Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

Modern Labor in Queensland: Its Rise and Failings, 1978–98

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2013), 105, (1), 1–26.

Abstract

This article explores the emergence of “modern Labor” in Queensland. Previously under Trades Hall control, Queensland Labor was transformed in 1980 when the Reform Group gained control after intervention by Labor’s Federal Executive. Between 1989 and 2012 it was only out of office once (1996–98). Labor’s restructure, however, brought neither rank-and-file involvement nor a substantial membership. Authority was vested in factional powerbrokers. Whereas prior to 1980 Queensland Labor was a union-controlled party (ie a labour party), it now became a faction-controlled party.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*The author would like to thank the two anonymous referees ofLabour Historyfor their comments and suggestions. Google Scholar

2.Steve Bracks, John Faulkner and Bob Carr, 2010 National Review: Report to the ALP National Executive(:ALP National Secretariat, 2010), 11, 9. Google Scholar

3.Bracks, Faulkner and Carr, 2010 National Review, 10–11. (Note: on p. 13 the Review indicates 45,000 members, but the Table on p. 10 suggests 38,000 members.) See also,Troy Bramston, “Troglodyte Club Refuses to Reform,” Australian, 5 December2011, 12. Google Scholar

4.These include,David Clune and Rodney Smith, ed., From Carr to Keneally: Labor in Office in NSW 1995–2011(:Allen & Unwin, 2012);Simon Benson, Betrayal: The Underbelly of Australian Labor(:Pantera Press, 2010);Troy Bramston, Looking for the Light on the Hill: Modern Labor’s Challenges(:Scribe Publications, 2011);Maxine McKew, Tales from the Political Trenches(:Melbourne University Press, 2012);Lindsay Tanner, Politics with Purpose(:Melbourne University Press, 2012);Frank Sartor, Fog on the Hill: How NSW Labor Lost its Way(:Melbourne University Press, 2011);David Marr, “The Political Journey of Kevin Rudd,” Quarterly Essay 38(June 2010);Tom Bramble and Rick Kuhn, Labor’s Conflict: Big Business, Workers and the Politics of Class(:Cambridge University Press, 2011);Bradley Bowden, “From Defeat to Catastrophe: The Labor Party in Rural New South Wales, 1988–2011,” Labour History, no. 103 (November 2011):227–46. Google Scholar

5.Rodney Cavalier, Power Crisis: The Self-Destruction of a State Labor Party(:Cambridge University Press, 2010);Rodney Cavalier, “Could Chifley Win Labor Preselection Today?,”inComing to the Party: Where to Next for Labor?, ed.Barry Jones(:Melbourne University Press, 2006), 57–65;Rodney Cavalier, “The Labor Party,”in Clune and Smith, From Carr to Keneally, 3–14. Google Scholar

6.Nick Dyrenfurth and Tim Soutphommasane, “Postscript,”inAll that’s Left: What Labor Should Stand For, ed.Nick Dyrenfurth and Tim Soutphommasane(:Australian Scholarly Publishing, 2010), 209. Google Scholar

7.Michael Hogan, Local Labor: A History of the Labor Party in Glebe 1891–2003(:Federation Press, 2004), 212. Google Scholar

8.Vere Gordon Childe, How Labour Governs(:Melbourne University Press, 1963), 20. Google Scholar

9.Frank Bongiorno, “Remembering Ol’ 55: The Victorian Fabian Society and the Road to Intervention,”inThe Great Labor Schism: A Retrospective, ed.Brian Costar, Peter Love and Paul Strangio(:Scribe, 2005), 324–39;Paul Strangio, “Closing the Split: Before and After Federal Intervention in the Victorian ALP,” in Costar, Love and Strangio, The Great Labor Schism, 340–65. Google Scholar

10.Strangio, “Closing the Split,” 356. Google Scholar

11.Ross Fitzgerald and Harold Thornton, Labor in Queensland: From the 1880s to 1988(:University of Queensland Press, 1989). Google Scholar

