Down Syndrome as Pure Simulacrum

Smith, Sharon; Smith, Kieron

doi:https://doi.org/10.3828/jlcds.2021.24

Journal of Literary & Cultural Disability Studies (2021), 15, (3), 287–305.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3828/jlcds.2021.24
Language: English
Pages: 19

Abstract

The article questions both the dominant metanarrative around Down syndrome and its numerous tropes, but also the dominant counter-narrative for effectively re-enforcing this. In order to expose the dominance of the image over the reality of Down syndrome, the article utilizes Baudrillard’s concept of the simulacra. It demonstrates how attempts to challenge the deficit model relating to Down syndrome continue to incorporate both the specific language and underlying metaphors of Down syndrome as other. Despite greater positive visibility in advertisements, television, and the press, there continues to be an increase in terminations and no progress on inclusion in education or the workplace. The article opposes both received narratives and metaphors around Down syndrome and poses a new challenge to the disparate, but ultimately impotent dominant counter-arguments and argues for a renewed focus on the real, the material experiences of people with Down syndrome. This is the only way that the dominant prevalent image of Down syndrome can be overcome.

FormatArticle

£25.00

READ THIS ARTICLE

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Works Cited

Bakar, Faima. “Model with Down’s Syndrome Becomes Brand Ambassador for Benefit Cosmetics.” Metro. 10 Jan. 2019. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Baron, Saskia. “Jellyfish, National Theatre Review: Ben Weatherill’s Play Hits the Right Notes.” theartsdesk.com. 11 Jul. 2019. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Baudrillard, Jean. The Perfect Crime. London: Verso, 1996. Print. Google Scholar

Baudrillard, Jean. Screened Out. London: Verso, 2002. Print. Google Scholar

Baudrillard, Jean. Simulacra and Simulation. Michigan: U of Michigan P, 2019. Print. Google Scholar

Baudrillard, Jean. Simulations. New York: Semiotext(e), 1983. Print. Google Scholar

BBC News. “Down’s Syndrome Mother Denies Vanity.” BBC. 18 Nov. 1998. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/216479.stm. Web. Google Scholar

Boseley, Sarah. “Is Autism Screening Close to Reality? Call for Ethics Debate As Tests in Womb Could Allow Termination of Pregnancies.” The Guardian. 12 Jan. 2009. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Buckley, Frank and Sue Buckley. “Wrongful Deaths and Rightful Lives: Screening for Down Syndrome.” Down Syndrome Research and Practice 12.2 (2008): 79-86. Print. Google Scholar

Burch, Leah. “A World Without Down’s Syndrome? Online Resistance on Twitter: #worldwithoutdowns and #justaboutcoping.” Disability & Society 32.7 (2017): 1085-89. Print. Google Scholar

Croce, Maria. “Mums and Dads of Children with Down’s Syndrome Create Incredible Book of Images.” Daily Record. 5 Oct. 2019. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Davis, Lennard J. “The End of Identity Politics: On Disability as an Unstable Category.” The Disability Studies Reader. 4th edition. Ed. Lennard J. Davis. New York: Routledge, 2013. 263-77. Print. Google Scholar

de Faria, Marina. D. and Leticia M. Casotti. ““Welcome to Holland!” People with Down Syndrome As Vulnerable Consumers.” European Journal of Marketing 53.11 (2019): 2245-67. Print. Google Scholar

Dobzhansky, Theodosius. “Differences Are Not Deficits.” The Bell Curve Debate, History Documents, Opinions. Ed. Russell Jacoby and Naomi Glauberman. New York: Times Books, 1995. 630-39. Print. Google Scholar

Estreich, George. The Shape of the Eye: Down Syndrome, Family, and the Stories We Inherit. Dallas: Southern Methodist UP, 2011. Print. Google Scholar

