Patriarchal Politics in Pre-Civil War Spain: Prostitution in Ángela Graupera’s Anarcho-feminist Novellas

MADDEN, DEBORAH

Bulletin of Hispanic Studies (2021), 98, (4), 375–394.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3828/bhs.2021.22
Language: English
Pages: 20

Abstract

For anarchists and leftists in pre-Civil War Spain, prostitution epitomized women’s sexual and economic subordination under patriarchal, capitalist structures. Though both anarchist and Marxist discourses conflated gender and class equality, believing women’s emancipation to be an organic consequence of social revolution, the lack of focus on female-specific concerns in anti-capitalist ideations has attracted criticism from feminist scholars. Grounding an analysis within these theoretical and historical contexts, this article interrogates how Ángela Graupera, a little-known Catalan activist and writer, used the trope of prostitution to examine these issues in her novellas, published as part of the La Novela Libre and La Novela Ideal series that were printed by the anarchist magazine La Revista Blanca in the 1920s and 1930s. Through a close reading of selected texts, the examination explores how prostitution functions as a metaphor for female subordination, facilitating a critique of androcentric socio-economic discourses and hegemonic sexual politics in early twentieth-century Spain.

Para los anarquistas e izquierdistas en la España pre-Guerra Civil, la prostitución ejemplificaba la subordinación sexual y económica de las mujeres bajo las estructuras patriarcales y capitalistas. Aunque ambos los discursos anarquistas y marxistas relacionaban la igualdad de clase con la de sexo, por una creencia que la emancipación de las mujeres sería una consecuencia orgánica de la revolución social, la critica feminista ha llamado atención a la falta de foco directo en las experiencias ginocéntricas en las ideologías anti-capitalistas. Con una consideración para estos contextos críticos y socio-políticos, este ensayo analiza cómo Ángela Graupera, una escritora y activista catalana poco conocida, utiliza el tropo de la prostitución para explorar estos temas en las novelas que publicó como parte de las series La Novela Libre y La Novela Ideal de la publicación anarquista La Revista Blanca en las décadas 1920 y 1930. El análisis examina cómo la prostitución funciona como una metáfora para la subordinación femenina que facilita una crítica de los discursos socio-económicos andocéntricos y la política sexual hegemónica en la España al principio del siglo XX.

FormatArticle

£25.00

READ THIS ARTICLE

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Works cited

Álvarez Junco, José, 1976. La ideología política del anarquismo español (1868-1910) (Madrid: Siglo Veintiuno Editores). Google Scholar

Álvarez Rey, Leandro, 1987. Sevilla durante la dictadura de Primo de Rivera: La Unión Patriótica (1923-1930) (Seville: Diputación Provincial de Sevilla). Google Scholar

Arce Pinedo, Rebeca, 2006. Dios, patria y hogar: la construcción social de la mujer española por el catolicismo y las derechas en el primer tercio del siglo XX (Santander: Universidad de Cantabria). Google Scholar

Bakunin, Mikhail, 1953. ‘Women, Marriage, and Family’, in The Political Philosophy of Bakunin: Scientific Anarchism, ed. by Grigoriî Petrovich Maximoff. (London: The Free Press of Glencoe), pp. 326-27. Google Scholar

Barrett, Michèle, 1988. Women’s Impression Today: The Marxist/ Feminist Encounter (London and New York: Verso). Google Scholar

Bender, Rebecca, 2003. ‘First-Wave Spanish Feminism: Negotiating the Changing Faces of Motherhood and Maternity Through Narrative’, Unpublished PhD Thesis, The Pennsylvania State University. Google Scholar

Blau DuPlessis, Rachel, 1985. Writing Beyond the Ending: Narrative Strategies of Twentieth-Century Women Writers (Bloomington: Indiana University Press). Google Scholar

Bookchin, Murray, 1977. The Spanish Anarchists: The Heroic Years 1868-1936 (New York: Free Life). Google Scholar

