Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

Economic Thought and Social Democracy in Australasia and Scandinavia, 1919–39

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2018), 114, (1), 113–130.

Abstract

The New Zealand Labour Party and the Swedish Social Democratic Party were early pioneers of the welfare state, winning government and enacting reform from 1935 and 1932 respectively. The federal Australian Labor Party (ALP), however, struggled in government from 1929 to 1931 to respond to the Depression and was only able to develop a comprehensively reformist approach in government from 1941. This paper compares the development of economic policy in the three parties in the 1920s and 1930s, and suggests that the extent to which party leaders engaged with new economic thinking in the 1920s contributed to the parties’ success or otherwise in enacting policy reform.

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

1.For example,Neal Lawson, “Social Democracy without Social Democrats: How Can the Left Recover?” New Statesman, 12 May2016, accessed March2018,https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/staggers/2016/05/social-democracy-without-social-democrats-how-can-left-recover; “Rose, Thou Art Sick,”Economist, 2 April2016, accessed March2018,https://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21695887-centre-left-sharp-decline-across-europe-rose-thou-art-sick;Ashley Lavelle, The Death of Social Democracy: Political Consequences in the 21st Century(:Ashgate, 2008); Poul Nyrup Rasmussen and Udo Bullmann, “The Social Democracy to Come,”Social Europe: Occasional Paper 11(October2016), accessed March2018,https://www.socialeurope.eu/book/op-11-social-democracy-come. Google Scholar

2.Geoff Eley, Forging Democracy: The History of the Left in Europe, 1850–2000(:Oxford University Press, 2002), 287;Peter Gourevitch, Politics in Hard Times: Comparative Responses to International Economic Crises(:Cornell University Press, 1986); Stuart Macintyre, Australia‘sBoldest Experiment: War and Reconstruction in the 1940s(:NewSouth, 2015). Google Scholar

3.Sheri Berman, The Primacy of Politics: Social Democracy and the Making of Europe’s Twentieth Century(:Cambridge University Press, 2006), esp. ch.7. Google Scholar

4.Winton Higgins andGeoff Dow, Politics against Pessimism: Social Democratic Possibilities since Ernst Wigforss(:Peter Lang, 2013), 20. Google Scholar

5.Erik Olssen, The Red Feds: Revolutionary Industrial Unionism and the New Zealand Federation of Labour 1908–14(:Oxford University Press, 1988);Peter Franks andJim McAloon, Labour: The New Zealand Labour Party 1916–2016(:Victoria University Press, 2016). Google Scholar

6.Ian Turner, Industrial Labour and Politics: The Dynamics of the Labour Movement in Eastern Australia 1900–21(:Hale &Iremonger, 1979);Ross McMullin, Light on the Hill: The Australian Labor Party 1891–1991(:Oxford University Press, 1991). Google Scholar

7.Berman, Primacy of Politics;Donald Sassoon, One Hundred Years of Socialism: The West European Left in the Twentieth Century(:Fontana, 1987). Google Scholar

8.Christopher Lloyd, “Regime Change in Australian Capitalism: Towards a Historical Political Economy of Regulation,” Australian Economic History Review 42, no.3(2002):238–66. Google Scholar

9.Marian Sawer, “Andrew Fisher and the Era of Liberal Reform,” Labour History, no.102(May2012):71–86. Google Scholar

10.Terry Irving, “Labourism: A Political Genealogy,” Labour History, no.66(May1994):1–13. Google Scholar

11.Tim Battin, “Keynesianism, Socialism, and Labourism, and the Role of Ideas in Labor Ideology,” Labour History, no.66(May1994):33–44. Google Scholar

12.Sawer, The Ethical State? Social Liberalism in Australia(:Melbourne University Press, 2003), 13. Google Scholar

13.Sawer, “Andrew Fisher and the Era of Liberal Reform.” Google Scholar

14.Donald E. Moggridge, Maynard Keynes: An Economist’s Biography(:Routledge, 1992), 452. Google Scholar

