Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

Taking Control: The Work-In Phenomenon in the Australian Metal Trades, 1969–78

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2015), 109, (1), 93–109.

Abstract

During the union upsurge of the early 1970s, the “work-in” became a term to describe actions during which workers continued work in defiance of retrenchment. This article analyses the contours of the work-in phenomenon during this period as it occurred in the Australian metal trades. It is observed that the work-in was not only occasionally successful as a tactic for reversing retrenchments, but, in many cases, was expressive of an impulse among workers to challenge or subvert capitalist relations of production. The work-in phenomenon at times circulated with ideas of self-management and even worker ownership, in a tendency referred to by left-wing unionists as “workers’ control.” Shop committees were the basis of the work-in tactic, and a contest developed between the power of unionists and capitalist authority at the enterprise level, of which the work-in was indicative. The study draws on rank-and-file sources, including the Victorian metal worker journal, Link, and records of the Communist Party of Australia. These sources are used to give an overview of developments hitherto neglected in radical historiographies of the period. Work-ins and worker ownership have become resurgent features of industrial action since the global recession of 2008, giving presentist value to an analysis of the 1970s.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

1.For an example of a recent campaign to reinstate unionists, seeLuba Grigorovitch, “This Win is Yours,” RTBU Express: Official Newsletter of the Rail Divisions of the RTBU Victorian Branch 1, no. 8(July2014). Google Scholar

2.Tom Bramble, Trade Unionism in Australia: A History from Flood to Ebb Tide(:Cambridge University Press, 2008), 41–71. Google Scholar

3.Jack Hutson, “Workers Control,” Australian Left Review, no. 1(February–March1969):8. Google Scholar

4.“Symposium: Workers’ Control,” Australian Left Review, no. 41(August1973):12. Google Scholar

5.Gar Alperovitz, American Beyond Capitalism: Reclaiming Our Wealth, Our Liberty, and Our Democracy(:John Wiley & Sons, 2005), vi. Google Scholar

6.See for exampleGar Alperovitz, What Then Must We Do? Straight Talk about the Next American Revolution(:Chelsea Green Publishing, 2013). See alsoRichard D. Wolff, Democracy at Work: A Cure for Capitalism(:Haymarket Books, 2012). See alsoJ. K. Gibson-Graham,Jenny Cameron, andStephen Healy, Take Back the Economy: An Ethical Guide for Transforming Our Communities(:University of Minnesota Press, 2013). Google Scholar

7.See for exampleVan Badham, “Christmas Cheer for Sacked Turkey Workers Comes in the Form of Co-op,” The Age, 15 December2014. See alsoMichael Green, “Workers’ Cooperatives: A Stake in the Business,” The Age, 27 August2014. Google Scholar

8.Meredith Burgmann,Verity Burgmann andRay Jureidini, “Doing Without the Boss: Workers’ Control Experiments in Australia in the 1970s,” Labour History, no. 103(November2012):103. Google Scholar

9. Ibid., 105. Google Scholar

10. Ibid., 104. Google Scholar

11.SeeColin Crouch, Class Conflict and the Industrial Relations Crisis: Compromise and Corporatism in the Policies of the British State(:Humanities Press, 1977). Google Scholar

12.Alan Tuckman, “Workers’ Control and the Politics of Factory Occupation,”inOurs to Master and to Own: Workers’ Control from the Commune to the Present, ed.Immanuel Ness andDario Azzellini(:Haymarket Books, 2011), 285. Google Scholar

13.Ken Coates, The New Worker Co-operatives(:Spokesman Books, 1976), 11. Google Scholar

14.Meredith Burgmann andVerity Burgmann, Green Bans, Red Union: Environmental Activism and the New South Wales Builders Labourers’ Federation(:University of New South Wales Press, 1998), 297. Google Scholar

