Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

Resisting Whig History: Putting the Australian New Left in Perspective

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2018), 114, (1), 153–168.

Abstract

The theoretical insights associated with the Australian New Left contribute to enriching our understanding of the intricacies of Australian history. Two of the most influential works associated with the movement, A New Britannia and Class Structure in Australian History, are compared to enable a consideration of both objective and subjective accounts of class. This paper has three parts. First, it identifies the historic context of history written in Australia within the Whig tradition of the Old Left. Second, it examines how debates within the British New Left came to influence discussions in the Australian New Left. Finally, it suggests that McQueen provided foundations to the theoretical approach to class undertaken inClass Structure in Australian History. It is argued that class remains an important and necessary abstraction in order to engage with the relationship between existing political economic structures and social subjects.

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

1.Henry Paternoster, “Questioning the Legacy of Class Structure in Australian History: An Australian ‘Historical’ Class Analysis?” Labour History, no.111(November2016): 99–120;Terry Irving “The Lower Depths: Paternoster on Class Structure in Australian History,” Labour History, no.111(November2016):121–23. Google Scholar

2.Stuart Macintyre “Radical History and Bourgeois Hegemony,” Intervention, no.2(1972):47–73. Google Scholar

3.Ernest Scott A Short History of Australia(:H. Milford, 1918). Google Scholar

4.Macintyre, “Radical History and Bourgeois Hegemony.” Google Scholar

5.Scott, A Short History of Australia, v. Google Scholar

6.Keith Hancock, Australia(:Jacaranda Press, 1930). Google Scholar

7.Macintyre, “Radical History and Bourgeois Hegemony.” Google Scholar

8.Robert Pascoe, The Manufacture of Australian History(:Oxford University Press, 1979). Google Scholar

9.Raewyn Connell, “Images of Australia,”inSocial Change in Australia: Readings in Sociology, ed.Donald Ernest Edgar(:Cheshire Books, 1974). Google Scholar

10.S. Macintyre, “Old Left,”inThe Oxford Companion to Australian History, Oxford Reference, accessed March2018,http://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/acref/9780195515039.001.0001/acref-9780195515039-e-1098. Google Scholar

11.Connell, “Images of Australia,” 33–34. Google Scholar

12.Allan Martin, The Whig View of Australian History and Other Essays(:Melbourne University Publishing, 1962). Google Scholar

13.Hancock, Australia, 197. Google Scholar

14.Connell, “Images of Australia,” 39. Google Scholar

15.Edward Shann, An Economic History of Australia(:Cambridge University Press, 1930). Google Scholar

16.S. Macintyre, “Old Left.” Google Scholar

18.Pascoe, The Manufacture of Australian History, 4. Google Scholar

19.Thomas Barnes andDamien Cahill, “Marxist Class Analysis: A Living Tradition in Australian Scholarship,” Journal of Australian Political Economy 70(2012):47–69. Google Scholar

20.Hancock cited in Connell, “Images of Australia,” 35. Google Scholar

21.Terry Irving, andRaewyn Connell, Class Structure in Australian History(:Longman Cheshire, 1979), 3–26. Google Scholar

22.Macintyre, “Radical History and Bourgeois Hegemony,” 62. Google Scholar

23.Brian Fitzpatrick, A Short History of the Australian Labor Movement(:Macmillan, 1944);Ian Turner, Industrial Labour and Politics: The Labour Movement in Eastern Australia: 1900–1921(:Australian National University, 1965);Russel Ward, The Australian Legend(:Oxford University Press, 1958). Google Scholar

24.Fitzpatrick, A Short History of the Australian Labor Movement, 11. Google Scholar

25.Don Watson, Brian Fitzpatrick: A Radical Life(:Hale &Iremonger, 1979). Google Scholar

26.Fitzpatrick, A Short History of the Australian Labor Movement, 11. Google Scholar

27.Turner, Industrial Labour and Politics, 6e. Google Scholar

28.Humphrey McQueen, A New Britannia(:University of Queensland Press, 1970). Google Scholar

