Labour History

Mutualism and Labourism in the Experience of Westfund

Labour History (2017), 112, (1), 61–79.

Abstract

This paper explores the dynamic by which “labourism” potentially undermines “mutualism” by examining the experience of Westfund under Australian Labour Party governments. The principle of self-help and the act of organising to provide mutual benefits have strong traditions in the labour movement. Westfund was a health fund established in 1953 by the Western District Branch of the Miners’ Federation in Lithgow New South Wales, largely to provide medical benefits to miners. Organised labour historically has also campaigned for state provision of welfare services. In Australia, the notion of “Labourism” refers to a particular approach adopted by organised labour whereby they represented their interests directly in the political sphere through the Australian Labor Party. When the labour movement achieved its aim of a more universal health care system under the Whitlam ALP government, Westfund chose to work within the system in order to survive. Mutualism and labourism co-existed. The subsequent introduction of Medicare by the Hawke ALP government brought changes which created a more threatening business environment for health funds. In this instance to mitigate the danger it posed to their business, Westfund chose to oppose more aggressively aspects of the universal health system. Westfund weakened its institutional ties to the labour movement, and became more autonomous from its roots as a mutual.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*The authors would like to thank Labour History’s two anonymous referees. They also thank Westfund for providing access to archival materials held at their head office in Lithgow. This article is based on materials collected as part of a larger project charting the history of Westfund which was funded by that organisation. Google Scholar

1.Maurice Glasman, “Labour as a Radical Tradition,” in The Labour Tradition and the Politics of Paradox: The Oxford London Seminars 2010–2011, ed. Maurice Glasman, Jonathan Rutherford, Marc Stears and Stuart White (London: London Oxford Seminars, 2011), 23. Google Scholar

2.Andrew Gale and David Watson, Adventures in Health Risk: A History of Australian Health Insurance (Melbourne: Institute of Actuaries of Australia, 2007), 18. Google Scholar

3.Johnston Birchall, People-Centered Businesses: Co-operatives, Mutuals and the Idea of Membership (Houndsmills, UK: Palgrave Macmillan, 2011), 6. Google Scholar

4.Ibid. Google Scholar

5.Nikola Balnave and Greg Patmore, “Rochdale Consumer Co-operatives in Australia: Decline and Survival,” Business History 54, no. 6 (2012): 987; Johnston Birchall, “A ‘Member-Owned Business’ Approach to the Classification of Co-operatives and Mutuals,” Journal of Co-operative Studies 44, no. 2 (2011): 4–15; Birchall, People-Centered Businesses, 3. Google Scholar

6.Race Matthews, Jobs of Our Own: Building a Stake-Holder Society: Alternatives to the Market and the State (Annandale, NSW: Pluto Press, 1999), 168–73. Google Scholar

7.Dan Weinbren and Bob James, “Getting a Grip: The Roles of Friendly Societies in Australia and Britain Reappraised,” Labour History, no. 88 (May 2005): 87, 96. Google Scholar

8.Leslie Falk, “Coal Miners’ Prepaid Medical Care in the United States - and Some British Relationships, 1792–1964,” Medical Care 4, no. 1 (1966): 38. Google Scholar

9.Robin Gollan, The Coalminers of New South Wales: A History of the Union, 1860–1960 (Parkville, Vic.: Melbourne University Press, 1963), 28. Google Scholar

10.David Green and Lawrence Cromwell, Mutual Aid or Welfare State: Australia’s Friendly Societies (North Sydney: George Allen & Unwin, 1984), 79. Google Scholar

11.Nikki Balnave and Greg Patmore, “The AMWU: Politics and Industrial Relations, 1852–2012,” in Organise, Educate, Control: The AMWU in Australia 1852–2012, ed. Andrew Reeves and Andrew Dettmer (Clayton, Vic.: Monash University Publishing, 2013), 5. Google Scholar

12.Sidney Webb and Beatrice Webb, Industrial Democracy (London: Amalgamated Society of Engineers, 1898), 159. More recently, in 1987, the Australian Council of Trade Unions (ACTU) argued that “[i]ncreased pressure on public spending in areas such as social security, health benefits, education, etc, may make it worthwhile to look at the provision of membership services to fill the gaps. Unions should also give consideration to the provision of insurance and financial services; superannuation advice; topping-up of health benefits; arts, cultural and social services, and credit facilities.” ACTU, Future Strategies for the Trade Union Movement (Melbourne: ACTU, 1987), 19. Google Scholar

