Labour History

Black-Bans and Black Eyes: Implications of the 1971 Springbok Rugby Tour

Labour History (2015), 108, (1), 145–163.

Abstract

The 1971 Springbok rugby tour has become infamous for disruptive anti-apartheid protests, which culminated in the declaration of a State of Emergency in Queensland. Opposed to the racist selection policies of the South African national team, the trade union movement and the New Left attempted to directly stop the tour. Conservative governments took extreme measures to undermine a union black-ban, while rugby games were marred by clashes between police and demonstrators. This article offers the first sustained examination of this protest campaign. It traces efforts to stop the tour, connecting the role of the union movement to that of the New Left, and examines the reactions of governments and police forces.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*This article is based on my honours thesis, entitled“‘There were Two Games Going on’: Disruptive Protest and the 1971 Springbok Tour”(Hons thesis,School of Historical Studies, University of Melbourne2012). It has been revised, abridged, and procrastinated over, but its argument remains intact. I would like to thank my supervisor, Professor Stuart Macintyre, who provided invaluable assistance in the planning, research, and writing of the thesis. I benefitted greatly from his influence. I would also like to thank Associate Professor Sean Scalmer, who assessed the initial thesis, andLabour History‘s two anonymous referees. Google Scholar

1.Most dedicated works on the tour were narrative accounts published in its immediate aftermath. SeeStewart Harris, Political Football: The Springbok Tour of Australia, 1971(:Gold Star Publications, 1972);Mark Steer, The Whole World Watched(:K. Howard, 1971). Andrew Bear used the tour for a media analysis case study in“Demonstrations and the Australian Press,” Politics 7, no. 2(1972):155–59. Brief, salient treatments of the subject appear in the historiography of Australian protest movements. SeeChristine Jennett, “Signals to South Africa: The Australian Anti-Apartheid Movement,”inPolitics of the Future: The Role of Social Movements, ed.Christine Jennett andRandal G. Stewart(:Macmillan, 1989), 98–155;Jennifer Clark, “‘The Wind of Change’ in Australia: Aborigines and the International Politics of Race, 1960–1972,” International History Review 20, no. 1(1998):91–93;C. A. Rootes, “The Development of Radical Student Movements and Their Sequlae,” Australian Journal of Politics and History 43, no. 2(1988):182;Sean Scalmer, Dissent Events: Protest, the Media, and the Political Gimmick in Australia(:University of NSW Press, 2002), 23–24;Robin Gerster andJan Basset, Seizures of Youth: The Sixties and Australia(:Hyland House, 1991), 79–82. Google Scholar

2.Roger Fieldhouse, Anti-Apartheid: A History of the Movement in Britain: A Study in Pressure Group Politics(:Merlin Press, 2005), 6–16;Clark, “The Wind of Change,” 91–93. Google Scholar

3.Commonwealth Parliamentary Debates, House of Representatives (CPDHR) 71–72(6 April1971):1456. Google Scholar

4.Ibid.Paul Webster, “PM Accuses the Unions,” Australian, 28 June1971. Google Scholar

5.Douglas Booth andColin Tatz, One-Eyed: A View of Australian Sport(:Allen and Unwin, 2000), 156;“Play Cricket with South Africa,” Australian Gallup Polls, release 2255A, March1971. Google Scholar

6.Geoffrey Bolton, The Oxford History of Australia, vol. 5, 1942–1995: The Middle Way, 2nd edn (:Oxford University Press, 1996), 166–70;Scalmer, Dissent Events, 23–24. Google Scholar

7.Editorial, “Taking Sides on South Africa,” Sunday Australian, 27 June1971. Google Scholar

8.Brian Kennedy, “Southern African Immigration in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries,”inThe Australian People: An Encylopedia of the Nation, its People and their Origins, ed.James Jupp(:Cambridge University Press, 2001), 688–89. Google Scholar

9.SeeHakan Thorn, Anti-Apartheid and the Emergence of a Global Civil Society(:Palgrave Macmillan, 2006), xiv–18;Drew Hutton andLibby Connors, A History of the Australian Environment Movement(:Cambridge University Press, 1999), 4–5;Verity Burgmann, Power, Profit and Protest: Australian Social Movements and Globalisation(:Allen and Unwin, 2003), 15–19. Google Scholar

