Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

Adopted Apprentices: Juvenile Recruitment in Australian Circus, 1847–1942

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2016), 110, (1), 97–124.

Abstract

Recent studies on the history of circus in Australia draw attention to the practise of recruiting male and female juveniles as trainee performers to augment a circus family or circus troupe. In oral recollections, circus people loosely described these juveniles as “apprenticed” or “adopted.” Although several nefarious examples of recruitment have been previously described in detail, historians have not explained the wider contexts in which such recruitment took place. The constant need for circus proprietors to embellish their programs drove the demand for these juveniles. This article explores the factors influencing the supply of juvenile circus labour, focussing on the evolving social, legislative and economic contexts within which juveniles were recruited into circus between 1847 (the foundation year of circus in Australia) and 1942 (when most circus companies temporarily ceased operations owing to wartime restrictions and by which time juvenile recruitment was largely extinguished). The study highlights the worth of deeper scholarly enquiry into this previously neglected group of young workers. It also demonstrates the complexity of labour practises in theatrical entertainments, generally, and in itinerant entertainments such as circus in particular. In doing so, the study suggests the need to reconsider the distinction between the margins and mainstream of Australian labour and social history.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*The author thanks Emeritus Professor John Ramsland and Dr Brian Dickey for reviewing preliminary drafts of this article. The author also acknowledges the diligent and critical evaluation ofLabour History’sanonymous referees. Google Scholar

1.C. M. H. Clark, A History of Australia, Volume 4: The Earth Abideth for Ever, 1851–1888(:Melbourne University Press, 1973), 55. Google Scholar

2.Graeme Davison,J. W. McCarty andAilsa McLeary, Australians: 1888(:Fairfax, Syme & Weldon Associates, 1987), 241. Google Scholar

3.Victor Emeljanow, Editorial, Popular Entertainment Studies 5, no. 2(2014):1–5. Google Scholar

4.Katharine Brisbane, ed., Entertaining Australia: An Illustrated History(:Currency Press, 1991), 8;M. Willson Disher, Fairs, Circuses and Music Halls(:William Collins, 1942), 20. Google Scholar

5.See for example:Lorne Cummings andMark St Leon, “Juggling the Books: The Use of Accounting Information in Circus in Australia,” Accounting History 14, no. 1(2009):11–33;Kim Baston, “Circus Music: The Eye of the Ear,” Popular Entertainment Studies 1, no. 2(2010):6–25;Gillian Arrighi, “Negotiating National Identity at the Circus: FitzGerald Brothers’ Circus in Melbourne, 1892,” Australasian Drama Studies, no. 54(2009):68–86. Google Scholar

6.Mervyn King withMark St Leon, The Silver Road: The Life Story of Mervyn King, Circus Man(:Butterfly Books, 1991). Google Scholar

7.Bradley Bowden, “Re-considering the Use of Child Labour: Why Nineteenth Century Australia was Different to Other Modernizing Nations”(paper presented at American Academy of Management Best Paper Proceedings,, 2009). Google Scholar

8.See for example:John Shields, “Deskilling Revisited: Continuity and Change in Craft Work and Apprenticeship in Late Nineteenth Century New South Wales,” Labour History, no. 68(May1995):1–29;Maree Murray, “The Child is Not a Servant: Children, Work and the Boarding Out Scheme in New South Wales, 1880–1920,” Labour History, no. 77(November1999):190–206;Cameron Nunn, “Juveniles as Human Capital: Re-evaluating the Economic Value of Juvenile Male Convict Labour,” Labour History, no. 108(May2015):53–69. Google Scholar

9.John Ramsland andMark St Leon, Circus Children: The Australian Experience(:Butterfly Books, 1993). Google Scholar

10.Gillian Arrighi, The FitzGerald Brothers’ Circus: Spectacle, Identity and Nationhood at the Australian Circus(:Australian Scholarly Publishing, 2015), 25. Google Scholar

11.Brenda Assael, “The Circus and Respectable Society in Victorian Britain”(PhD diss.,Graduate Department of History, University of Toronto, 1998);Brenda Assael, The Circus and Victorian Society(:University of Virginia Press, 2005). Google Scholar

12.John Ramsland, Children of the Back Lanes: Destitute and Neglected Children in Colonial New South Wales(:University of New South Wales Press, 1986);Donella Jaggs, Neglected and Criminal: Foundations of Child Welfare Legislation in Victoria(:Melbourne Centre for Youth and Community Studies, Phillip Institute of Technology, 1986);Anne O’Brien, Poverty’s Prison: The Poor in New South Wales, 1880–1918(:Melbourne University Press, 1988);John Seymour, Dealing with Young Offenders(:Law Book Company, 1988), 25–62. Google Scholar

