Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

Employee Participation and Industrial Welfarism in Australia, 1890–1965

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2017), 112, (1), 137–154.

Abstract

Non-union forms of representative employee participation have a long history in Australia, notwithstanding the privileging of trade union representation by the conciliation and arbitration system. One common form of representative employee participation occurred in the administration of industrial welfare schemes when they spread through large Australian organisations, particularly during and after World War II. However, the employee participation literature has largely neglected this significant historical movement in management strategy. A conceptual framework derived from contemporary employee participation literature is used to evaluate the substance of employee participation in administration of Australia company welfare schemes during the period 1890–1965. Conclusions are twofold: management’s motivation to introduce industrial welfare schemes was a combination of social integration in periods of industrial conflict, as well as organisational efficiency; and whilst employees often influenced decisions in substantial ways in the administration of welfare schemes, the scope of this influence was very narrow.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*The authors would like to thank Labour History’s two anonymous referees. Google Scholar

1.For example, P. J. Gollan, R. Markey and I. Ross, eds, Works Councils in Australia: Future Prospects and Possibilities (Sydney: Federation Press, 2002). Google Scholar

2.D. Adam and R. Markey, “Comparing Employee Voice in Australia and the UK: AWRS and WERS,” Australian Workplace Relations Survey Conference, Australian Fair Work Commission, June 2015, Melbourne, accessed April 2017, https://www.fwc.gov.au/documents/awrs/Comparing-employee-voice-Australia-UK.pdf; A. Morehead, M. Steele, M. Alexander, K. Stephen and L. Duffin, Changes at Work: The 1995 Australian Workplace Industrial Relations Survey (Melbourne: Longman, 1997), 189. Google Scholar

3.J. Teicher, P. Holland, A. Pyman and B. Cooper, “Australian Workers: Finding Their Voice?” in What Workers Say: Employee Voice in the Anglo-American Workplace, ed. R. B. Freeman, P. Boxall and P. Haynes (Ithaca: ILR Press, 2007), 138. Google Scholar

4.R. Markey and G. Patmore, “Employee Participation and Labour Representation: ICI Works Councils in Australia, 1943–75,” Labour History, no. 97 (November 2009): 53–73; R. Markey and G. Patmore, “Employee Participation in Health and Safety in the Australian Steel Industry: Port Kembla, 1935–2006,” British Journal of Industrial Relations 49, no. 1 (2011): 144–67. Google Scholar

5.N. Balnave “Company-Sponsored Recreation in Australia: 1890–1965, Labour History, no. 85 (November 2003): 129. Google Scholar

6.J. W. Budd, P. J. Gollan and A. Wilkinson, “New Approaches to Employee Voice and Participation in Organizations,” Human Relations 63, no. 3 (2010): 303–305; R. Markey and K. Townsend, “Contemporary Trends in Employee Involvement and Participation,” Journal of Industrial Relations 55, no. 4 (2013): 475–87. Google Scholar

7.G. Strauss, “An Overview,” in Organizational Participation: Myth and Reality, ed. F. Heller, E. Pusic, G. Strauss and Bernard Wilpert (New York: Oxford University Press, 1998), 15. Google Scholar

8.A. Wilkinson, P. J. Gollan, M. Marchington and D. Lewin, “Conceptualising Employee Participation in Organizations,” in The Oxford Handbook of Participation in Organizations, ed. A. Wilkinson, P. J. Gollan, M. Marchington and D. Lewin (New York: Oxford University Press, 2010), 4–5. Google Scholar

9.P. Blyton, and P. Turnbull, The Dynamics of Employee Relations (Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan, 2004), 257. Google Scholar

10.C. Pateman, Participation and Democratic Theory (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1970). Google Scholar

11.F. Heller, “Playing the Devil’s Advocate: Limits to Information Sharing in Theory and Practice,” in Heller, Pusic, Strauss and Wilpert, Organizational Participation, 149–50. Google Scholar

12.S. Webb and B. Webb, Industrial Democracy (London: Longmans Green, 1902); Budd, Gollan and Wilkinson, “New Approaches to Employee Voice,” 304. Google Scholar

13.H. Knudsen and R. Markey, “Works Councils: Lessons from Europe for Australia,” in Gollan, Markey and Ross. Works Councils in Australia, 102–103. Google Scholar