10.Burgmann, Power, Profit and Protest. Google Scholar

11.Frederic Jameson, “Periodising the 60s,”inThe Ideologies of Theory, Essays: 1971–86, vol. 2, The Syntax of History(:Routledge, 1988), 180–85. Google Scholar

12.SeeBurgmann, Power, Profit and Protest, 18 Google Scholar

13.Jennett, “Signals to South Africa,” 105–106. Google Scholar

14.Jennifer Clark, Aborigines & Activism: Race, Aborigines & the Coming of the 60s(:University of Western Australia Press, 2008), 1–3, 33–4, 135. Google Scholar

15.Fieldhouse, Anti-Apartheid, 18–21;David R. Black, “‘Not Cricket’: The Effects and Effectiveness of the Sport Boycott,”inHow Sanctions Work: Lessons from South Africa, ed.Neta C. Crawford andAudie Klotz(:Macmillan, 1999), 213–31;Douglas Booth, The Race Game: Sport and Politics in South Africa(:Frank Cass, 1998), 89–95, 99;Dennis Brutus, The Dennis Brutus Tapes: Essays at Autobiography, ed.Bernth Lindfors(:James Currey, 2011), 121. Google Scholar

16.Dennis Brutus, “Sport and Apartheid,” Current Affairs Bulletin 46, no. 12(October1970):179. Also seeChris De Broglio, South Africa: Racism in Sport(:Christian Action Publications, 1970). Google Scholar

17.Father R. J. Buckhorn quoted by Dr Richard Klugman inCPDHR 71–72 (22 April1971):1957. Google Scholar

18.Claude Forell, “Hooliganism Won’t Help the Africans,” Age, 1 July1971. Google Scholar

19.SeeW. E. H. Stanner, After the Dreaming: The 1968 Boyer Lectures(:ABC, 1968), 18–29. Google Scholar

20.SeeJennett, “Signals to South Africa,” 108–17;Political Football(video), written and directed by James Middleton(:ABC, 2005);Thorn, Anti-Apartheid, 2;David Hostetter, “‘An International Alliance of People of All Nations Against Racism’: Non-Violence and Solidarity in the Antiapartheid Activism of the American Committee on Africa, 1952–65,” Peace and Change 32, no. 2(2007):134–52. Google Scholar

21.Scalmer, Dissent Events, 69. Google Scholar

22.Brutus, “Sport and Apartheid,” 180. Google Scholar

23.Peter Hain, Don’t Play with Apartheid: The Background to the Stop the Seventy Tour Campaign(:George Allen & Unwin, 1971), 11, 84–85. Google Scholar

24.Ibid.;April Carter, Direct Action and Liberal Democracy(:Routledge and Kegan and Paul, 1973), 57–59. Google Scholar

25.Jennett, “Signals to South Africa,” 109, 115–16;Penny O’Donnell andLynette Simons, eds, Australians Against Racism: Testimonies from the Anti-Apartheid Movement in Australia(:Pluto Press, 1995), 6–8. Google Scholar

26.The Anti-Apartheid Movement (Sydney), Protesters Guidebook, or, How to Make Sure There Will Be No More All-White Springbok Sporting Tours of Australia and How to Do Your Darndest to Stop the Rugby Games in which the Springboks Play in July and August 1971(:Anti-Apartheid Movement, 1971), 2. See alsoDe Broglio, South Africa, 37. Google Scholar

27.Dennis Altman, “Don’t Shoot, We are Your Children,”inComing Out in the Seventies(:Wild and Woolley, 1979), 193–95;Peter Hain, “Direct Action and the Springbok Tours,”inDirect Action and Democratic Politics, ed.Robert Benewick andTrevor Smith(:George Allen & Unwin, 1972), 201. Google Scholar

28. CPDHR 71–72 (22 April1971):1955. See also editorial,“Time to Choose,” Australian, 25 June1971; editorial,“Taking Sides on South Africa,” Sunday Australian, 27 June1971; editorial,“Time to Go Home,” Age, 2 July1971; editorial,“The Departing Springboks,” Courier Mail, 3 August1971. Google Scholar