15.James Bennett, Rats and Revolutionaries: The Labour Movement in Australia and New Zealand 1880–1940(:University of Otago Press, 2004), 140; generally,P. J. O’Farrell, Harry Holland: Militant Socialist(:Australian National University Press, 2004). Google Scholar

16.Munro, New Zealand Parliamentary Debates(NZPD) 195 (1922):430. Google Scholar

17.Howard, NZPD 191(1921): 324–32; Howard, NZPD 196(1922): 752. Howard relied on theEconomistfor access to both McKenna and Cassel’s thought. Google Scholar

18.McCombs, NZPD 196(1922):646. Google Scholar

19.McCombs, NZPD 218(1928): 209; William Trufant Foster and Waddill Catchings, Profits(:Houghton Mifflin, 1925). Google Scholar

20.Quoted byMcCombs, NZPD 218(1928):210–11. Google Scholar

21.McCombs, NZPD 227(1931):166–75. Google Scholar

22.McCombs, NZPD 231(1932):340. Google Scholar

23.Holland, NZPD 209(1926):671–73. Google Scholar

24.Holland, NZPD 233(1932):59–71. Google Scholar

25.Holland, NZPD 231(1932):167–78. Google Scholar

26.Malcolm McKinnon, The Broken Decade: Prosperity, Depression and Recovery in New Zealand 1928–39(:University of Otago Press, 2016), 351. Google Scholar

27.Nash, NZPD 224(1930):44–48. Google Scholar

28.Moggridge, Maynard Keynes, 481, 490–95, 507–18; Nash, NZPD 231(1932):247–50. Google Scholar

29.Walter Nash, Financial Power in New Zealand: The Case for a State Bank(:New Zealand Worker, 1925). Google Scholar

30.Nash, NZPD 224(1930):44–48. Google Scholar

31. Ibid., 330–34. Google Scholar

32.Nash, NZPD 233(1932): 86–90; Nash, Financial Power in New Zealand. Google Scholar

33.A. G. B. Fisher, Economic Self-Sufficiency(:Clarendon Press, 1939), 5. Google Scholar

34.The affirmations are given in Nash, NZPD 237(1933):246–47. Google Scholar

35.SeeDonald Markwell, John Maynard Keynes and International Relations: Economic Paths to War and Peace(:Oxford University Press, 2006), 152–65, quote at165. Google Scholar

36.John King, “From Giblin to Kalecki: The Export Multiplier and the Balance of Payments Constraint on Economic Growth, 1930–1933,” History of Economics Review 42, no.1(1998):62–71. Google Scholar

37.Francis G. Castles, The Social Democratic Image of Society: A Study of the Achievements and Origins of Scandinavian Social Democracy in Comparative Perspective(:Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1978); Sassoon, One Hundred Years of Socialism. Google Scholar

38.Göran Therborn, “A Unique Chapter in the History of Democracy: The Social Democrats in Sweden,”inCreating Social Democracy: A Century of the Social Democratic Labor Party in Sweden, ed.Klaus Misgeld,Karl Molin andKlas Åmark(:Pennsylvania State University Press, 1992), 17. For an older discussion, seeHerbert Tingsten, The Swedish Social Democrats: Their Ideological Development(:Bedminster Press, 1973). Google Scholar

39.Higgins andDow, Politics against Pessimism, 99. Google Scholar

40.Villy Bergström, “Party Program and Economic Policy: The Social Democrats in Government,”inMisgeld,Molin andÅmark, Creating Social Democracy, 136. Google Scholar

41.Higgins andDow, Politics against Pessimism, 99. Google Scholar

42. Ibid., 132. Google Scholar

43. Ibid., 188–89. Google Scholar

44. Ibid., 105–106, 131–34, 188–89. Google Scholar

45.Martin Kragh, “The ‘Wigforss Connection’: The Stockholm School vs. Keynes Debate Revisited,” European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 21, no.4(2014):4. Google Scholar

46.Sven Anders Söderpalm, “The Crisis Agreement and the Social Democratic Road to Power,”inSweden’s Development from Poverty to Affluence, ed.Steven Koblik(:University of Minnesota Press, 1975), 265–66. Google Scholar

