Labour History

Juveniles as Human Capital: Re-evaluating the Economic Value of Juvenile Male Convict Labour

Labour History (2015), 108, (1), 53–69.

Abstract

The application of “Human Capital” theory by Nicholas and others in the late 1980s to reframe our understanding of convictism was a watershed moment in colonial historical analysis. This was because it shifted debate away from the moral character of the convicts and reconceptualised them as a valuable labour commodity that was to be understood in the context of much broader patterns of forced labour migration. Drawing on pre-transportation records and evidence relating to two institutions for transported juvenile convicts — the Carters’ Barracks (Sydney) and Point Puer (Port Arthur, Van Diemen’s Land), this article examines the economic conceptualisation of juvenile male convict labour and critiques whether the same “Human Capital” theory can be applied to the juvenile convicts who were sent to New South Wales and Van Diemen’s Land. The study posits that this conceptual approach frames the juvenile transportation phenomenon too narrowly temporally, socially and economically.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*The author would like to thankLabour History‘s two anonymous referees. Google Scholar

1.Gwendoline Griffin andRonald Howell, Port Macquarie: The Winding Sheet(Port Macquarie Historical Society:, 1996), 102. Google Scholar

2.Carters’ Barracks Convict Returns, 1833, Reel 600, 4/2223, State Records NSW (SRNSW). Google Scholar

3.Ibid. Google Scholar

4.Griffin andHowell, Port Macquarie, 102. Google Scholar

6.Griffin andHowell, Port Macquarie, 103. Google Scholar

7.Ibid., 67–68. Google Scholar

8.Ibid., 103. Google Scholar

9.Kim Humphery, “Objects of Compassion: Young Male Convicts of Van Diemen’s Land,” Australian Historical Studies 25, no. 98(April1992):14. Google Scholar

10.Stephen Nicholas, ed., Convict Workers: Reinterpreting Australia’s Past(:Cambridge University Press, 1988). Google Scholar

11.Kerin Gorton andJohn Ramsland, “Prison Playground? Child Convict Labour and Vocational Training in New South Wales, 1788–1840,” Journal of Educational Administration and History 34, no. 1(April2002):51–62;Beverley Earnshaw, “The Convict Apprentices,” Push from the Bush, no. 5(December1979):82–97;Jan Kociumbas, Australian Childhood: A History(:Allen and Unwin, 1997). Google Scholar

13.Eris O’Brien, The Foundation of Australia (1786–1800): A Study of English Criminal Practice and Penal Colonization in the Eighteenth Century(:Sheed & Ward, 1937; reprinted Westport, Conn.: Greenwood, 1973);A. G. L. Shaw, Convicts and the Colonies: A Study of Penal Transportation from Great Britain and Ireland to Australia and Other Parts of the British Empire(:Faber and Faber, 1966);C. M. H. Clark, A History of Australia, vol. 2, New South Wales and Van Diemen’s Land 1822–1838(:Melbourne University Press, 1968, reprinted1987);Robert Hughes, The Fatal Shore: A History of the Transportation of Convicts to Australia, 1787–1868(:Collins Harvill, 1987). Google Scholar

14.A detailed and comprehensive overview of the development of convict labour historiography can be found inDavid Andrew Roberts, “The ‘Knotted Hands that Set Us High’: Labour History and the Study of Convict Australia,” Labour History, no. 100(May2011):33–50. Google Scholar

15.Alan Atkinson, “Four Patterns of Convict Protest,” Labour History, no. 37(November1979):28–51. Google Scholar

16.Ibid., 37. Google Scholar

17.David Neal, The Rule of Law in a Penal Colony: Law and Power in Early New South Wales(:Cambridge University Press, 1991). Google Scholar

18.Stephen Nicholas andPeter Shergold, “Unshackling the Past,”inNicholas, Convict Workers, 7. Google Scholar

19.Ibid., 9. Google Scholar

20.Ibid., 7. Google Scholar

21.Stephen Nicholas andPeter Shergold, “Convicts as Migrants,”inNicholas, Convict Workers, 43. Google Scholar

22.Raymond Evans andWilliam Thorpe, “Historical Considerations IX: Power, Punishment and Penal Labour: Convict Workers and Moreton Bay,” Australian Historical Studies 25, no. 98(1992):90–111. Google Scholar

23.Ibid., 94. Google Scholar

24.See alsoHamish Maxwell-Stewart, “Convict Workers, ‘Penal Labour’ and Sarah Island: Life at Macquarie Harbour, 1822–1834,”inIan Duffield andJames Bradley, eds, Representing Convicts: New Perspectives on Convict Forced Labour Migration(:Leicester University Press, 1997), 124–62;Richard Tuffin, “The Evolution of Convict Labour Management in Van Diemen’s Land: Placing the ‘Penal Peninsula’ in a Colonial Context,” Papers and Proceedings: Tasmanian Historical Research Association 54, no. 2(August2007):69–83. Google Scholar

25.Deborah Oxley, “Female Convicts,”inNicholas, Convict Workers, 85–97;Deborah Oxley, Convict Maid’s(:Cambridge University Press, 1996); andDeborah Oxley, “Representing Convict Women,”inDuffield andBradley, Representing Convicts, 88–105. Google Scholar