13.Jan Kociumbas, Australian Childhood: A History(:Allen & Unwin, 1997);Robert van Krieken, Children and the State: Social Control and the Formation of Australian Child Welfare(:Allen & Unwin, 1991). Google Scholar

14.Marian Quartly,Shurlee Swain andDenise Cuthbert, withKay Dreyfus andMargaret Taft, The Market in Babies: Stories of Australian Adoption(:Monash University Publishing, 2013). Google Scholar

15.Ceridwen Spark andDenise Cuthbert, Other People’s Children: Adoption in Australia(:Australian Scholarly Publishing, 2009). Google Scholar

16.Stephen Garton, Out of Luck: Poor Australians and Social Welfare, 1788–1988(:Allen & Unwin, 1990). Google Scholar

17.Sue Wilkes, The Children History Forgot: Young Workers of the Industrial Age(:Robert Hale, 2011);Peter Kirby, Child Labour in Britain, 1750–1870(:Palgrave Macmillan, 2003);Jane Humphries, Childhood and Child Labour in the British Industrial Revolution(:Cambridge University Press, 2010). Google Scholar

18.See, for example,King, The Silver Road. Google Scholar

19.Nunn, “Juveniles as Human Capital.” Google Scholar

20.Bradley Bowden, “The Rise and Decline of Australian Unionism: A History of Industrial Labour from the 1820s to 1910,” Labour History, no. 100(May2011):51–82;Georgina Murray andJenny Chester, “Economic Wealth and Political Power in Australia, 1788–2010,” Labour History, no. 103(November2012):1–16;Michael Quinlan, “The Low Rumble of Informal Dissent: Shipboard Protests Over Health and Safety in Australian Waters, 1790–1900,” Labour History, no. 102(May2012):131–55. Google Scholar

21.Beverley Kingston, The Oxford History of Australia, Volume 3, 1860–1900(:Oxford University Press, 1988), 284–86. Google Scholar

22.John M. Golby andA. William Purdue, The Civilisation of the Crowd: Popular Culture in England, 1750–1900(:Sutton Publishing, 1999), 39. Google Scholar

23. Ibid., 69;Arthur H. Saxon, The Life and Art of Andrew Ducrow & The Romantic Age of the English Circus(:Archon Books, 1978), 19;Ruth Manning-Sanders, The English Circus(:Werner Laurie, 1952), 20;Kellow Chesney, The Victorian Underworld(:Penguin Books Australia, 1978), 74;H. Cunningham, Leisure in the Industrial Revolution(:Croom-Helm, 1980), 32, 34;Y. S. Carmeli, “The Invention of Circus and Bourgeois Hegemony: A Glance at British Circus Books,” The Journal of Popular Culture 29, no. 1(1995), 213ff. Google Scholar

24.Helen Stoddart, Rings of Desire(:Manchester University Press, 2000), 50. Google Scholar

25.Arrighi, FitzGerald Brothers, 26. Google Scholar

26.Saxon, The Life and Art of Andrew Ducrow, 39–40. Google Scholar

27.William J. Baumol andH. G. Bowen, Performing Arts: The Economic Dilemma, A Study of Problems Common to Theater, Opera, Music and Dance(:The Twentieth Century Fund, 1966), 162–63. Google Scholar

28.Anon., “Boy Tumblers and Acrobats: Showing the Training They Need”, fromChums, c.1896, reproduced inMaitland Daily Mercury, 11 January1897. Google Scholar

29.Mervyn King, inMark St Leon, Australian Circus Reminiscences(:The Author, 1984), 274. Google Scholar

30.Richard Waterhouse, Private Pleasures, Public Leisure: A History of Australian Popular Culture since 1788(:Longman Australia Pty Limited, 1995), 45–46;Kingston, Oxford History of Australia, Volume 3, 1860–1900, 222. Google Scholar

31.Mark St Leon, Circus: The Australian Story(:Melbourne Books, 2011), 29–33. Google Scholar

32. Cornwall Chronicle, 1 and 29 December1847. Google Scholar

33. Ibid., 19 January, 1 March, 5 July, 5 August, 13 September, 8 November1848. Google Scholar

34. Ibid., 13 September1848. Google Scholar

35. Ibid., 30 December1848;Sydney Sportsman, 8 January1908. Google Scholar

36. Sydney Morning Herald, 15 October1850. Google Scholar

37.Andrew Seltzer, “Labour, Skills and Migration,”inThe Cambridge Economic History of Australia, ed.Simon Ville andGlenn Withers(:Cambridge University Press, 2015), 178ff. Google Scholar