47.Higgins andDow, Politics against Pessimism, 120–22. Google Scholar

48. Ibid., 131. Google Scholar

49. Ibid., 141. Google Scholar

50.Tingsten, The Swedish Social Democrats, 279–80. Google Scholar

51.Higgins andDow, Politics against Pessimism, 114–18;Moggridge, Maynard Keynes, 390–93. Google Scholar

52.Higgins andDow, Politics against Pessimism, 120. Google Scholar

53.Carl G. Uhr, “Economists and Policymaking 1930–1936: Sweden’s Experience,” History of Political Economy 9, no.1(1977):89–121. Google Scholar

54.Bent Hansen, “Unemployment, Keynes, and the Stockholm School,” History of Political Economy 13, no.2(1981): 256–77; Otto Steiger, “Bertil Ohlin and the Origins of the Keynesian Revolution,”History of Political Economy 8, no.3(1976): 341–66; Don Patinkin, “On the Relation between Keynesian Economics and the ‘Stockholm School,’”Scandinavian Journal of Economics 80, no.2(1978):135–37. Google Scholar

55.Hansen, “Unemployment, Keynes, and the Stockholm School”; Eskil Wadensjö, “The Committee on Unemployment and the Stockholm School,”inThe Stockholm School of Economics Revisited, ed.Lars Jonung(:Cambridge University Press, 1991), 113–17; Bo Gustafsson, “Comment,” inJonung, The Stockholm School, 124–28. Google Scholar

56.Kragh, “The Wigforss Connection,”11–12; see alsoLeif Lewin, “The Debate on Economic Planning,”inKoblik, ed.Sweden’s Development from Poverty to Affluence, 284–85. Google Scholar

57.Higgins andDow, Politics against Pessimism, 143–47. Google Scholar

58.Kragh, “The Wigforss Connection,”16–18, 24; Wadensjö, “The Committee on Unemployment and the Stockholm School,” 116;Otto Steiger, “Comment,”inJonung, The Stockholm School, 130–32;Carl G. Uhr, “The Emergence of the ‘New Economics’ in Sweden: A Review of a Study by Otto Steiger,” History of Political Economy 5, no.1(1973):246–48. Google Scholar

59.Kragh, “The Wigforss Connection,” 18. Google Scholar

60.Higgins andDow, Politics against Pessimism, 151. Google Scholar

61. Ibid., 152. Google Scholar

62.Donald Winch, “The Keynesian Revolution in Sweden,” Journal of Political Economy 74, no.2(1966):170–72. Google Scholar

63.Bede Nairn, Civilising Capitalism: The Beginnings of the Australian Labor Party(:Melbourne University Press, 1989), 193. Google Scholar

64.Ross McMullin, Light on the Hill: The Australian Labor Party 1891–1991(:Oxford University Press, 1991), 75. Google Scholar

65.D. A. Hamer, The New Zealand Liberals: The Years of Power 1891–1912(:Auckland University Press, 1988). Google Scholar

66.Sawer, “Andrew Fisher and the Era of Liberal Reform,” 71. Google Scholar

67.McMullin, Light on the Hill, 126–27. Google Scholar

68.J. R. Robertson, J. H. Scullin: A Political Biography(:University of Western Australia Press, 1974), 77–80, 111–14;Peter Love, Labor and the Money Power: Australian Labour Populism, 1890–1950(:Melbourne University Press, 1984), 109. Google Scholar

69.Robertson, J. H. Scullin, 197. Google Scholar

70.Ross Fitzgerald, “Red Ted”: The Life of E. G. Theodore(:University of Queensland Press, 1994), 233and generally233–36. Google Scholar

71.Love, Labor and the Money Power, 85. Google Scholar

72.McMullin, Light on the Hill, 158. Google Scholar

73.Bruce J. McFarlane, Professor Irvine’s Economics in Australian Labour History, 1913–1933(:Australian Society for the Study of Labour History, 1996), 22. Google Scholar

74.Quoted Fitzgerald, Red Ted, 238. Google Scholar

75.C. B. Schedvin, Australia and the Great Depression(:Sydney University Press, 1970), 172–75. Google Scholar