Fox, Sam, Peter Farrell, and Pauline Davis. “Factors Associated with the Effective Inclusion of Primary Aged Pupils with Down’s Syndrome.” British Journal of Special Education. 31.4 (2004): 184-90. Print. Google Scholar

Frank, Arthur W. “Why I Wrote… the Wounded Storyteller: a Recollection of Life and Ethics.” Clinical Ethics 4 (2009): 106-08. Print. Google Scholar

Fraser, Benjamin. Cognitive Disability Aesthetics: Visual Culture, Disability Representations and the (In)Visibility of Cognitive Difference. Toronto: U of Toronto P, 2018. Print. Google Scholar

Gee, Alison. “A World Without Down’s Syndrome?” BBC News Magazine. 29 Sep. 2016. www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-37500189. Web. Google Scholar

Gordy, Sarah. “Champagne, Snakes and Stealing Chips.” Made Possible. Ed. Saba Salman. London: Unbound, 2020. 55-74. Print. Google Scholar

Gould, Stephen Jay. “Dr Down’s Syndrome.” The Panda’s Thumb, More Reflections in Natural History. London: Penguin, 1990. 133-39. Print. Google Scholar

Haller, Beth. A. and Sue Ralph. “Are Disability Images in Advertising Becoming Bold And Daring? An Analysis of Prominent Themes in US and UK Campaigns.” Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Hughes, Pascale. “Child Models with Down’s Syndrome and Cerebral Palsy Join River Island’s New Campaign.” inews. 19 Feb. 2018. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Jarman, Michelle. “Entanglements of Disability, Ethnicity, and Relations: Orienting Toward Belonging in George Estriechs’s The Shape of the Eye.” The Journal of American Culture 36.3 (2013): 194-05. Google Scholar

Karim, Fariha. “Abort Babies with Down’s, Says Dawkins.” The Times. 21 Aug. 2014. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Kellner, Douglas. “Jean Baudrillard.” The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Winter 2019 edition. Ed. Edward N. Zalta. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

King, Gillian A., Lonnie Zwaigenbaum, Susanne King, Donna Baxter, Peter Rosenbaum, and Anita Bates. “A Qualitative Investigation of Changes in the Belief Systems of Families of Children with Autism or Down Syndrome.” Child: Care, Health & Development 32.3 (2006): 353-69. Print. Google Scholar

Kingsley, Emily P. Welcome to Holland. 1987. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Kittay, Eva. “Planning a Trip to Italy, Arriving in Holland: the Delusion of Choice in Planning a Family.” International Journal of Feminist Approaches to Bioethics 3.2 Special Issue: Disability Studies in Feminist Bioethics (2010): 9-24. Print. Google Scholar

Lalvani, Priya. “Constructing the (M)Other: Dominant and Contested Narratives on Mothering a Child with Down Syndrome.” Narrative Inquiry 21.2 (2011): 276-93. Print. Google Scholar

Lalvani, Priya.. “Mother.” Constructing the (M)Other: Narratives of Disability, Motherhood, and the Politics of Normal. Ed. Priya Lalvani. New York: Peter Lang, 2019. 1-15. Print. Google Scholar

Lalvani, Priya.. “Mothers of Children With Down Syndrome: Constructing the Sociocultural Meaning of Disability.” Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities 46.6 (2008): 436-45. Print. Google Scholar

Lalvani, Priya.. “The Strange Case of the Two Journals: Ableism, Academia, and the Birth of a Child.” Constructing the (M)Other: Narratives of Disability, Motherhood, and the Politics of Normal. Ed. Priya Lalvani. New York: Peter Lang, 2019. 137-52. Print. Google Scholar

Maclean, Dave. “Iceland Is Close to Becoming the First Country Where No Down’s Syndrome Children Are Born.” Independent. 16 Aug. 2017. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Mandle, Chris. “Gap Casts First Model with Down’s Syndrome for Ellen Degeneres’ Kids Range.” Independent. 25 Aug. 2015. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Marsh, Beezy. “Smile That Made Down’s Girl a Sainsbury’s Star: Natty Is Face of Supermarket’s Children’s Clothing Campaign After Beating Hundreds of Hopefuls.” 22 Jun. 2014. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

