Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

The Genesis and Performance of an Australian Wage-Fixing System in Papua New Guinea

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2016), 110, (1), 143–160.

Abstract

The functioning of inherited institutions, including those regulating labour markets, in former colonised countries is embedded with their character and history. Yet, there has been surprisingly little academic interest in the changing roles and performance of post-colonial labour market institutions. These institutions can express values – linked to, for example, fairness in decision-making and equitable distribution – strongly held in the colonising country at the time of transplantation. Such values can then shape institutional experience in the colony and post-colonial society. This article examines the establishment and performance, over four decades, of an Australian-styled system for fixing minimum wages established in colonial-era Papua New Guinea (PNG) and centred on the PNG Minimum Wages Board (MWB). The article uses documentary evidence, in-depth interviews and the author’s own experience as participant in the important 2000 round of MWB deliberations. In doing so, it highlights how the MWB’s composition changed to more fully reflect indigenous circumstances. It also examines how earlier priorities of socio-economic equity amid development, via arguments base on needs, have come under fierce pressures from organised employers’ arguments for prioritising capacity to pay at the firm and national level. This reshaped MWB’s wage fixing within a largely deregulated bargaining system despite the much more difficult economic circumstances of the lowly paid in this struggling, developing nation.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*The author thanks the journal’s anonymous referees for all their helpful, critical feedback. He would particularly like to thankLabour History’scaretaker editor, Peter Sheldon, for the very substantial editorial work he provided on this article. Google Scholar

1.Valentin Seidler, Colonial Legacy and Institutional Development: The Cases of Botswana and Nigeria, Department of Development Studies(:University of Vienna, 2012), 15–27. Google Scholar

2.Colin Filer,Marj Andrew,Pauline Carr,Benedict Imbun andBill Sagir, “The Social and Economic Impact on the Resource Sector Job Stream in Papua New Guinea,”inWorld Development Report Companion Volume on “JOBS” in the World Extractive Industry(:World Bank, 2016, in press). Google Scholar

3.Jubilee Australia, Pipe Dreams: The PNG LNG Project and the Future Hopes of a Nation(:Jubilee Research Centre, 2012), accessed April 2016,http://www.jubileeaustralia.org/page/work/pipe-dreams-report. Google Scholar

4.Jane Thomason andMatthew Hancock, PNG Mineral Boom: Harnessing the Extractive Sector to Deliver Better Health Outcomes(:ANU, Development Policy Centre, Discussion Paper2, January2011).“Millennium Development Goals,” Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, accessed April 2016,http://www.dfat.gov.au/un/millennium-development-goals.html. Google Scholar

5.Theo Levantis andMike Manning, The Business and Investment Environment in PNG: The Private Sector Perspective(:Institute of National Affairs, Discussion Paper, no. 86, 2006);Sinclair Dinnen, Law and Order in a Weak State: Crime and Politics in Papua New Guinea(:University of Hawaii Press, 2001). Google Scholar

6.Asian Development Bank, Papua New Guinea Economic Outlook(:ADB, 2013), 7–10. Google Scholar

7.AusAID, Papua New Guinea(:Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, 2012). Google Scholar

8.Nelson Hank,Brian Jinks andPeter Biskup, Readings in New Guinea History(:Angus & Robertson, 1973), 324. Google Scholar

9.Australian Bureau of Statistics, “A Short History of Australian Aid,” Year Book Australia, 2001, accessed April 2016,http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/featurearticlesbytitle/A30A0205261ABEECCA2569DE00200135?OpenDocument. Google Scholar

10. Ibid. Google Scholar

11.Quoted in,Rory Ewin, “The Papua New Guinea Constitution: Australia’s Role in its Development, 1960–1975”(Honours thesis,Australian National University, 1990), 3, accessed April 2016,http://www.speedysnail.com/pacific/png.html. Google Scholar

