Town Planning Review

The politics of participation in post-disaster planning: local needs and perspectives versus global aspirations in plans for Montserrat’s new capital

Town Planning Review (2020), 91, (6), 577–600.

Abstract

Drawing on interviews with residents and officials, this article investigates how local needs and perceptions have been balanced against other aspirations in plans for Montserrat’s new capital. This new settlement would replace the former capital, Plymouth, which was destroyed in a volcanic eruption and abandoned permanently in 1997. The article finds that residents’ needs and perspectives were given relatively little attention in the planning process and resulting plans for the capital. However, it also finds that residents and officials now hold relatively similar views on the existing plans and on what attributes are ultimately desirable in a capital. This suggests that adopting more participatory planning approaches in the future could build on this shared vision and result in plans that are more publicly and politically sustainable and more likely to be realised.

Access Token
£25.00

References

ANDERSSON, E., WARBURTON, D. and WILSON, R. (2007), ‘The true costs of public participation’, in T. Brannan, P. John and G. Stoker (eds), Re-energizing Citizenship, London, Palgrave, 138-62. Google Scholar

ARNSTEIN, S. (1969), ‘A ladder of citizen participation’, Journal of the American Institute of planners, 35, 216-24. Google Scholar

BALDACCHINO, G. (2004), ‘The coming of age of island studies’, Tijdschrift voor economische en sociale geografie, 95, 272-83. Google Scholar

BEIERLE, T. (2000), ‘The quality of stakeholder-based decisions: lessons from the case study record’ (Discussion Paper 00-56), Washington, DC, Resources for the Future. Google Scholar

CAMPANELLA, T. (2011). ‘Jane Jacobs and the life and death of American planning’, Places Journal, https://placesjournal.org/article/jane-jacobs-and-the-death-and-life-of-american-planning/ (accessed 3 March 2020). Google Scholar

COOKE, B. and KOTHARI, U. (2001), Participation: The New Tyranny? London, Zed Books. Google Scholar

CORNWALL, A. (2000), Beneficiary, Consumer, Citizen: Perspectives on Participation for Poverty Reduction, Volume 2, Stockholm, Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency. Google Scholar

CORNWALL, A. (2008), ‘Unpacking “participation”: models, meanings and practices’, Community Development Journal, 43, 269-83. Google Scholar

DA COSTA, A. (2019), ‘Indonesia plans to move crowded capital city out of crowded Java island’, Reuters, 29 April 2019. Google Scholar

DE ALBUQUERQUE, K. and McELROY, J. (1992), ‘Caribbean small-island tourism styles and sustainable strategies’, Environmental Management, 16, 619-32. Google Scholar

DFID (DEPARTMENT FOR INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT) (2016), ‘Montserrat budget aid 2015/16’, https://devtracker.dfid.gov.uk/projects/GB-1-204161/ (accessed 29 April 2016). Google Scholar

DITTMER, J. (2004), ‘The Soufriere Hills volcano and the postmodern landscapes of Montserrat’, Focus on Geography, 47, 1-7. Google Scholar

EINSTEIN, K., PALMER, M. and GLICK, D. (2019), ‘Who participates in local government?Evidence from meeting minutes’, Perspectives on Politics, 17, 28-46. Google Scholar

ELLIS, R. and DISINGER, J. (1981), ‘Project outcomes correlate with public participation variables’, Journal of the Water Pollution Control Federation, 53, 1564-67. Google Scholar

EUROPEAN UNION (2012), ‘Linking relief, rehabilitation and development: towards more effective aid’, http://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/briefing_note/join/2012/491435/EXPO-DEVE_SP(2012)491435_EN.pdf (accessed 13 August 2019). Google Scholar

EVANS-COWLEY, J. and HOLLANDER, J. (2010), ‘The new generation of public participation: Internet-based participation tools’, Planning Practice and Research, 25, 397-408. Google Scholar

FERGUS, H. (2003), Montserrat: History of a Caribbean Colony, Oxford, Macmillan. Google Scholar

FRIEDMAN, T. (2010), ‘Too many hamburgers?’ New York Times, 21 September 2010. Google Scholar

FUNG, A. (2006), ‘Varieties of participation in complex governance’, Public Administration Review, 66, 66-75. Google Scholar

GLOBAL HUMANITARIAN PLATFORM (2010), Local Capacity and Partnership: A New Humanitarian Business Model, Geneva, Global Humanitarian Platform. Google Scholar

GOLDMAN, I. and ABBOT, J. (2004), ‘Overview: decentralization and participatory planning’, PLA Notes, 49, 5-14. Google Scholar

GOVERNMENT OF MONTSERRAT (2007), Condition and Sustainability Survey of Look Out Prefabricated Force 10 Houses, Brades, Government of Montserrat. Google Scholar

GOVERNMENT OF MONTSERRAT (2011a), Census 2011: Montserrat at a Glance, Brades, Government of Montserrat. Google Scholar

GOVERNMENT OF MONTSERRAT (2011b), Consultation Draft: Physical Development Plan for North Montserrat 2012-2022, Brades, Government of Montserrat. Google Scholar

GOVERNMENT OF MONTSERRAT (2012), Montserrat Land Info Database, http://landinfo.gov.ms (accessed 1 June 2016). Google Scholar

HAAS, J., KATES, R. and BOWDEN, M. (1977), Reconstruction Following Disaster, Cambridge, MA, MIT Press. Google Scholar