26.William Murray Robbins, “Management and Resistance in the Convict Gangs, 1788–1830,” Journal of Industrial Relations 45, no.3(September2003):360–77;William Murray Robbins, “Governor Macquarie’s Job Descriptions and the Bureaucratic Control of the Convict Labour Process,” Labour History, no. 96(May2009):1–18. Google Scholar

27.Duffield andBradley, Representing Convicts. Google Scholar

28.Heather Shore, Artful Dodgers: Youth and Crime in Early Nineteenth-Century London(:Royal Historical Society, 1999; reprint:Boydell Press, 2002);Jeanie Duckworth, Fagin’s Children: Criminal Children in Victorian England(:Hambledon and London, 2002);Peter King andJ. Noel, “The Origins of the Problem of Juvenile Delinquency: The Growth of Juvenile Prosecutions in London in the Eighteenth and Early Nineteenth Centuries,” Criminal Justice History 14(1993):17–41. Google Scholar

29.Michel Foucault, Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison, trans.Alan Sheridan, 2nd ed. (:Vintage Books, 1995);D. J. Bosley, “The Problem of the Young Offender: An Ideal Solution? Agricultural Reformatories in England and France,”inA. G. Hess andP. F. Clement, eds, History of Juvenile Delinquency: A Collection of Essays on Crime Committed by Young Offenders, in History and Selected Countries, vol. 1(:Scientia Verlag, 1993), 289–324;Henri Gaillac, Le Maison de Correction: 1830–1945(:Cujas, 1971). Google Scholar

30.Chris Leonards “Border Crossings: Care and the ‘Criminal Child’ in Nineteenth Century European Penal Congress,”inPamela Cox andHeather Shore, ed., Becoming Delinquent: British and European Youth 1650–1950, (:Dartmouth Publishing, 2002), 105–21. Google Scholar

31.Chris Leonards “Priceless Children? Penitentiary Congress Debating Childhood: A Quest for Social Order in Europe, 1846–1895,”inHerman Roodenburg, ed., Social Control in Europe(:Ohio State University Press, 2004), 137. Google Scholar

32.Nicholas andShergold, “Unshackling the Past,” 7. Google Scholar

33.Nicholas andShergold, “Convicts as Migrants,” 48. Google Scholar

34.Appropriation List, 1835–36, CON27/1/2, Tasmanian Archive and Heritage Office (TAHO). Google Scholar

35.Kociumbas, Australian Childhood, 23 Google Scholar

36.Gorton andRamsland, “Prison Playground,” 60. Google Scholar

37.Earnshaw, “The Convict Apprentices,” 93. Google Scholar

38.Gorton andRamsland, “Prison Playground,” 58. Google Scholar

39.Ibid., 61. Google Scholar

40.Humphery, “Objects of Compassion.” Google Scholar

41.Appropriation List, 1835–36, CON27/1/2, TAHO. Google Scholar

42.Ibid. Google Scholar

43.Ibid. Google Scholar

44.F. C. Hooper, Prison Boys of Port Arthur: A Study of the Point Puer Boys’ Establishment, Van Diemen’s Land, 1834–1850(:F. W. Cheshire, 1967), 26. Google Scholar

45.Terry Newman, Becoming Tasmanian(:Parliament of Tasmania, 2005), 134. Google Scholar

46. Tasmanian Description Lists, 1828–53, CON18,TAHO. Google Scholar

47.Bryan Gandevia, “A Comparison of the Height of Boys Transported to Australia from England, Scotland and Ireland, c 1840 with Later British and Australian Development,” Australian Paediatric Journal 13(1977):91–96. Google Scholar

48.Thomas E. Jordan, “Transported to Van Diemen’s Land: The Boys of the ‘Frances Charlotte’ (1832) and ‘Lord Goderich’ (1841),” Child Development 56, no. 4(August1985):1092–99. Google Scholar

49. Appropriation List, 1835–36, CON27/1/2,TAHO. Google Scholar

50.Dianne Payne, “Rhetoric, Reality and the Marine Society,” London Journal 30, no. 2(December2005):72. Google Scholar

51.Stephen Nicholas andRichard H Steckel, “Heights and Living Standards of English Workers during the Early Years of Industrialisation, 1770–1815,” Journal of Economic History 52, no. 4(December1991):946;Nicholas andShergold, “Convicts as Migrants,” 48. Google Scholar

52.Ibid. Google Scholar

53.Gorton andRamsland, “Prison Playground,” 54. Google Scholar

54.Nicholas, Convict Workers, 64. Google Scholar

55.Gorton andRamsland, “Prison Playground,” 56. Google Scholar

56.Appropriation List, 1835–36, CON27/1/2, TAHO. Google Scholar

57.Ibid. Google Scholar

58.Report from the Select Committee on the Police of the Metropolis, 1828, quoted inShore, Artful Dodgers, 39. Google Scholar

59.Shore, Artful Dodgers, 40. Google Scholar

60.Ibid. Google Scholar

61.Nicholas, Convict Workers, 74. Google Scholar

62.Evidence taken at Bow Gaol Liverpool, May1837, HO 73/16, Public Records Office, National Archives (PRO NA). Google Scholar