Brown, Joan L. (ed.), 1991. Women Writers of Contemporary Spain: Exiles in the Homeland (Newark: University of Delaware Press). Google Scholar

Canalias, Anna, 1934. ‘La dona catalana i la política’, L’autonomista, 11 July: 1. Google Scholar

Chancer, Lynn, 1992. Sadomasochism in Everyday Life: The Dynamics of Power and Powerlessness (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press). Google Scholar

Christie, Stuart, 2000. ‘We, the Anarchists!’: A Study of the Iberian Anarchist Federation (FAI) 1927-1937 (Hastings, UK: Meltzer Press/ Jura Media). Google Scholar

Cleminson, Richard, 1995. ‘Beyond Tradition and “Modernity”: The Cultural and Sexual Politics of Spanish Anarchism’, in Spanish Cultural Studies: An Introduction. The Struggle for Modernity, ed. Helen Graham and Jo Labanyi. (Oxford: Oxford University Press), pp. 116-23. Google Scholar

Cleminson, Richard, 2003. ‘“Science and Sympathy” or “Sexual Subversion on a Human Basis”? Anarchists in Spain and the World League for Sexual Reform’, Journal of the History of Sexuality 12.1: 110-21. Google Scholar

Cleminson, Richard, 2005. ‘L’anarquista nu. Naked Anarchism or the Dissolution of an Ideology: A Comment on Patrick Paul Garlinger’s “Pleasurable Insurrections”’, Bulletin of Hispanic Studies 82.3: 371-79. Google Scholar

Coiner, Constance, 1996. ‘Literature of Resistance: The Intersection of Feminism and the Communist Left in Meridel Le Seur and Tillie Olsen’, in Radical Revisions: Rereading 1930s Culture, ed. Bill Mullen and Sherry Lincoln. (Champaign, IL: The University of Illinois Press), pp. 144-66. Google Scholar

Cole, Gregory, 2000. Spanish Women Poets of the Generation of 1927 (Lewiston, PA: Mellen). Google Scholar

Conde, Carmen, 1954. Poesía femenina española viviente: antología (Madrid: Castilla). Google Scholar

Conde, Carmen, 1967. Poesía femenina española (1939-1950) (Barcelona: Bruguera). Google Scholar

Conde, Carmen, 1971. Poesía femenina española (1950-1960) (Barcelona: Bruguera). Google Scholar

Cruz-Cámara, Nuria, 2015. La mujer moderna en los escritos de Federica Montseny (London: Tamesis). Google Scholar

Davies, Catherine, 1991. ‘The Sexual Representation of Politics in Hispanic Feminist Narrative’, in Feminist Readings of Spanish and Latin-American Literature, ed. Lisa Condé and Stephen Hart. (Lewiston, NY, and Lampeter, Wales: The Edwin Mellen Press), pp. 107-20. Google Scholar

Davies, Catherine, 1994. Contemporary Feminist Fiction in Spain: The Work of Montserrat Roig and Rosa Montero (Oxford: Berg). Google Scholar

Davies, Catherine, 1998. Spanish Women’s Writing 1849-1996 (London: Athlone Press). Google Scholar

De Esteban, Jorge, and Luis López Guerra, 1982. Los partidos políticos en la España actual (Barcelona: Planeta). Google Scholar

Drinkwater, Judith, 1995. ‘“Esta cárcel de amor”: Erotic Fiction by Women in Spain in the 1980s and 1990s’, Letras Femeninas 21.1/2: 97-111. Google Scholar

Engels, Friedrich, 1971a [1847]. ‘Principles of Communism’, in Birth of the Communist Manifesto, ed. Dirk J. Struik. (New York: International Publishers), pp. 169-89. Google Scholar

Engels, Friedrich, 1971b [1847]. ‘Draft of the Communist Confession of Faith’, in Birth of the Communist Manifesto, ed. Dirk J. Struik (New York: International Publishers), pp. 163-69. Google Scholar

Fox-Lockert, Lucia, 1979. Women Novelists in Spain and Spanish America (Metuchen, NJ, and London: Scarecrow Press). Google Scholar