13.Webb and Webb, Industrial Democracy, 152. Google Scholar

14.Ibid., 154. Google Scholar

15.Ibid., 161. Google Scholar

16.Ibid., 155. Google Scholar

17.Ibid., 171. Google Scholar

18.Ibid., 767. Google Scholar

19.A. M. McBriar, Fabian Socialism and English Politics, 1884–1918 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1962), 69. Google Scholar

20.T. Horton, “A Short Guide to the Minority Report,” in From the Workhouse to Welfare, ed. E. Wallis (London: Fabian Society, 2009). Google Scholar

21.G. D. H. Cole, The British Co-Operative Movement in a Socialist Society (London: George Allen and Unwin Ltd, 1951), 15. Google Scholar

22.Glasman, “Labour as a Radical Tradition,” 21–23. Google Scholar

23.Peter Beilharz, “The Labourist Tradition and the Reforming Imagination,” in Australian Welfare: Historical Sociology, ed. R. Kennedy (Melbourne: Macmillian, 1989), 137. Google Scholar

24.Peter Beilharz, “Australian Laborism, Social Democracy, and Social Justice,” Social Justice 16, no. 3 (1989): 15–29. Google Scholar

25.Beilharz, “The Labourist Tradition and Reforming Imagination,” 132–53. Google Scholar

26.Humphrey McQueen, “Laborism and Socialism,” in The Australian New Left, ed. Richard Gordon (Melbourne: William Heinemann, 1970), 43–65. Google Scholar

27.Beilharz, “The Labourist Tradition and Reforming Imagination,” 137. Google Scholar

28.Francis G. Castles, The Working Class and Welfare: Reflections on the Political Development of the Welfare State in Australia and New Zealand, 1890–1980 (Wellington: Allen and Unwin, 1985), 77–79. Google Scholar

29.Ibid., 103. Google Scholar

30.Jim Hagan, The History of the ACTU (Melbourne, Vic.: Longman Cheshire, 1981), 14. Google Scholar

31.Castles, The Working Class and Welfare, 104. Google Scholar

32.Greg Patmore and David Coates, “Labour Parties and the State in Australia and the UK,” Labour History, no. 88 (May 2005): 123–24; Leighton James and Ray Markey, “Class and Labour: The British Labour Party and the Australian Labor Party Compared,” Labour History, no. 90 (May 2006): 31–36. Google Scholar

33.Brian Dickey, No Charity There: A Short History of Social Welfare in Australia, 2nd ed. (Sydney: Allen and Unwin, 1987), 128–29; James Gillespie, The Price of Health: Australian Governments and Medical Politics 1910–1960 (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1991), 105–109; Hagan, The History of the ACTU, 173–74. Google Scholar

34.Green and Cromwell, Mutual Aid or Welfare State, 160–70; Newcastle Morning Herald, 1 July 1953, 4; Gillespie, The Price of Health, 277; Sidney Sax, A Strife of Interests: Politics and Policies in Australian Health Services (North Sydney: George Allen and Unwin, 1984), 60–65; Sydney Morning Herald, 1 July 1953, 5. Google Scholar

35.Ann-Marie Boxall and James Gillespie, Making Medicare: The Politics of Universal Health Care in Australia (Sydney: University of New South Wales Press, 2013), 35; Commonwealth of Australia, Health Insurance: Report of the Commonwealth Committee of Enquiry (Canberra: Australian Government Printing Office, 1969), 7; Jennifer De Voe and Stephanie Short, “A Shift in the Historical Trajectory of Medical Dominance: The Case of Medibank and the Australian Doctors’ Lobby,” Social Science and Medicine, no. 57 (2003): 348–49; Gale and Watson, Adventures in Health Risk, 4; Sax, A Strife of Interests, 75–96. Google Scholar