63.Edmund Burke, “Extracts from the Report of John Henry Capper esq. Superintendent of Ships and Vessels Employed in the Confinement of Offenders under Sentence of Transportation Jan 21, 1826,”inThe Annual Register or a View of the History, Politics and Literature of the Year 1826(;Baldwin, Craddock and Joy, 1827), 21. Google Scholar

64.Appropriation List, 1835–36, CON27/1/2, TAHO. Google Scholar

65. TheEuryalusprison hulk, quarterly returns, 1826–43, HO 8/7–78, PRO NA. Google Scholar

66.Ibid. Google Scholar

67.William Augustus Miles, Rough notes V, “Tuesday Sept 29,”HO 73/16, PRO NA. Google Scholar

68.The Euryalus prison hulk, quarterly returns, 1826–43, HO 8/7–78, PRO NA. Google Scholar

69.Earnshaw, “The Convict Apprentices,” 93. Google Scholar

70.Kociumbas, Australian Childhood, 23. Google Scholar

71.Kerin Joy Gorton, “Carters’ Barracks and Point Puer: The Confinement Experience of Convict Boys in Colonial Australia”, 1820–1850(PhD diss.,University of Newcastle, 2002), 258. Google Scholar

72.Michael Belcher, The Child in NSW Society, 1820–37(PhD diss.,University of New England, 1982), 207. Google Scholar

73.Evidence ofW. Macarthur, “Committee on Immigration, 1838,”inBelcher, The Child in NSW, 207. Google Scholar

74.Ibid. Google Scholar

75.Ibid., 209. Google Scholar

76.John Sidney, A Voice from the Far Interior of Australia(:Smith, Elder, 1847). Google Scholar

77.Belcher, The Child in NSW, 209. Google Scholar

78.Hely, Miscellaneous Correspondence from Carters’ Barracks, 1833, reel 600, vol. 4/2223, SRNSW. Google Scholar

79.Governor Macquarie to Earl Bathurst, despatch marked “No. 28 of 1820 per ship Tuscan”, in Library Committee of the Commonwealth Parliament, Historical Records of Australia, series 1,Governor’s Despatches to and from England, vol. 10, January 1819–December 1822(:William Applegate Gullick, 1917), 368. Google Scholar

80.Murray toHely, 1833, reel 600, vol. 4/2223, SRNSW. Google Scholar

81.Ibid. Google Scholar

82. The Sydney Gazette, Thursday 1 August1833, 3. Google Scholar

83.Hely, 1833, reel 600, vol. 4/2223, SRNSW. Google Scholar

84.Ibid. Google Scholar

85.Assignment Returns, 1833, reel 600, vol. 4/2223, SRNSW. Google Scholar

86.Ibid. Google Scholar

87.Hely, 1833, reel 600, vol. 4/2223, SRNSW. Google Scholar

88.Correspondence from Governor George Arthur to Colonial Under-Secretary Robert W Hay, 8 February1834, cited inF. C. Hooper, Prison Boys of Port Arthur: A Study of the Point Puer Boys’ Establishment, Van Diemen’s Land, 1834–1850(:F. W. Cheshire, 1967), 1. Google Scholar

89.Appropriation List, 1835–36, CON27/1/2, TAHO. Google Scholar

90.Ibid. Google Scholar

91.Ibid. Google Scholar

92.Ibid. Google Scholar

93.Hugh Cunningham, The Children of the Poor: Representations of Childhood since the Seventeenth Century, (:Basil Blackwell, 1991), 25. Google Scholar

94.Ibid., 28. Google Scholar

95.Shore, Artful Dodgers, 125. Google Scholar

96.Burke, The Annual Register, 21. Google Scholar

97.Cunningham, The Children of the Poor, 29. Google Scholar

98.Gorton, “Carters’ Barracks and Point Puer,” 243. Google Scholar

99.Ibid. Google Scholar

100. “Proposed Institution of Carters Barracks by Governor Darling 1826,”Carters’ Barracks Miscellaneous Returns, reel 600, vol. 4/2223,SRNSW. Google Scholar

101. Miscellaneous Correspondence, n.d., reel 600, vol. 4/2223,SRNSW. Google Scholar

102. The Monitor, Friday 6 April, 1827. Google Scholar

103. Memorandum accompanying Minutes no. 39 relating to the Carters’ Barracks, Governor’s Minutes, 16 February1826, reel 600, vol. 4/990,SRNSW. Google Scholar

104.Hely toMurray, 1833, reel 600, vol. 4/2223,SRNSW. Google Scholar

105.Murray toHely, Ibid. Google Scholar

106.Ibid. Google Scholar

107.Charles O’Hara Booth, Report from the Select Committee on Transportation(:House of Commons, 1838), Appendix B, Enclosure 2, no. 38, 223. Google Scholar

108.Ibid. Google Scholar

109.Horne Report, 1843, C0280/157/520, TAHO. Google Scholar

110.Booth, Select Committee on Transportation, 221. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Nunn, Cameron