76.Fitzgerald, Red Ted, 277–78. Google Scholar

77. Ibid., 279. Google Scholar

78. Ibid., 223, 278. Google Scholar

79. Ibid., 280–83;McFarlane, Professor Irvine’s Economics, 59–60. Google Scholar

80.See, generally,McFarlane, Professor Irvine’s Economics. Google Scholar

81. Ibid., appendix3. Google Scholar

82.Fitzgerald, Red Ted, 280–83. Google Scholar

83.McFarlane, Professor Irvine’s Economics, 22. Google Scholar

84.Fitzgerald, Red Ted, 292–93;McMullin, Light on the Hill, 166–69. Google Scholar

85.Love, Labor and the Money Power, 112. Google Scholar

86.McMullin, Light on the Hill, 174. Google Scholar

87.Bede Nairn, The “Big Fella”: Jack Lang and the Australian Labor Party 1891–1949(:Melbourne University Press, 1986), 223. Google Scholar

88.McMullin, Light on the Hill, ch.8. Google Scholar

89.James Scullin, election speech delivered at Richmond, Vic., 15 August1934, Australian Federal Election Speeches, Museum of Australian Democracy, accessed March2018,http://electionspeeches.moadoph.gov.au/speeches/1934-james-scullin. Google Scholar

90.Love, Labor and the Money Power, 145. Google Scholar

91.Bennett, Rats and Revolutionaries, 138. Google Scholar

92.Alex Millmow, The Power of Economic Ideas: The Origins of Keynesian Macroeconomic Management in Interwar Australia 1929–1939(:ANU E-Press, 2010), 214. Google Scholar

93.Love, Labor and the Money Power, 145. Google Scholar

94.Millmow, The Power of Economic Ideas, 212. Google Scholar

95. Ibid., 215–16. Google Scholar

96.Selwyn Cornish, “Sir Edward Ronald Walker,”inA Biographical Dictionary of Australian and New Zealand Economists, ed.J. E. King(:Edward Elgar, 2007), 295–99. Google Scholar

97.Millmow, The Power of Economic Ideas, 215. Google Scholar

98. Ibid., 216. Google Scholar

99.Macintyre, Australia’s Boldest Experiment, 13–14. Google Scholar

100.Greg Whitwell, The Treasury Line(:Allen and Unwin, 1986), 65. Google Scholar

101.Cornish, “Sir Edward Ronald Walker.”See, generally, Macintyre, Australia’s Boldest Experiment. Google Scholar

102.Tim Rowse, Nugget Coombs: A Reforming Life(:Cambridge University Press, 2002), 87–90. Google Scholar

103.Love, Labor and the Money Power, 150. Google Scholar

104.Margaret Weir andTheda Skocpol, “State Structures and the Possibilities for ‘Keynesian’ Responses to the Great Depression in Sweden, Britain, and the United States,”inBringing the State Back In, ed.Peter B. Evans, Dietrich Rueschemeyer and Theda Skocpol (:Cambridge University Press, 1985), 108. Google Scholar

105.John Maynard Keynes, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money(:Macmillan, 1970), 33. Google Scholar

107.Results for the general election of the Australian House of Representatives, 23 October1937, are available on the Australian Politics and Elections Database, University of Western Australia, accessed March2018,http://elections.uwa.edu.au. Google Scholar

108.Leslie Lipson, The Politics of Equality: New Zealand’s Adventures in Democracy(:Victoria University Press, 2011), 210. Google Scholar

109.John Singleton, Central Banking in the Twentieth Century(:Cambridge University Press, 2011), 63–64. Google Scholar

110.McKinnon, The Broken Decade, chs8–9. Google Scholar

111.Francis G. Castles, Australian Public Policy and Economic Vulnerability: A Comparative and Historical Perspective(:Allen &Unwin, 1988), 128–32. Google Scholar

112.R H Tawney, quoted inLawrence Goldman, The Life of R. H. Tawney: Socialism and History(:Bloomsbury, 2014), 156. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

McAloon, Jim