Labour History

Opposition to the Accord as a Social Contract in the 1980s

Labour History (2013), 105, (1), 47–62.

Abstract

The approaches that organised workers and their unions took to the Accord in the 1980s are typically explained in terms of consent and conformity, the suppression of worker dissent, or waning industrial militancy that might otherwise have enabled opposition. These explanations are problematic; the lack of a substantial challenge to the labour movement’s adherence to the Accord was not predetermined. In particular, some unionists were motivated to oppose the Accord because they thought, in various ways, that the Accord imposed a social contract on labour that subordinated it to capital. However, their actions were inconsistent and disparate. Some of those who held to this oppositional sensibility identified a regeneration of the political party Left, which would then guide and unite such action, but they did not try to implement it. The way was left open for a radical decline in union strength in the 1990s.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*The author would like to thank Doug Hunt and the two anonymous referees ofLabour Historyfor their valuable comments and suggestions. Google Scholar

1.Ashley Lavelle, The Death of Social Democracy: Political Consequences in the 21st Century(:Ashgate, 2008), 13. Compare: Joe Collins and Drew Cottle, “Labor Neoliberals or Pragmatic Neo-Laborists? The Hawke and Keating Labor Governments in Office, 1983–96,”Labour History, no. 98 (May 2010): 33–35. Google Scholar

2.Australian Centre for Industrial Relations Research and Training, Australia at Work: Just Managing?(:Prentice Hall, 1999), chs 2–6;Tom Bramble, Trade Unionism in Australia: A History from Flood to Ebb Tide(:Cambridge University Press, 2008), 125, 138–39;Ian Watson, John Buchanan, Iain Campbell and Chris Briggs, Fragmented Futures: New Challenges in Working Life(:Federation Press, 2003), 44, 95–101, 119–29. Google Scholar

3.Boris Frankel, “Picking up the Pieces,” Arena Magazine, no. 7 (October–November1993):5; Google Scholar

4.Mark Beeson, “Organised Labour in an Era of Global Transformation: Australia Reconstructed Revisited,” Journal of Australian Political Economy 39(June1997):68;Herb Thompson, “Raising Profit at Workers’ Expense,” Australian Left Review, no. 89 (Spring1984):15; Also:Mark Bray and Pat Walsh, “Accord and Discord: The Differing Fates of Corporatism under Labo(u)r Governments in Australia and New Zealand,” Labour & Industry 6, no. 3(October1995):21. Google Scholar

5.Tony Brown, “Silencing Dissent to Win Consent: National Training Reform in the Accord Years,” Labour & Industry 15, no. 1(2004):38–45;Boris Frankel, When the Boat Comes in: Transforming Australia in the Age of Globalisation(:Pluto Press, 2001), 208;Gerard Griffin, “The Authority of the ACTU,” Economic and Labour Relations Review 5, no. 1(1994):85–98;Scott MacWilliam, “Marginalising Opposition to the Accord,” Arena, no. 92 (1990):146–48;Anne O’Callaghan, “The Development and Adoption of the Accord and its Impact on Western Australian Trade Unions in the Aftermath”(Honours diss.,Curtin University of Technology, 1996), 33–36, 51;Liz Ross, Dare to Struggle, Dare to Win! Builders Labourers Fight Deregistration, 1981–94(:Vulgar Press, 2004), 117;Gerry R. Voll, “Time’s up for TUTA: A Corporatist Casualty,” Labour & Industry 8, no. 2(1997):88–95. Google Scholar

6.Chris Briggs, “The Paradox of ACTU Hegemony,” Labour & Industry 12, no. 3(2002):77, 86–95. Google Scholar

7.Brown, “Silencing Dissent,” 41;O’Callaghan, “The Development and Adoption of the Accord,” 31–33. Ian Hampson suggested a “much trodden career path from union leadership to political incumbency” was a key contributor to an inability of unions to campaign against the ALP:Ian Hampson, “The Accord: A Post-Mortem,” Labour & Industry 7, no. 2(1996):72–73. Google Scholar