15.Pete Thomas, Miners in the 1970s: A Narrative History of the Miners Federation(:Miners Federation, 1983), 21. See alsoPete Thomas, The Nymboida Story: The Work-Ins That Saved a Coalmine(:Australian Coal and Shale Employees Federation, 1975). Google Scholar

16.Tom O’Lincoln, Years of Rage: Social Conflicts in the Fraser Era(:Bookmarks, 1993), 119–23. Google Scholar

17.See for exampleBarry Hill, Sitting In(Port Melbourne,, 1991). Google Scholar

18.Tom O’Lincoln, Into the Mainstream:The Decline of Australian Communism(:Red Rag Publications, 2009), 176. Google Scholar

19. Ibid. Google Scholar

20.Drew Cottle andAngela Keyes, “The 1971 Harco ‘Stay-Put’: Workers’ Control in One Factory?” The Hummer: Bulletin of the Sydney Branch of the Australian Society for the Study of Labour History 4, no. 1(Summer 2003–04), accessed September 2015,http://asslh.org.au/hummer/vol-4-no-1/harco/. Google Scholar

21.John Cleary, interview with author, 12 August2014. Google Scholar

23.For an overview of rank-and-filism, seeJonathan Zeitlin, “Rank and Filism in British Labour History: A Critique,” International Review of Social History 34, no. 1(April1989):45. See alsoTom Bramble, “Trade Union Organization and Workplace Industrial Relations in the Vehicle Industry 1963 to 1991,” Journal of Industrial Relations 35, no. 1(1993):54. Google Scholar

24.Christopher Wright, The Management of Labour: A History of Australian Employers(:Oxford University Press, 1995), 185. See alsoBramble, Trade Unionism in Australia, 41–71. Google Scholar

25.Quoted byThomas Bramble, “Australian Union Strategies since 1945,” Labour & Industry: A Journal of the Social and Economic Relations of Work 11, no. 3(April2001):14. Google Scholar

26.Little research has been undertaken on the activities of shop committees at this time. The most recent study isMalcolm Rimmer andPaul Sutcliffe, Slaves to Our Own Apathy: The Growth and Decline of the Shop Committee Movement in Australia, Research Report, no. 4, Business Research Centre (:North Brisbane College of Advanced Education, 1979). Google Scholar

27.Cleary, interview. Google Scholar

28.Susanna Short, Laurie Short: A Political Life(:Allen & Unwin, 1992), 233. Google Scholar

29.Tom Sheridan, Mindful Militants: The Amalgamated Engineering Union in Australia, 1920–1972(:Cambridge University, 1975), 280. See alsoJack Hutson, Penal Colony to Penal Powers(:Amalgamated Metals Foundry and Shipwrights’ Union, 1983). Google Scholar

30.Henry S. Albinksi, Politics and Foreign Policy in Australia: The Impact of Vietnam and Conscription(:Duke University Press, 1970), 208–9. Albinski passes commentary on the radicalisation of Australian society generally, but ignores the labour movement, as has been identified elsewhere; seeM. J. Saunders, “The Trade Unions in Australia and Opposition to Vietnam and Conscription,” Labour History, no. 43(November1982):64. Google Scholar

31.Stohl refers to the “nexus between civil conflict and international conflict” as “one of the most venerable hypotheses in the social science literature.” SeeMichael Stohl, “The Nexus of Civil and International Conflict,”inHandbook of Political Conflict: Theory and Research, ed.Ted Robert Gurr(:The Free Press, 1980), 297. See alsoBeverly J. Silver, “World-Scale Patterns of Labor-Capital Conflict: Labor Unrest, Long Waves, and Cycles of World Hegemony,” Review(Fernand Braudel Center) 18, no. 1(Winter1995):155–92. Google Scholar

32.Milton Derber, “Changing Union-Management Relations at the Plant Level in Australian Metalworking 1969–1976,” Journal of Industrial Relations 19, no. 1(March1977):2. Google Scholar

33.SirWalter Scott, “Looking into the 1970s”(paper presented at the Autumn Seminar of the Royal Institute of Public Administration, 1970). Google Scholar