12.Peter Beattie, In the Arena: Memoirs of an ALP State Secretary(:Boolarong, 1990);Peter Beattie, Making a Difference(:HarperCollins, Sydney, 2005);Wayne Swan, “The Labor Party,”inPolitical Crossroads: The 1989 Queensland Election, ed.Rosemary Whip and Colin Hughes(:University of Queensland Press, 1991), 96–112. Google Scholar

13.The Labor literature is best reviewed in, Nick Dyrenfurth, “Labour and Politics,” Labour History, no. 100 (November 2011):105–26. Google Scholar

14.Bramble and Kuhn, Labor’s Conflict, 24. Google Scholar

15.The most significant Marxist accounts are: Robin Gollan, Radical and Working Class Politics: A Study of Eastern Australia 1850–1910(:Melbourne University Press, 1960);Ian Turner, Industrial Labour and Politics: The Dynamics of the Labour Movement in Eastern Australia, 1900–1920(:Hale & Iremonger, 1979);Verity Burgmann, “InOur Time”: Socialism and the Rise of Labor, 1885–1905(:George Allen & Unwin, 1985). Google Scholar

16.Peter Beilharz, Transforming Labor: Labour Tradition and the Labor Decade in Australia(:Cambridge University Press, 1994);Graham Maddox, The Hawke Government and the Labor Tradition(:Penguin, 1989);Andrew Scott, Fading Loyalties: The Australian Labor Party and the Working Class(:Pluto Press, 1991). Google Scholar

17.Humphrey McQueen, A New Britannia(:Penguin, 1970);Ann Curthoys and Andrew Markus, ed., Who are Our Enemies? Racism and the Working Class in Australia(:Hale & Iremonger, 1978);R. W. McConnell and T. H. Irving, Class Structure in Australian History(:Longman Cheshire, 1980). Google Scholar

18.John Norton, ed., The History of Capital and Labour in All Lands and Ages(:Oceanic Publishing, 1888);George Black, Labor in Politics: The New South Wales Labor Party(:Workman, 1894);William Spence, Australia’s Awakening(:Worker Trustees, 1909). Google Scholar

19.Keith Hancock, Australia(:Ernest Benn, 1930);Bede Nairn, Civilising Capitalism: The Beginnings of the Australian Labor Party(:Melbourne University Press, 1973);D. J. Murphy, R. B. Joyce and Colin Hughes, ed., Prelude to Power: The Rise of the Labour Party in Queensland 1885–1915(:Jacaranda Press, 1970);D. J. Murphy, ed., Labor in Politics: The State Labor Parties in Australia 1880–1920(:University of Queensland Press, 1975);Jim Hagan and Ken Turner, A History of the Labor Party in New South Wales 1891–1991(:Longman Cheshire, 1991). Google Scholar

20.Hancock, Australia, 198. Google Scholar

21.John Rickard, Class and Politics: New South Wales, Victoria and the Early Commonwealth, 1890–1910(:ANU Press, 1976);Bruce Scates, A New Australia: Citizenship, Radicalism and the First Republic(:Cambridge University Press, 1997);Frank Bongiorno, The People’s Party: Victorian Labor and the Radical Tradition, 1875–1914(:Melbourne University Press, 1996);Nick Dyrenfurth, Heroes and Villains: The Rise and Fall of the Early Labor Party(:Australian Scholarly Publishing, 2011). Google Scholar

22.Barry Jones, “Where are We Coming From,”in Jones, Coming to the Party, 3–28;John Button, “Beyond Belief: What Future for Labor?,”in Jones, Coming to the Party, 47–56;John Faulkner, “Apathy and Anger,”in Jones, Coming to the Party, 66–78;Cavalier, “The Labor Party,” 3–14;Cavalier, Power Crisis;Cavalier, “Could Chifley Win,”57–65. Google Scholar

23.Cavalier, Power Crisis, 51–52. Google Scholar

24.Cavalier, Power Crisis, 184. Google Scholar

25.Robert Michels, Political Parties: A Sociological Study of the Oligarchical Tendencies of Modern Democracy(:Peter Smith, 1978), 52. Google Scholar