36.Boxall and Gillespie, Making Medicare, 37. Google Scholar

37.Australian Women’s Weekly, 9 July 1975, 15; Boxall and Gillespie, Making Medicare, 36–77; Canberra Times, 18 November 1974, 6; 24 December 1974, 3; 24 March 1975, 3, 18 April 1975, 9; De Voe and Short, “A Shift in the Historical Trajectory of Medical Dominance,” 349–50; Dickey, No Charity There, 173; Stephen Duckett, “Making a Difference in Health Care,” in The Hawke Government: A Critical Retrospective, ed. Susan Ryan and Troy Bramston (North Melbourne, Vic.: Pluto Press, 2003), 215–16; Gale and Watson, Adventures in Health Risk, 5; Heather Gardner, “Political Parties and Health Policies,” in The Politics of Health: The Australian Experience, ed. Heather Gardiner, 2nd ed. (Melbourne, Vic.: Churchill Livingstone, 1995), 167–68; Sax, A Strife of Interests, 108–22; Richard Scotton and Christine MacDonald, The Making of Medibank (Kensington, NSW: School of Health Services Management, University of NSW, 1993), 19–29, 41–44, 50–146. Data from Commonwealth Department of Health, Operations of the Registered Medical Benefits and Hospital Benefits Organizations: Annual Reports for the respective years. Google Scholar

38.Boxall and Gillespie, Making Medicare, 79–89, 101; Sax, A Strife of Interests, 129–30, 136–38, 155–56; Scotton and MacDonald, The Making of Medibank, 249–57. Google Scholar

39.Australian Trade Union Training Authority, Statement of Accord by the Australian Labor Party and the Australian Council of Trade Unions regarding Economic Policy, February 1983 (Wodonga: TUTA, 1983), 17. Google Scholar

40.Duckett, “Making a Difference in Health Care,” 216; Gillespie and Boxall, Making Medicare, 143–44. Google Scholar

41.Gale and Watson, Adventures in Health Risk, 6–7. Google Scholar

42.Andrew Metcalfe, For Freedom and Dignity: Historical Agency and Class Structure in the Coalfields of NSW (North Sydney: Allen & Unwin, 1988), 61. Google Scholar

43.Joseph Carne, Geology and Mineral Resources on the Western Coalfield with Maps and Sections (Sydney: NSW Government Printer, 1908), 190; Greg Patmore, “Localism and Labour: Lithgow 1869–1932,” Labour History, no. 78 (May 2000): 60; Metcalfe, For Freedom and Dignity, 61–63. Google Scholar

44.Patmore, “Localism and Labour,” 61–64. Google Scholar

45.John Benson, “English Coal-Miners’ Trade Union Accident Funds,” Economic History Review 28, no. 3 (1975): 401–12; Ray Christison, A Light in the Vale: Development of the Lithgow District Miners’ Mutual Protective Association 1875–1900 (Lithgow, NSW: City of Greater Lithgow Mining Museum, 2012), 26–27, 63; Eskbank Lodge Minutes, 2 December 1889, MLMSS 1692, Mitchell Special Collections, State Library of NSW; Falk, “Coal Miners’ Prepaid Medical Care in the United States”; Lithgow Mercury, 3 March 1905, 4; Lithgow Valley Collieries Yearly Sick and Accident Fund Minutes, 27 February 1909, 17 March 1911, City of Greater Lithgow Mining Museum Collection; National Advocate (Bathurst), 7 October 1896; Vale of Clwydd Lodge Minutes, 6 May 1881, E165/33/1A, Noel Butlin Archives Centre, Australian National University. Google Scholar

46.Lithgow Mercury, 11 May 1917, 4; 15 June 1917, 6; 3 August 1917, 3; 17 August 1917, 6; 24 November 1917, 2; 25 January 1918, 6; 6 February 1918, 2; 10 May 1918, 6; 22 May 1918, 2; 14 June 1918, 6; 16 August 1918, 6; 19 August 1918, 2; 18 November 1918, 2; 16 December 1918, 2; 23 December 1918, 2; 20 January 1919, 2; 31 January 1919; Public Hospitals Act, NSW Act no. 8, 1929, section 40; Sydney Morning Herald, 13 October 1919, 7. Google Scholar

47.Common Cause, 25 June 1938, 8; 23 July 1938, 4. Google Scholar

48.Barrier Daily Truth, 25 July 1946, 3; Gillespie, The Price of Health, 201; Mudgee Guardian and North-Western Representative, 18 July 1946, 16; Steelworks Mine Lodge Minutes, 23 July 1946, City of Greater Lithgow Mining Museum Collection. Google Scholar