38. Sydney Morning Herald, 7 December1850;Geelong Advertiser, 25 May1853. Google Scholar

39. Sydney Morning Herald, 26 March1851, 26 May1852. Google Scholar

40. New York Times, 17 February1881. Munro was given the professional name of James “Melville.” He later won fame as an equestrian in American circus. Google Scholar

41.Waterhouse, Private Pleasures, 45–46. Google Scholar

42.Raelene Frances, Selling Sex: A Hidden History of Prostitution(:UNSW Press, 2007), 147. Google Scholar

43.Kirby, Child Labour in Britain, 43;Patricia Grimshaw, “The Australian Family: An Historical Interpretation”inThe Family in the Modern World: Australian Perspectives, ed.Ailsa Burns,Gill Bottomley andPenny Jools(:George Allen & Unwin, 1983), 34. Google Scholar

44.Kirby, Child Labour in Britain, 43;Ramsland, Children of the Back Lanes, 63, 65, 70. Google Scholar

45. Sydney Morning Herald, 25 February, 21 March, 18 April1851;Maitland Mercury, 10, 17, 24 and 31 May1851. Google Scholar

46.Seltzer, “Labour, Skills and Migration,” 183. Google Scholar

47.Wray Vamplew, ed., Australians: Historical Statistics(:Fairfax, Syme & Weldon Associates, 1987), 41, 132–33. Google Scholar

48.Mervyn King, interviewed byMark St Leon,Glebe, September-October1989, ORAL TRC 2366, National Library of Australia (NLA). Google Scholar

49.John Rickards, Australia: A Cultural History(,Longman, 1988), 84. Google Scholar

50.Grimshaw, “Australian Family,” 35–36, 40–41, 43;Anne Summers, Damned Whores and God’s Police(:Penguin Books Australia, 2002), 365;Ruth Teale, ed., Sources on Women in Australia, 1788–1914(2:Oxford University Press, 1978), 127;King, interview. Google Scholar

51. Mudgee Liberal, 13 July1858. Google Scholar

52. Australian Town & Country Journal, 2 and 9 January, 15 May1875. Google Scholar

53.R. Dickson, “Culturing Personal Leadership,” CMA Magazine 69, no. 1(February1995):10–14;S. A. Snell andJ. W. Dean, “Integrated Manufacturing and Human Resource Management,” Academy of Management Journal 35, no. 3(1992):467–504. Google Scholar

54.Bowden, cited byArrighi, FitzGerald Brothers, 26. Google Scholar

55.Seltzer, “Labour, Skills and Migration,” 194–95. Google Scholar

56. Maitland Mercury, 9 February1853. Google Scholar

57. Bathurst Free Press, 3 June1854. Google Scholar

58. South Australian Advertiser, 27 July1865. Google Scholar

59. Illustrated Sydney News, 2 June1855;Mudgee Liberal, 20 July1858. Google Scholar

61. Outdoor Showman, November-December1948. Google Scholar

62.Mark St Leon, “Celebrated at First, Then Implied and Finally Denied: The Erosion of Aboriginal Identity in Circus, 1851–1900,” Aboriginal History 32(2008):83–101. The available evidence suggests that the only Aborigines inducted into circus in this era were males. The apparent lack of induction of Indigenous females into circus defies explanation. The extension of state control over Aboriginal welfare prevented Indigenous girls from being recruited into such morally-dangerous institutions and saved them for lives of domestic service. However, such measures would not explain why “half-caste” girls – who were barred from reserves and missions and forced onto the margins of the white community – were not recruited into circus. Google Scholar

63.Richard Broome withAlex Jackomos, Sideshow Alley(:Allen & Unwin, 1998), 23;J. Morrison, quoted inMichael Cannon, Life in the Country: Australia in the Victorian Age, Volume 2(:Thomas Nelson Australia, 1973), 247;Cornwall Chronicle, 4 March1843. Google Scholar

64.King, interview. Google Scholar

65. South Australian Advertiser, 4 January1862. Google Scholar

66.Richard Cashman, “Cricket,”inSport in Australia: A Social History, ed.Wray Vamplew andBrian Stoddart(:Cambridge University Press, 1994), 70. Google Scholar

67.Vamplew, Australians: Historical Statistics, 41. Google Scholar

68.Gareth Stedman Jones, Outcast London(:Harmondsworth, 1984), 31;Kirby, Child Labour in Britain, 69–70;Cannon, Life in the Country, 247. Google Scholar