26.Paul Kelly, The End of Certainty: Power, Politics and Business in Australia(:Allen & Unwin, 2008), 20–21. Google Scholar

27.Nick Dyrenfurth, “It’s the Culture, Stupid,”in Dyrenfurth and Soutphommasane, All that’s Left, 26. Google Scholar

28.In particular, Vicky Braund, “Timely Vibrations: Labor’s Marketing Campaign,”inLabor to Power: Australia’s 1972 Election, ed.Henry Mayer(:Angus & Robertson, 1973), 18–28;Neal Blewett, “Labor 1968–1972: Planning for Victory,”in Mayer, Labor to Power, 6–16. Google Scholar

29.Bracks, Faulkner and Carr, 2010 National Review, 9. Google Scholar

30.Dyrenfurth and Soutphommasane, “Postscript,” 210. Google Scholar

31.Bradley Bowden, Simon Blackwood, Cath Rafferty and Cameron Allan, ed., Work & Strife in Paradise: The History of Labour Relations in Queensland 1859–2009(:Federation Press, 2009), 304–5. Google Scholar

32.Brian Costar, “For the Love of Christ, Mick, Don’t Hit Him,”in Costar, Love and Strangio, The Great Labor Schism, 62. Google Scholar

33.Mark Hearn and Harry Knowles, One Big Union: A History of the Australian Workers Union 1886–1994(:Federation Press, 1996), 250–51. Google Scholar

34.Denis Murphy, Address to Labor Members: Bardon RSL, 5 February1978, series OMEQ/62/57, Box 2624, John Oxley Library (hereafter JOL), Brisbane. Google Scholar

35.Centre Caucus, Submission to the ALP National Executive on the Queensland ALP, circa November 1979, series OMEQ/62/57, Box 2721, JOL, 8. Google Scholar

36.Socialist Left, “What Now? Socialist Left View,”c. 1980, series 2657, Terry Hampson file, JOL, 1. Google Scholar

37.Bowden et al., Work & Strife in Paradise, 299–300, 305. Google Scholar

38.Compiled from Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS), Census: Historical Data, 1976–96, accessed September2013 http://www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/censushome.nsf/home/historicaldata?opendocument&navpos=280. Google Scholar

39.Unless otherwise stated, the electoral statistics cited in this article are drawn from ABC News, Antony Green’s Electoral Publication Archive, accessed September 2013,www.abc.net.au/elections/archive/#qld. Google Scholar

40.Australian, 7–8 May1988, 8. Google Scholar

41.Peter Beattie, State of the Party Report, 29 June1980, 3, series OMEQ/62/57, Box 2721, JOL. Google Scholar

42.Labor Party(Queensland) Membership Committee Minutes, 16 May 1983, series OMEQ/62/57, Box 2676, JOL. Google Scholar

43.Peter Beattie, Labor (Queensland) State Secretary’s Report to State Council, 13 April1985, series 3163, Box 4733, JOL;Peter Beattie, Labor (Queensland) State Secretary’s Report to State Council, 6–8 August 1988, 21, 23, series 27249, Box 15682, JOL;Lindsay Jones, Labor (Queensland) Assistant Secretary’s Report to State Council, 28 November 1992, 5–6, series 27249, Box 15682, JOL;Mile Kaiser, Labor (Queensland) State Secretary’s Report to State Conference, 7–9 June 1997, 10, series 27249, Box 15685, JOL. Google Scholar

44.Adrian McGregor, “Labor Reformers in Queensland,” National Times, 27 March – 1 April1978, 29;Beattie, In the Arena, 14–15. Google Scholar

45.Malcolm Mackerras, “The Swing: Variability and Uniformity,”in Mayer, Labor to Power, 234–41;Blewett, “Labor 1968–72,” 12. Google Scholar