29.Ward, The Australian Legend, 1. Google Scholar

30. Ibid., 2. Google Scholar

31. Ibid., 21. Google Scholar

32. Ibid., 66. Google Scholar

33. Ibid., 309. Google Scholar

34.Connell, “Images of Australia,” 33. Google Scholar

35.Edward Palmer Thompson, “The Peculiarities of the English,” Socialist Register 2, no.2(1965): 311–62;Perry Anderson, “The Origins of the Present Crisis,” New Left Review 1, no.23(1964), accessed March2018,https://newleftreview.org/I/23/perry-anderson-origins-of-the-present-crisis; Thomas Nairn, “The Nature of the Labour Party: Part 1,”New Left Review 1, no.27(1964), accessed March2018,https://newleftreview.org/I/27/tom-nairn-the-nature-of-the-labour-party-part-i. Google Scholar

36.Wade Matthews, “The Poverty of Strategy: E. P. Thompson, Perry Anderson, and the Transition to Socialism,” Labour/Le Travail 50(2002):217–41. Google Scholar

37.Scott Hamilton, The Crisis of Theory: E. P. Thompson, the New Left and Postwar British Politics(:Oxford University, 2012). Google Scholar

38.Matthews, “The Poverty of Strategy,” 222. Google Scholar

39.Edward Palmer Thompson, “Socialism and the Intellectuals: A Reply,” Universities and Left Review 2(1957):20–22. Google Scholar

40.Hamilton, The Crisis of Theory, 55–60. Google Scholar

41.Matthews, “The Poverty of Strategy,” 224–26. Google Scholar

42.Anderson, “The Origins of the Present Crisis”;Nairn, “The Nature of the Labour Party.” Google Scholar

43.Matthews, “The Poverty of Strategy,” 226. Google Scholar

44.Anne Sassoon, “Hegemony,”inA Dictionary of Marxist Thought, ed.Tom Bottomore(:Blackwell, 1985). Google Scholar

45.Gregory Elliott, Perry Anderson: The Merciless Laboratory of History(:University of Minnesota Press, 1998), 14. Google Scholar

46. Ibid., 15. Google Scholar

47.Anderson, “The Origins of the Present Crisis.” Google Scholar

48.Nairn, “The Nature of the Labour Party.” Google Scholar

49.Matthews, “The Poverty of Strategy,” 228. Google Scholar

50.Thompson, “The Peculiarities of the English,” 314. Google Scholar

51. Ibid., 319. Google Scholar

52.Hamilton, The Crisis of Theory, 120. Google Scholar

53.Matthews, “The Poverty of Strategy,” 230. Google Scholar

54. Ibid., 230–40. Google Scholar

55.Barnes andCahill, “Marxist Class Analysis.” Google Scholar

56. Ibid. Google Scholar

57.McQueen, A New Britannia. Google Scholar

58.Irving andConnell, Class Structure in Australian History. Google Scholar

59.Barnes andCahill, “Marxist Class Analysis,” 50. Google Scholar

60.Pascoe, The Manufacture of Australian History, 140. Google Scholar

61.Humphrey McQueen, “Convicts and Rebels,” Labour History, no.15(November1968):3–30. Google Scholar

62. Ibid., 25 Google Scholar

63.Russel Ward, “Australian Legend Re-visited,” Australian Historical Studies 18, no.71(1978):179. Google Scholar

64.Russel Ward, “Convicts and Rebels: A Reply,” Labour History, no.16(March1969):58. Google Scholar

65.Ward, The Australian Legend, 68. Google Scholar

66.McQueen, A New Britannia;Terry Irving, “Head-Standing,”The Bulletin, 12 December1970, 55. Google Scholar

67.McQueen, A New Britannia, 251;Edward Palmer Thompson, The Making of the English Working Class(:Victor Gollancz, 1963). Google Scholar

68.McQueen, A New Britannia, 250; Anderson, “The Origins of the Present Crisis”; Nairn, “The Nature of the Labour Party.” Google Scholar