Freud, Sigmund, 2011 [1905]. Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality, trans. James Strachey. (Mansfield Centre, CT: Martino). Google Scholar

Galerstein, Carolyn (ed.), 1986. Women Writers of Spain: An Annotated Bio-Bibliographical Guide (New York; Westport, CT; London: Greenwood Press). Google Scholar

Glick, Thomas, 2006. ‘Marañón, Intersexuality and the Biological Construction of Gender in 1920s Spain’, Cronos 8: 121-38. Google Scholar

Gobierno de España, 1889. Código civil (Real Decreto de 24 de julio de 1889). Referencia: BOE-A-1889-4763. (Texto initial publicado el 25/07/1889) (Madrid: Ministerio de Gracia y Justicia). boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-1889-4763&tn=0&p=18890725 Accessed 28 March 2021. Google Scholar

Gobierno de España, 1931. Constitución de la República Española (Madrid: Cortes Constituentes). bit.ly/3kMAGLT. Accessed 28 March 2021. Google Scholar

Gonzàlez i Vilalta, Arnau, 2006. La irrupció de la dona en el catalanisme (1931-1936) (Barcelona: Publicacions de l’Abadia de Montserrat). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, n. d. Amor que vuelve (Barcelona: R. Vives). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, n. d. Ansias de volar (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, n. d. El batelero (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, n. d. La cadena (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, c. 1926. La venganza de Jaime (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, c. 1928a. El corazón del esfinge (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, c. 1928b. El retorno a la tierra (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, c. 1928c. La pequeña hechicera (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, c. 1929a. Bajo los cerezos (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, c. 1929b. Como las abejas (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, c. 1929c. En las garras del hombre (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, c. 1930. La moral de la gente bien (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, 1931a. El despertar (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, 1931b. Los viejos (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, 1932a. La vocación (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, 1932b. Padre y verdugo (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, 1933a. La pequeña rebelde (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, c. 1933b. Los rebeldes (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, 1935. El gran crimen: lo que he visto yo en la guerra (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Graupera, Ángela, 1936. La casita blanca (Barcelona: Publicaciones de La Revista Blanca). Google Scholar

Guereña, Jean-Louis, 2003. La prostitución en la España contemporánea (Madrid: Marcial Pons Historia). Google Scholar

Guereña, Jean-Louis, 2008. ‘Prostitution and the Origins of the Governmental Regulatory System in Nineteenth-Century Spain: The Plans of the Trienio Liberal, 1820-1823’, Journals of the History of Sexuality 17.2: 216-34. Google Scholar

Guettel, Charnie, 1974. Marxism and Feminism (Toronto: Canadian Women’s Educational Press). Google Scholar

Hartmann, Heidi, 1981. ‘The Unhappy Marriage of Marxism and Feminism: Towards a More Progressive Union’, in Women and Revolution: A Discussion of the Unhappy Marriage of Marxism and Feminism, ed. Lydia Sargent. (Quebec: Black Rose Books), pp. 1-42. Google Scholar

Haug, Frigga, 2015. ‘The Marx within Feminism’, in Marxism and Feminism, ed. Shahrzad Mojab. (London: Zed Books), pp. 76-101. Google Scholar

Heywood, Paul, 1993. El marxismo y el fracaso del socialismo organizado en España, 1879-1936, trans. Eva Rodríguez Halffter. (Santander: Servicio de Publicaciones de la Universidad de Cantabria). Google Scholar

La humanitat, 1934. ‘Un manifest a les dones catalanes’, 13 January: 4. Google Scholar

Jagoe, Catherine, 1994. Ambiguous Angels: Gender in the Novels of Galdós (Berkley and London: The University of California Press). Google Scholar

Kaplan, Temma, 1971. ‘Spanish Anarchism and Women’s Liberation’, Journal of Contemporary History 6.2: 101-110. Google Scholar

Kern, Robert, 1978. Red Years, Black Years: A Political History of Spanish Anarchism, 1911-1937 (Philadelphia, PA: Institute for the Study of Human Issues). Google Scholar