46.Labor Reform Group, Case for Reform(:Labor Reform Group, 1978), 7, 10–11. Google Scholar

47.Calculated from ABS, Census: Historical Data, 1976, 1986 and 1996, accessed September 2013,http://www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/censushome.nsf/home/historicaldata?opendocument&navpos=280. Google Scholar

48.Loyal Labor Members, “Expel these Grubs: They are Traitors to the Labor Cause,”Brisbane1978, Denis Murphy Collection (hereafter DMC), Fryer Library, Brisbane;Bob Hendricks, Letter to ALP Members, 22 April 1978, series OMEQ/62/57, Box 2721, JOL. Google Scholar

49.Australian, 17 January1980, 2. Google Scholar

50.Peter Beattie, News Release: Reform Group, 25 July1978, series OMEQ/62/57, Box 2721, JOL. Google Scholar

51.Beattie, Arena, 49;Centre Caucus Newsletter 1, no. 1(1979):1; Google Scholar

52. Socialist Challenge, October1978, 1. Google Scholar

53.Strangio, “Closing the Split,” 355. Google Scholar

54.Denis Murphy, ALP: State of Queensland, Administrative Committee Circular, 26 February1981, series OMEQ/62/57, Box 2721, JOL. Google Scholar

55.Socialist Left, “What Now?,” 1. Google Scholar

56.Centre Caucus, Centre Caucus Newsletter, June 1980, OMEQ/62/57, Box 2695, JOL, 2–4. Google Scholar

57.Labor Party(Queensland) Administrative Committee Minutes, 18 March 1980, series 2657, Terry Hampson File, JOL. Google Scholar

58.Denis Murphy, ALP State Secretaryship: Confidential Paper, 31 August1981, 4–5, Box 2, DMC. Google Scholar

59.Fitzgerald and Thornton, Labor in Queensland, 318. Google Scholar

60.Murphy, Secretaryship, 2, 5. Google Scholar

61.Madeleine McPherson and Kev Hooper, Report on the Tour of South West Queensland, March1980, series 2657, Terry Hampson File, JOL. Google Scholar

62.Denis Murphy, Correspondence to John Button, 19 August1981, Box 2, DMC. Google Scholar

63.Swan, “Labor Party,” 100–1. Google Scholar

64.Denis Murphy, Centre Majority Faction Meeting, 6 July1982, Box 4, DMC. Google Scholar

65.Fitzgerald and Thornton, Labor in Queensland, 318;Denis Murphy, Correspondence to Bill Hayden, 20 August1981, Box 2, DMC. Google Scholar

66.Centre Majority, “What is Centre Majority?,”Brisbane1984, series 2657, Terry Hampson File, JOL. Google Scholar

67.Australian, 27 June1984, 1. Google Scholar

68.Beattie, Labor(Queensland) State Secretary’s Report to State Council, 13 April1985. Google Scholar

69.Rob Whiddon, Urgent Notice to Centre Caucus Members, 4 February1980, series OMEQ/62/57, Box 2695, JOL. Google Scholar

70.Jackie Byrne, “Centre Majority: Power & Principle,”June1984, series 2657, Terry Hampson File, JOL. Google Scholar

71.Criminal Justice Commission (CJC), The Shepherdson Inquiry: An Investigation into Electoral Fraud(:CJC, 2001), 100–14. Google Scholar

72.Cited, CJC, The Shepherdson Inquiry, 23. Google Scholar

73.Labor Party (North Cairns), Resolution to State Council, June1986, series 3290, Box 4743, JOL. Google Scholar

74.David Barbagallo, “Testimony to the Shepherdson Inquiry,” Shepherdson Inquiry: Redacted Transcripts of Mike Kaiser, Lee Bermingham, Warwick Powell and David Barbagallo(:Crime and Misconduct Commission, 2001), 3052, 3044. Google Scholar