12. Ibid. Google Scholar

13.Merze Tate, “Australia and Self-Determination for New Guinea,” Australian Journal of Politics and History 17, no. 2(August1971):247. Google Scholar

14.United Nations, Report of the 1962 United Nations Visiting Mission to the Trust Territory of New Guinea(:UN, 1962), 24–26. Google Scholar

15.Ron May, State and Society in Papua New Guinea: The First Twenty Five Years(:University of Melbourne Press, 2001), 83–84. Google Scholar

16.Benedict Imbun, “Labour Relations in Papua New Guinea: A Historical Review of Literature, 1920–2006,” Labour and Management in Development Journal 8(2007):1–13. Google Scholar

17.Colin Filer andBenedict Imbun.“A Short History of Mineral Development Policies in Papua New Guinea, 1972–2002,”inPolicy Making and Implementation: Studies from Papua New Guinea, ed.Ron May(:ANU E-Press, 2009), 75–116. Google Scholar

18. Ibid., 76. Google Scholar

19.Desh Gupta, Political Economy of Growth and Stagnation in Papua New Guinea(:UPNG Press, 1992), 62. Google Scholar

20.Ben Finney, Big-Men and Business: Entrepreneurship and Economic Growth in the New Guinea Highlands(:University Press of Hawaii, 1973). Google Scholar

21.Benedict Imbun, “Struggling or in Transition: Small Household Growers and the Coffee Industry in Papua New Guinea,” Asia Pacific Viewpoint 55(2014):24–37. Google Scholar

22.Gupta, Political Economy, 62. Google Scholar

23.Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research, Papua New Guinea Coffee and Cocoa Policy Linkages(:ACIAR, Final Report, project no. PLIA/2005/148, 2007);“Problems in Coffee Production,” Post Courier(Port Moresby), 11 March2010. Google Scholar

24.Imbun, Dynamics of Wage Fixation in a Developing Country: The Case of Papua New Guinea(:Nova Science Publishers, 2008), 35. Google Scholar

25. Ibid., 29;Gerard Ward, “Contract Labour Recruitment from the Highlands of Papua New Guinea, 1950–1974,” International Migration Review 24(1990):273–96. Google Scholar

26.Michael Hess, “‘In the Long Run …’: Australian Colonial Labour Policy in the Territory of Papua and New Guinea,” Journal of Industrial Relations 25, no. 1(1983):51–67. Google Scholar

27.Imbun, “Have We Walked ‘on the Clear(ed) Path’? An Assessment of the Development of Industrial Relations in Papua New Guinea,”inBuilding a Nation in Papua New Guinea: Views of the Post-Independence Generation, ed.David Kavanamur,Charles Yala andQuinton Clements(:Pandanus Books, 2003), 149–62. Google Scholar

28.James Christopher Gissua, “Arbitration in Paradise: Industrial Dispute Resolution in Papua New Guinea”(PhD diss.,University of NSW, 1997), 38–45. Google Scholar

29.Hess, “In the Long Run.” Google Scholar

30.Gissua, “Arbitration in Paradise,” 38–45. Google Scholar

31.Imbun, “Have We Walked.” Google Scholar

32.Hess, Unions under Economic Development: Private Sector Unions in Papua New Guinea(:Oxford University Press, 1992), 45–55. Google Scholar

33.Michael Hess, “Papua New Guinea’s First Peak Union Council: Creating Unions to Fill a Bureaucratic Need?” Australian Journal of Politics and History 34(1988):28–36. Google Scholar

34.Imbun, Dynamics of Wage Fixation, 18–22. Google Scholar

35.S. Carrol, “The Changing Emphasis of Wage Policy in Papua New Guinea: The Reasons and Underlying Causes,”(Honours thesis,University of Sydney, 1993), 23–34. Google Scholar

36.Mike Daley, Industrial Relations System in Papua New Guinea(:Kundu Pacific, 1987), 124–35. Google Scholar