Kirkpatrick, Susan, 2003. Mujer, modernismo y vanguardia en España (1898-1931) (Madrid: Ediciones Cátedra). Google Scholar

Lacarra Lanz, Eukene, 2002. ‘Legal and Clandestine Prostitution in Medieval Spain’, Bulletin of Hispanic Studies 79.3: 265-85. Google Scholar

Lannon, Francis, 2011. ‘Gender and Change: Identity and Reform in the Second Republic’, in A Companion to Spanish Women’s Studies, ed. Xon de Ros and Geraldine Hazbun. (Woodbridge, UK: Tamesis), pp. 273-86. Google Scholar

Lynch, Karen, 2003. The “Heterosexualisation” of Sadism and Masochism, Hecate 29.1: 34-46. Google Scholar

Marx, Karl, 1957. ‘Revelation of the Mystery of the Emancipation of Women, or Louise Morel’ (1845), in The Holy Family or Critique of Critical Critique, by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, trans. R. Dixon. (Moscow: Foreign Languages Publishing House), pp. 258-60. Google Scholar

Marx, Karl, 1976 [1867]. Capital: A Critique of Political Economy, Vol. 1, trans. Ben Fowkes. (London: Penguin Books in association with New Left Review). Google Scholar

Marx, Karl, and Friedrich Engels, 2009 [1848]. The Communist Manifesto, intro. Robert Conquest, trans. Samuel Moore. (Washington, DC: Regnery Publishing). Google Scholar

Maurice, Jacques, 1990. El anarquismo Andaluz: campesinos y sindicalistas (Cádiz: Editorial Crítica). Google Scholar

Miró, Ivan, and Jordi Garcia, 2012. ‘Cooperatives 1842-1939/ BCN. Guia d’història urbana’, 1st ed. (November). (Barcelona: Museu d’història de Barcelona). Google Scholar

Modleski, Tania, 1990. Loving with a Vengeance: Mass-Produced Fantasies for Women (New York: Routledge). Google Scholar

Moglen, Helene, 2001. The Trauma of Gender: A Feminist Theory of the English Novel (Berkeley: The University of California Press). Google Scholar

Montseny, Federica, 1927. ‘Una jornada de las Prostituídas’, La Revista Blanca 100: 111. Google Scholar

Montseny, Federica, 1928. ‘Libertad’, La Revista Blanca 111, 1 January: 456, 457. Google Scholar

Montseny, Federica, 1937. Mi experiencia en el Ministerio de Sanidad y Asistencia Social (Valencia: Comisión de Propaganda y Prensa del Comité Nacional de la CNT). Google Scholar

Montseny, Federica, 1987. Mis primeros cuarenta años (Barcelona: Plaza y Janés). Google Scholar

Nash, Mary, 1975. ‘Dos intelectuales anarquistas frente al problema de la mujer: Federica Montseny y Lucía Sánchez Saornil’, Convivium: Revista de Filosofía 44-45: 72-99 Google Scholar

Nash, Mary, 1983. Mujer, familia y trabajo en España, 1875-1936 (Barcelona: Anthropos). Google Scholar

Nash, Mary, 1995. Defying Male Civilization: Women in the Spanish Civil War (Denver, CO: Arden Press). Google Scholar

Nash, Mary, 1999. ‘Un/Contested Identities: Motherhood, Sex Reform and the Modernization of Gender Identity in Early Twentieth-Century Spain’, in Constructing Spanish Womanhood: Female Identity in Modern Spain, ed. Victoria Lorée Enders and Pamela Beth Radcliff. (Albany, N.Y.: University of New York Press), pp. 25-49. Google Scholar

Olson Buck, Carla, 1994. ‘Rewriting the Novela Rosa: Carmen Martín Gaite’s Fragmentos de interior’, Hispanófila 112: 27-38. Google Scholar