34.Cleary, interview. Google Scholar

35.Malcolm Saunders, “The Trade Unions in Australia and Opposition to Vietnam and Conscription, 1965–73,” Labour History, no. 43(1982):64–82. Google Scholar

36.Gavin Souter, “Sacking the Boss: From ‘Working-In’ to Taking Over,” Sydney Morning Herald, 28 July1973. Google Scholar

37.SeeKen Coates, Workers’ Control: Another World is Possible: Arguments from the Institute for Workers’ Control(:Spokesman, 2003). See alsoKen Coates andTony Topham, The New Unionism: The Case for Workers’ Control(:Peter Owen, 1972). See alsoErnie Roberts, Workers’ Control(:George Allen & Unwin, 1973). Google Scholar

38.Hutson, “Workers Control,” 8–9. For histories of the British shop stewards, seeCarter Goodrich, The Frontier of Control: A Study in British Workshop Politics, 2nd ed. (:Pluto Press, 1975). See alsoJames Hinton, The First Shop Stewards’ Movement(:Allen & Unwin, 1973). Google Scholar

39.SeeVerity Burgmann, Revolutionary Industrial Unionism: The Industrial Workers of the World in Australia(:Cambridge University Press, 1995), 3–4. Google Scholar

40. Modern Unionism and the Workers’ Movement(:Communist Party of Australia, 1970), 10. Google Scholar

41.Denis Freney, “Workers’ Control Perspectives,” Australian Left Review, no. 39(1973):3. Google Scholar

42. “What is Workers’ Control?”(included in the Queensland Workers’ Control Conference Proceedings, Brisbane, 17–18 November1973). Google Scholar

43.Mick Tubbs andLloyd Caldwell, The Harco Work-In: An Experience of Workers’ Control(:Sydney Centre for Workers’ Control, 1973), 2. See alsoM. Tubbs, “They Refused to Take Sack,” Tribune, 1 December1971, 4. Google Scholar

44.Mick Tubbs, interview with author, 4 September 2014. Google Scholar

45.“Refusing the Sack,” Tribune, 18–24 January1972, 11. Google Scholar

46.“Stay Put on Ships and Metal Shops,” Tribune, 14 December1971. Google Scholar

47.Tubbs andCaldwell, The Harco Work-In, 2. Google Scholar

48. Ibid., 18. Google Scholar

49.“Work-Ins in Melbourne,” Tribune, 6–12 November1973, 12. Google Scholar

50.“They Gave the Boss the Sack and Got a Rise in Pay,” Boilermakers and Blacksmiths’ Society Journal(February–March1972):3. Google Scholar

51.“The Workers Sacked the Boss,” Tribune, 1–7 February1972, 4. Google Scholar

52.Mick Tubbs, “For Right to Work and Not Some ‘Right’ to Fire,” Tribune, 17 November1971, 4. Google Scholar

53.R. Dixon, “130,000 Workless by March,” Tribune, 8 December1971, 3. See also“Action on Sackings Scores a Victory,” Tribune, 1 December1971, 4. Google Scholar

54.“On Workers’ Control,” Tribune, 13–19 June1972, 11. Google Scholar

55.John Wallace andJoe Owens, Workers Call the Tune at Opera House(:National Workers Control Conference, 1973), 3. Google Scholar

56. Ibid., 5. Google Scholar

57.Victor Wallis, “Workers’ Control and Revolution,”inOurs to Master and to Own: Workers’ Control from the Commune to the Present, ed.Dario Azzellini andImmanuel Ness(:Haymarket Books, 2011), 10. Google Scholar

58.“Police Arrest Work-In Men,” Tribune, 6–10 April1973, 2. Google Scholar

59.“Clydemaster Bosses Pay for Sacking 25,” The Link: Eastern Suburbs Metal Workers Bulletin, September1976. Google Scholar

