Labour History

Women’s Work: The Professionalisation and Policing of Fortune-Telling in Australia

Labour History (2015), 108, (1), 37–52.

Abstract

In the early twentieth century, fortune-telling was being heralded by Australian newspapers as the nation’s latest fad. It was enjoyed as a popular form of entertainment, particularly by women. For other women though, fortune-telling represented a source of income, and sometimes their sole means of support. At the same time, fortune-telling was actually a criminal offence, leaving women who practised it vulnerable to police prosecution. Yet while fortune-telling had long been illegal and associated with a variety of criminal practices, the federation period witnessed a growth in legal activity against it. This was due in part to the increased visibility brought about by the practice’s professionalisation, which prompted innovations in policing that opened up other areas of work to female involvement. This article thus probes some of the changes that took place in the culture of women’s work during this crucial era.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*The author would like to thankLabour History‘s two anonymous referees. Google Scholar

1.Samuel T. Knaggs, Dr. De Lion, Clairvoyant: Confessions of a Vagabond Life in Australia(:Angus and Robertson, 1895), 59–61. Google Scholar

2. Capricornian, 27 July1901, 6;Broadford Courier, 20 September1901, 6;Examiner, 23 May1903, 7. Google Scholar

3.Western Australia, Police Act 1892;Queensland, 1899Criminal Code;Victoria, Police Ofences Act 1907;New South Wales, Police Offences (Amendment) Act 1908;South Australia, Police Act 1916;Tasmania, Police Amendment Act 1917.The Commonwealth’sPost and Telegraph Act 1901also made it an offence to carry on a fortune-telling business by mail. Google Scholar

4.Alfred J. Gabay, Messages from Beyond: Spiritualism and Spiritualists in Melbourne’s Golden Age 1870–1890(:Melbourne University Press, 2001), 100;Stan McMullin, Anatomy of a Seance: A History of Spirit Communication in Central Canada(:McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2004), 17. Google Scholar

5.Trove, National Library Australia,http://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper, research conducted June 2013. Google Scholar

6. Examiner, 30 March1907, 9;Register, 15 June1916, 7;Mercury, 27 June1903, 7;Examiner, 23 May1903, 7. Google Scholar

7.Andrew Davies, Leisure, Gender and Poverty: Working-Class Culture in Salford and Manchester, 1900–1939(:Open University Press, 1992), 79–80. Google Scholar

8. Sydney Morning Herald, 30 April1900, 9;Argus, 14 August1901, 1;Queensland Figaro, 18 February1904, 8;Mercury, 23 May1904, 5;Advertiser, 8 October1904, 5;West Australian, 17 February1906, 8. Google Scholar

9. Daily News, 10 March1900, 3;Brisbane Courier, 4 April1900, 9;Mercury, 17 December1900, 3;Register, 21 October1901, 4;Examiner, 14 June1906. Google Scholar

10. Western Mail, 25 May1901, 65;Queenslander, 18 October1902, 856;Malvern Standard, 27 November1915, 3. Google Scholar

11.Davies, Leisure, Gender and Poverty, 80–81. Google Scholar

12. Bathurst Free Press and Mining Journal, 16 January1903, 2. Google Scholar

13.Alana Jayne Piper, “‘A Menace and an Evil’: Fortune-telling in Australia, 1900–1918,” History Australia 11, no. 3(2014):53–73. Google Scholar

14. Worker, 7 August1909, 11;Worker, 5 April1902, 10;Worker, 26 April1902, 3. Google Scholar

15. Worker, 24 January1903, 6. Google Scholar

16.Davies, Leisure, Gender and Poverty, 56;Richard Waterhouse, Private Pleasures, Public Leisure: A History of Australian Popular Culture since 1788(:Longman, 1995), 62. Google Scholar

17.Beverley Kingston, My Wife, My Daughter and Poor Mary Ann: Women and Work in Australia(:Thomas Nelson Australia, 1980), 5;Edna Ryan andAnne Conlon, Gentle Invaders: Australian Women at Work(:Penguin, 1989), 51. Google Scholar