69.Heather Shore, Artful Dodgers: Youth and Crime in Early Nineteenth-Century London(:Boydell Press, 2002), 14–19. Google Scholar

70. Herald(Melbourne), 11 July1908. Google Scholar

71. Evening News, 15 May1897. Google Scholar

72. Sydney Morning Herald, 10 September1900. Google Scholar

73. Sunday Times, 10 November1895. Google Scholar

74. New Zealand Mail, 21 March1901. Google Scholar

75. Bulletin, 26 November1892. Google Scholar

77.Arrighi, FitzGerald Brothers, 25;Garton, Out of Luck, 74–77. Google Scholar

79.Anon., “The Growth of a Great Circus,” Australasian Stage Annual 1(1900):45–46. Google Scholar

80. Sydney Mail, 9 September1900;Townsville Daily Bulletin, 12 October1937. Google Scholar

81.J. Grant Pattison, Battlers’ Tales of Early Rockhampton(:Fraser & Jenkinson, 1939), 91. Google Scholar

82. Sydney Morning Herald, 22 December1897. Google Scholar

83. Official Year Book of the Commonwealth of Australia, no. 1(1908):155. Google Scholar

84.Van Krieken, Children and the State, 53. Google Scholar

85. Ibid., 71. Google Scholar

86.Nell Musgrove, The Scars Remain: A Long History of Forgotten Australians and Children’s Institutions(:Australian Scholarly Publishing, 2013), 56. Google Scholar

87.Jaggs, Neglected and Criminal, 118. Google Scholar

88. Sydney Sportsman, 7 February1906. Google Scholar

89.Frances, Selling Sex, 123;Teale, Sources on Women, 229. Google Scholar

90.Teale, Sources on Women, 229. Google Scholar

91.Katharine Susannah Prichard, Haxby’s Circus(:Angus & Roberston, 1988), 105. Google Scholar

92.Hall, 1928, cited inJaggs, Neglected and Criminal, 118. Google Scholar

93.R. W. Connell andT. H. Irving, Class Structure in Australian History: Documents, Narrative and Argument(:Longman Cheshire, 1980), 123–26. Google Scholar

94.Seymour, Dealing with Young Offenders, 3. Google Scholar

95. Ibid., 25–62. Google Scholar

96.Spark andCuthbert, Other People’s Children, 24. Google Scholar

97.Jan Kociumbas, Australian Childhood: A History(:Allen & Unwin, 1987), 108–109;Kristy Thinee andTracy Bradford, Connecting Kin: Guide to Records: A Guide to Help People Separated from Their Families Search for Their Records(:NSW Department of Community Services, 1998), 11. Google Scholar

98.Musgrove, Scars Remain, 49. Google Scholar

99.Cunningham, Leisure in the Industrial Revolution, 416. Google Scholar

100.Albert Gordon Austin, Australian Education, 1788–1900: Church, State and Public Education in Colonial Australia(:Sir Isaac Pitman & Sons, 1965), 181. Google Scholar

101.Garton, Out of Luck, 70. Google Scholar

102. Education Act(, 1872), Sec. 13 (III). Google Scholar

103. Gundagai Times, 15 May1899. Google Scholar

104.Brian K. de Garis, “1890–1900,”inA New History of Australia, ed.Frank Crowley(,William Heinemann, 1974), 241;Connell andIrving, Class Structure, 205–206. Google Scholar

105.Van Krieken, Children and the State, 129. Google Scholar

106.Kerry Carrington withMargaret Pereira, Offending Youth: Sex, Crime and Justice(:Federation Press, 2009), 7. Google Scholar

107. Geelong Advertiser, 30 January, 3 February1879;Sydney Morning Herald, 4 February1879;Argus, 27 November1891;Daily Telegraph, 21 January1893;Silver Age, 24, 25 April1890. With respect to the Godfrey case, the deceased boy’s father, a South Australian government official, had “virtually sold” the illegitimate child “when a mere baby” to the acrobat Jack Ice (Ise/Hise). The infant died at Broken Hill, NSW, from injuries inflicted by Ice in the course of his acrobatic training. Google Scholar

108. South Australian Register, 8 December1894. Google Scholar

109.Charles G. Heydon, cited inCecil Edward Weigall, Infants’ Custody, Maintenance & Protection Acts (NSW)(:The Law Book Company of Australasia, 1908), 170. Google Scholar