75.Sue Yarrow, “Top Dog to Old Hat: Jack Egerton and the Trades Hall Group, 1957 to 1980,” Queensland Journal of Labour History, no. 16 (2013):30;Howard Guille and Ross Gwyther, “Interview with Dick Williams: President of the Queensland Branch of the ALP and former Secretary of the ETU,” Queensland Journal of Labour History, no. 16 (2013):38; Google Scholar

76.John Campbell, Circular to All Socialist Left Members, 12 January1987, series OMEQ / 72, JOL. Google Scholar

77.Beattie, Arena, 36–44. Google Scholar

78.ANOP Research, Four Old Marginal Seats(:ANOP, 1986), 3. Google Scholar

79.ABS, Census of Population and Housing: Selected Family and Labour Force Characteristics, Australia, 1996, no. 2017.0 (1998): 37, accessed September 2013,http://www.ausstats.abs.gov.au/ausstats/subscriber.nsf/0/CA25687100069892CA2568890026FEBE/$File/20170_1996.pdf. Google Scholar

80.Centre Majority, Centre Majority News Circular, c. January1984, series 2657, Terry Hampson File, JOL, 4. Google Scholar

81.Labor (Queensland)Political Strategy Committee Minutes, 12 September 1987, series 3290, Box 4750, JOL. Google Scholar

82.Fitzgerald and Thornton, Labor in Queensland, 357. Google Scholar

83.Swan, “Labor Party,” 99. Google Scholar

84.John Wanna, “Queensland: Consociational Factionalism or Ignoble Cabal,”inThe Machine: Labor Confronts the Future, ed.John Warnhurst and Andrew Parkin(:Allen & Unwin, 2000), 130. Google Scholar

85.Cited, CJC, Shepherdson Inquiry, 1;Queensland Court of Appeal, Queen v Karen Ehrmann, case 253 of 2000, 21 February 2001, accessed September 2013,http://archive.sclqld.org.au/qjudgment/2001/QCA01–050.pdf. Google Scholar

86.CJC, Shepherdson Inquiry, 21, viv-xviii, 170. Google Scholar

87.Cited, CJC, Shepherdson Inquiry, 108–9. Google Scholar

88.CJC, Shepherdson Inquiry, 112. Google Scholar

89.CJC, Shepherdson Inquiry, 33. Google Scholar

90.Cited CJC, Shepherdson Inquiry, 30. Google Scholar

91.Labor (Queensland)Companies Board Minutes, 29 February 1988, series 3290, Box 4746, JOL. Google Scholar

92. Queensland Labor Party Return, 1998–99(:Australian Electoral Commission, 1999). Google Scholar

93.John Budd, Treasurer’s Report to Labor (Queensland) State Council, 25 March1995, series 27249, Box 5688, JOL. Google Scholar

94.Mike Kaiser, Correspondence to Kurilpa Branch, 1 October1996;Mike Kaiser, Correspondence to Chardons Corner Branch, 1 October1996, series 27249, Boxes 15695 and 15698, JOL. Google Scholar

95.Beattie, Labor (Queensland) State Secretary’s Report to State Council, 6–8 August1988;Jones, Labor (Queensland) Assistant Secretary’s Report to State Council, 28 November1992. Google Scholar

96.CJC, Shepherdson Inquiry, 29. Google Scholar

97.Jones, Labor (Queensland) Assistant Secretary’s Report to State Council, 28 November1992. Google Scholar

98.Mike Keane, Correspondence to Peter Beattie, 7 October1997, series 27249, Box 15699, JOL. Google Scholar

99. Queensland Parliamentary Debates(QPD)(26 May1995):12104. Google Scholar

100.QPD(11 April1991):7134, 7481. Google Scholar

101.Labor Party (Queensland), The Young Inquiry: The ALP Queensland Branch Committee of Inquiry into the 1995 State Election Results(:Labor Party, October1995), 8–9. Google Scholar

102.Reproduced in, Laurie Gillespie, “Public Sector Reform: Renaissance or Rout?”inPublic Sector Reform Under the First Goss Government, ed.Glyn Davis(:Griffith University, 1993), 283. Google Scholar