8.Gwynneth Singleton, The Accord and the Australian Labour Movement(:Melbourne University Press, 1990), 197–98;Gwynneth Singleton, “The Accord in Retrospect,”inAustralia in Accord: An Evaluation of the Prices and Incomes Accord in the Hawke-Keating Years, ed.Kenneth Wilson, Joanne Bradford and Maree Fitzpatrick(:South Pacific Publishing, 2000), 87–92. Google Scholar

9.Peter Ewer, Ian Hampson, Chris Lloyd, John Rainford, Stephen Rix, Meg Smith, Politics and the Accord(:Pluto Press, 1991), 19–20, 78–83. Google Scholar

10.Bramble, Trade Unionism in Australia, 116–57. Google Scholar

11.Ibid., 131. Google Scholar

12.R. A. Foster, Australian Economic Statistics 1949–50 to 1994–95(:Reserve Bank of Australia, 1996), 187, 213;David Peetz, Unions in a Contrary World: The Future of the Australian Trade Union Movement(:Cambridge University Press, 1998), 5. Google Scholar

13.Lars T. Lih, Lenin Rediscovered: What Is to Be Done? In Context(:Haymarket, 2008), ch. 1. Google Scholar

14.Antonio Gramsci, “The Fable of the Beaver,”inSelections from the Prison Notebooks of Antonio Gramsci, ed.Quintin Hoare and Geoffrey Nowell Smith(:Lawrence and Wishart, 1971), 226. Google Scholar

15.Bramble did not make this outlook explicit in his book, but see Tom Bramble, “Social Democracy and the ‘Failure’ of the Accord,” in Wilson, Bradford and Fitzpatrick, Australia in Accord, 251, 257–58. For a critical discussion of this outlook, seeJohn Kelly, Trade Unions and Socialist Politics(:Verso, 1988), ch. 7. Google Scholar

16.Bramble, Trade Unionism in Australia, 251. Google Scholar

17.Ibid., 178. Google Scholar

19.Tom McDonald and Audrey McDonald, Intimate Union: Sharing a Revolutionary Life(:Pluto Press, 1998), 217–20, 225–26. Google Scholar

20.Peetz, Unions in a Contrary World, 151. Google Scholar

21.Jim McIlroy, “Meeting Discusses Labour Struggles after Wage Case,” Direct Action, 6 December1983, 13. Google Scholar

22.“Unions Reaffirm their Support for Accord,” The Metal Worker, May 1983, 1. Google Scholar

23. The Metal Worker, 1981–84. Google Scholar

24.ACTU Research Section, Wage Movements in the 60 Largest Federal Awards/Agreements, 10 August 1982, Australian Council of Trade Unions, N147, Box 580, Wage Rates W. J. Kelty 1981, Noel Butlin Archives (NBA), Canberra; Bramble, Trade Unionism in Australia, 116;Michael Rizzo, “The Left and the Accord” (MA diss., Latrobe University, 1991), 59. Google Scholar

25.John Burgess and Duncan Macdonald, “Productivity, Restructuring and the Trade Union Role,” Labour & Industry 3, no.1(March1990):44–57;Frank Enright, “Employers Plan to Break Waterfront Union,” Green Left Weekly, 23 February1994, accessed September 2013,https://www.greenleft.org.au/node/7204;Peetz, Unions in a Contrary World, 161–63. Google Scholar

26.Rowan Burns, “Why Should I Join the Union,” Australian Society(July1986):55; Google Scholar

27.Garry Whiteman, “Victorian Shunters Oppose Wage Freeze,” Direct Action, 19 April1983, 10;Bramble, Trade Unionism in Australia, 128. Google Scholar