110.O’Brien, Poverty’s Prison, 1988, 181. Google Scholar

111. Bulletin, 20 November1897. Google Scholar

112.Heydon, cited inWeigall, Infants’ Custody, 242–43. Google Scholar

113.Van Krieken, Children and the State, 107. Google Scholar

114.Eric Trevail, transcript of interview withMark St Leon andHazell Barry, Sydney, June1987, ORAL TRC 2692/9, NLA. Google Scholar

115.Weigall, Infants’ Custody, 242–43. Google Scholar

116.State Children Relief Board, Annual Report(1912):46. Google Scholar

117. Ibid., (1916):53. Google Scholar

118. The Showman 1, no. 2(31 July1909):1, photocopy of original in possession of the author. Google Scholar

119.Musgrove, Scars Remain, 50. Google Scholar

120.Timothy Augustine Coghlan, The Decline of the Birth-Rate in New South Wales(,Government Printer, 1903), 9, cited inSummers, Damned Whores, 367. Google Scholar

121.Teale, Sources on Women, 135–36. Google Scholar

122.Summers, Damned Whores, 365–67. Google Scholar

123.Thinee andBradford, Connecting Kin, 12. Google Scholar

124.Marilyn Lake, “State Socialism for Australian Mothers: Andrew Fisher’s Radical Maternalism in its International and Local Contexts,” Labour History, no. 102(May2012):55–70;King, interview. Google Scholar

125.Captain Grose, A Dictionary of Buckish Slang, University Wit and Pickpocket Eloquence(:Digest Books, 1971), np. Google Scholar

126.Jaggs, Neglected and Criminal, 118. Google Scholar

127.King, interview. Google Scholar

128.Adrian Francis St Leon, inSt Leon, Australian Circus Reminiscences, 168. Google Scholar

129.Sadie St Leon, inibid., 134. Google Scholar

130.King, interview. Google Scholar

131.Seymour, Dealing with Young Offenders, 67. Google Scholar

132.Kociumbas, Australian Childhood, 156. Google Scholar

133.Marizles Martin in St Leon, Australian Circus Reminiscences, 12, 20, 64. Google Scholar

134.Mark Valentine St Leon, “Wirth, May Emmeline (1894–1978),” Australian Dictionary of Biography, Volume 12(:National Centre of Biography, Australian National University, 1990), accessed April 2016,http://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/wirth-may-emmeline-9158/text16169. Google Scholar

135.Thinee andBradford, Connecting Kin, 12. Google Scholar

136.Kociumbas, Australian Childhood, 156. Google Scholar

137.Mavis Dennis, transcript of interview with Mark St Leon, Perth, 1987, held by the author. Google Scholar

138.Thinee andBradford, Connecting Kin, 66. Google Scholar

139.Madge Seymour, transcript of interview withMark St Leon,Brisbane, 1987, ORAL TRC 2692/1, NLA. Google Scholar

140. Argus, 19 November1924;Dubbo Weekender, 18 December2010. Google Scholar

141.Emily Lyons, transcript of interview with Robert Willis and John Meredith, Dubbo, 2 November 1990, ORAL TRC 2590/10, NLA; Emily Lyons, transcript of a telephone conversation with Mark St Leon, December 2007, held by the author;Mick andPhyl Joffe, Endangered Characters of Australia: Their Yarns and Caricatures, Volume 1(:Mick & Phyl Joffe, 1988), 128–29. Google Scholar

142.Weigall, Infants’ Custody, 209. Google Scholar

143.Emily Lyons, notes from a telephone conversation with Mark St Leon, 2007, held by the author. Google Scholar

144.Anthony M. Platt, The Child Savers: The Invention of Delinquency(:University of Chicago Press, 1969), xxvii. Google Scholar

145.Jaggs, Neglected and Criminal, 133. Google Scholar

146.Carrington, Offending Youth, 8–9. Google Scholar

147.Thinee andBradford, Connecting Kin, 12. Google Scholar

148.Rex Rickard, notes of conversation with Mark St Leon, Sanctuary Point, 2010, held by the author. Google Scholar

149. Sun Herald, 17 May1953. Google Scholar

150.Garton, Out of Luck, 31. Google Scholar

151. Longreach Leader, 8 August1952. Google Scholar

152. Courier-Mail, 23 September1954;Jaggs, Neglected and Criminal, 135. Google Scholar

153. Sunday Telegraph, 18 August1974. Google Scholar

154.Philip Cornford, “The Circus Lives,” National Times, November1973, 12. Google Scholar

155. “Arts Training Bodies,” Department of Communications and the Arts, Australian Government, accessed April 2016,http://arts.gov.au/about/who-we-support/training-bodies. Google Scholar

156.St Leon, Circus, 240ff. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Leon, Mark St