O’Neill, Maggie, 2001. Prostitution and Feminism: Towards a Politics of Feeling (Cambridge, UK; Oxford; Maiden, MA: Polity). Google Scholar

Pérez, Janet, 1988. Contemporary Women Writers of Spain (Boston: Twayne). Google Scholar

Perry, Mary Elizabeth, 1978. ‘“Lost Women” in Early Modern Spain: The Politics of Prostitution’ Feminist Studies 4.1: 195-214. Google Scholar

Prado, Antonio, 2006. ‘Escritoras Anarco-Feminists en La Revista Blanca (1898-1905/ 1923-1936)’, unpublished PhD Dissertation, University of Illinois. Google Scholar

Prado, Antonio, 2011. Matrimonio, familia y estado: escritoras anarcho-feministas en ‘La Revista Blanca’ (1898-1936) (Madrid: Fundación de Estudios Libertarios Anselmo Lorenzo). Google Scholar

Raabe, Wesley, 1996. ‘Galdós’s Depiction of a Prostitute’, Revista Hispánica Moderna 49.1: 20-33. Google Scholar

Radway, Janice A., 1991. Reading the Romance: Women, Patriarchy, and Popular Literature (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press). Google Scholar

Real Mercadal, Neus, 1998. El club femení i d’esports de Barcelona, plataforma d’acció cultural (Barcelona: Publicacions de l’Abadia de Montserrat). Google Scholar

Real Mercadal, Neus, 2003. ‘Dona i literatura en els anys trenta: la narrativa de les escriptores catalanes fins a la guerra civil’, PhD Thesis, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona. Google Scholar

Real Mercadal, Neus, 2006. Dona i literatura a la Catalunya de preguerra (Barcelona: Publicacions de l’Abadia de Montserrat). Google Scholar

Rivas Arjona, Mercedes, 2013. ‘II República española y prostitución: el camino hacia la aprobación del Decreto abolicionista de 1935’, ARENAL 20.2: 345-68. Google Scholar

Rodríguez-Jiménez, Rubén, 2006. ‘Writing Beyond the Ending: La autoridad político-cultural y la cuestión del honor a través del sistemo sexo/ género en Valor agravio y mujer y Fuentevejuna’, Letras Hispanas 3. Google Scholar

Scott, Catherine, 1995. Gender and Development; Rethinking Modernization and Dependency Theory (Boulder, CO: Lynn Riener). Google Scholar

Sinclair, Alison, 2007. Sex and Society in Early Twentieth-Century Spain: Hildegart Rodríguez and the World League for Sexual Reform (Cardiff: University of Wales Press). Google Scholar

Sosa-Velasco, Alfredo, 2010. Médicos Escritores em España, 1885-1955: Santiago Ramón y Cajal, Pío Baroja, Gregorio Marañón y Antonio Vallejo Nágera (Woodbridge, UK: Tamesis). Google Scholar

Threlfall, Monica, 2005. ‘Gendering the Transition to Democracy: Reassessing the Impact of Women’s Activism’, in Gendering Spanish Democracy, ed. Monica Threlfall, Christine Cousins and Celia Valiente. (London: Routledge), pp. 11-54. Google Scholar

Valiente, Celia, 2004. ‘State Feminism and Central State Debates on Prostitution in Post-Authoritarian Spain’, in The Politics of Prostitution: Women’s Movements, Democratic States and the Globalisation of Sex, ed. Joyce Outshoorn. (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press), pp. 205-24. Google Scholar

Vanguardia, La, 1926a. Report of ‘La mujer y la ley’ conference. Barcelona, 12 February: 9. Google Scholar

Vanguardia, La, 1926b. Report of ‘La mujer y la ley’ conference. Barcelona 19 February: 8. Google Scholar

Vanguardia, La, 1950. ‘Necrologicas’, ‘Doña Clara Maestu Puigvendrelló’. Barcelona, 29 April: 13. Google Scholar

Winston, Colin, 1985. Workers and the Right in Spain, 1900-1936 (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press). Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

MADDEN, DEBORAH

Bulletin of Hispanic Studies