14.H. Ramsay, “Cycles of Control: Worker Participation in Sociological and Historical Perspective,” Sociology 11, no. 3 (1977): 481–506. Google Scholar

15.Blyton and Turnbull, The Dynamics of Employee Relations, 258. Google Scholar

16.G. Patmore, Worker Voice: Employee Representation in the Workplace in Australia, Canada, Germany, the UK and the US 1914–39 (Liverpool: Liverpool University Press, 2016). Google Scholar

17.B. E. Kaufman and D. Taras, eds, Nonunion Employee Representation: History, Contemporary Practice, and Policy (New York: M. E. Sharpe, 2000); R. Markey, “Non-Union Employee Representation in Australia: A Case Study of the Suncorp Metway Employee Council Inc. (SMEC),” Journal of Industrial Relations 49, no. 1 (2007): 187–210. Google Scholar

18.Balnave, “Company-Sponsored Recreation in Australia,” 130–32; J. Melling, “Employers, Industrial Welfare, and the Struggle for Work-Place Control in British Industry,” in Managerial Strategies and Industrial Relations: An Historical and Comparative Study, ed. H. Gospel and C. Littler (London: Heimann Educational Books, 1983), 57; M. McCallum, “Corporate Welfarism in Canada, 1919–39,” Canadian Historical Review 71, no. 1 (1990): 46–49; S. Jacoby, Employing Bureaucracy: Managers, Unions and the Transformation of Work in American Industry, 1900–45 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1985), 54; R. Edwards, Contested Terrain: The Transformation of the Workplace in the Twentieth Century (New York: Basic Books, 1979), 92–93. Google Scholar

19.C. Forster, “The Economy, Wages and the Establishment of Arbitration,” in Foundations of Arbitration: The Origins and Effects of State Compulsory Arbitration, 1890–1914, ed. S. Macintyre and R. Mitchell (Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1988), 203–24; J. Hagan, The History of the ACTU (Melbourne: Longman, 1981), 25–38. Google Scholar

20.F. R. E. Mauldon, “Co-operation and Welfare in Industry,” in An Economic Survey of Australia, ed. D. B. Copland (Philadelphia: American Academy of Political and Social Science, 1931), The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 158 (November 1931): 185. Google Scholar

21.Advisory Council of Science and Industry (ACSI), Welfare Work, (ACSI) Bulletin, no. 15 (1919); ACSI, Industrial Cooperation in Australia, (ACSI) Bulletin, no. 17 (1920). Google Scholar

22.Mauldon, “Co-operation and Welfare in Industry,” 185. Google Scholar

23.ACSI, Industrial Cooperation in Australia, 25; C. Wright, The Management of Labour: A History of Australian Employers (Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1995), 22–23; Markey and Patmore, “Employee Participation and Labour Representation,” 53–74. Google Scholar

24.Patmore, Worker Voice, 44, 202; E. Eklund, “‘Intelligently Directed Welfare Work’? Labour Management Strategies in Local Context: Port Pirie, 1915–1929,” Labour History, no. 76 (May 1999): 130. Google Scholar

25.Markey and Patmore, “Employee Participation in Health and Safety in the Australian Steel Industry,” 151. Google Scholar

26.G. S. Beeby, “Industrial Conditions in Great Britain and the United States of America,” NSW Industrial Gazette 16, no. 2, Special Supplement (1919): 85A–90A; G. Patmore, Australian Labour History (Melbourne: Longman Cheshire, 1991), 147. Google Scholar

27.Wright, Management of Labour, 22. Google Scholar

28.Ibid., 62–63. Google Scholar

29.N. Balnave, “The State and Employment Relations: Wartime Welfarism,” International Employment Relations Review 9, no. 1 (2003): 61–73. Google Scholar

30.T. Sheridan, Division of Labour: Industrial Relations in the Chifley Years, 1945–1949 (Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1989). Google Scholar

31.Markey and Patmore, “Employee Participation in Health and Safety in the Australian Steel Industry,” 153. Google Scholar

32.Mauldon, “Co-operation and Welfare in Industry,” 186. Google Scholar

33.G. Cass, Workers’ Benefit or Employers’ Burden: Workers’ Compensation in New South Wales 1880–1926 (Kensington: Industrial Relations Research Centre, UNSW, 1983), 53–85. Google Scholar