18. Fitzroy City Press, 5 June1903, 3. Google Scholar

19. Daily News, 6 March1907, 10. Google Scholar

20.Margaret Anderson, “Good Strong Girls: Colonial Women and Work,”inGender Relations in Australia: Domination and Negotiation, ed.Kay Saunders andRaymond Evans, (:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich Group, 1992), 227. Google Scholar

21.Raelene Frances, “Shifting Barriers: Twentieth Century Women’s Labour Patterns,”inGender Relations in Australia: Domination and Negotiation, ed.Kay Saunders andRaymond Evans(:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich Group, 1992), 251. Google Scholar

22. Daily News, 17 July1917, 6. Google Scholar

23. Barrier Miner, 2 September1909, 2. Google Scholar

24. Sydney Morning Herald, 7 March1903, 11. Google Scholar

25. Queensland Figaro, 17 September1903, 16. Google Scholar

26. Sydney Morning Herald, 28 February1905, 8. Google Scholar

27. North Western Advocate and Emu Bay Times, 16 August1913, 5. Google Scholar

28. Bathurst Free Press and Mining Journal, 16 January1903, 2. Google Scholar

29. Truth(Melbourne), 27 March1909, 5;Argus, 15 April1909, 8. Google Scholar

30. Traralgon Record, 22 February1907, 4. Google Scholar

31. Barrier Miner, 18 February1918, 4;Register, 11 September1917, 8. Google Scholar

32. Fortune Telling by Cards: Weather Omens, the Oracle of Destiny, Chiromancy, Physiognomy(:William Nicholson, c1900);W. H. Johnston, Zingara Fortune Teller: A Complete Treatise on the Art of Predicting Future Events(:McKay, c1901);R. Dimsdale Stocker, Book of Fate: How to Know Your Luck(:Gaskill and Marriott, c1902). Google Scholar

33.Richard Waterhouse, “Cultural Transmissions,”inCultural History in Australia, ed.Hsu-Ming Teo andRichard White(:UNSW Press, 2003), 120. Google Scholar

34.Trove results as at 10 May2014. Google Scholar

35.Raelene Frances, “Gender, Working Life and Federation,”inWorking the Nation: Working Life and Federation, 1890–1914, ed.Mark Hearn andGreg Patmore(:Pluto Press, 2001), 36. Google Scholar

36. Bathurst Free Press and Mining Journal, 7 March1903, 2. Google Scholar

37. Western Mail, 23 January1904, 39;Brisbane Courier, 17 February1917, 4. Google Scholar

38. Cairns Post, 22 May1912, 8;Barrier Miner, 11 May1912, 5. Google Scholar

39. Brisbane Courier, 31 August1917, 3;West Australian, 13 June1903, 6. Google Scholar

40. Daily News, 9 May1916, 8;Brisbane Courier, 17 June1911, 5. Google Scholar

41. Mercury, 16 April1918, 8. Google Scholar

42. Traralgon Record, 22 February1907, 4. Google Scholar

43. Cumberland Argus and Fruitgrowers Advocate, 22 April1908, 3. Google Scholar

44. Bathurst Free Press and Mining Journal, 16 January1903, 2. Google Scholar

45. Examiner, 23 May1903, 7. Google Scholar

46. Sydney Morning Herald, 14 January1909, 3. Google Scholar

47. Argus, 6 March1903, 7;Daily News, 9 May1916, 8. Google Scholar

48. Inquirer & Commercial News, 18 January1901, 7. Google Scholar

49. Singleton Argus, 21 March1907, 1;Brisbane Courier, 17 February1917, 4. Google Scholar

50. Mercury, 14 August1918, 3. Google Scholar

51. Examiner, 30 March1907, 9. Google Scholar

52. Argus, 2 March1903, 5. Google Scholar

53.Inquiry by Mrs A. E. Church, 3 April1912, Item 318941, Series 16855, Queensland State Archives (hereafter QSA). Google Scholar

54.Inquiries by police into Lord’s background intimate that she may have left her proof-reading role as a result of bullying and harassment by male co-workers; freedom from such environments was perhaps another part of fortune-telling’s attraction as a form of women’s work. Report on Inquiries into Character of Nellie Lord, 5 July1912, Item 318941, Series 16855, QSA. Google Scholar