49.Common Cause, 6 June 1953, 6; Western District Board of Management Meeting Minutes, Australasian Coal and Shale Employees Federation (ACSEF), 13 September 1952, 1 June 1953, Lithgow City Library. Google Scholar

50.Common Cause, 26 February 1955, 3; Interview by authors with Len Ashworth, Editor of Lithgow Mercury, Lithgow, 13 January 2015; Letter, G. Danaher to M McNamara, 18 March 1987, Westfund Archives Lithgow (hereafter WAL; Lithgow Mercury, 27 July 1955, 1. Google Scholar

52.Memo, Medibank, 19 June 1978, WAL; Westfund, Annual Report: 1976–1977, no page numbers. Google Scholar

53.Boxall and Gillespie, Making Medicare, 82–83. Google Scholar

54.Ibid., 85–87. Google Scholar

55.Westfund, 29th Annual Report: 1981–82, 1; Interview by authors with Grahame Danaher, CEO of Westfund, Lithgow, 13 January 2015; Interview by authors with Howard Fisher, Chair of Westfund, Lithgow, 13 January 2015; Telephone interview by authors with Ross White, Director of Westfund, 19 January 2016; Lithgow Mercury, 23 November 1981, 4; The Press, 22 June 1982, 3; Western District Board of Management Meeting Minutes, ACSEF, 17 October 1975, Lithgow City Library; Westfund, 1953–1993 (Lithgow, NSW: Westfund, 1993), no page numbers; Data from Commonwealth Department of Health, Operations of the Registered Medical Benefits and Hospital Benefits Organizations: Annual Reports for the respective years; Boxall and Gillespie, Making Medicare. Google Scholar

57.Westfund, Annual Report 1985/86. Google Scholar

59.Lithgow Mercury, 4 April 1987; Grahame Danaher’s Report to WDHF Board Meeting, 23 September 1988 and 22 June 1990, WAL. Google Scholar

60.Letter from Simmons to Blewitt, 28 September 1983, WAL. Google Scholar

61.Healthdate, 23 November 1987; Lithgow Mercury, 5 March 1988; Letters from Simmons to Blewett dated 28 September 1983, 16 November 1983, WAL. Google Scholar

62.Healthdate, 19 January 1988; Letters, McPherson, Town Clerk, Council of the City of Greater Lithgow to Executive Officer, WDHF, 28 January 1988; WDHF to Jim Angel, Mayor City of the Blue Mountains, 17 February 1988; WDHF to R. J. Hawke, 29 March 1988, Prime Minister; Press Release, VHIAA (Voluntary Health Insurance Association of Australia), 9 March 1988, WAL; Lithgow Mercury, 5 March 1988. Google Scholar

63.Gale and Watson, Adventures in Health Risk, 4. Google Scholar

64.Ibid., 6. Google Scholar

65.Media Release, “Wrong Advice Forces Up Health Insurance Costs,” NIB Health Funds, 28 February 1990; Letter, D. Simmons to G. Danaher, 20 March 1990, WAL. Google Scholar

68.Lithgow Mercury, 26 May 1987; Wellington Times, 14 June 1995. Google Scholar

69.Media Release, “Wrong Advice Forces Up Health Insurance Costs.” Google Scholar

70.Letter WDHF to Member, undated; Facsimile of press advertisement, 21 March 1990; Facsimile, NSW Teachers Federation, “A Threat to Union Based Health Funds,” 1 March 1990; Letter, HIRMAA (Health Insurance Restricted Membership Association of Australia) to Editor, Lithgow Mercury, 16 March 1990; Letter, Government Employees Health Fund to Editor, Lithgow Mercury, 9 March 1990; Facsimile copy (1 March 1990) of letter Labor Council of New South Wales to N. Blewett, 29 March 1989; WDHF, Reply to Blewett and Simmons Statement, undated, WAL; Lithgow Mercury, 1 March 1990; WestCare, March 1990, December 1990. Google Scholar

71.Fund Management Report to WDHF Annual General Meeting, 29 September 1992, WAL. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Knowles, Harry

Patmore, Greg

Westcott, Mark