28.Bramble, Trade Unionism in Australia, 133, 136, 147, 156–57;Mary Cassidy, “Metal Stewards Grudgingly Accept No-Strike Clause,” Direct Action, 11 October1983, 4;Ramani de Silva, “Heinz Strikers Defeat Freeze,” Direct Action, 24 August1983, 10;Ramani de Silva, “Food Preservers Battle Nestle Lockout,” Direct Action, 8 November1983, 11;Douglas Lorimer, “ALP, Union Tops Ram through Wage Freeze Accord,” Direct Action, 20 September1983, 3;Jim McIlroy, “Up Against the Accord,” Direct Action, 23 January1985, 3;“SA Nurses,” Direct Action, 11 October1983, 10;Brad Norrington, Sky Pirates: The Pilot’s Strike that Grounded Australia(:ABC Enterprises, 1990);Fred Phillips, “Qld Telecom Workers Say No!” Direct Action, 11 October1983, 10;Don Sutherland, “Metal Fatigue,” Australian Left Review, no. 85 (Spring1983):27;Janet Wilson, “Bell Street Delegates Sacked,” Direct Action, 20 March1985, 6. Google Scholar

29.Gerry R. Voll, “Time’s up for TUTA,” 92. Google Scholar

30.Amalgamated Metal Workers Union (AMWU)National Council, Minutes, March1987, AMWU Victorian Branch, 101/38, Box M9, National Council Meeting Minutes and Documents 1987, University of Melbourne Archives (UMA), Melbourne; AMWU Sydney Branch, Minutes, 1988, AMWU, Z102, Box 520, NBA; Greg Harrison, Metal Industry Award Restructuring, AMWU, Z102, Box 665, NBA. Other unionists who commented on the lack of a broad discussion in the unions of the Accord, include Gabriel Avery (Federated Clerks Union organiser), Hughie Williams (Transport Workers Union Brisbane sub-branch secretary), and Don Sutherland. For Avery, seeJanet Parker and Janice Ryan, “Workers, Women Unite Against Bjelke-Petersen,” Direct Action, 19 June1985, 3; for Williams, see“Talking Union,” Green Left Weekly, 10 July1991, accessed September 2013,https://www.greenleft.org.au/node/1011; for Sutherland, seeDon Sutherland, “Metal Fatigue,” 27. Google Scholar

31.Robert Ryan, “Sack Pack Friday at the Dockyards,” Direct Action, 3 September1986, 3. Google Scholar

32. The Metal Worker, March1987, 1;The Metal Worker, August1988, 8. Google Scholar

33.Catherine Brown, “WA Union Leaves ALP,” Direct Action, 30 October1990, 5. Google Scholar

34.Communist Party of Australia, National Executive Verbatim, 8 August 1981, Communist Party of Australia, ML MSS 5021, Box 9 (155), 1982 Congress, Mitchell Library (ML), Sydney, 18. Google Scholar

35.Ewer, Politics and the Accord, 110–11;Rizzo, “The Left and the Accord,” 70–71. Google Scholar

36.Douglas Lorimer, “Why Laurie Carmichael Attacks the Heinz Workers,” Direct Action, 20 September1983, 5. Google Scholar

37.Tom Bramble, Trade Unionism in Australia, 117–22;Rizzo, “The Left and the Accord,” 27–30, 35–37, 52, 64;Sean Scalmer and Terry Irving, “The Rise of the Modern Labour Technocrat: Intellectual Labour and the Transformation of the Amalgamated Metal Workers’ Union, 1973–85,” Labour History, no. 77 (November1998):71–74. Google Scholar

38.Brian Aarons, “Life under Labor,” Australian Left Review, no. 86 (Summer1983):20;Communist Party of Australia, 28th Congress 1984, Communist Party of Australia, ML MSS 5021, Box 11 (155), ML; Communist Party of Australia, Notes on the Accord and New Agreement between the ACTU and the Labor Government, March 1986, Communist Party of Australia, ML MSS 5021 add on 1936, Box 14 (76), NO Correspondence 1986, ML, 2–12;Rizzo, “The Left and the Accord,” 99. Google Scholar