55.Audrey Eccles, Vagrancy in Law and Practice under the Old Poor Law(:Ashgate, 2012), 1–2, 146. Google Scholar

56.Lynne Hume, “Witchcraft and the Law in Australia,” Journal of Church and State 37(1995):145–46. Google Scholar

57. Sunday Times, 18 January1903, 4. Google Scholar

58. Warwick Argus, 9 November1901, 5;Evelyn Observer and Bourke East Record, 9 January1903, 4. Google Scholar

59.Jill Roe, Beyond Belief: Theosophy in Australia, 1879–1939(:New South Wales University Press, 1986). Google Scholar

60. Camperdown Chronicle, 17 February1916, 6;Warwick Examiner and Times, 12 December1917, 7;North Western Advocate and the Emu Bay Times, 2 November1917, 3. Google Scholar

61.Kate Wright, Your Neighbours: The Gypsies in Australia(:Zeus Publications, 2011), 64–66. Google Scholar

62. Sydney Morning Herald, 14 January1902, 4. Google Scholar

63. Euroa Advertiser, 8 August1902, 3;Gippsland Times, 16 January1908, 3;W. Ross Johnston, The Long Blue Line: A History of the Queensland Police(:Boolarong Publications, 1992), 170. Google Scholar

64. Horsham Times, 16 March1900, 2;Dubbo Liberal and Macquarie Advocate, 21 May1902, 3. Google Scholar

65.Gwenda Morgan andPeter Rushton, Rogues, Thieves, and the Rule of Law: The Problem of Law Enforcement in North-East England, 1718–1800(:UCL Press, 1998), 88. Google Scholar

66.Michael Ryan, Prostitution in London, with a Comparative View of That of Paris and New York(:H. Bailliere, 1839), 107–108. Google Scholar

67.Fergus Hume, The Mystery of a Hansom Cab(:Sun Books, 1971), 97. Google Scholar

68. Examiner, 23 May1903, 7;West Gippsland Gazette, 29 September1903, 6. Google Scholar

69.James Morton andSusanna Lobez, Gangland Queensland(:Melbourne University Publishing, 2012), 5. Google Scholar

70.Jill Harsin, Policing Prostitution in Nineteenth-Century Paris(:Princeton University Press, 1985), 249. Google Scholar

71.“Report from the Select Committee upon a Bill for the Prevention of Contagious Diseases,” Victorian Parliamentary Papers 1(1878):3. Google Scholar

72. Advertiser, 31 July1902, 5. Google Scholar

73. Truth(Melbourne), 7 April1917, 6. Google Scholar

74.Raelene Frances, “‘White Slaves’ and White Australia: Prostitution and Australian Society,” Australian Feminist Studies 19, no. 33(2004):185–200. Google Scholar

75. Argus, 7 March1903, 19;Argus, 28 February1903, 15. Google Scholar

76.Patrick Morgan, Folie à Deux: William and Caroline Dexter in Colonial Australia(:Quakers Hill Press, 1999), 123. Google Scholar

77.Police Constable Norton re Fortune Tellers’ Advertisements, 11 August1921, Item 318941, Series 16855, QSA. Google Scholar

78.Alex Owen, The Darkened Room: Women, Power, and Spiritualism in Late Nineteenth Century England(:Virago, 1989), 121–22. Google Scholar

79.Edwin M. Hale, The Great Crime of the Nineteenth Century(:C. S. Halsey, 1867), 17. Google Scholar

80.Frank Bongiorno, The Sex Lives of Australians: A History(:Black Inc., 2012), 71. Google Scholar

81. Clipper, 30 June1900, 3;Truth(Melbourne), 14 March1914, 3. Google Scholar

82.Lyn Finch andJon Stratton, “The Australian Working Class and the Practice of Abortion 1880–1939,” Journal of Australian Studies 12, no. 23(1988):57. Google Scholar

83. The West Australian, 28 November1917, 8. Google Scholar

84.Letter re Madame Le Grin, 11 January1917, Unit 595, VPRS 897/P0, Public Records Office of Victoria (hereafter PROV). Google Scholar