29.Robert Duffield, “Who is Running the Country?” Australian, 26 June1971. Google Scholar

30. CPDHR 71–72 (22 April1971):1955;Blanche D’Alpuget, Hawke: The Early Years(,Melbourne University Press, 2010), 291;Patricia Bowden, “Hawke’s Return Foreshadows Reformist-Revolutionary Conflict,” Australian Financial Review, 30 July1971. Google Scholar

31.“ACTU Executive Minutes, 13 May 1971,”inAustralian Trade Unionism in Documents, ed.Jim Hagan(:Longman Cheshire, 1986), 208–10. SeeD’Alpuget, Hawke, 290–99,John Hurst, Hawke: The Definitive Biography(:Angus and Robertson, 1979), 99–101. Google Scholar

32.Tom Bramble, Trade Unionism in Australia: A History from Flood to Ebb Tide(:Cambridge University Press, 2008), 55;D. W. Rawson, Unions and Unionists in Australia(:Allen and Unwin, 1978), 136;D’Alpuget, Hawke, 263–68, 272. Google Scholar

33.SeeBurgmann, Power, Profit and Protest, 19–20. See alsoVerity Burgmann andMeredith Burgmann, Green Bans, Red Union: Environmental Activism and the New South Wales Builders Labourers’ Federation(:UNSW Press, 1998), 121–32. Google Scholar

34.Bob Hawke, The Hawke Memoirs(:Heinemann, 1994), 58–59;D’Alpuget, Hawke, 290. Google Scholar

35.“No Business of Unions to Interfere, Says Lynch,” Age, 5 July1971;“ACTU Chief Can’t Take Role of PM, Says Labor MP,” Australian, 28 June 71;Ian Carroll, “Is Hawke Running the Country?” Age, 2 July1971. See alsoRupert Lockwood, War on the Waterfront: Menzies, Japan and the Pig-Iron Dispute(:Hale and Ironmonger, 1987), 39. Google Scholar

36.Paul Webster, “McMahon Offers a VIP Jet for Tour,” Australian, 26 June1971;Carroll, “Is Hawke Running the Country?”;Hurst, Hawke, 101. Google Scholar

37.SeeCarroll, “Is Hawke Running the Country?”;Hurst, Hawke, 101. Google Scholar

38.“Tasmanian TLC Man Gives a Rap to Hawke,” Age, 3 July1971. Google Scholar

39.“Australian Political Chronicle, May—August 1971: The Commonwealth,” Australian Journal of Politics and History 17, no. 3(1971):416–28;“Public Supports McMahon’s L-CP,” Australian Gallup Polls, no. 2253(March1971);Jenny Hocking, Gough Whitlam: A Moment in History, vol. 1(:Miegunyah Press, 2009), 337. Google Scholar

40.“Play Cricket with South Africa,” Australian Gallup Polls, no. 2255A (March1971);“Cricket with South Africa is Alright,” Australian Gallup Polls, no. 2270A(May1971). Google Scholar

41.Bear, “Demonstrations and the Australian Press,” 155–59. Google Scholar

42.Editorial, “Cynical Misuse of Prime Minister’s Power,” Australian, 26 June1971; editorial,“Taking Sides on South Africa,” Sunday Australian, 27 June1971;Bruce Grant, “Government Gaffe Makes Protest Essential,” Age, 30 June1971; editorial;“Air Cover for Apartheid,” Nation, 10 July1971. Google Scholar

43.“Lawyers Urge PM to Stop Rugby Tour,” Australian, 8 July1971. Google Scholar

44.See“ACTU Executive Minutes, 24 May 1938,”inAustralian Trade Unionism in Documents, 126–27;Lockwood, War on the Waterfront, 222–34. Google Scholar

45.“Springbok Tour in Balance as Vital Talks Held,” Australian, 24 June1971; Interview with Mr. Hawke on the ABC in Launceston, 23 June 1971 (transcript), in Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Central Office, South Africa: Relations with Australian Sporting Teams, A1838, 201/10/10/3 part 2, National Archives of Australia. Google Scholar