HICKEY, S., and MOHAN, G. (2004), ‘Towards participation as transformation: critical themes and challenges’, in S. Hickey and G. Mohan (eds), Participation: From Tyranny to Transformation? Exploring New Approaches to Participation in Development, London, Zed Books, 3-25. Google Scholar

HOOPER, M. (2015), ‘Will the city rise again? The contested geography of housing reconstruction in post-disaster Haiti’, Housing Studies, 30, 1016-35. Google Scholar

INTERNATIONAL RESCUE CORPS (1989), ‘Hurricane Hugo: commander’s report’, http://www.intrescue.info/hub/index.php/missions/montserrat-hurricane-sept-1989/ (accessed 1 January 2019). Google Scholar

ISHAM, J., NARAYAN, D. and PRITCHETT, L. (1995), ‘Does participation improve performance? Establishing causality with subjective data’, World Bank Economic Review, 9, 175-200. Google Scholar

LANE, M. (2005), ‘Public participation in planning: an intellectual history’, Australian Geographer, 36, 283-99. Google Scholar

LOWNDES, V., PRATCHETT, L. and STOKER, G. (2001), ‘Trends in public participation. Part 1: local government perspectives’, Public Administration, 79, 205-22. Google Scholar

LUBELL, M. and LEACH, W. (2005), ‘Watershed partnerships: evaluating a collaborative form of public participation’ (report for the National Research Council’s Panel of Public Participation in Environmental Assessment and Decision Making), Washington, DC. Google Scholar

LYONS, M. (2009), ‘Building back better: the large-scale impact of small-scale approaches to reconstruction’, World Development, 37, 385-98. Google Scholar

McCLEAN, D. (2010), World Disasters Report: Focus on Urban Risk, Geneva, International Federation of the Red Cross. Google Scholar

MDC (2015), ‘Little Bay and Carr’s Bay’, http://Mdc.ms (accessed 20 April 2016). Google Scholar

MIRAFTAB, F. (2004), ‘Invited and invented spaces of participation: neoliberal citizenship and feminists’ expanded notion of politics’, Wagadu, 1, 1-7. Google Scholar

MITLIN, D. (2008), ‘With and beyond the state: co-production as a route to political influence, power and transformation for grassroots organizations’, Environment and Urbanization, 20, 339-60. Google Scholar

MOSER, S. (2010), ‘Putrajaya: Malaysia’s new federal administrative capital’, Cities, 27, 285-97. Google Scholar

MOSER, S. (2015), ‘New cities: old wine in new bottles?’, Dialogues in Human Geography, 5, 31-35. Google Scholar

PHILPOTT, S. (1973), West Indian Migration: The Montserrat Case, London, Athlone Press. Google Scholar

POCKO LAB (2014), ‘Montserrat’, http://www.pocko.com/content/montserrat/ (accessed 21 June 2016). Google Scholar

PROKOPY, L. (2005), ‘The relationship between participation and project outcomes: evidence from rural water supply projects in India’, World Development, 33, 1801-19. Google Scholar

PULSIPHER, L. (2001), ‘Our “Maroon” in the now-lost landscapes of Montserrat’, Geographical Review, 91, 132-42. Google Scholar

PUTNAM, R. D. (2001), Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community, New York, Simon and Schuster. Google Scholar

ROACH, B. (2015), ‘MDC “Shut Down”’, https://www.themontserratreporter.com/mdc-shut-down/ (accessed 17 April 2019). Google Scholar

SKOGAN, W. (2004), ‘Representing the community in community policing’, in W. Skogan (ed.), Community Policing: Can It Work? Belmont, CA, Wadsworth, 57-75. Google Scholar

SPHERE PROJECT (2016), Core Standard 1: People-Centered Humanitarian Response, www.spherehand-book.org/en/core-standard-1-people.centered-humanitarian-response (accessed 30 June 2016). Google Scholar

SWORD-DANIELS, V., WILSON, T., SARGEANT, T., ROSSETTO, S., TWIGG, J., JOHNSTON, D., LOUGHLIN, S. and COLE, P. (2014), ‘Consequences of long-term volcanic activity for essential services in Montserrat: challenges, adaptations and resilience’, Geological Society Memoirs, 39, 471-88. Google Scholar

TANDON, R. (2008), ‘Participation, citizenship and democracy: reflections on 25 years’ of PRIA’, Community Development Journal, 43, 284-96. Google Scholar

UHLENDAHL, T., SALIANB, P., CASAROTTOC, C. and DOETSCHD, J. (2011), ‘Good water governance and IWRM in Zambia: challenges and chances’, Water Policy, 13, 845-62. Google Scholar

UN HABITAT (2016), ‘Revised zero draft of the New Urban Agenda’, www.habitat3.org/zerodraft (accessed 30 June 2016). Google Scholar

USGS (2004), Caribis - Caribbean Island Nations Coastline Boundaries: Open-File Report 2004-1400, Woods Hole, MA: United States Geological Survey. Google Scholar

USLANER, E. M. (2003), ‘Civic engagement in America: why people participate in political and social life’ (report to the Knight Civic Engagement Project). Google Scholar

WATSON, V. (2009), ‘The planned city sweeps the poor away: urban planning and 21st century urbanization’, Progress in Planning, 72, 151-93. Google Scholar

WATSON, V. (2013), ‘African urban fantasies: dreams or nightmares?’, Environment and Urbanization, 26, 1-17. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Hooper, Michael