39.Peter Ewer, “Vital Policy Issue Still Simmering,” Australian Society 4, no. 8(1985):27–29;Rizzo, “The Left and the Accord,” 65, 95, 132;The Metal Worker, July1984, 1, 9–12;The Metal Worker, April 1985, 3;The Metal Worker, May 1985, 3;The Metal Worker, June 1985, 3;The Metal Worker, July 1985, 7;Kim Windsor, “Workers Help Plan for Jobs,” Australian Society 4, no. 7(1985):20–21. Google Scholar

40.Robynne Murphy, “We Just Don’t Get Paid Enough,” Direct Action, 11 June1986, 6. Google Scholar

41.Laurie Carmichael, “Accord Stress,” The Metal Worker, May1986, 4;Communist Party of Australia, Notes on the Accord, March1986, 9–14;Doug Lorimer, “Accord’s Left Supporters Getting Nervous,” Direct Action, 16 April1986, 16;“Free Market Policies Strain Accord,” The Metal Worker, April1986, 1. Google Scholar

42.Rizzo, “The Left and the Accord,” 146–54. Google Scholar

43.Peter Botsman, “Rethinking the Class Struggle,” Arena, no. 82 (1988):34–52;Joe Palmada, “State of the Unions,” Australian Left Review, no. 103 (February–March1988):22; Google Scholar

44.Excerpts of this speech were republished as:“Radical One Day, ACTU President the Next,” Green Left Weekly, 13 September1995, accessed September 2013,https://www.greenleft.org.au/node/10742. Google Scholar

45.Rizzo, “The Left and the Accord,” 69–74. Google Scholar

46.Stan Sharkey, interview with author, 1994. Google Scholar

47.Brown, “Silencing Dissent to Win Consent,” 37. Google Scholar

48.Sharkey, Interview. Google Scholar

49.Sharkey, Interview. Google Scholar

50.Brown, “Silencing Dissent to Win Consent,” 37;Rizzo, “The Left and the Accord,” 91;Sharkey, Interview. Google Scholar

51.De Silva, “Heinz Strikers,” 10;Ramani de Silva, “Labor Bashes Food Preservers,” Direct Action, 28 November1984, 3;Reihana Mohideen and Tom Wilson, “Plumbers Support Wage Rise, Shorter Hours Drive,” Direct Action, 13 August1986, 3;Rizzo, “The Left and the Accord,” 22–27, 35–36, 38, 155–60. Google Scholar

52.Rizzo, “The Left and the Accord,” 75, 84, 86. Google Scholar

53.Sue Reilly, “Metal Unions Set Pace on Acceptance of Wage Cuts,” Direct Action, 4 October1983, 10. Google Scholar

54.Food Preservers Union, (file)“Nat. Wage Sept 84,”1984, Food Preservers Union, Box F5, UMA. Google Scholar

55.Rizzo, “The Left and the Accord,” 98. Google Scholar

56.T. D. Ryan to L. Kyriacou, 13 November1984, Food Preservers Union, F43, UMA, 2, emphasis added. Google Scholar

57.Ramani De Silva, “You Can’t Have Consensus Between Capital and Labor,” Direct Action, 30 January1985, 13. Google Scholar

58.Federated Confectioners Association, (file) “ALP Correspondence To/From,” 1989–90, Food Preservers Union, Box F5, UMA;“Victorian Left Unions May Leave ALP,” Direct Action, 31 January1989, 5;Steve Painter, “Hartley Calls for New Party,”16 July1986, 5. Google Scholar

59.O’Callaghan, “The Development and Adoption of the Accord,” 26. Google Scholar

60.Ibid., 44. Google Scholar

61.Michael Rowney, “Summit Communique Rebuffed,” Direct Action, 12 July1983, 14. Google Scholar

62.Ross, Dare to Struggle, 78;Michael Rowney, “WA delay,” Direct Action, 18 October1983. Google Scholar

63.Greg Harrison, ACTU meeting, green folder, 1988, AMWU, Z102, Box 667, NBA. The UTLC in SA had a similar position. Google Scholar