46.For details of the extent of the black-ban seeCarroll, “Is Hawke Running the Country?” Google Scholar

47.“Tour Supporters Urged to Attend Airport,” Sydney Morning Herald, 23 June1971;“S Africa’s Cricketer’s not for NZ,” Sydney Morning Herald, 3 July1971. Google Scholar

48.“Springbok Tour: Police Help to Build Barrier at Oval,” Canberra Times, 20 July1971;Vincent Basile, “Port Will Stop until Monday,” Age, 2 July1971;Carroll, “Is Hawke Running the Country?”;Hurst, Hawke, 101;Burgmann andBurgmann, Green Bans, Red Union, 121–22. Google Scholar

49.Dennis O’Brien, “Now Read On,” Bulletin, 17 July1971. Google Scholar

50.Tim Dare, “Police Guard the Springboks,” Australian, 26 June1971;“It’s All Quiet on the Western Front: Protesters Are Outclassed, Out-Manoeuvred,” Sunday Australian, 27 June1971. Google Scholar

51.Max Beattie, “Protesters Invade Rugby Game,” Age, 1 July1971;Ian Frykberg, “Police Arrest 65 at Match,” Age, 1 July 1971. Google Scholar

52.Jennett, “Signals to South Africa,” 105–106, 109. Google Scholar

53.Anti-Apartheid Movement, Protesters’ Guidebook, 2. Google Scholar

54.“Cricket Won’t Be so Lovely,” Australian, 3 July1971;Leon Reis, “Cautious Cricket,” Australian, 10 July1971. Google Scholar

55.“Huge Guard on Players,” Australian, 3 July1971. Google Scholar

56.“Bishop Claims NZ Tour ‘Off,’” Sydney Morning Herald, 8 July1971. Google Scholar

57.SeeBharatan Kumarappa, “Editor’s Note,”inM. K. Gandhi, Non—Violent Resistance (Satyagraha)(:Schocken Books, 1961), ii;Martin Luther King Jr., “Letter from Birmingham City Jail,”inCivil Disobedience: Theory and Practice, ed.Hugo Bedeau(:Pegasus, 1969), 72–89;Sean Scalmer, Ghandhi in the West: The Mahatma and the Rise of Radical Protest(:Cambridge University Press, 2011), 206–13. Google Scholar

58.For disruptive protest as “non-violence,” seeMax Beattie, “Today Ian Will Leap,” Age, 3 July1971;David Manning andDavid Harcourt, “Protest is People,” Bulletin, 10 July1971;“Police Recipe: Firmness, Tact,” Sydney Morning Herald, 10 July1971. Google Scholar

59.Anti-Apartheid Movement, Protesters’ Guidebook, 4–8. Google Scholar

60.Vincent Smith, “Policing Protest: There’s a Lot More to It than a Strong Arm and a Notebook,” National Times, 12 July1971. Google Scholar

61.Carter, Direct Action and Liberal Democracy, 119. Google Scholar

62.Don Dunstan, Don Dunstan: The First 25 Years in Parliament, compiled byRichard Yates(:Hill of Content, 1978), 70–71. Google Scholar

63.Harris, Political Football, 71–72;Smith, “Policing Protest.” Google Scholar

64.TheSydney Morning Heraldreported 65 arrests, The Age, 80. SeeBeattie, “Protesters Invade Rugby Game”;Frykberg, “Police Arrest 65 at Match.” Google Scholar

65.SeeRoberto Da Matta, “Carnival in Multiple Planes,”inRite, Drama, Festival, Spectacle: Rehearsals toward a Theory of Cultural Performance, ed.John J. MacAloon(:Institute for the Study of Human Issues, 1984), 208–40. Google Scholar

66.Douglas Booth andColin Tatz, One-Eyed: A View of Australian Sport(:Allen and Unwin, 2000), 157. Google Scholar

67.Scalmer, Dissent Events, 69. Google Scholar

68.Rob Lynch, “A Symbolic Patch of Grass: Crowd Disorder and Regulation on the Sydney Cricket Ground Hill,”inCrowd Violence in Australian Sport, ASSH Studies in Sports History, no. 7 (:Australian Society for Sports History, 1992), 27passim. Google Scholar