34.R. Hamilton, Waltzing Matilda and the Sunshine Harvester Factory: The Early History of the Arbitration Court, the Australian Minimum Wage, Working Hours and Paid Leave (Melbourne: Fair Work Australia, 2011), 153–56. Google Scholar

35.L. R. Wall, “Social and Recreational Clubs in Queensland Industry,” Personnel Practice Bulletin 11, no. 1 (1955): 44; Balnave, “Company-Sponsored Recreation in Australia 1890–1965,” 136. Google Scholar

36.Wright, Management of Labour, 62–63. Google Scholar

37.E. Ross, A History of the Miners’ Federation of Australia (Sydney: Australasian Coal and Shale Employees’ Federation, 1970), 378. Google Scholar

38.“Our Story,” Maritime Super, accessed April 2017, http://www.maritimesuper.com.au/main/aboutus/our-story; B. Fitzpatrick and R. J. Cahill, The Seamen’s Union of Australia 1872–1972: A History (Sydney: Seamen’s Union of Australia, 1981), 285. Google Scholar

39.K. Swoboda, “Chronology of Major Superannuation and Retirement Income Changes in Australia,” Parliament of Australia, Parliamentary Library, Research Paper Series, 2013–14, accessed April 2017 http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/download/library/prspub/2981801/upload_binary/2981801.pdf. Google Scholar

40.Balnave, “The State and Employment Relations,” 64. Google Scholar

41.Wright, Management of Labour, 63–64. Google Scholar

42.Balnave, “The State and Employment Relations,” 64–69. Google Scholar

43.Mauldon, “Co-operation and Welfare in Industry,” 183. Google Scholar

44.Patmore, Worker Voice, 43–45. Google Scholar

45.G. Patmore, “A History of Industrial Relations in the NSW Government Railways: 1855–1929” (Ph.D. diss., Department of Industrial Relations, University of Sydney, 1985), 310. Google Scholar

46.G. Patmore, “Employee Representation Plans in the United States, Canada, and Australia: An Employer Response to Workplace Democracy,” Labor 3, no. 2 (2006): 63. Google Scholar

47.R. Markey, In Case of Oppression: The Life and Times of the Labor Council of NSW (Sydney: Pluto Press, 1994): 105–106. Google Scholar

48.ACSI, Industrial Co-operation in Australia, 41, 56; Patmore, Australian Labour History, 146. Google Scholar

49.ACSI, Industrial Co-operation in Australia, 9. Google Scholar

50.Patmore, “A History of Industrial Relations in the NSW Government Railways,” 400. Google Scholar

51.R. Frances, “‘No More Amazons’: Gender and Work Process in the Victorian Clothing Trades, 1890–1939,” Labour History, no. 50 (May 1986): 110–11. Google Scholar

52.ACSI, Industrial Co-operation in Australia, 9; B. Ellem and J. Shields, “Making a ‘Union Town’: Class, Gender and Consumption in Inter-War Broken Hill,” Labour History, no. 78 (May 2000): 129–30. Google Scholar

53.Eklund, “Intelligently Directed Welfare Work,” 140; M. Hearn, Working Lives: A History of the Australian Railways Union (NSW Branch) (Sydney: Hale and Iremonger, 1990). Google Scholar

54.ACSI, Industrial Co-operation in Australia, 34. Google Scholar

55.“Works Canteen Controlled by Employees,” Manufacturing and Management (15 May 1947): 425. Google Scholar

56.“Recreation Club David Jones,” Minute, 15 September 1949, Series SP 146/1, item 582/2/14, National Archives of Australia. Google Scholar

57.Christopher Wright, “The Rise of Modern Labour Management: The Formalisation of Employment and Work Relations in Australian Manufacturing Industry, 1940–1972” (Ph.D diss., University of Sydney, 1990), 192. Google Scholar

58.Mauldon, “Co-operation and Welfare in Industry,” 183. Google Scholar

59.Eklund, “Intelligently Directed Welfare Work,” 131, 142, 145 endnote 27. Google Scholar

60.Wright, “The Rise of Modern Labour Management,” 33. Google Scholar

61.N. Balnave, “Industrial Welfarism in Australia: 1890–1965” (Ph.D diss., University of Sydney, 2002). Google Scholar

62.Patmore, Worker Voice, 62, 65; B. E. Kaufman, “Accomplishments and Shortcomings of Nonunion Employee Representation in the Pre-Wagner Act Years: A Reassessment,” in Kaufman and Taras, Nonunion Employee Representation, 40–45. Google Scholar