37. Ibid. Google Scholar

38.Douglass Smith, Labour and the Law in Papua New Guinea(:ANU Development Studies Centre, 1975), 55–68. Google Scholar

39.Ian Duncan,Brant Layton,Chris Nixon andSimon Wear, Papua New Guinea Agriculture: Issues and Options(:Institute of National Affairs, Discussion Paper, no. 92, 2006), 13–22. Google Scholar

40. Ibid. Google Scholar

41.Imbun, Dynamics of Wage Fixation, 18–22. Google Scholar

42.Hugh Mannur, Wages and Economic Growth in Papua New Guinea(:University of Papua New Guinea and Friedrich Ebert, 1992). Google Scholar

43. Minimum Wages Board Determination(:Department of Labour, 1974). Google Scholar

44.Benedict Imbun.“‘A Lot of Talking’ and No Significant Economic Progress: A Review of Wage Policy in Papua New Guinea,” Journal of Pacific Studies 28(2005):218–45. Google Scholar

45.Benedict Imbun.“The Dilemma of Wage Fixation in a Developing Country: The Case of Papua New Guinea,” International Journal of Employment Studies 2(1994):249–66. Google Scholar

46.Benedict Imbun, “Minimum Wage Debates in a Developing Country Setting: The Case of Papua New Guinea,” Economic and Labour Relations Review 26, no. 1(2015):1–17. Google Scholar

47.Department of Labour and Industrial Relations, Public Notice: 2013 PNG Minimum Wages Board Determination(:Department of Labour and Industrial Relations, 2013). Google Scholar

48.Benedict Imbun, Industrial and Employment Relations in the Papua New Guinea Mining Industry: The Case of Porgera(:UPNG Press, 1999), 46. Google Scholar

49.Imbun, “The Dilemma of Wage Fixation.” Google Scholar

50.Minimum Wages Board, 2000 PNG Minimum Wage Determination Terms of Reference(:Department of Labour and Employment, 8–14 June2000). Google Scholar

51.John Paska, telephone interview with author, 26 October2013. Google Scholar

52.Theo Levantis, Papua New Guinea: Employment, Wages and Economic Development(:Asia Pacific Press, 2000), 48. Google Scholar

53.“PNG Growers Submission,” 2000 PNG Minimum Wages Board Determination(hereafter2000 MWBD)(:Department of Labour and Employment, 2000). Google Scholar

54.“PNGTUC Submission,” 2000 MWBD, 50. Google Scholar

55.“PNG Employers Federation Submission,” 2000 MWBD, 6. Google Scholar

56.“University of Papua New Guinea Submission,” 2000 MWBD. Google Scholar

57.“Amalgamated Workers’ Union Submission,” 2000 MWBD. Google Scholar

58.“Pangu Pati Submission,” 2000 MWBD. Google Scholar

59.“Various Organisations’ Submissions,” 2000 MWBD. Google Scholar

60.Samson Kolapen, General Secretary, PNG Forest Workers Union, interview with author, PNGTUC Office, Port Moresby, 3 November2014. Google Scholar

61.Joel Alpmeldey, The Issue of Minimum Wage in Papua New Guinea: A Discussion Paper(:Department of Labour and Employment, 1994). Google Scholar

62.Benedict Imbun, The PNGTUC Position on Minimum Wage Policy for the Country(:PNGTUC Office, 1999). Google Scholar

63. 2000 MWBD, 29. Google Scholar

64. Ibid., 29. Google Scholar

65. Ibid., 55. Google Scholar

66.“Rural sector in turmoil after rise in minimum wages,” The National, 5 December2000. Google Scholar

67.John Paska, telephone interview with author, PNGTUC Office, Port Moresby, 23 January2014. Google Scholar

68.“NTCC Determines New Minimum Wage for Country,” Post-Courier, 29 January2001. Google Scholar

69.Sam Thomas, telephone interview with author, PNG Employers Federation, Port Moresby, 2 December2013. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Imbun, Benedict Y.