60.Derber, “Changing Union-Management Relations,” 15. Google Scholar

62.Tom Bramble, “Conflict, Coercion and Co-option: The Role of Full-Time Officials in the South Australian Branch of the Vehicle Builders Employees’ Federation, 1967–80,” Labour History, no. 63(November1992):142. Google Scholar

63.“G.M.H. Jack-Up,” Tribune, 11 August1971, 4. Google Scholar

64.Renfrey Clark, “Car Worker Jailed for Refusing the Sack,” Direct Action, no. 83(24 April1975):5. Google Scholar

65.“How Unions Looked after the Essential Services,” Tribune, 8–14 August1972. Google Scholar

66. Ibid. Google Scholar

67.“Unions to Free Some Oil,” The Herald, 26 July1972, 1. Google Scholar

68.“Work-In,” Link, March1978. Google Scholar

69. Ibid. Google Scholar

70.“Unanderra Workers Refuse Sack,” Tribune, 29 May–4 June1973, 4. Google Scholar

71.“Metal Workers Occupy Balmain Job: Work-In to Stop Sackings,” Tribune, 28 January1975, 4. Google Scholar

72.“Steward Blacklisted,” Link, September1976. Google Scholar

73. Ibid. Google Scholar

74.“‘Jobs before Profits’ Say Striking A.P.M workers,” Link, November1978. Google Scholar

75. Ibid. Google Scholar

76.“Kenworth Militants Sacked,” Link, November–December1976. Google Scholar

77. Ibid. Google Scholar

78.Derber, “Changing Union-Management Relations,” 15. Google Scholar

79. RPM: Militant Workers’ Bulletin, no. 5(December1974):6. Google Scholar

80.“Olex Lilydale: Long Dispute over Retrenchments,” Link, June1978. Google Scholar

81.Anna Stewart, “The Business Offensive in the United States: Will It Spread?” Journal of Industrial Relations 22, no. 4(December1980):488. Google Scholar

82.SeeBreen Creighton, “Law and the Control of Industrial Conflict,”inPower, Conflict and Control in Australian Trade Unions, ed.Kathryn Cole(:Pelican Books, 1982), 132. See alsoAlex Carey, Taking the Risk Out of Democracy: Propaganda in the US and Australia(:University of New South Wales Press, 1995), 99. Google Scholar

83.Creighton, “Law and Control of Industrial Conflict,” 145. Google Scholar

84. AMWU Monthly Journal, July1976, 8. Google Scholar

85.“Indexation: Moore Rip Offs,” Link, March1977, emphasis in the original. Google Scholar

86.In the UK, work-ins were undermined by the 1975Employment Protection Act, which “consolidated the role of the trade union as negotiating terms and conditions of redundancy and allowed collective resistance to dissipate.” SeeTuckman, “Workers’ Control and the Politics of Factory Occupation,” 297. Google Scholar

87.Harvie Ramsay, “Worker Participation in Historical and Sociological Perspective,” Sociology 11, no. 3(September1977):496. Google Scholar

88. Industry and Society: A Discussion Document(:Central Industrial Secretariat, c.1974), 6. See alsoCommunication, Consultation, Negotiation(:Central Industrial Secretariat, c.1974). Google Scholar

89.The Liberal Party of Australia, “Worker Participation or Workers’ Control?”, September1973, item N63/307, Noel Butlin Archive, Canberra. Google Scholar

90.Norman Dufty, “Industrial Democracy in Australia,” International Studies of Management & Organization 17, no. 2(Summer1987):11. Google Scholar

91.Ray Markey andGreg Patmore, “The Role of the State in the Diffusion of Industrial Democracy: South Australia, 1972–79,” Economic and Industrial Democracy 30, no. 1(2009):37–66. Google Scholar

92.Raymond Markey andGreg Patmore, “Employee Participation and Labour Representation: ICI Works Councils in Australia, 1942–75,” Labour History, no. 97(November2009):68. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Oldham, Sam