63.D. Nelson, Managers and Workers: Origins of the New Factory System in the United States 1880–1920 (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1975), 118–19. Google Scholar

64.S. Brandes, American Welfare Capitalism, 1880–1940 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1976), 130. Google Scholar

65.Jacoby, Employing Bureaucracy, 53. Google Scholar

66.Markey and Patmore, “Employee Participation in Health and Safety in the Australian Steel Industry,” 153. Google Scholar

67.For example, Markey and Patmore, “Employee Participation and Labour Representation.” Google Scholar

68.E. White and L. F. Edmonds, “Management-Employee Committees in Australia,” Bulletin of Industrial Psychology and Personnel Practice 9, no. 3 (1953): 3–11. Google Scholar

69.L. R. Wall and W. P. Butler, “Management-Employee Committees: The Results of Australian Research,” Bulletin of Industrial Psychology and Personnel Practice 15, no. 1 (1959): 40. Google Scholar

70.Eklund, “Intelligently Directed Welfare Work,” 133. Google Scholar

71.ACSI, Industrial Co-operation in Australia, 33, 40. Google Scholar

72.Nelson, Managers and Workers, 118. Google Scholar

73.Eklund, “Intelligently Directed Welfare Work,” 131, 145 endnote 27. Google Scholar

74.ACSI, Industrial Co-operation in Australia, 30–31, 40. Google Scholar

75.Ibid., 9, 11. Google Scholar

76.M. Kangan, “Employee Services in Large Tasmanian Establishments,” Personnel Practice Bulletin 10, no. 1 (1954): 41. Google Scholar

77.Ibid., 36, 41–42. Google Scholar

78.C. O. Turner, “Employee Security Plans and Procedures,” Manufacturing and Management (15 August 1946): 74–75. Google Scholar

79.E. Eklund, “Managers, Workers, and Industrial Welfarism: Management Strategies at ER&S and the Sulphide Corporation, 1895–1929,” Australian Economic History Review 37, no. 2 (1997): 150. Google Scholar

80.ACSI, Industrial Co-operation in Australia, 10. Google Scholar

81.Eklund, “Managers, Workers, and Industrial Welfarism,” 150. Google Scholar

82.ACSI, Industrial Co-operation in Australia, 20–21. Google Scholar

83.Eklund, “Managers, Workers, and Industrial Welfarism,” 150. Google Scholar

84.C. O. Turner, “One Day’s Stoppage in Twenty Years,”’ Personnel Practice Bulletin 15, no. 2 (1959): 21. Google Scholar

85.G. Blainey, The Peaks of Lyell (Hobart: St David’s Park Publishing, 1993), 225. Google Scholar

86.Eklund, “Intelligently Directed Welfare Work,” 132, 145 endnote 27. Google Scholar

87.ACSI, Industrial Co-operation in Australia, 48–49. Google Scholar

88.“Industrial Cafeteria Advisory Committees,” Department of Labour and National Service, 13 April 1945, Series SP 146/1, item 572/8/8, National Archives of Australia. Google Scholar

89.S. E. G. Imer, “Social and Recreational Activities in NSW Industry,” Personnel Practice Bulletin 15, no. 3 (1959): 7. Google Scholar

90.Wall, “Social and Recreational Clubs in Queensland Industry,” 47–48. Google Scholar

91.Ibid., 46. Google Scholar

92.Imer, “Social and Recreational Activities in NSW Industry,” 7–8. Google Scholar

93.Ibid., 7–8. Google Scholar

94.Shaw, “Works Canteen Controlled by Employees,” 424. Google Scholar

95.Ibid., 424–25. Google Scholar

96.Ibid. Google Scholar

97.H. V. Wallage, “Welfare without Waste,” Personnel Practice Bulletin 24, no. 2 (1968):142–43. Google Scholar

98.Shaw, “Works Canteen Controlled by Employees,” 424. Google Scholar

99.P. Griffin, “Employee Welfare in a Textile Company,” Personnel Practice Bulletin 22, no. 1 (1966): 27. Google Scholar

100.Markey, “Non-Union Employee Representation in Australia.” Google Scholar

101.Blyton and Turnbull, The Dynamics of Employee Relations. Google Scholar

102.Pateman, Participation and Democratic Theory. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Balnave, Nikola

Markey, Raymond