69.“Bolte Calls M-Day Protesters Loud Mouths,” Age, 2 July1971. Google Scholar

70.Robert Haldane, The People’s Force: A History of Victoria Police(:Melbourne University Press, 1986), 255–59;Peter Blazey, Bolte: A Political Biography(:Mandarin Australia, 1990), 142–58. Also seeBarry York, “Baiting the Tiger: Police and Protest during the Vietnam War,”inPolicing in Australia: Historical Perspectives, ed.Mark Finnane(:New South Wales University Press, 1987)171–87. Google Scholar

71.Patrick Boyce, “The New Game, Hide and Seek,” Age, 5 July1971. Google Scholar

72.Robert Mayne, “Police Batons Crash Down: Unruly Crowd,” Sun-Herald, 4 July1971;“Bolte Puts Blame on Protesters,” Australian, 6 July1971. Google Scholar

73.“It was Bungers versus Batons,” Age, 5 July1971;Max Beattie,David English, andMark Lawrence, “The PC Kicked 1, 2, 3 Times,” Age, 5 July1971;“Violence Wracks the City,” Age, 5 July1971;Harris, Political Football, 81–82. Google Scholar

74. “Violence Wracks the City.” Google Scholar

75.Beattie, et al., “The PC Kicked 1, 2, 3 Times.” Google Scholar

76.SeeGandhi, Non-Violent Resistance;King, “Letter from Birmingham City Jail.” Google Scholar

77.Gandhi, Non-Violent Resistance, 60–61. Google Scholar

78.Robert Benewick, “The Threshold of Violence,”inBenewick, Direct Action and Democratic Politics, 49–52. Google Scholar

79.Hutton andConnors, A History of the Australian Environmental Movement, 7. Google Scholar

80.Gerster andBassett, Seizures of Youth, 79–82;“Church Leaders Say Stop the Tour,” Australian, 7 July1971;“Lawyers Urge PM to Stop Rugby Tour,”8 July1971. Google Scholar

81.“Hamer: No Order to ‘Crack Down,’” Age, 6 July1971;“Cabinet ‘Appalled’ at Riot Weapons,” Sydney Morning Herald, 6 July1971. SeeThorn, Anti-Apartheid, 156–57;Robert Mast, “Law and Order in Comparative Perspective,”inBenewick, Direct Action and Democratic Politics, 109–26. Google Scholar

82.“Police Recipe: Firmness, Tact,” Sydney Morning Herald, 10 July1971;Malcolm Saunders, “‘Law and Order’ and the Anti-Vietnam War Movement: 1965–72,” Australian Journal of Politics and History 28, no. 3(1983):373–74. Google Scholar

83.“Protesters Promise No Violence at SCG,” Sydney Morning Herald, 6 July1971;“Police Told to ‘Play it Cool’ with Protesters,” Australian, 6 July1971;“Springboks get SCG,”9 July1971;New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly 98 (21 September1971):1208. Google Scholar

84.Tim Dare, “59 Arrested in Noisiest Tour Protest,” Australian, 7 July1971. Google Scholar

85.Albert Grundligh, “Playing for Power? Rugby, Afrikaner Nationalism and Masculinity in South Africa c.1900–c.1970,”inMaking Men: Rugby and Masculine Identity, ed.John Nauright andTimothy J. L. Chandler(:Frank Cass, 1996), 181–205. Google Scholar

86.SeeNeville Leck, “We Won’t Be Halted,” Rand Daily Mail(Johannesburg), 2 July1971;“Aussies Told to Resist Blackmail,” Rand Daily Mail, 5 July1971;George Richards, “We’re Not Afraid, Say Boks: No Violence is Expected Today,” Rand Daily Mail, 6 July1971. Google Scholar

87.John Seward, “Shame of the Springboks,” Australian, 11 July1971. Google Scholar