64.H. G. Truslove to Tom Ryan, 12 December1984, Food Preservers Union, Box F43, UMA, 2. Google Scholar

65.O’Callaghan, “The Development and Adoption of the Accord,” 23–26. Google Scholar

66.Ross, Dare to Struggle, 235. Google Scholar

67.Greg Harris, “Fighting the Accord Swindle,” Direct Action, 2 May1984, 6. Google Scholar

68.Greg Harris, “Accord: An Agreement with Ourselves,” Direct Action, 16 May1984, 10. Google Scholar

69.SeeHarris, “Fighting the Accord Swindle,” 6. Google Scholar

70.Australian Council of Trade Unions, Minutes 1989 Congress, 1989, ACTU Congresses, S784, Box 4, NBA; Phillip Bryne and Bill Mason, “Divide and Rule Beats Mail Sorters,”Direct Action, 30 October 1985, 5;Communist Party of Australia, Congress correspondence from National, 1984, Communist Party of Australia, Series MSS 5021, Box 11 (155), ML; Reihana Mohideen and Steve Painter, “Victorian Nurses Defy Government Threats,”Direct Action, 12 November 1986, 4–5;Janet Parker, “ETU Officials Oppose Action,” Direct Action, 29 November1985, 6;Chris Slee, “Tramways Union Secretary Ousted,” Direct Action, 28 November1989, 5;A Vehicle Builders Union member, “Officials Push GM-H Tradesmen Back to Work,” Direct Action, 10 October1984, 6;Garry Walters, “Secret Deals Defeat Melbourne Trammies,” Direct Action, 6 February1990, 14. Google Scholar

71.Reihana Mohideen, “Issues Facing the Labor Movement: An Interview with Pat Gorman,” Direct Action, 28 October1987, 7. Google Scholar

72.Sally Francis, “South Coast Miners Want Catch-up,” Direct Action, 18 October1983, 10. Google Scholar

73.John Garcia, “ACTU Wages Conference a Formality,” Direct Action, 8 April1987, 3. Google Scholar

74.Reihana Mohideen, “The Future of Australian Unionism and the Left: An Interview with Pat Gorman,” Direct Action, 4 November1987, 15;Mohideen, “Issues Facing the Labor Movement,” 7. Google Scholar

75.Matthew O’Halloran, “The Coal Crisis,” Direct Action, 5 August1987, 8–9;John Maitland, “Behind the Crisis in Coal,” Direct Action, 6 September1988, 7;Dick Nichols, “Coal Bosses Target Miners’ Award,” Direct Action, 29 June1988, 2;Stephen Robson, “ACTU Joins ALP, Bosses to Kill Wage Rises,” Direct Action, 30 August1988, 4. Google Scholar

76.Tom Wilson, “Miners, Power Workers in Dispute,” Direct Action, 4 May1988, 4. Google Scholar

77.Bradley Bowden, “A Collective Catastrophe: Productivity Maximisation and Workplace Bargaining in the Australian Coal Industry,” Journal of Industrial Relations 42, no. 3(2000):373;Nichols, “Coal Bosses,” 2;Dick Nichols, New Right Trade Unionism and the Crisis of the Left(:New Course, 1987), 25–27, Dick Nichols, “Stormy Meetings Protest Tribunal Decision,”Direct Action, 11 October 1988, 4. Google Scholar

78.John Adamson, David Grove, Garry Main and Norrian Rundle, “What Alternative to Keltyism?,” Direct Action, 22 May1990, 9. This article consists of the text of a speech by each author. Google Scholar

79.Ibid., 9. This reference is to the speech of David Grove, an Food Preservers Union official. Google Scholar

80.Rizzo, “The Left and the Accord,” 24. Google Scholar

81.Adamson et al., “What Alternative to Keltyism?,” 9. Google Scholar

82.Nichols, New Right Trade Unionism, introduction. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Strauss, Jonathan