69.McQueen, A New Britannia, 181. Google Scholar

70. Ibid., 182. Google Scholar

71. Ibid., 250. Google Scholar

72. Ibid. Google Scholar

73.Pascoe, The Manufacture of Australian History. Google Scholar

74.Stuart Macintyre, “The Making of the Australian Working Class: An Historiographical Survey,” Historical Studies, 18, no.71(1978):233–53. Google Scholar

75.Irving, “Head-Standing,” 55–56. Google Scholar

76.Humphrey McQueen, A New Britannia: An Argument Concerning the Social Origins of Australian Racialism and Nationalism, rev. ed. (:Penguin, 1986), 12. Google Scholar

77.Frank Bongiorno, “Two Radical Legends: Russel Ward, Humphrey McQueen and the New Left Challenge in Australian Historiography,” Journal of Australian Colonial History 10, no.2(2008):201–22. Google Scholar

78.Irving, “Head-Standing,” 57. Google Scholar

79. Ibid. Google Scholar

80.Terry Irving, “Symposium: What is Labour History?” Labour History, no.12(March1967):77–81. Google Scholar

81. Ibid., 77. Google Scholar

82.Terry Irving andBaiba Berzins “History and the New Left: Beyond Radicalism,”inThe Australian New Left: Critical Essays and Strategy, ed.Richard Gordon(:William Heinmann Australia, 1970), 66–94. Google Scholar

83.Raewyn Connell, Ruling Class, Ruling Culture(:Cambridge University Press, 1977). Google Scholar

84. Ibid.;Vere Gordon Childe, How Labour Governs(:University of Queensland Press, 1923);Brian Fitzpatrick, British Imperialism and Australia: 1783–1833(:Sydney University Press, 1939);Brian Fitzpatrick, The British Empire in Australia: An Economic History 1834–1939(:Melbourne University Press, 1941); Fitzpatrick, A Short History of the Australian Labor Movement. Google Scholar

85.Robin Gollan, Radical and Working Class Politics: A Study of Eastern Australia, 1850–1910(:Melbourne University Press, 1960); Turner, Industrial Labour and Politics. Google Scholar

86.Connell, Ruling Class, Ruling Culture, 23. Google Scholar

87. Ibid., 26–27. Google Scholar

88.Solomon Encel, Equality and Authority: A Study of Class, Status and Power in Australia(:Tavistock Publications, 1970). Google Scholar

89.Irving andConnell, Class Structure in Australian History. Google Scholar

90.Terry Irving andRaewyn Connell “Scholars and Radicals: Writing and Re-thinking Class Structure in Australian History,” Journal of Australian Studies 40, no.1(2015):3–15. Google Scholar

91.Irving andConnell Class Structure in Australian History, x. Google Scholar

92. Ibid., 7. Google Scholar

93. Ibid., 11. Google Scholar

94.Robert White, “R. W. Connell: Situational Analysis and Populist Strategies,” Thesis Eleven 9, no.1(1984):97–107. Google Scholar

95.Irving andConnell, Class Structure in Australian History, 10. Google Scholar

96.Anthony Giddens, The Class Structure of the Advanced Societies(:Hutchinson, 1975); Thompson, The Making of the English Working Class. Google Scholar

97.Irving, andConnell, Class Structure in Australian History, 357–58. Google Scholar

98. Ibid., x–xi. Google Scholar

99.Thompson, The Making of the English Working Class, 9–11. Google Scholar

100.Irving andConnell, Class Structure in Australian History, 19. Google Scholar

101.Stuart Rosewarne, “Symposium on Class Structure in Australian History,” Intervention, no.16(1982):7–15. Google Scholar

102.Kay Daniels, “Symposium on Class Structure in Australian History,” Intervention, no.16(1982):15–18. Google Scholar

103.Philip McMichael, “Symposium on Class Structure in Australian History,” Intervention, no.16(1982):19–24. Google Scholar

104.Verity Burgmann, “Symposium on Class Structure in Australian History,” Intervention, no.16(1982):25–30. Google Scholar

105.Geoff Eley, The History of the Left in Europe 1850–2000(:Oxford University Press, 2002). Google Scholar

106.Brett Heino, Regulation Theory and Australian Capitalism(:Rowman &Littlefield International, 2017). Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Williams-Brooks, Llewellyn