88.“Emergency Act is ‘Comic Opera,’” Age, 15 July1971. Google Scholar

89.“Police and Tour Fans Pour in for Orange March,” Sydney Morning Herald, 13 July1971;“‘Success’ Claims as Rugby Tour Ends,” Sydney Morning Herald, 9 August1971;Harris, Political Football, 105–107. Google Scholar

90.Robert Mayne, “Police Take Law into Their Own Hands,” Sydney Morning Herald, 5 July1971. Google Scholar

91. “Police and Tour Fans Pour in for Orange Match.” Google Scholar

92.“Violence Wracks City,” Age, 5 July1971;Human Rights Commission (Australia), Civil Disobedience and the Use of Arrest as Punishment: Some Human Rights Issues(:Australian Government Publishing Service, 1986), 4–5. Google Scholar

93.Canberra Civil Liberties Council, General Report of the Council for Civil Liberties on the Springbok Match in Canberra on July 21 1971(:Canberra Civil Liberties Council, 1971), 12–13 Google Scholar

94.Harris, Political Football, 33. Google Scholar

95.Joh Bjelke-Petersen, Don’t You Worry about That! The Joh Bjelke-Petersen Memoirs(:Angus and Robertson, 1990), 99;Hugh Lunn, Johannes Bjelke-Petersen: A Political Biography(:University of Queensland Press, 1987), 58–85. Google Scholar

96.Bjelke-Petersen, Don’t You Worry about That, 100–101;“Premier Announces End of State of Emergency,” Courier Mail, 3 August1971;Lunn, Johannes Bjelke-Petersen, 89–92. Google Scholar

97.Professor H. W. Wooten QC, “An Emergency in Queensland is so Very Wide,” Sydney Morning Herald, 16 July1971;Raymond Evans, “Springbok Tour Confrontation: Tower Mill/Wickham Park, Wickham Terrace,”inRadical Brisbane: An Unruly History, ed.Raymond Evans andCarole Ferrier withJeff Rickett(:Vulgar Press, 2004), 278–79. Google Scholar

98.SeeRootes, “The Development of Radical Student Movements,” 173–86;Ross Fitzgerald, From 1915 to the Early 1980s: A History of Queensland(:University of Queensland Press, 1984), 558–61. Google Scholar

99.Harris, Political Football, 129–30;Ray Whitrod, Before I Sleep: Memoirs of a Modern Police Commissioner(:University of Queensland Press, 2001), 178–79;“Wild Chase in City Park,” Courier Mail, 23 July1971. Google Scholar

100.“Student Take-Over at Uni ‘a Strike,’” Courier Mail, 24 July1971. See alsoHarris, Political Football, 132–33. Google Scholar

101.Dan O’Neill, “A Factual Kind of Introduction,”inUp the Right Channels, ed.Dan O’Neill, et. al.(:James Prentice, 1970), 8. Google Scholar

102.Editorial, “Clear Away Any Doubts,” Courier Mail, 24 July1971;“Emergency Act is Comic Opera.” Google Scholar

103.“Australian Political Chronicle, May—August 1971: Queensland,” Australian Journal of Politics and History 17, no. 3(1971):442;Raymond Evans, A History of Queensland(:Cambridge University Press, 2007), 225;Saunders, “Law and Order,” 375. Google Scholar

104.Peter Allen, “Tear-Gas Bomb Used against Springboks,” Sun-Herald, 8 August1971. Google Scholar

105. “Student Take-Over at Uni a Strike.” Google Scholar

106. “Success Claims as Rugby Tour Ends.” Google Scholar

107.Harris, Political Football, 254–55. Google Scholar

108.Quoted inClark, “The Wind of Change in Australia,” 116. Google Scholar

109.“Police Chief Says He Could Not Ensure Tour Safety,” Australian, 7 September1971. Google Scholar

110.“Tour Off: Bradman Hits It for a Six,” Australian, 9 September1971. Google Scholar

111.“He Warns of ‘Anarchy’ in Big Protests,” Age, 13 September1971;CPDHR 71–72 (22 April1971):1952. Google Scholar

112.Meredith Burgmann, “What the Demos Won,” Nation, 18 September1971. Google Scholar

113.Booth andTatz, One Eyed, 170–71. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Scott, Nick