85. Brisbane Courier, 31 October1917, 4. Google Scholar

86. Advertiser, 18 May1901, 6;Mercury, 23 August1902, 6. Google Scholar

87. Sydney Morning Herald, 26 October1904, 7. Google Scholar

88. Advertiser, 24 June1903, 6. Google Scholar

89. Sydney Morning Herald, 17 January1903, 6;Argus, 2 March1903, 5;Mercury, 7 August1903, 6. Google Scholar

90. Argus, 12 February1907, 4;Daily News, 6 March1907, 10;Sydney Morning Herald, 29 May1907, 6. Google Scholar

91. Evening News, 14 January1901, 6;Argus, 22 January1909, 4. Google Scholar

92.Circular from the Prime Minister’s Office, 30 March1917, Item 318941, Series 16855, QSA. Google Scholar

93.Report re Fortune Tellers, 11 February1907, Unit 1037, VPRS 3992/P0, PROV. Google Scholar

94.Detective Sergeant Power re Fortune Tellers, 5 June1917, Item 318941, Series 16855, QSA. Google Scholar

95.Ibid. Google Scholar

96. Argus, 25 November1915, 8;Argus, 12 May1917, 20. Google Scholar

97. Daily News, 17 July1917, 6. Google Scholar

98. Brisbane Courier, 20 October1917, 11. Google Scholar

99. Sydney Morning Herald, 20 January1903, 7. Google Scholar

100.Marian Aveling andJoy Damousi, Stepping out of History: Documents of Women at Work in Australia(:Allen and Unwin, 1991), 88. Google Scholar

101. Brisbane Courier, 11 December1919, 5;Brisbane Courier, 31 May1929, 16. Google Scholar

102.Nicola Imogen Bowes, “Criminal Nation: The Crime Fiction of Mary Helena Fortune”(PhD thesis,University of Queensland, 2008), 240–41. Google Scholar

103. Prahran Telegraph, 16 Sep1916, 4. Google Scholar

104. Brisbane Courier, 20 October1917, 11;Colleen A. Woolley, Arresting Women: A History of Women in the Victoria Police(:Victoria Press, 1997), 12. Google Scholar

105. Advertiser, 18 March1914, 14. Google Scholar

106. North Western Advocate and Emu Bay Times, 17 February1909, 1. Google Scholar

107. Daily News, 6 July1917, 7. Google Scholar

108. Truth(Melbourne), 12 May1917, 6. Google Scholar

109.Woolley, Arresting Women, 26–27. Google Scholar

110.Ibid., 44. Google Scholar

111.Tim Prenzler, “Policewomen and Queensland,” Queensland Review 2, no. 2(1995):69. Google Scholar

112.Mark Finnane, Police and Government: Histories of Policing in Australia(:Oxford University Press, 1994), 2. Google Scholar

113.Ibid., 106–107. Google Scholar

114.Tim Prenzler, “Women in Australian Policing: An Historical Overview,” Journal of Australian Studies 18, no. 42(1994):80. Google Scholar

115. Register, 7 September1917, 6;Advertiser, 7 September1917, 6. Google Scholar

116.Vince Kelly, Rugged Angel: The Amazing Career of Policewoman Lillian Armfield(:Angus and Robertson, 1961), 196–97. Google Scholar

117.Report by Sub-Inspector Reardon, 17 September1926, Item 318941, Series 16855, QSA. Google Scholar

118.Owen, The Darkened Room, 2–3. Google Scholar

119.Jeanna Sutton, “Women in the Job,”inPolicing Australia: Old Issues, New Perspectives, ed.Peter Moir andHenk Eijkman(:Macmillan Company of Australia, 1992), 68. Google Scholar

120.Joy Damousi, “Margaret Cuthbertson, Factory Inspection and the Political Lives of Working Women, 1890–1914,”inHearn andPatmore, Working the Nation, 249–63. Google Scholar

121.Hume, “Witchcraft and the Law in Australia,” 135–50. Google Scholar

122. Barrier Miner, 10 July1941, 5;Canberra Times, 26 February1942, 4. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Piper, Alana