103.Glyn Davis, “Executive and Policy Co-ordination,”inThe Goss Government: Promise and Performance of Labor in Queensland, ed.Bron Stevens and John Wanna(:Macmillan, 1993), 32–50. Google Scholar

104.“Transcript of Interview with Mike Kaiser, 16 May 1996,”inElectoral Wrath: The 1995 Queensland General Election, ed.Andrew Fraser(:Griffith University, 1997), 94. Google Scholar

105.ABS, Commonwealth Census of Population and Housing: Characteristics of Population and Dwellings in Local Government Areas, Queensland, 1971, no. 2429.0 (1978):4, accessed September 2013,http://www.ausstats.abs.gov.au/ausstats/free.nsf/0/ABA3DAEA88A4E9D6CA257589000F0416/$File/24290_1976_LGA_QLD.pdf;ABS, Commonwealth Census of Population and Housing: Characteristics of Queensland, 1991, no. 2710.3 (1993):31, 73, accessed September 2013,http://www.ausstats.abs.gov.au/ausstats/free.nsf/0/1AD7ACAE3C0CC34BCA2574BE0083393A/$File/27103_1991_60_Census_Characteristics_of_Queensland.pdf. Google Scholar

106.Nicholas Rothwell, “Hanson’s Heartland,” Australian, 6–7 July1998, 22. Google Scholar

107.ABS, Commonwealth Census of Population and Housing: Selected Family and Labour Force Characteristics for Statistical Local Areas, Queensland, 1996, no 2017.3 (1998):9, 12–13, 30, 34, accessed September 2013,http://www.ausstats.abs.gov.au/Ausstats/subscriber.nsf/0/CA25687100069892CA256889001FFD8E/$File/20173_1996.pdf. Google Scholar

108.ABS, Census of Population and Housing: Selected Family and Labour Force Characteristics, Australia, 1996, no. 2017.0 (1998):37. Google Scholar

109.Parliament of Australia, 1998 Queensland Election, accessed September 2013,http://www.aph.gov.au/About_Parliament/Parliamentary_Departments/Parliamentary_Library/Publications_Archive/CIB/cib9899/99CIB02. Google Scholar

110.See, for example, Paul Williams, “How Did They Do It? Explaining Queensland Labor’s Second Electoral Hegemony,” Queensland Review 18(2011):112–33. Google Scholar

111.Queensland Treasury, Annual Economic Report 2009–10(:Queensland Treasury, 2010), 3–16. Google Scholar

112.Dean Jaensch, Peter Brent and Brett Bowen, Australian Political Parties in the Spotlight(:Australian National University, 2004), 55. Google Scholar

113.Michael McKenna, “Grassroots Abandon ALP,” Australian, 28 March2013, 1, 6. Google Scholar

114.Australian Electoral Commission (AEC), Australian Labor Party State of Queensland: Disclosure Return 2006–07(:Australian Electoral Commission, 2007);AEC, Australian Labor Party State of Queensland: Disclosure Return 2010–11(:Australian Electoral Commission, 2011). Google Scholar

115.AEC, Labor Holdings Pty Ltd: Associated Entity Disclosure Return 2002–03(:Australian Electoral Commission, 2003);AEC, Labor Holdings Pty Ltd: Associated Entity Disclosure Return 2005–06(:Australian Electoral Commission, 2006);AEC, Labor Holdings Pty Ltd: Associated Entity Disclosure Return 2011–12(:Australian Electoral Commission, 2012). Google Scholar

116.Michael McKenna, “ALP Eyes Union Cash Bailout,” Australian, 3–4 August2013, 7. Google Scholar

117.AEC, Australian Labor Party State of Queensland: Disclosure Return 2010–11, 1–7. Google Scholar

118.Murphy, Address, 6. Google Scholar

119.Michels, Political Parties, 52. Google Scholar

120.Karl Marx, “The Eighteen Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte,” Collected Works of Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, Volume 1(:Foreign Languages Publishing House, 1951), 225. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Bowden, Bradley