McDonagh, Patrick. Idiocy, A Cultural History. Liverpool: Liverpool UP, 2008. Print. Google Scholar

McStay, Kirsten. “Amy Features in Book About Real Life Stories of People with Down’s Syndrome.” Daily Record. 18 Dec. 2019. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Merriman, Andy. Tales of Normansfield, The Langdon Down Legacy. Teddington: Down’s Syndrome Association, 2007. Print. Google Scholar

Nichol, Rachael. “‘We Are the Lucky Few’: Dad Speaks Out About What It’s Like to Have a Child with Down Syndrome.” ChronicleLive. 26 Aug. 2019. Web. 16 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

O’Neill, Leona. “Wouldn’t Change A Thing: Northern Ireland Families Celebrate the Lives of Children with Down’s Syndrome in New Book.” Belfast Telegraph. 21 Oct. 2019. Print. Google Scholar

Phillips, Sally. “Parents of Kids with Down’s Syndrome Are the Lucky Few.” Metro. 11 Oct. 2019. Print. Google Scholar

Piepmeier, Alison. “Saints, Sages, and Victims: Endorsement of and Resistance to Cultural Stereotypes in Memoirs by Parents of Children with Disabilities.” Disability Studies Quarterly 32.1 (2012). Web. 17 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Prussing, Erica, Elisa J. Sobob, Elizabeth Walker, and Paul S. Kurtin. “Between ‘Desperation’ and Disability Rights: a Narrative Analysis of Complementary/Alternative Medicine Use by Parents for Children with Down Syndrome.” Social Science & Medicine 60 (2005): 587-98. Print. Google Scholar

Rutter, Susan and Suzannah Syman. “He’ll Never Join the Army”: A Report on a Down’s Syndrome Association Survey into Attitudes to People with Down’s Syndrome Amongst Medical Professionals. Teddington: Down Syndrome Association, 1999. Print. Google Scholar

Scope. Getting Away with Murder: Disabled People’s Experiences of Hate Crime in the UK. London: Scope, 2008. Print. Google Scholar

Shakespeare, Tom. “Are We Really More Accepting of Down’s Syndrome?” The Guardian. 24 Nov. 2008. Print. Google Scholar

Shakespeare, Tom.. “Debating Disability.” Journal of Medical Ethics 34.1 (2008): 11-14. Print. Google Scholar

Skotko, Brian G. “With New Prenatal Testing, Will Babies with Down Syndrome Slowly Disappear?” Archives of Disease in Childhood 94.11 (2009): 823-26. Google Scholar

Slee, Roger. “How Do We Make Inclusive Education Happen When Exclusion Is a Political Predisposition?” International Journal of Inclusive Education 1.8 (2013): 895-907. Print. Google Scholar

Smith, Kieron. The Politics of Down Syndrome. Winchester: Zero Books, 2011. Print. Google Scholar

Smith, Sharon. “Punching Me in the Face Would Have Been Preferable…” I Live for Glitter. 8 Apr. 2010. Web. 17 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Stumbo, Ellen. “43 Models With Down Syndrome.” yahoo! News. 21 Mar. 2019, Web. 17 Mar. 2021. Google Scholar

Telegraph Reporters. “Mother Wins Compensation from NHS over Son Born with Down’s Syndrome.” The Telegraph. 8 Oct. 2019. Print. Google Scholar

Weatherill, Ben. Jellyfish. London: Bloomsbury Methuen Drama, 2018. Print. Google Scholar

Wright, David. Downs: The History of a Disability. Oxford: Oxford UP, 2011. Print. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Smith, Sharon

Smith, Kieron

Journal of Literary & Cultural Disability Studies