s Weekly, December 5, 1914. Google Scholar

129.Tusan, Women Making News, 1. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Kirkby, Diane